We know how tough it is to referee an NFL game. Plays go by in seconds, rules are broken in half the time, and fans are screaming at you no matter what your decision is. But there are some calls in history that just make us stand up and cry foul. Whether it was lack of foresight, constrained by antiquated laws, or just plain wrong, these decisions have made the NFL referee a position on the field that just can't get a break. Some blown calls are funny, some are heart-breaking, and no matter what, the fans will still be screaming. Keep in mind, though, these referees are human, not saints...
10. The Holy Roller
This play didn't seem divine so much as confusing. Bill King, the Raiders commentator, couldn't believe this play was actually happening. Madden didn't believe it was real. No one believed it was real, and yet the play stood. Ten seconds left in the 1978 game between the Raiders and Chargers, San Diego up 20-14. Quarterback Ken Stabler goes back to pass, is almost sacked and then...this happens. The referees allowed because they could not tell if Stabler, the quarterback, or running back Pete Banaszak intentionally flung the ball forward. Thirty-five years later, I could tell that sitting in my living room.
9. The Fog Bowl
Sometimes the refs just have to call the game. Yes, real men can play in anything, can face any condition. But if you're a referee, don't you have to be able to see the game to be able to call it? Nobody could see anything! Players on both sides of the field had to tell coaches what just happened to decide on new strategies. Watching the game made one think you were on a bad channel, or your anttena was broken and you were being rewarded with static. But no, this game was "called" as best it could. The Eagles would go on to lose the game, and whilst having an explosive defense that dominated in the regular season, was forever labeled as postseason foul-ups. Maybe a rescheduled game might've changed that for the Eagles' benefit, and the city of Brotherly Love just might have a few Lombardi trophies to show off.
8. Renfro Catch
Ah, the days before instant replay. When the call was the call, so just shut up and deal with what the call was...even if it was completely wrong. In the 1979 playoffs, the Houston Oilers were finally having some sort of relevance. A punishing running back with Earl Campbell, a sturdy and successful quarterback Dan Pastorini, and a catchy nickname as the "Luv Ya Blues". Then they went up against the Steelers. In the middle of the game, Pastorini sails a beautiful pass to wide receiver Mike Renfro, who unfortunately "did not" get his feet in bounds. The Steelers would win the game and go on to winning their fourth Lombardi trophy. The Houston Oilers cannot say definitively that they would've won this game, because the Steelers went on to increase their lead after the "incomplete". But it could've been a huge momentum shifter, and certainly would give the Oilers a better chance at winning. Regardless, this game was one of the main reasons the NFL now uses instant replay in officiating.
7. Phantom Push, QB Sneak Super Bowl 40
He's in? The Steelers were going to win Super Bowl XL. Jerome "The Bus" Bettis, the sixth all-time leading rusher, was retiring, the super bowl was being played in his hometown of Detroit, and the Steelers were the first sixth seed to ever make it to football's biggest stage. This was a foregone conclusion. But the refs should've made it seem a little less obvious. Two plays in the game really stuck in the mind of Seahawks' fans. Early in the first-quarter, Darrel Jackson was called for pass interference, bringing back a sure touchdown. Later in the half, quarterback Ben Roethlisberger's sneak into the endzone didn't really seem to make it all the way in. Fourteen points that would've definitely changed the outcome of the 21-10 victory for the Steelers, especially given Roethlisberger's poor performance in the game. The referees could've just handed the game to Pittsburgh.
6. Super Bowl 47 Non-Call
While calling a game wrong can be bad, not calling it at all can be far worse. Just ask the San Francisco 49ers about this past year's Super Bowl. It seemed that the Ravens could do no wrong, and Ray Lewis was destined for greatness. But after one of the weirdest blackouts in playoffs history, the 49ers were set to make a comeback. Late in the fourth quarter, down 34-31, the 49ers were set to even beat the Ravens. And then Michael Crabtree gets held, and quarterback Colin Kaepernick's throw goes out of the end zone. Everyone who wasn't a Ravens fan was screaming at the refs. One of the most classic cases of pass interference, on the most televised sports event in history, and you don't call it? This cost the 49ers a ring, and instead gave it to the Ravens, and Joe Flacco is suddenly one of the greatest quarterbacks in the league. How does this even make sense?
