Doctor Who returns to our screens this week with a new, much older, form thanks to the casting of 12th Doctor Peter Capaldi. For Capaldi's debut episode, titled Deep Breath, the Doctor Who team are going all out to ensure success. Penned by showrunner Steven Moffat and directed by Kill List and Sightseers' Ben Wheatley, Deep Breath surrounds Capaldi with plenty of familiar faces, from Jenna Coleman's returning companion Clara to the inter-species lesbian mystery solvers (and their baked potato headed manservant) the Paternoster Gang. As the presence of the latter should clue us in to, the episode sends the Doctor back to the Victorian age where, in this case, a tyrannosaur is loose on the streets. Thanks in part to this recurring cast of Victorian characters, 19th century London (or Cardiff) is rapidly catching up with 21st century London (or Cardiff) as the place the Doctor keeps coming back to out of all of space and time. The Victorian period has, however, always been a popular one with the Doctor Who producers. Maybe it's because the popular fictions of the period provide ample (and public domain) inspirations as the Victoriana aesthetic makes up so much of the Doctor's personal style. Maybe it's because a period drama view of BBC Britishness is easily marketable to the show's increasingly keen US audience. Maybe it's just because of the abundant, easily accessible filming locations that aren't quarries. Whatever the reason, the Doctor loves a Victorian adventure. Here are ten of the best against which to measure Deep Breath.
Honourable Mention
For the purposes of this list, "Victorian" has been defined as Britain in the 19th century (albeit not necessarily bound by the reign of Queen Victoria herself). Doctor Who's love of Victoriana, however, extends to other times and places. Not only have there been relatively frequent visits to other parts of the world in the 19th century (from the Wild West to Van Gogh's Arles, and that's just in the past couple of years), but even other worlds in the distant future are not averse to a Victorian theme. Perhaps the standout of these future-Victoriana-worlds is A Christmas Carol, the Michael Gambon starring festive special set in a Dickensian city with bonus flying sharks. Probably the best of the Christmas specials of the Nu-Who era, A Christmas Carol is a fine piece of neo-Victorianism, but let's get on with the Doctor's adventures in the real 19th century.
10. The Crimson Horror
Writer Mark Gatiss went back to his Northern roots for this Yorkshire set episode in which iconic Yorkshire actress Dame Diana Rigg not only gets to use her native accent for once, but also appear alongside her daughter. Gatiss' grim oop North script riffs off Sherlock Holmes, understandably given his other collaboration with Moffat, and real social, industrial history to create a mystery around strange goings on at a Saltaire-esque model community. Inspired by the "repulsive story of the red leech" referenced but never further described in the original Holmes stories, The Crimson Horror is a decent mash-up of mystery and Gothic with the fact that the Doctor is sidelined for much of the early part of the episode giving the supporting cast a chance to shine. Sonataran butler Strax's once amusing shtick is becoming a little tiresome and there is a particularly lame GPS gag, but the episode does develop the character of Jenny into a far more interesting and adventurous one than in her previous mostly sidekick-centric appearances. The real draw here, though, is Rigg. Gatiss wrote the part of the villainous Mrs. Gillyflower, who is in a bizarre symbiotic relationship with a poisonous red leech, specifically for the Game of Thrones star on discovering that she had never acted opposite her daughter Rachael Stirling. The existent family dynamic gives extra weight to the twisted relationship between Mrs. Gillyflower and her blind daughter Ada, played by Stirling, while Rigg is clearly having a ball playing such an evil character.
