10 Confusing Game Of Thrones Moments Nobody Understands
In the game of thrones, you either win or get confused.
The return of Game Of Thrones has fans scrambling for their season 5 DVDs in order to remember who everyone is, where they are, and what they’re doing.
Understandably, tracking the whereabouts of the numerous brooding, mostly bearded men (and one blonde woman) battling for the Iron Throne can be a confusing task, and it’s not helped by certain moments of the show that appear to be designed to confuse the viewer.
To be fair, it's understandable that not every set up will pay off and there will be some scenes that don't make sense until way down the line - adapting George R. R. Martin's sprawling fantasy epics into an easily digestible TV show was never going to be a simple task.
And yet, the Herculean task of bringing the Seven Kingdoms to life does not necessarily excuse entire subplots that spent a whole season to go nowhere, characters entirely disappearing from the narrative or just downright baffling moments.
An assassin made of smoke, anyone?
Let's get to it...
10. Jon Sends Sam Away
Let's do a little thought excercise. Imagine you're a young, talented soldier and have risen swiftly to the very top of your profession. The leader of your squadron, if you will. Let's imagine that the rest of the group is largely filled with set-in-their-ways old men who are, to put it mildly, distrustful of you.
Now let's imagine that one of your first act as leader is to open the doors of your fortress to the very people you are meant to be fighting, which further alienates the rest of your group. Mutiny is very much in the air.
In this scenario, what would you decide to do with your only remaining friend and ally? Would you keep him by your side, knowing that without at least one person to defend you you will at the mercy of a group of men who may well be planning to kill you? Or would you send him far away so he could get an education?
If you answered "send him far away" then you are Jon Snow, and you've just ensured your own demise by sending Samwell Tarly away from Castle Black. Totally isolated, it wasn't long until Snow was killed by the rest of the Watch, making Jon's decision to keep his enemies close and his friends impossibly distant all the more confusing.
9. Where Is Gendry?
Remember Gendry? I can't blame you if you don't, we haven't seen him now for two seasons (and counting).
Gendry was a blacksmith, Arya's friend and the (unknowing) illegitimate son of King Robert. The show hinted that the character may end up having a big say in the fate of the Iron Throne, but was last seen on a rowboat in season 3 after being freed from the machinations of Stannis and Melisandre by the ever-noble Davos Seaworth. Why was it hinted that he'd have such importance, only for him to be totally forgotten?
We still haven't seen or heard of Gendry's ultimate fate, so he could yet return before Game Of Thrones' tale is told, but as far as we know he's still bobbing about on some unnamed sea in a rowboat. Such a confusing waste of a promising character.
8. Daenerys Ruling Meereen
Daenerys Targaryen is a fan favourite Game Of Thrones, and why not? She's one of the few characters on a notoriously bleak show that tries to do the right thing, and might actually be a good and just ruler if she ever gets to sit on the Iron Throne. Also, she has dragons.
Her quest to take back the throne that she believes is her birthright has only gone as far as Essos to date, way across the sea from where she plans to end up. During her time liberating far flung cities, she spent a long time in Meereen, ruling the city from its Great Pyramid.
This is how she spent most of the most recent season, listening to requests from her subjects, settling disputes and generally just being Judge Judy inside a pyramid. Could she not have left one of her trusted advisers to rule in her stead and continued her march to the Iron Throne? She commands dragons, and yet locked them away to be queen of a backwater city no one cares about. Surely a head-scratching decision.
7. Tyrion Kills Tywin
Tyrion killing his father is not that confusing - it makes sense, given his father Tywin spent almost all his time on screen barely bothering to conceal his hatred for him.
One of season 5's big "oh my god" moments had certainly been building, but the actual context of the scene is confusing. The catalyst for the murder isn't any of the awful things Tywin says to Tyrion, instead it's that he calls his son's ex-girlfriend Shea a...well, not a very nice word. Fair enough, ordinarily - but remember, Tyrion himself had literally just murdered her. Why would he care at that point?
Don't forget, at one point Tywin tells Tyrion that he wanted to drown him when he was born. Tyrion lets that one pass, but kills him for insulting Shea? Where's the logic in that?
6. Theon's Fake Escape
Theon Greyjoy should be a more likeable character than he actually is. He might still go on to become a hero - the tail end of season five saw the beginnings of what looks like a spinal regrowth for a character snapping out of his "Reek" waking coma.
Of course, there's one man responsible for Theon's broken spirit, and every viewer hopes that man will end up on the pointy end of the a blade sometime soon: Ramsey Bolton. Theon spends much of the third season as a prisoner in the Dreadfort, physically and psychologically tortured by Roose Bolton's insane son.
Things get weird(er) when Theon actually believes he has escaped. The fake escape is in fact an elaborate ruse by Ramsey, but it's really elaborate. Not only does Ramsey break Theon out of the Dreadfort, but he gives him a horse and even goes as far as killing his own soldiers to keep up the ruse before eventually, of course, Theon ends up back in captivity.
