10 Decisions That Have Already Doomed Upcoming TV Shows

Let's be honest, nobody asked for an Echo series.

By Jack Pooley /

Making a movie is hard, but getting a TV series to the finish line is absolute lunacy.

Advertisement

Generally produced under much tighter time and budgetary constraints than an equivalent film, it's frankly impressive that anyone can produce quality long-form entertainment that sustains interest for hours and hours.

But it's also fair to say that many shows are ultimately doomed to fail because of a creative or business decision made much earlier in the process.

No matter how good parts of the series might be, it comes back to this one gripe which ends up sinking the whole enterprise, either critically, ratings-wise, or both.

These 10 upcoming TV shows, easily some of the most anticipated series of the next 12 months, might already be destined for critical and/or commercial failure because they've committed to an extremely risky idea.

Perhaps they're forging ahead without beloved cast members, have taken way too long to bring a new season to the screen, or even centered the show around a character nobody's really interested in.

It'd certainly be great to be wrong about these shows, but at the same time it's probably best to keep your expectations in check...

10. No Other Original Cast Members - Frasier Revival

On paper it's incredibly easy to see why Paramount is dusting off Frasier, inarguably one of the greatest and most beloved sitcoms of all time, for a revival almost 20 years after its original 11-season run ended.

Advertisement

Described as a "third act" of Frasier's (Kelsey Grammer) story, it goes without saying that there's absolutely an audience curious to see what Frasier, Niles (David Hyde Pierce), Daphne (Jane Leeves), and Roz (Peri Gilpin) have been up for two decades.

Except, the 10-episode revival series won't feature any other legacy characters apart from Frasier himself, with David Hyde Pierce reportedly turning down an offer to return, while Jane Leeves and Peri Gilpin are also apparently not part of the new season.

Instead, Grammer will be joined by Nicholas Lyndhurst, playing Frasier's old college buddy Alan, and Jack Cutmore-Scott appearing as Frasier's son Freddy.

But given that Frasier's entire charm involved him bouncing dialogue off Niles, Daphne, and Ros - not to mention the departed John Mahoney - it's tough to muster much enthusiasm for a revival lacking 80% of its mainline cast.

And even if the show ends up being a pleasant surprise, the missing cast members are sure to diminish interest among all but the most die-hard Frasier fans. This isn't how it was supposed to go.

9. Setting It Up In Another Star Wars Show - The Mandalorian (Season 3)

There's absolutely no denying that The Mandalorian's third season is one of the most anticipated TV shows of the entire year, but it also comes with a huge caveat, that more casual Star Wars fans might end up feeling a little lost.

Advertisement

After all, season two ended with Mando (Pedro Pascal) leaving Grogu with Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill), as provided an intriguing setup for season three.

But this matter was ultimately resolved in another Disney+ Star Wars series, The Book of Boba Fett, where Mando and Grogu were reunited, as will surely confuse just about anyone who didn't watch it.

It perhaps speaks to a wider issue with cinematic universes that have storytelling strands spread across different shows of varying importance. But even so, turning the latter half of The Book of Boba Fett into a glorified Mandalorian season 2.5 was probably a mistake all things considered.

It's easy to suspect that Disney originally planned a more prolonged separation between the two characters, but as Grogu's immense popularity grew they decided to abruptly pivot and get the duo back together.

Either way, it's messy as universe-based storytelling goes, and ensures those who don't obsessively watch every Star Wars series are basically paying the price for it.

8. Recasting Arnold Schwarzenegger & Jamie Lee Curtis - True Lies

It was just a matter of time before James Cameron's hit 1994 spy action-thriller True Lies got adapted into a TV show, but beyond touting a budget that can't hold a candle to the $120 million Cameron movie, the series has made one majorly fatal mistake.

Advertisement

Rather than use the True Lies branding to tell a similar-but-different story about a spy who keeps his job secret from his suburban housewife, the CBS show has literally positioned itself as a reimagining of the film, recasting the roles of Harry and Helen Tasker as played so brilliantly by Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jamie Lee Curtis.

As such, fans of the movie are immediately called to compare the performances of Steve Howey and Ginger Gonzaga to Schwarzenegger and Curtis, and to the surprise of nobody they just don't seem to measure up.

That the uninspired trailer also shows the pair literally reenacting sequences from the Cameron movie only further suggests it's going to listlessly coast off what came before rather than try to fashion its own identity with an identifiable name.

Don't be shocked if True Lies is cancelled long before its first season is even over.

7. Taking Too Long Between Seasons - Good Omens (Season 2)

Believe it or not, Neil Gaiman's Good Omens premiered back in May 2019, and by the time its second season premieres sometime this summer, more than four years will have passed since we last saw it.

