10 Greatest Star Trek Bottle Episodes

A bottle show saves money for a series, so how has Star Trek used them to great effect?

By Sean Ferrick /

So, what is a bottle show? They're rather simple to explain: an executive looks at the budget, panics, and demands a show set entirely on standing sets.

Advertisement

Making anything, from stage plays to blockbuster films, comes with a price tag. So, a clever way around the ballooning costs of television has been the use of bottle shows - episodes that don't incur additional costs for set building, and often, though not always, using the main cast rather than guest stars.

Star Trek has been a bit loose on the interpretation when it comes to the use of guest stars in their bottle shows, though they have been clever in how they've structured these episodes. This is a list that could easily run for three or four sequels, so the episodes we've focused on here are some of the most immediate examples that come to mind.

Put up your feet, switch off any devices that are sucking up electricity in the background, save your money, and enjoy these budgeted bastions of brilliance.

10. A Night In Sickbay

Full disclosure: this writer cannot stand this episode. The idea may have been cute, but the execution sets my teeth on edge. However, it is a perfect example of a bottle show, this one hailing from Enterprise, so let's swallow that bile and carry on.

Advertisement

Porthos is sick! That's enough to rally most Trekkies up in arms to save the best crewman on the ship. Dr. Phlox says that only time will tell if he'll make it, so his dutiful best friend - Captain Archer - wows to stay by his side through the night.

The episode, in truth, should have been so much funnier than it ended up becoming. Archer is on edge throughout, Phlox is on, ahem, full display, and we are treated to a plethora of exotic alien animal life. Though of course, we get a happy ending (seriously: Trekkies may have rioted otherwise), the episode falls a bit flat when all of its components come together. 

Still, no one can argue that it didn't save the show a bit of money - so stuffed doggo or no - we tip our caps to this episode! 

9. Distant Voices

Distant Voices is another third-season entry from Deep Space Nine - who must have been trying to tighten the belt that year, though when one considers episodes like Past Tense and The Die Is Cast, it begins to make a bit more sense.

Advertisement

This is an idea that the show would revisit several more times in its run - empty the station, turn off the lights, and hey presto - spooky scenery. Bashir, suffering from a Lethean psychic attack, wanders the corridors of his mind, represented by familiar locations - the standing sets.

It was Ronald D. Moore's idea to set the action aboard the station, while the idea of not using regular actors was nixed early on. Andrew Robinson was delighted to play this version of Garak, with Alexander Siddig commenting, pre-filming, that this story was a challenge - having to take the character and age him up so much, all within the confines of 44 minutes. 

The gamble paid off, as did the efforts of Michael Westmore. This episode won an Emmy award for Outstanding Individual Achievement in Makeup for a Series, beating Voyager's Faces to the punch. 

8. One

One is a later episode in Voyager's fourth season, serving as an effective two-hander between Jeri Ryan and Robert Picardo. The episode's conceit sees the crew placed in stasis for a month-long trip through a dangerous nebula, with only the Doctor and Seven immune to its effects.

Advertisement

Cue hijinks.

This was a heavy episode for Ryan to film as she is effectively in every scene. As the episode progresses, her co-stars get fewer and fewer, until eventually it is just her. Director Kenneth Biller reflected that she was a pleasure to work with, was always present and ready, and managed the script despite its hyper-reliance on her.

The stasis chamber set was a re-use of Seven's cargo bay, while the pods themselves had previously appeared in The Thaw and Resolutions - another cost-saving technique as the season prepared to ramp up for the finale, Hope & Fear.

A fun production fact saw the filming for One run late into the evening on 26th Feb '98, only to begin again in the morning - while production on the series' finale had to patiently wait for the lead actors to get out of burn make-up from this episode.

7. The Doomsday Machine

The Doomsday Machine is a slight outlier on this list, as it features new sets that debut, yet all of the action takes place - bar effects - on board the two ships Enterprise and Constellation, with a few key moments featuring a shuttlecraft as well.

Advertisement

So much of the story revolves around Decker's fallout from the Planet Killer's consumption of his crew, as well as Kirk's attempts to retake his ship from afar, that it finds itself here. Saying that the redesigned Engineering set appears for the first time here, as does the ante-chamber where Kirk spends much of the episode.

The Doomsday Machine is iconic for its depiction of the huge space sock sucking up planets and repelling phaser fire, but the core of the story centres on Decker's descent into madness, battling with Spock as he goes. Kirk displays his calm as he pilots the Constellation into the maw of the machine - all of this, of course, takes place on either the standing set of the Enterprise bridge, or this new chamber.

6. Time Squared

The fun thing about Time Squared is how it handles time travel. In almost all cases before this episode, time travel was simply a means to an end - whales or no whales. Here, however, there is a tangible effect on Picard as he travels into the past, including nausea, dizziness, and death. 

Advertisement

The last one may have come from the other Picard's phaser. It's not important.

What's important here is that the central idea - Picard goes six hours back in time - is fascinating. Never before had such a short hop back in time been explored, thus adding a level of tension to events as the clock is an awful lot shorter than we'd been used to.