9. The Mark Of The Rani
Another Northern set episode saw the 6th Doctor and companion Peri visiting the mining village of Killingworth, home of railway pioneer George Stephenson. The Mark of the Rani is actually set a few years before Victoria ascended to the throne, but its industrial themes and setting are still distinctly "Victorian" in style. According to this story Luddite rioters were miners turned violent by mind altering chemicals found in the gases of a suspicious bath house. Colin Baker's curmudgeonly harlequin take on the hero and Nicola Bryant's busty "American" student sidekick are not the most fondly remembered inhabitants of the TARDIS, but this two part serial is one of their better stories. This is due in large part to the fact that the story pitches the Doctor against not one but two renegade Time Lords in an uneasy and antagonistic alliance with each other. While this story marks the return of Anthony Ainley's Master, intent on using the rapid technological developments of the age as a spur to world domination, it is his rival the Rani that makes the story memorable. Written by husband and wife team Pip and Jane Baker and played by soap actor Kate O'Mara, the Rani was the only major female Time Lord (Time Lady?) antagonist in the show and was very popular for it. She remains widely rumoured for a return to the rebooted series if and when more Time Lord characters are likely to appear. The serial has some silliness (a bit with a human-tree transformation is ludicrous), but is best remembered for the manipulative mad scientist villainess and did provide both Victorians and a tyrannosaur long before the 12th Doctor's debut.
8. The Snowmen
Doctor Who is now a fixture in the festive TV line-up and nobody does Christmas quite like the Victorians. So it came as no surprise to find the 11th Doctor, moping over the sort-of death of Amy and Rory, hiding out in snowy Victorian London at Christmas 2012. This time, however, the snow was more than holiday themed set dressing, as the Doctor found himself faced with battling monstrous aggressive snowmen under the control of the cold hearted Dr. Simeon. Richard E. Grant had played a couple of non-canonical versions of the Doctor in the past, but was perfectly cast as a mean spirited, miserly Victorian bad guy, although the principle villain of the piece turned out to be the Gandalf-voiced Great Intelligence making its first appearance since 1968. Grant was good enough to make a return as the Intelligence's corporeal form in the better-than-usual season finale The Name of the Doctor, but there's plenty to enjoy in his more messed up human performance here. This episode also marked the return of Jenna Coleman in her second incarnation. Having been last seen as a souffle loving dying dalek, she was back as a feisty barmaid-cum-governess, confusing the Doctor and setting up the central mystery of the episodes that followed. Victorian Clara is probably her most engaging incarnation, as well as being more different from other modern companions than her 21st century au pair/teacher self, so it's kind of a shame that Moffat and co. didn't stick with their original plan and make her the permanent version of the character. It would be nice to have a historical companion again.
7. Ghost Light
Impressively ambitious and complex (for many, read: confusing and hard to follow) Ghost Light showed that Doctor Who had plenty of ideas even in the dying days of the original show. It must be said, though, that stories like this weren't exactly winning over the casual viewers that the series needed at this point. The last episode of the original run to be produced, although not the last aired, the story has 7th Doctor Sylvester McCoy making companion Ace confront her fears and her pyromaniac past by returning her to the "haunted" Victorian manner that she once burnt down. From there on the story involves a Neanderthal butler, a mad explorer out to hunt Queen Victoria, and a creepy presence in the cellar (which turns out to be not so much a cellar as a massive stone spaceship). The Theory of Evolution is the big Victorian theme on show here (along with the concept of the Victorian haunted house) with the story's alien threat attempting to evolve into the era's dominant lifeform, the Victorian British man. Much of this can be hard to keep up with, though, as writer Marc Platt's long script was cut down to a three part serial to the point where even the cast didn't know what was going on half the time. This does at least contribute to a sense of unease in an unusually dark storyline that saw McCoy showcasing a more hard edged, calculating Doctor, although he does say "wicked" at the end.