We get that Ramsey wants to break Theon's spirit, but why go to all that trouble? Wasn't fingernail pulling and genital removing enough? Killing a handful of good soldiers for a prank isn't a strategy that makes a lot of sense for a wannabe leader like Ramsey.
5. Stannis' Smoke Monster
Game Of Thrones has had a lot of recognisable guest stars over the years, but do you remember that time the smoke monster from Lost made an appearance?
OK, so it's not the same one, but when an apparently pregnant Melisandre - a Red Priestess and advisor/lover of would-be King Stannis Boratheon - birthed some man-shaped smoke inside a cave, many viewers were scratching their heads and harking back to the infamously impenetrable Lost.
The explanation for exactly why and how the coupling of Stannis and Melisandre resuted in a temporarily sentient wisp of smoke has not yet been explained and probably never will be. It's magic, deal with it. The smoke monster did assassinate Stannis' brother and rival for the Iron Throne, King Renly. It was perfectly done - Renly dies, no one quite knows how, and no one can link anything back to Stannis.
So, why not do it again? Why not make a list of enemies like Arya Stark does and have your smoke babies smoke-murder them?
Using magic powers as a Deux Ex Machina is pretty strange, never using them again for no real reason is even stranger.
4. Jaime And Bron In Dorne
Season 5 was quite divisive among fans, and one of those reasons can be expressed in one groan-inducing word: Dorne.
The trip to the exotic, far-flung kingdom was greeted with excitement by many, but Jaime Lannister and Bron strolling around in the Dornish sunshine in search of Jaime's daughter-niece Myrcella didn't really go anywhere and left everyone wondering how the scenes had not ended up on the cutting room floor.
There was a payoff in the end - as the reunited Jamie and Myrcella sail home towards King's Landing, we learn that she had been poisoned by the revenge seeking Dorish Princess Ellaria Sand. But to get there did we have to meet the disappointing Sand Snakes and see endless scenes of one of them flirting with Bron in prison?
The poisoning and subsequent death could have been done in one or two scenes and it's not clear why anyone saw hours of dull footage and thought "yeah, let's stretch that out over several episodes".
3. Bran And The Three-Eyed Raven
Kind of like Gendry, Bran Stark is another character you might have forgotten all about. He has not totally disappeared, but he did sit out the entirety of season 5. He's due to return - looking about ten years older judging by footage seen in the trailers - to hopefully clear up one of the shows most confusing moments to date.
Bran spent much of his time on screen being assailed by disturbing visions of a three-eyed raven. Bran sets out to find the source of these visions, and with the help of his trusty Hodor and new companions Jojen and Meera, he eventually does.
His path leads him to a tree on a hill, and this is where Game Of Thrones got very weird, very quickly. Bran's group was first attacked by re-animated skeletons before being assisted by a pixie-like forest-dwelling child, who brings them to safety inside the tree. If that wasn't enough, inside the tree is an old man - the three-eyed raven himself, his very limbs fused to the trees roots. He solemnly informs Bran that although he will never walk again, he will learn to fly...and that was the last we saw of Bran for a whole season's worth of episodes.
That scene may have meant more if you've read the books, but if you haven't, the sudden unexplained appearance of forest pixies and a magical tree-man might make you wonder exactly what you're watching.
2. Arya And The Faceless Men
Season 5 had its problems, among them Arya’s long stint learning her trade in the House of Black and White, home to assassins known as the Faceless Men.
I was one of those with high hopes for the storyline, hoping Arya would learn some cool face-switching black magic and use it to enact her revenge upon those who had wrong and killed (most of) the Stark family.
Instead, what we got were innumerable scenes of Arya doing menial tasks, ostensibly to help her learn her skills (like a Westerosi version of Daniel in Karate Kid), and it wasn’t exactly thrilling. We got to see her taunted by someone who may or may not be a young girl, and a man who may or may not be Jaqen H'ghar utter enigmatic nothings.
Did we need an entire season of that? Those in charge of Game Of Thrones seemed to think so.
1. Why Do The White Walkers Need Babies?
The Night's King is an enigmatic character in the Game Of Thrones universe; the frosty, undead and (presumably) immortal leader of the White Walkers. We've seen glimpses of his power thus far, notably in season 5's epic "Hardhome", but it's a scene from the previous season that prompted questions the show has not yet answered.
In the scene in question we see the Night's King touch a baby taken from the wildling Craster, turning it into a White Walker. So far, so sinister. It's a shocking moment and works well as the episodes closing scene - well, until you pause to think about it.
It's confusing really, because why would the White Walkers want babies? Of course, the natural answer is because they want more members for their undead army. But why a baby? We don't know if White Walkers age, but if so they will have to wait a decade (or more) for the baby to be of any use, and if they don't, the they have an undead baby for literally no reason at all.
When you can reanimate the corpses of the dead it doesn't make much sense to bother with tiny infants.