6 Reasons Why Man Utd Are Struggling Under David Moyes

By Martin Perry /

When Sir Alex Ferguson left Manchester United after 27 years in charge, many might not have expected new manager David Moyes to win the Premier League in his first season on charge. But no-one could have predicted that United would be languishing in 7th place in the league at this stage of the season. United have lost 8 out of their 26 games to date, winning just 12 (having drawn 6), leaving them 11 points adrift of a fourth and a place in next season's UEFA Champions League. They have also been knocked out of both domestic cup competitions, having been beaten at home to Swansea in the 3rd round of the F.A. Cup and lost a Capital One Cup semi final to Sunderland on penalties. Their qualification for the knockout stages of the Champions League, where they face Olympiakos in the Last 16, is the only real positive in a - in relative terms - disastrous campaign so far. United, dominant for so many years with Ferguson at the helm, have never finished below the top 3 in the 21 year history of the Premier League. A failure to finish in the top 4 would mark the first time United have not participated in the UEFA Champions League since the 1995/96 season, but their most realistic chance - and it would be appear to be a long shot given their form this season - of qualifying for next season's premier European competition is by winning this year's Champions League. This struggle cannot be put down to one singular reason, such as Moyes replacing Ferguson, but it's down to a multitude of reasons, many of which intertwine. Let's go through six main reasons that have culminated in the Red Devils' plight.

6. The Ferguson Factor

The first reason, and perhaps the most obvious one, is the fact that Sir Alex Ferguson is no longer the manager of Manchester United. He had been long established at the club, managing the team for close to 27 years. In that time, United achieved unprecedented success, winning 13 league titles, two European Cups, five F.A. Cups and four League Cups. So for a manager as successful as that, who, more importantly, had the presence he had, to leave the club would have a huge psychological impact on the players. Fergie has the manager was all any of the players knew; They weren't at a club that changed their manager every five minutes and Sir Alex, in many ways, was Manchester United. The players now knew that it wasn't Ferguson on the touchline, they weren't facing Ferguson - famous for his half time 'hairdryer' outbursts - in the dressing room at half time. In some ways, it didn't matter who replaced him as manager, whether it be David Moyes, José Mourinho or whoever, it was always going to be a blow to the team. Whether that be consciously or sub-consciously. Not just the players that might be affected by the lack of Ferguson, either. Perhaps the officials as well, who often were seemingly fearful of the Scot and many point towards that as being the reason for United getting the benefit of many dubious decisions, particularly at Old Trafford.

5. Overhaul Of Backroom Staff

When Ferguson left, as did the majority of his backroom staff, most notably assistant manager Mike Phelan and first team coach René Meulensteen. New manager David Moyes brought his own people in, including his assistant from Everton, Steve Round and Phil Neville as a coach, who had retired as an Everton player at the end of the previous season. The problem with an overhaul is the lack of continuity and thus a lack of experience in dealing with recurring injury problems with certain players, and man management of the elder statesmen in the team - in terms of training schedules, regularity of appearances and, therefore, keeping them fresh - which Ferguson and his team were renowned for. Meulensteen, who left despite Moyes asking him to stay on, took the majority of training sessions in previous seasons. Moyes, himself, now leads the team on the training field. Moyes 'draconian training methods' have since been criticised by the Dutch assistant national coach, Raymond Verheijen, attributing van Persie's pre-season thigh injury to a punishing summer warm-up. This leads me into my next point...

4. Injuries

Manchester United have struggled this season with injuries, most notably key front men Wayne Rooney and Robin van Persie, who have spent extended periods on the sidelines. Having on of the two out is not ideal, but when two of the team's best players are out at the same time, it leaves them struggling for goals and creativity. Robin van Persie had been the Premier League top goal scorer last season and United's best player in their title winning campaign, but has only managed to start 14 out of United's 26 league games this term. Rooney had got off to the season in fine form, seemingly rejuvenated under new manager Moyes, but he has only started 19 league games. With the other two strikers, Javier Hernandez and Danny Welbeck, also having time on the sidelines, United have often been left short up front. Such has been there struggle at the back with injuries, only Patrice Evra has started more than 18 league games. United have not been able to establish a solid, consistent back four. Rio Ferdinand, who had a solid 2012/13 season, has only been to start 7 league games. Things haven't been much better in midfield, with new signing Marouane Fellaini currently sidelined with a back problem, and wingers Nani and Ashley Young have also had their own issues, as well as key man Michael Carrick, amongst others.