6. Tooth And Claw
Ghost Light features a plot to achieve world domination by getting close to and then killing Queen Victoria and it must be a good scheme because here it is again courtesy of a Scottish werewolf in this 10th Doctor episode. Tooth and Claw was one of the first adventures for David Tennant's cooler and more enthusiastic version of the character and showcased his growing chemistry with Billie Piper's Rose, much of it revolving around trying to get Her Majesty to pronounce herself not amused. Pauline Collins had first featured in Doctor Who in 1967 when she turned down a permanent companion role after appearing in the 2nd Doctor story The Faceless Ones. The Doctor's Scottish alias here, James McCrimmon, is a reference to that story's companion and gives Tennant a rare chance to use his own accent briefly (and make yet another Sherlock Holmes reference in claiming to have studied at Edinburgh under Dr. Bell, Holmes' real life inspiration). In Tooth and Claw, Collins plays a formidable Queen Victoria, humanised by her grief over Albert, with a pragmatic sense and sharp tongue, but equally stern and judgmental in the face of the Doctor's flighty attitude to danger. In the end she both knights him and banishes him, creating a significant piece of modern Who mythology in establishing the institute named after this episode's setting: Torchwood House. The actual monster, the space werewolf, is underdeveloped and the effects are not up to making it feel real, but writer and showrunner Russell T. Davies was always better at character dynamics than big monsters and this episode offers plenty of Gothic atmosphere in the build up, in particular the discussion of ghost stories at dinner.
5. The Evil Of The Daleks
A pair of mad Victorian scientists create a time travel device using static electricity and mirrors in the first great Doctor Who Victorian story. Only the middle of the story is set in the Victorian era, though, with the first part involving a shady antiques dealer who turns out to be getting his second hand goods first hand, and the reveal that everything is part of a Dalek trap moving the final parts to Skaro. The bulk of the story takes place in a big manor house full of booby traps where the Doctor's companion Jamie attempts to rescue inventor's daughter Victoria, who would become the next companion. 2nd Doctor Patrick Troughton seems awfully happy to help the Dalek plan to use Jamie to extract "the human factor" that will make them unstoppable, largely because more human Daleks prove far less interested in widespread extermination (a lesson the Nazi pepper pots repeatedly fail to learn with every variant on the human-Dalek hybrid). The Evil of the Daleks was intended to be a send off for the Daleks with Terry Nation trying to flog his creation to America and, indeed, it would be five years before they appeared again, but it also ensured their popularity in the long term. A 1993 poll considered this the best Doctor Who story of all time on the show's 30th anniversary. Unfortunately it is very difficult to ascertain the truth of that thanks to the BBC's tendency to reuse tapes during the 1960s. Only one episode of this seven part serial survives and that was found at a car boot sale. The one part that does survive, which introduces both the Victorians and Victoria, is enough to convince that this would be worth seeing.
4. The Next Doctor
The rebooted Doctor has flirted with a steam punk aesthetic almost as often as he's flirted with Captain Jack Harkness, but the Christmas special that saw a gigantic steam powered Cyberman stomping through Victorian London is the closest the show has come to becoming a full on steam punk extravaganza. It's all part of a ploy by sinister Miss Hartigan, played by voice of Marks and Spencer Dervla Kirwan, who is taking children from the workhouse to build her giant CyberKing, a creature that it takes two Doctors to stop. Sort of.
With 10th Doctor David Tennant having recently announced the impending end of his tenure in the blue box, it was easy for audiences to believe that the eponymous Next Doctor might genuinely be the man that the BBC were lining up as number 11. Given the quality of David Morrissey's adventuresome yet emotional performance it's almost a disappointment that this was not the case.
Advertisement
As it was, though, there was plenty of pathos in both Russell T. Davies' script and Morrissey's performance to make the reveal that his "Doctor" was really teacher and near Cyberman victim Jackson Lake imprinted with the Doctor's life story an affecting one. With his not-so-sonic screwdriver and TARDIS that is really a hot air balloon, Lake is a fun creation that imagines how a genuinely Victorian Doctor might function.
