It's been a periodic subject of fierce debate ever since 2010 when they were awarded the rights ahead of Australia, the United States, Japan and South Korea, but Qatar's suitability as the host nation for the 2022 World Cup is being called into question in a big way once again over the last few days. This week FIFA are due to meet to discuss the issues with the wealthy desert state as host. By some margin the most controversial World Cup host there has ever been, which is really saying something for a tournament previously hosted by Fascist Italy and the Argentinian military junta of the 1970s, it seems hard to believe that FIFA will stick with their original decision. However, football's governing body still seems desperate to make a Qatari World Cup work at any cost. If they need any convincing to push them against keeping the world's premiere football event in Qatar, here are five excellent reasons to put the World Cup anywhere else.
5. Their Team Isn't Good Enough
It may sound like a petty and elitist reason to kick things off, but a World Cup is always at its best when the host nation is competitive. For a major sporting event really to capture the imagination it needs to have the local population behind it. If their team progresses to the later stages of the competition then it creates a far more positive attitude around the whole tournament. Just look at the improved national mood in this country during the 2012 Olympics. Conversely, a tournament can start to lack a little something in atmosphere after the host's elimination. South Africa, in 2010, were probably the first and, so far, only host nation who wouldn't have qualified for the competition by the normal route. Boosted by home support they gave a decent showing, beating France, but also became the first host not to make it out of the First Round, which was a bit of a let down for the tournament as a whole. At least South Africa were a reasonable team. A more talented previous generation had become African champions and qualified for the World Cup under their own steam in the immediately post-apartheid 90s. The Qatar team have no such pedigree. They have never qualified for the World Cup and only made it out of the First Round of the Asian Cup once. Currently 108th in the FIFA World Rankings, just below Azerbaijan and Botswana, Qatar failed to qualify for the upcoming World Cup. They only managed to beat one team, Lebanon, in their final qualifying group. Three humiliating defeats and a quick exit from the competition is not going to make for an enthusiastic set of local fans or, necessarily, advance the development of Qatari football.
4. The Climate Isn't Appropriate For Football
During the 1994 World Cup in the United States the need for TV coverage in Europe to air at a reasonable hour pushed matches to be played in sweltering mid-day heat. Players suffered from severe dehydration that was deemed to be quite dangerous for their health. Temperatures in Los Angeles in July tend to be just under 30°C. In Doha, Qatar, the average July temperature is 41°C and it can get as high as 50. Obviously it's impossible to play football in those kind of temperatures. The Qatar Stars League, the nation's main domestic competition, sensibly runs through the winter like most countries' football leagues. However, in order to host the World Cup during the summer, the Qatar Football Association promised to build air conditioned stadiums, which, apparently, will completely solve any concerns about players overheating. The stadium air conditioning plan sounds incredibly implausible when it comes to tackling the desert nation's baking hot summers, so a more likely alternative has been proposed: simply move the World Cup to the middle of winter. The only thing is, moving a major event with stakeholders in literally every country in the world could not be less simple. With most domestic competition taking place during the winter, domestic football associations are unlikely to be keen to shift their already packed schedules around to accommodate a winter World Cup. Meanwhile, other traditionally winter based sporting events and the broadcasters covering them for TV have expressed their own displeasure at a possible World Cup clash with either the Winter Olympics or the Superbowl. And if that's not enough trouble, a switch to winter is also likely to cause serious complaints from the losing bidders. The Australian bid team has threatened to sue if the switch is made, saying that they made their bid on the understanding there would be a summer tournament (which, from their perspective, is actually winter anyway).
3. There Are Allegations Of Corruption In Qatar's Successful Bid
For years FIFA has been dogged by accusations of corruption. Joao Havelange, FIFA president from the 1970s to the 1990s, has since been shown to have accepted millions of dollars of kickbacks from the organisation's financial partners. Since Havelange was succeeded by his former assistant Sepp Blatter in 1998, many of FIFA's executive committee have resigned under a cloud of financial misdealings. One of those executives, Chuck Blazer, was recently banned from all football related activities pending investigation into accusations that he embezzled up to $21 million. Blazer had previously made allegations against Qatari FIFA executive Mohammed Bin Hammam and then FIFA Vice President Jack Warner of trying to buy votes as part of Bin Hammam's campaign to replace Blatter as President. Bin Hammam withdrew from his campaign in 2011 amidst bribery accusations for which he was later cleared. However, in December he was suspended from all football for life due to "conflicts of interest" while in charge of the Asian Football Confederation. Warner resigned in 2011 after accusations of accepting bribes stretching across multiple World Cups. Given that all of these men were involved in the Executive Committee that awarded Qatar the 2022 World Cup, doubts have naturally been raised over the legality of that process as well. Blatter, who has made efforts to clean up corruption within the organisation over the last few years, has recently admitted that: "direct political influence" was involved in Qatar's successful bid. In the light of that, Michael Garcia, investigator for FIFA's ethics committee, has been asked to report on the bidding process for both the 2018 and 2022 World Cups. Qatar devoted a huge amount of money and influence to getting the World Cup, but plenty of countries in the past have used lobbying techniques. Until all the findings are made public there is no way of knowing if they broke any campaign rules, but this is yet another thing that casts a shadow over FIFA's operations.
