As easy as it is to cringe at embarrassing moments in other shows such as Star Trek (as we've already addressed here, here, and here), there are few shows that have the sheer amount of years necessary to promise decades worth of cringeworthy scenes like Doctor Who does - and this is coming from a fan. Over the course of 50+ years, the show has at times risen to narrative heights unimaginable - but at times it's also dropped to unimaginable lows. Some of this comes from the fact that, bless 'em, they often just didn't have the money necessary to perfect that effect or make that costume more convincing (or convincing at all, as seen above). Sometimes it's a matter of a guest actor getting just a little too happy at having a death scene, or not realizing that delivering a line in that particular way will make it a mini-meme for decades to come. What follows is a mere smattering from the entire show's run - a Whitt-man's sampler of cringe, if you will - but we're planning to address the cringeworthy moments in every decade of the show's existence soon enough. Tell us below in the comments about those Doctor Who moments that made you facepalm, and we may include them in an upcoming article! As usual, your mileage may vary, and what make strike us as cringeworthy may strike you as mere nitpicking. All's fair on the Internet, after all.
10. The First Doctor And The Red Indian - An Unearthly Child
No, that's not the title of some unproduced first season story or a bit of fanfic - that's the first moment that many of us look back upon from the 1960s and cringe at. And for once, it's not Hartnell misdelivering a line - he's spot on. In An Unearthly Child, when Susan is befuddled over why Ian and Barbara can't accept the TARDIS' existence, the Doctor draws her aside and very kindly explains it by making what is in hindsight the most racist analogy he can. He says that she must remember 'the Red Indian' confronted for the first time with a steam train and how his 'savage mind' would have treated it as an illusion the same way that Ian and Barbara's... um, savage minds are reacting to the TARDIS. It's tempting, given what we know about Hartnell, to blame the racism of the line on him, but this phrase was hardly considered racist at the time. Besides, it's right there in bold print in our handy copy of Titan's reprint of the script for The Tribe of Gum (same story, different title). Ian's reaction is to say they're being treated like children. No, sweetie, you're being treated like half-naked savages who wear feathers and do rain dances. If anything, that's worse.
9. 'Oh, Dear... The Myrka' - Warriors Of The Deep
Best we get this one out of the way sooner rather than later, shall we? This one falls under the category of scripts whose writers forgot the budget of the show they were working on. If we read Terrance Dicks' description of the Silurians' 'living weapon' from the Warriors of the Deep novelisation, the Myrka sounds very impressive: 'They caught a glimpse of glowing eyes, corrugated green skin and savage fangs.' The Doctor goes on to describe it as a cyborg, and if you had read the novelisation and hadn't seen the episode yet, as some of us had, that description had you excited at all the possibilities of what you would see. Then you got... ...two men who did pantomime horses for a living in a costume which is the reptilian equivalent of a pantomime horse. 'Oh, dear' doesn't even begin to cover it. Another big problem with the Myrka: it can kill you with a touch, because everything it touches turns to s**t. It's as if everyone's acting skills switch off the moment they see it. Only Davison seems suitably worried about it. The extras who get killed by the thing as they cower away from it along a corridor do fairly convincing dying screams, but then they just... kinda fall as gently as possible to the floor. Can't go hurting yourself if you're only getting five pounds per day and lunch, can you? And then there's... well, just watch. The madness begins at the :38 second mark:We love Ingrid Pitt, we really do, but this... this is enough to send you screaming into the night, or screaming into the nearest pillow with laughter, whichever comes more naturally. More people probably remember this moment and its cringiness than the Myrka itself. But just remember: it all starts with the Myrka. All cringiness starts with the Myrka. All cringiness. The Myrka. The Myrka.
