10 Best True Crime Documentaries Of 2021 (So Far)
Need some new docs to binge? These are the best ones currently on Netflix (and beyond).
"Crime doesn't pay".
If you're Netflix, that's nonsense. The grim world of murder, fraud, scandal and mystery certainly does reap huge rewards for the streaming service, and they've been quietly cranking out some bangers in 2021. The good news is that they're not the only ones - there's another top documentary on this very list that's exclusive to another platform.
Admittedly, most of them are from Netflix though, and with good reason. They've become masters of diving headfirst into a world of corruption, evil and lawlessness. Has there been anything to rival the outright absurdity of 2020's Tiger King, or the macabre of The Ripper? How about that same year's insanely-deep Ted Bundy: Falling For A Killer over on Amazon Prime?
Absolutely.
Strange disappearances go under the microscope here, and they're joined by profiles on some of the sickest serial killers to ever walk the streets. If that doesn't suit you, then there's also an outrageous doc on one seriously warped community, and even a splash of sensationalism that complements the dark story being told.
These are the best/most must-see true crime accounts 2021 has thrown up so far...
10. Murder Among The Mormons
The best crime stories add a touch of unpredictability to the case, and 'Murder Among The Mormons' has that in spades. Mark Hofmann, who was injured during a spate of 1980s bombings in Salt Lake City, Utah, provides a fascinatingly erratic case study here.
Don't discount this one on the sole basis that religion isn't your thing either - there's so much more to the story, but attempted exploitation of the Mormon church is definitely the centrepiece. Hofmann's forgeries weave across just three episodes, which makes the series short enough to tackle in one sitting.
Like many binge-friendly mini-series, you likely will be there till the end.
MATM is a gripping look at how community shapes its justice system. If that sounds like an odd sentence, then fire up the first episode and take a look for yourself. Hofmann, a colourful character who isn't as he first appears, got very bold with his aforementioned forgeries. Very bold.
9. The College Admissions Scandal
How far would you go to ensure your kid got into the right college? For some families, the answer is: REALLY far. In fact, those with money might not think twice about bribing administrators to get what they want. That, and the case of ex-high school basketball coach, Rick Singer, frames this one.
Its full title, for the record, is 'Operation Varsity Blues: The College Admissions Scandal'.
Singer reportedly made millions from down low payments that made sure children (who hadn't qualified) got into the right schools. Some celebrities were wrapped up in all of this too, which only adds to the drama sprinkled through the 103 minute special.
This doc was so controversial that one party (John B. Wilson) sued Netflix for misrepresentation. That side narrative shouldn't stop you from checking out what's on offer here though, or from scratching your head over how Singer hasn't been locked up to this day.
8. This Is A Robbery
Quick confession: This writer originally thought that 'This Is A Robbery' would be boring. After all, the subtitle is, "The World's Biggest Art Heist', and that's a bit of a niche topic. The kicker is that those responsible for the heist didn't just steal one or two valuable paintings - they stole 13.
Two men dressed up as police on the morning of 18 March 1990 and successfully swindled a staggering $500 million worth of artwork from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. The actual police (not just lads dressed up like them) offered $10m to anyone who could bring the paintings back where they belonged.
The mystery is still ongoing.
Arguably the best thing about the doc is that it maps out how the duo pulled off their daring heist in the first place. You might just find yourself sucked into this four-parter - before you know it, you'll be hunting for those paintings yourself. OK, maybe not.
7. Elize Matsunaga: Once Upon A Crime
'Once Upon A Crime' has a neat twist. Namely, the killer (Elize Matsunaga herself) comes along for the ride and freely answers questions about her crimes. In 2016, Elize confessed to murdering her husband Marcos four years prior. She then cut his body into pieces.
Matsunaga cuts a calm figure as she recalls Marcos' adultery and the breakdown of their relationship. It's all quite harrowing stuff, but Elize seems like a normal-enough person throughout, and her dysfunctional marriage to her husband is almost as gripping as the grisly murder details. That's the hook here; Matsunaga still isn't quite sure what caused her to go so far. Adultery is cited as one reason, but never an excuse for what happened.
Elize now resides in a maximum security prison close to where she lived with Marcos in São Paulo. There's something altogether chilling about that fact alone, and the series doesn't shy away from the length (19 years) of her sentence.
6. Why Did You Kill Me?
Many people are drawn in by crime docs (particularly murder-based ones) because of the unanswered questions about why folks did what they did. In 'Why Did You Kill Me?', asking such questions isn't just encouraged - it's the point.
Tortured mother Belinda Lane wants to know why her 24-year old daughter Crystal was shot dead by thugs in 2006. More than that, Belinda wants justice for Crystal, and promised never to rest until she gets it. The determination is admirable, the heartbreak is tragic (Belinda was in the car behind Crystal when gang members opened fire on her vehicle in LA) and the fact that Lane used MySpace to seek answers sounds like something out of a movie.