3. Horror Of Fang Rock
Set in the early 20th century this storyline may almost be too late to be Victorian (reference is made to King Edward VII), but given that it's real world inspiration, the unexplained disappearance of three lighthouse keepers in Scotland's Flannan Isles, happened in 1900 it probably still counts (the Doctor even quotes from the Wilfrid Wilson Gibson poem Flannan Isle at the end of the final part of the serial, just to make the inspiration obvious). Another story inspired by a cursed or haunted setting, Horror of Fang Rock was a four part serial penned by regular Doctor Who writer Terrance Dicks in which 4th Doctor Tom Baker and his savage warrior woman companion Leela (in less revealing costume than usual) wind up on an island off the South coast, rumoured to be cursed by a "Beast" and home to a lighthouse whose power is erratic at best and a dead lighthouse keeper. After the failing electricity of the lighthouse causes a ship to crash into the rock, it becomes clear that it is not the only crash landing here. An alien ship belonging to the Sonatarans' mortal enemy the Rutans has also crashed and poses a serious threat to the lighthouse and its occupants. The isolated foggy lighthouse is a classic ghostly setting and is well used here, keeping the serial tightly focused on a small amount of locations and characters means that a genuinely unsettling creepy atmosphere is maintained throughout. Dicks' script has few ambitions beyond being a solid slice of sci-fi horror and in sticking to that focus it succeeds admirably.
2. The Unquiet Dead
The return of Doctor Who in 2005 was a major TV event that generated a lot of press coverage and debate. Christopher Eccleston's damaged but charming performance remains a standout in the generations of actors who have played the role. However, the really good stories involving Eccleston's 9th Doctor and companion Rose didn't really get going until mid-way through the one series the actor appeared in. That is, with the exception of The Unquiet Dead, a finely crafted piece of Whovian Christmas chiller from a clear admirer of the form. Regular Doctor Who and Christmas ghost story writer Mark Gatiss began his work on TV Doctor Who here and (with the exception of the excellent "making of" drama An Adventure in Space and Time) he has yet to match this episode in his other writing for the show. While not actually aired at Christmas, The Unquiet Dead has all the elements of a good Dickens holiday ghost story (note how aficionado Gatiss has his Doctor tell Dickens he loves the scariness of The Signalman, memorably dramatised in A Ghost Story For Christmas, the same series for which Gatiss would later write). The episode, in which alien species the Gelth exist only in gaseous form and leap from gaslight to reanimated corpse made good use of the Victorian setting, even adding a spooky seance for good measure, and introduced the concept of the "Rift" in space and time running through Cardiff (which proved useful for explaining why so much happens there and set up a future spin-off). The star turn, though, is Simon Callow's Dickens. After all these years of one man shows and the like, Callow is basically a career Dickens and knows just how to bring the writer to life as a slightly miserable but ultimately brilliant man.
1. The Talons Of Weng-Chiang
The serial that immediately preceded Horror of Fang Rock in the 4th Doctor and Leela's adventures was a six part serial widely regarded as one of the greatest Doctor Who stories of them all. Coming at a time when the show was at its most popular and producer Peter Hinchcliffe attempted to make Hammer Horror-esque stories for a family audience, The Talons of Weng-Chiang mashed up Arthur Conan Doyle and Sax Rohmer for a fun slice of lurid pulp Victoriana. The first part of the serial alone involves Chinese magicians, ventriloquism, gangs, and a giant rat that lives in the sewer and that's even before it gets to the mysterious Weng-Chiang and his search for the Time Cabinet. There's also a homunculus at some point. That the story received some criticism at the time for being too disturbing (and indeed was partly responsible for the later shift to a sillier tone) should probably prove a selling point to audiences today. Tom Baker enjoys himself thoroughly in a performance that ditches his trademark scarf in favour of Sherlock Holmes' deerstalker. In fact, The Talons of Weng-Chiang contains even more Holmes references than the Moffat era. The "Yellow Peril" nature of the story means that it would be unlikely to be made now. If modern audiences can get beyond the somewhat suspect characterisation of the Chinese characters, however, they will be rewarded with one of the most well written, enjoyably Gothic stories in the whole of Doctor Who.