8. The Eleventh Doctor Is 'Doctor Who?' - Asylum Of The Daleks
Most of the time, Matt Smith's bits of mania while playing the Eleventh Doctor can be somewhat entertaining, but the man can't be left alone in the TARDIS. No, seriously - when he is, he has a terrible habit of just dancing around and going on about how great it is that he's so enigmatic. Or maybe we're just remembering one scene that manages to overload the entire 'Doctor Who?' trope that the show's been dangling over our heads for decades just a little too much. It comes at the end of Asylum of the Daleks, after the Doctor has dropped Amy and Rory off at home again. Granted, they've just been discussing his name. For no other apparent reason, all by himself, he's at the top of the stairs, dancing and spinning, and saying 'Doctor Who?' over and over again as he twirls around the console. Well, it's only three times. But for fans who hate it whenever their favourite show is a little too on-the-nose about the show's enigmatic title, this scene feels like it goes on forever. That, and it messes up a perfectly decent Dalek episode. Open hand, insert face, close hand.
7. The Fish People - The Underwater Menace
OK, OK, let's all agree that Doctor Who, particularly in the 1960s, did not have the most... robust budget for things that most science fiction series would consider an absolute necessity, such as special effects and costuming. Despite this knowledge, it is nearly impossible at times not to cringe at what that low budget hath wrought, particularly when it comes to the Fish People in The Underwater Menace. All but Episode Three of this story was missing until 2011, when Episode Two was found. Sadly, that just gives us more chance to see this sort of thing:Let's imagine what the casting call for this episode must've been like: 'Both male and female actors wanted for film work on DR. WHO. Must be able to swim. Must also be willing to have horrible felt eyes glued to one's ocular sockets, to have bits of crap attached to one's face, and to lose all sense of dignity on teatime TV.' Which wouldn't have been so bad, we imagine, if sequences like the one above didn't go on forever. Let's not even talk about the music, shall we? There's only so much of this sort of thing we can take.
6. The Eighth Doctor's 'Who Am Ah?' - The TV Movie
Oh, 1996 - in the form of the American TV Movie, you gave us so much to cringe over. While there are loads to ooh and ahh about in this failed pilot as well, there are more than a few moments that just make you wish that Americans had never heard of Doctor Who. Case in point: the newly regenerated Doctor is making his stumbling way out of the morgue where he's just woken up and into a disused part of the hospital that's under renovation. (Which is why it looks like that. What, you didn't think that all American hospitals had floors open to the elements with broken glass everywhere? Our healthcare may be bad, but it's not that bad.) Anyway, he stumbles in there, somehow avoiding the broken glass on the floor until he sees his own (new) reflection in it. He whispers, 'Who am I?' And then, in one of those rare cases in which McGann decides to eschew subtlety altogether, he drops to the ground, the music swells, the scene is lit by lightning, he throws his arms out Christ-like, and he shouts, "Who...am...ahh?" Yes, he says "Ahh," not "I," dammit. We've run the disc back over that moment so often the laser is wearing a groove into it. It's not a matter of accent differences, either. Oh, and it's an over-the-top moment of cringeworthiness, too.
5. The Seventh Doctor's Solo - The Happiness Patrol
It's like Rose Tyler always says, 'Give a man an open mike...' Sadly, that's exactly what the director does for the Seventh Doctor in The Happiness Patrol - which, you must grant, has several other cringey moments of its own - leading to McCoy giving us his rendition of As Time Goes By. Or it's the Doctor's rendition. Actually, we don't know, and we don't care. It's a moment that makes many of us wince every time, and not just because McCoy does it so over the top. Or maybe it's the fact that he does it at all - we've noticed that genre TV fans get stroppy if their favourite shows get musical, unless it's Buffy, of course. Now, if he were to get up there and tell some funny jokes about something falling from the sky, that would be worth seeing. Hey, wait...