5. Steelers-Lions Thanksgiving: He-Tails?
Fans can understand blowing plays. The tackle may or may not have been holding, the running back may or may not have stepped out of bounds. But a coin toss? You messed up a coin toss? Yes, a coin toss. Phil Luckett was the referee and will forever be remember infamously in Pittsburgh for the 1998 Thanksgiving game against the Detroit Lions. Tied at the end of regulation, Pittsburgh captain Jerome Bettis (yes, twice), calls "Tails" as the coin flips through the air, but unfortunately Luckett heard "Heads". As you might suspect, the Lions won the coin flip, and would go on to win the game. This game goes down in infamy simply because no one figured you could possibly screw up a coin toss. After Thanksgiving, teams made their call before the flip, but for screwing up a coin toss, this just hits that spot between stand-up comedy and schadenfreude that football fans just love.
4. The Bert Emanuel Rule
This one stings for the defensive-minded souls. For most football fans, the 1999 NFC championship game was the classic argument of offense vs. defense come to life. The "Greatest Show on Turf," scoring at will without even thinking about it. And the Buccaneers, the mean defensive struggles that just wanted to pound you into the ground. Can a great defense can destroy a dominant offense? One of the greatest debates in American Football...decided by a guy looking at a camera. Trailing 11-6 with 47 seconds to go, the Bucs' Bert Emanuel makes a solid thirteen-yard catch to keep the drive going...until for some reason the refs decided to have another look. While Emanuel clearly had control of the ball the entire time, under the rules if the ball even grazes the ground it's an incomplete. The Buccaneers wouldn't score another point. This is especially heartbreaking for Tampa fans. For the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, this was their first real chance ever to change a legacy. The Bucs are no longer possibly the worst franchise in history, they have beaten the "Greatest Show on Turf". Think again. The worst part about this call is that the rules were changed the very next year, making the catch legitimate if it were just one year later. To make the sting even worse, it became known as the "Bert Emanuel Rule".
3. The Immaculate Reception
Before I get into this play, I have to admit that I am a Steelers fan. I love the team, and furthermore I love this play. Taken at face value, Franco Harris is seemingly sent by God to bring the Steelers out of squalor and into the promised land, defeating the dark thugs of the league, the Oakland Raiders. And it was an unbelievable play.Did the ball touch the ground, making it incomplete? Did the ball touch Running back "Frenchy" Fuqua's hands? Did Harris run out of bounds? And did the refs even consider any of this before calling the play? So many questions that have for the most part been debated without answer for over forty years. Now, while it's a good controversy, how does this affect the legacy of football? Because Steelers fans never shut up about it! In the center of Pittsburgh's airport is a statue of Franco Harris catching the football. The football for the Immaculate Reception is in a steel vault. And every year, until every single person who was around that game is long gone, we will have to endure the controversy that is the Immaculate Reception.
2. Packers - Seahawks...It's Good?
A picture's worth a thousand words, and this one summed up everything about the replacement refs. During the referee strike of the past season, football fans were subjected to blown calls, missed plays and general below-average performances by replacements. But the game between the Packers and Seahawks on Monday night just sealed the fact that sometimes one needs a professional's touch. During the final seconds, with Seattle down 7-12, receiver Golden Tate shoved a defensive back aside, just as Packers' M.D. Jennings intercepts the ball in the endzone. Jennings and Tate took hold of the ball, and crashed together to the ground, both holding on for dear life. And in a picture that defined the season, the referees couldn't come to a consensus. They eventually gave the touchdown to the Seahawks, and the rage of football fans everywhere brought back the real refs with high praise. Unfortunately for the replacements, the above photo is not going anywhere.
1. The Tuck Rule
Could there be anything else? It started a dynasty, paved the way for Tom Brady to be one of the best quarterbacks of all time...and yet how was that not a fumble? You look over this again and again and come to a few conclusions. Tom Brady did in fact try to throw the ball. He stopped, and drew the ball to himself. The ball flew out of his hands when the only receiver he could've thrown the ball too had to have been three feet underground. And if this is all true and legal...why aren't quarterbacks repeating that motion the entire play? They'll never deal with a fumble again! This play set up the Patriots' dyansty of the 2000s, and everyone once again had to deal with the Raiders saying they were cheated out of a victory. Thank you, refs, for all you do. Did I miss any call? Angry at how I put it? Comment Below!