3. Ageing Squad

For players such as Ryan Giggs, Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic, key players in recent years, it might just be one season too far. Giggs is now 40 and in a part time coaching role as well, and is expected to retire at the end of the season. Vidic has already announced he will leave, Ferdinand's future remains uncertain but has been struggling with injury and Patrice Evra might also follow Vidic out of the exit door. The form of the above players, the first three mentioned particularly, has not been up to the previous high standards this season. Whether that it's just a case of it age catching up with them or other reasons isn't always quantifiable, but other points mentioned might be factors. It could be that they are disheartened by the departure of Ferguson, whose previously mentioned man management of the elder statesmen perhaps got the last drop of quality out of these players last season. It could well be the change in backroom staff and training methods that have contributed to their relatively poor form as well. Maybe Giggs' new role as a coach is now his priority, perhaps Ferdinand is no longer getting the management of injuries he requires, perhaps Vidic can rejuvenate his own career at a new club. The problem is, though, that United haven't got the players ready to step in to the fray of the quality they were. Younger players such as Phil Jones, Chris Smalling and Adnan Januzaj haven't quite reached their peak yet. Ferguson did admit in his autobiography that he stopped planning for the future when he new his was going to retire, but then again, he can hardly plan signings when there's a new manager coming in. Which takes us to our next point...

2. Insufficient Summer Transfer Activity

The only major arrival in the summer was the capture of Marouane Fellaini from Everton, plus the arrival of January signing Wilfired Zaha, who's spent the remainder of he previous season back on loan at previous season at old club Crystal Palace. Fellaini has failed to make an impact and missed most of the season through injury. Zaha, who hasn't really been given a chance, has since been sent on loan to Cardiff in January. Premier League winning teams cannot afford to rest on their laurels, as Manchester City found out last season. Even though United won the league by 11 points last season, they still needed to make at least 2 or 3 big signings to keep up with big spending rivals such as Chelsea, City and Arsenal. United's failure to capture big names can perhaps be attributed not just to the managerial change from Ferguson to Moyes, but also the resignation of Chief Executive of David Gill, who was replaced by Ed Woodward. Ferguson and Gill made a great team when it came to transfers, but the lack of experience of Moyes and Woodward saw United leaving the Fellaini deal to the last minute, spending more than they would have had to if they'd signed him 4 weeks prior. As mentioned, there are a number of of ageing players, but a lot of younger talent who are yet to reach their peak. United needed to buy a few top quality players to continue playing at the standards they are used to. The January acquisition of Juan Mata is likely to prove too little, too late, with regards to this season in any case.

1. Tactics

In the wake of United's recent 2-2 draw with Fulham, then-Fulham boss René Meulensteen described United's tactics as "predictable" as he saw a dominating Red Devils launch 81 crosses into the box, which he said was easy to defend against. The result was described by Moyes as a 'new low' after seeing his side once again lack a cutting edge in the final third. Of course, it can take a a new manager time to get accustomed to the strengths and weaknesses of a new squad, and how best to employ these players in varying roles. That can't be an excuse, however, given the success that José Mourinho had in his first year at Chelsea and that of Manuel Pellegrini at Manchester City this season. But Moyes' inability, so far, to find an effective system has been a reason for United's struggle, and out of the reasons listed so far, the one he can be most held accountable for. Obviously, as mentioned, he has had injuries to deal with and perhaps hasn't got the strongest squad that he would hope for, but he's failed, thus far, to get the best out of the team, even at times when he has had the majority of his star names available. The Fulham game being a prime example. Managers need to be given time, it's no good getting rid of them willy nilly, but it's something that Moyes will need to get right as soon as possible if he is to see out the remainder of his six year contract.