4. Colonel Archer's Dalek Disco Death - Resurrection Of The Daleks
Yeah, yeah, we know - it's not fair in a general list like this to take two examples of the exact same season (the Myrka appeared in Season 21, too) - but did you really think we would leave this one out? The end of Resurrection of the Daleks is pretty damned grim - heck, the entire story is - because it ends in an all-out massacre destroying Daleks and Dalek duplicates alike. This includes Colonel Archer (no relation to Sterling Archer) and his men, who by then have all been killed and replaced by creatures who act just like human beings. Except when they're exterminated. Or maybe this is just the case with Colonel Archer, because when his men are exterminated, they all scream and die, like you do, but he... he... Heh. Heh heh. Hee hee hee hee ha ha ha ha ha hah HAAAH! Sorry, sorry. Heh. He, um, he starts dancing. Or he has an epileptic fit, or something. Heh. Anyway, it's not a normal death. It's quite the embarrassing death, so much so that we couldn't even find a single YouTube video or GIF file of it - that's how much fans seem to want to completely disavow that it ever happened. But please, if you haven't seen it, go seek it out. We all could use a good laugh, even if it utterly destroys the tension of the scene.
3. The Bandril Ambassador - Timelash
Just as with Colonel Archer's unfortunate(ly acted) demise, you can tell how much fans are willing to disavow something by how few images of it you can find doing a Google or Bing search. Our search for an image of the Bandril Ambassador from Timelash - a story that regularly comes in dead last in lists of worst Doctor Who stories - turned up exactly two such images. Neither were of sufficient quality to show just how ghastly this thing is, nor to communicate just how much it makes most fans want to crawl away and die whenever they see it. Now, we've already said that we know Doctor Who always had to work on a shoestring budget, and this story more than any other in the 1980s reveals that, right down to the Christmas tree tinsel in the Timelash itself. But the Bandril Ambassador takes the cake, and could probably hold onto it, too, because he is a hand puppet. Pure and simple. There's no point in even trying to suspend disbelief on this one - disbelief would have to be surgically removed from your body and then transplanted into someone else in order for you to believe this was a serious attempt to suggest an alien lifeform. Much like it would have to be removed and transplanted before you believed that Timelash was a serious attempt at a Doctor Who story.
2. The Fourth Doctor Attacked Hilariously - Nightmare Of Eden
From everything we hear, working on Nightmare of Eden was not fun for anybody, but you wouldn't know it from watching the story. In fact, it's not until you see this story that you realize that John Nathan-Turner, when he took over as producer the following year, might have had a point when he said that Tom Baker's sense of humour needed to be reined in a little. Case in point: the Doctor is being attacked by one of this week's monsters, a Mandrel (not to be confused with Barbara Mandrell and the Mandrell Sisters, a country-western variety show from the same era that also featured monsters on a weekly basis). The Doctor is chased by one into a projection of the monster's home planet Eden (long story), and we hear him rather than see him being chased and attacked by it. And we know he's being chased and attacked by it because of Baker's helpful commentary: 'Steady, steady. This way. Not that way! This. Oh! Oh! Oh, my fingers, my arms, my legs! Ah! My everything! Argh!' Again, no video clips of this exist on YouTube. Can't imagine why. That would mean someone would want to see it, and none of us do. And speaking of things we never, never wanted to see...
1. Mickey And The Burping Garbage Bin - Rose
If this doesn't qualify as the most cringey moment in Doctor Who history, it certainly comes close to qualifying as the most cringey moment in NuWho, and it's one of the moments in the very first episode of the 2005 series that made all us old-timers wonder if we were cut out for the new millennium. You already know the scene we're talking about, even though you fast-forward past it every time, just like we and so many others do. It's when a garbage bin that's been possessed by the Nestene Consciousness decides to lure Mickey Smith into its clutches. It does so by bonding to his hands so he can't get away, then it tugs him back, flips him into the air, catches him, closes its lid... ...and burps. We would likely all agree that everything is fine - or mostly fine - until that burp. Then the cringing begins. Actually, the cringing begins long before that, as we all know what's coming, and we only hope that it won't this time. But it always does. Always. The Myrka. We're sure we've left out plenty of moments that made you embarrassed about your favourite show and everyone involved in it, so if we did, leave them in the comments below!