There is a version of the story that would have seen this as a prequel to Q, Who? Maurice Hurley felt that the episode was weaker for the removal of Q as the cause, feeling that the Enterprise simply flying into the Mobius was an anti-climactic ending. This then is one of the tantalising hints at the Q arc we could have seen through The Next Generation's second season. 

5. Magic To Make The Sanest Man Go Mad

This one, according to producer Aaron Harberts, was designed to save money - let there be no doubt about that! The time loop was a handy way to keep all of the action in a set amount of spaces, without having to consistently add new locales. This also allowed the episode to play with the form.

Advertisement

In a move similar to The Next Generation's Cause And Effect, this episode locks the characters into a time loop, gradually becoming aware, or at least having Stamets retain his knowledge, along with Rainn Wilson's returning Harry Mudd.

The episode, for all of its cost-saving, ends up being one of the more enjoyable - and certainly one of the more silly - episodes in Discovery's first season. Hindsight adds a slightly savage satisfaction in seeing Lorca bumped off the mortal coil again and again, but to expand there would venture into spoiler territory.

Anthony Rapp commented that the episode was a frantic one to film, with many moving parts. The party scene took four days to complete, so even with the show sitting firmly in the 'bottle show' camp, it wasn't necessarily the quickest turnaround of a script in Star Trek history.

4. The Adversary

Closing out Deep Space Nine's third season is the paranoid thriller The Adversary. While there had been other plans for the season's end that were put on hold, though would eventually surface as Homefront and Paradise Lost, this show - set almost exclusively aboard the Defiant - truly ratches up the threat of the Changelings.

Advertisement

Lawrence Pressman returned to Deep Space Nine, having previously appeared as Tekheny Ghemor, as Ambassador Krajenski, at least to start with. The episode borrows from The Thing From Another World, the 1951 adaptation of John W. Cambell Jnr.'s Who Goes There? The isolation, along with the very real threat that the coopted Defiant poses, helps to build the tension throughout.

The episode also builds on the premise that 'no Changeling has ever harmed another' - a phrase that had been repeated several times through the series' third season. Odo and 'Krajenski's' final fight in engineering sets one of the largest plot threads in Star Trek history into motion, not least with the final warning - you are too late. We are everywhere.

That the episode achieves its aims while barely leaving the Defiant's confines is a triumph. 

3. Where Silence Has Lease

Where Silence Has Lease is an early episode of The Next Generation's second season, featuring a vocal cameo from The Terminator's Earl Boen as the ghostly apparition of Nagilum. Though the episode features nebulae, holes in space, and Romulan Warbirds - it never truly leaves the Enterprise.

Advertisement

Director Winrich Kolbe was introduced to Star Trek in this outing and would go on to direct such episodes as All Good Things. He found the restriction of having to film primarily on the bridge challenging. As he described it - visiting the bridge was exciting. Remaining on the bridge was dull - tan walls, that carpet, and not much space to move.

This pushed him into more choreography than had previously been seen on the ship, as well as playing with the effects to keep things interesting. When Riker and Worf board 'the Yamato', the background hum of the bridge noises is slightly off - signifying that all is not well on board the ship.

Showrunner Maurice Hurley was pleased with how the episode played out, enjoying that it pushed the scientific sides of these characters a little further than an encounter with the Ferengi, or even the Borg, would have done. 

2. Lower Decks

Lower Decks is an episode that has such a strong legacy that it can sometimes be easy to forget it was a bottle show. The Next Generation's seventh season is dotted with gems, if perhaps the year overall meandered here and there. Lower Decks is a particular highlight, and Shannon Fill's (almost) final turn as Sito Jaxa stands above all else.

Advertisement

Though the action rarely leaves the Enterprise in this episode, switching the focus to these junior officers allowed audiences a fresh glance at the inner workings of the flagship. We were already familiar with Nurse Ogawa, and of course, Sito, but all five (let's not forget Ben!) of these people stand out.

The episode is of course most famous for its crushing finale, but stands as a perfect example of how to handle a cost-saving exercise and still deliver on the promise of exploration and inter-personal relationships. 

Though the mean folk over on Star Trek: Lower Decks seem to have confirmed Sito's death, we still cling to no body = no death here, so for now, Sito still lives, perhaps having adventures in the shuttle with her new Cardassian friend. One can but dream. 

1. Shuttlepod One

Shuttlepod One has taken on a life of its own, with dramatic readings of the script to mark the episode's anniversary, and an entire podcast featuring Conner Trinneer and Dominic Keating, but the original episode was intended to be a small-scale event.

Advertisement

Small scale, that is, in that only six of the show's main cast members appear on screen. The bulk of the story takes place in the eponymous craft, with the audience watching Trip and Reed grow their beards, wrap up in blankets, and comment on their colleagues' bums, while the oxygen levels drop.

The episode is perhaps best remembered for truly humanising Reed, who until that point had been a little rigid in his role as tactical officer. Here, we learned that he was, in fact, a raging lothario back on Earth. Trip listens to him record his various goodbye letters to his various lovers, and both character and audience alike are shocked.

As often happens with bottle shows, this installment became a favourite of cast and fans alike. Manny Coto wrote a reference to this story into the script for Similitude, the third season episode that broke hearts worldwide, with Keating in particular citing this episode as his favourite outing. 

Advertisement