2. There Will Likely Be Discrimination Against Fans (And Players)
Over recent months there has been a lot of concern over Russia's new laws opposing "the propagandising of non-traditional sexual relations among minors", essentially banning talking about homosexuality, in the light of the country's hosting of the upcoming Winter Olympics and the 2018 World Cup. If people are worried about gay fans making the trip to Russia, then that counts double for Qatar, a country where homosexuality remains illegal. The Gay Football Supporters' Network has complained that Blatter: "says that football is 'everything for everyone' but he has not yet explained just how FIFA is going to ensure that LGBT football players and supporters will be welcome in Qatar". For his part, Blatter, whose understanding of his organisation's remit to promote a tolerant and enlightened attitude is apparent in his statement that women footballers should "have tighter shorts", suggested gay fans "should refrain from sexual activity" during the tournament. It's not just fans, though. By 2022 it's very possible that there could be out gay players competing in the World Cup as well. US forward Robbie Rogers was the first internationally capped player to come out earlier this year, who's to say there won't be many more nine years from now? "Acts of sodomy" are punished in Qatar by a prison sentence of one to three years. Corporal punishment and flogging are also used. Amnesty International reported that during 2012 at least six foreign nationals were subjected to 40 or 100 lashes for: "offences related to alcohol consumption or illicit sexual relations". Yes, public displays of intimacy of all kinds are also illegal, as is public consumption of alcohol. Hardly conducive to the big international party that the World Cup typically represents.
1. The Stadiums Are Being Built With Slave Labour
Perhaps it should have been expected when such a major building project as all the stadiums and infrastructure to host the World Cup is handed to a country with a known history of exploiting migrant labourers, but the findings of a recent report in The Guardian still came as a shock to many, including authorities at FIFA. UEFA President Michel Platini, one of the people who voted in favour Qatar as host, has stated that he is "much more concerned" about these reports than about the discussion to move the whole thing to winter, suggesting that if anything stands in the way of Qatar remaining World Cup host then it could be this. There are 1.2 million migrant labourers currently working on construction projects around Qatar's World Cup plans, with a further 500,000 expected to arrive in the coming years. In particular labourers from Nepal, of which there are well over 300,000 working on World Cup related construction, are caught in chain of exploitation taking them from their villages in Nepal to building sites like Lusail City, a city being built from scratch complete with the Final's 90,000 capacity stadium. There are reports of labourers being denied free access to drinking water in the desert heat. During the summer Nepalese workers died at a rate of almost one a day, often young men having sudden heart attacks. Between 4 June and 8 August at least 44 workers died, mostly from heart failure and workplace accidents. The report predicts that up to 4000 labourers could be killed through bad working conditions between now and kick off in the first game. Migrant workers run into debt instantly by having to pay recruitment agents in Nepal to get them jobs in Qatar. Being forced to repay these debts while their wages often remain unpaid and their identity documents are confiscated places these migrant labourers in an inescapable position that is tantamount to forced labour. "These working conditions and the astonishing numbers of deaths of vulnerable workers go beyond forced labour to the slavery of old where human beings were treated as objects," said Aidan McQuade, director of Anti-Slavery International, last week. Even if FIFA doesn't pull the World Cup, it must do something to prevent this treatment of the workers putting it together. So, what's the solution to all this? Well, a number of interested parties have suggested that the best thing for all concerned would be simply to get the executive committee to vote again on all the 2022 bids. It was quite unusual of FIFA to award two World Cups together at once in 2010 and there would still be nine years for a newly selected host nation to get things together in good time for their own event. The United States, Japan and South Korea have all successfully hosted the competition in recent years, while Australia put on a good show with the 2000 Olympics and have an ever improving football culture. Any of those would be well placed to take over.