This is as real and raw as drama gets.
Incredibly, Lane created a fake MySpace profile for Crystal and systematically hunted down her daughter's killers. She got into lots of legal trouble herself, but there's a sense of natural justice about the entire story that's hard to switch off from.
5. Confronting A Serial Killer
Time for a break from Netflix.
'Confronting A Serial Killer' aired on Starz instead, and it charts the forged relationship between author Jillian Lauren and prolific murderer Sam Little. You've probably never heard of Little, but he's one of the most dangerous serial killers in history; Sam killed at least 60 people during his reign of terror.
As the title suggests, Lauren confronts Little and tries to get him to talk about his crimes. Of course, she's unsuccessful at first, but Jillian refuses to give up and eventually gets a few things out of the cold-blooded butcher. This is one for those who prefer hearing details about a serial killers mindset and approach.
It'll cause goosebumps.
Lauren's dedication to the cause across five episodes will have you rooting her on. Meanwhile, talking head comments from a few family members of the victims might leave you depressed. There's a real fine line between the psychological detective work being done and real people picking up the pieces of their lives.
4. John Wayne Gacy: Devil In Disguise
Few reading this need an introduction to the horrors of one John Wayne Gacy. His run of brutal murders between 1972-1978 claimed a reported 33 lives and turned him into one of the world's most shocking serial killers. So, what more can be said after decades of documentation?
Maybe some words from the man himself, and some revelations about his family.
That's what 'Devil In Disguise' goes for. It mixes interview footage with Gacy (filmed shortly before his death by lethal injection in 1994) with comments from friends and family members who knew him best. The result is a whirlwind trip through the psyche of a remorseless murderer who lived a warped double life.
Pictures of John dressed up as a clown should be enough to give most people nightmares, but he was arguably even more chilling out of the greasepaint. Don't sleep on this one despite the fact that Gacy has been examined countless times.
3. The Vanishing At The Cecil Hotel
Some reviewers haven't been kind to Netflix 'Crime Scene: The Vanishing At Cecil Hotel', but it's still worth your time for the sheer mystery of it all. In 2013, the body of 21-year old Eilsa Lam was found floating in a water tank on the roof of the titular Cecil Hotel in LA.
CCTV footage from beforehand showed a clearly-distressed Lam hiding in an elevator and acting strangely; that will be most people's introduction to the case, because clips of that went viral online before the release of this four-part documentary investigation into Lam and the unsettling history of the Cecil.
Tragedy and conspiracy theory mix to great effect here - nothing seems to be normal about the hotel. The filmmakers did a nifty job of setting the scene for Eilsa's disappearance by exploring the Cecil's past, then Lam's death is a hammer blow that'll leave you stunned.
Ignore the negative reviews and give it a chance if you're into mysteries and conspiracy theory.
2. The Sons Of Sam
A word of warning about 'The Sons Of Sam: A Descent Into Darkness' going in: Maury Terry, the journalist who acts as the main focus here, died in 2015. His accounts are read by actor Paul Giamatti, so there's a dramatic tinge to the narrative that some won't favour.
Don't let it put you off, 'cause this is one hell of a story.
Maury dedicated his life to proving that killer David Berkowitz, who murdered six people between 1976-1977, wasn't acting alone. His findings were documented in the 1988 book 'The Ultimate Evil', but more about Berkowitz has come to light since then, and it's all here.
Giamatti does a masterful job of playing Terry without over-doing it, and the doc drums up new questions about a legendary case. Anyone interested in Charles Manson, cults and/or seriously deep investigations will get a kick out of 'The Sons Of Sam'.
It's one of the best true crime examples on the market right now.
1. Night Stalker
Like 'The Vanishing At The Cecil Hotel', some reviewers bemoaned the sensationalistic approach to retelling Richard Ramirez' story in 'Night Stalker'. That's fair enough, but it must be hard to talk about these subjects without succumbing to a little drama here and there.
It kinda' comes with the territory, and it's why so many people are interested in the first place.
Fresh knowledge from detectives Gil Carrillo and Frank Salerno makes 'Night Stalker' an essential watch regardless. Four parts also seems to be the sweet spot for Netflix, and they absolute nail the pacing here. Ramirez is introduced gently, the officers come across as well-meaning citizens and there's a particularly tense moment at a dental surgery in episode three that'll get your heart racing.
Is it exhaustive? Probably not, but this is one of the most watchable serial killer docu-series you're likely to see. It successfully puts across the idea that Ramirez terrorised an entire city as well as his unfortunate victims.
Which 2021 true crime documentary is your favourite so far? For more crime content, check out 10 Things We Learned From VICE’s Dark Side Of The Ring: New Jack and 10 Things Netflix’s Ted Bundy Documentary Left Out!