Advertisement

Between the long wait and the fact that the first season effectively adapted all of Gaiman and Terry Pratchett's 1990 novel, most surely assumed that Good Omens would be a one-off limited series.

When you consider that Amazon generally isn't great at promoting their shows - at least those not called The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power - it's incredibly easy to believe that the upcoming season two will come and go without making a dent.

Regardless of the new season's ultimate quality, with so many fans assuming the show was over Amazon clearly screwed up by waiting so long to get production going again.

The belated season drop has a strong chance of resulting in underwhelming viewing figures, and in turn ensuring that a potential third season never comes to pass.

6. Bringing Raffi Back - Star Trek: Picard (Season 3)

The third and apparently final season of Star Trek: Picard will once again give the series a soft reset by ditching most of the ongoing cast and reuniting Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart) with his old Enterprise crewmates.

Advertisement

While it's understandable to a point that most of the prior cast members won't return, given that their stories were largely wrapped up, many fans groaned when it was revealed that fanbase punching bag Raffi (Michelle Hurd) would actually be coming back.

It's certainly no fault of actress Michelle Hurd, but Raffi was by far the most widely hated character of Picard's first two seasons, due to her obnoxiously brash personality and generally sloppy, inconsistent characterisation.

Knowing we'll have to put up with a season's worth of Raffi calling Picard "JL" again will place a huge dampener on the nostalgic appeal of seeing Patrick Stewart back with his The Next Generation co-stars.

5. Changing The "Creative Direction" During Shooting - The Idol

On paper, there are many reasons to be excited about HBO's upcoming drama series The Idol.

Advertisement

Co-created by Sam Levinson (Euphoria) and The Weeknd, the show revolves around a pop star (Lily-Rose Depp) who begins a relationship with a cult leader (The Weeknd) in an attempt to regain her standing as the sexiest pop star in America. Yup.

The Idol boasts one hell of an ensemble cast, also including Jane Adams, Dan Levy, Eli Roth, Rachel Sennott, Hank Azaria, Elizabeth Berkley, and the late Anne Heche.

But production on the show behind-the-scenes has been rickety to say the least, with series director Amy Seimetz abruptly exiting the show half-way through filming, after several episodes had already been shot.

Reports indicate that The Weeknd felt the show was "leaning too much into a female perspective," resulting in Levinson eventually taking over as director.

For a show focused on a woman's experiences, it's an extremely bad look to edge out the female director and replace her with, well, the guy who directed Assassination Nation and Malcolm & Marie.

Don't be surprised if the end result, switching between Seimetz and Levinson's directorial visions half-way through, is an absolute mess of tones and ideas.

4. Recasting Geralt - The Witcher (Season 3)

Though Henry Cavill has already completed shooting the upcoming third season of The Witcher, he made the shock announcement late last year that he won't be returning for season four, with Liam Hemsworth instead being drafted in to replace him.

Advertisement

To say the fanbase was left devastated is an understatement, many feeling that Cavill was Geralt of Rivia, and that it'd be nigh-on impossible for any actor - let alone Hemsworth, no offense to him - to fill those shoes.

And so while fans still have another season of Cavill-starring Witcher goodness to savour, the online sentiment suggests that many won't even bother tuning in.

The depressed sentiment among the fandom, that there's little point continuing on with the knowledge that Cavill will be imminently exiting, makes it damn-near certain that season three's viewing figures will take a major nosedive.

And as for season four, one suspects many won't stick around for more than a single episode, only to satisfy their curiosity about Hemsworth's performance, if they even give him a chance at all.

Netflix were obviously in a tricky bind here, but announcing Cavill's departure before season three had even aired was probably a mistake - one that's poisoned the well in advance of its release.

3. Making It A Prequel To The Movie - Grease: Rise Of The Pink Ladies

Because IP is king and original ideas are trash, of course Paramount are soon set to premiere Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies.

Advertisement

The prequel series, set four years before the iconic movie in 1954, chronicles the origins of Rydell High's Pink Ladies, because the legions of Grease fans out there were evidently hankering for a deepening of the musical franchise's "lore."

But regardless of whether the series is actually any good, it already feels destined to flop ratings-wise because it's gotten swept up in exhausting culture war debates.

The decision to make this new iteration of Grease more inclusive and diverse sounds great on paper, though it might've also made sense to set the show a little closer to the present, rather than going backwards to a time that was even more bigoted and, well, aggressively white.

While there are a lot of bad-faith arguments against the Grease prequel series and its "unrealistic" depiction of 1950s America, one suspects it might end up suffering the same fate as 2016's female-led Ghostbusters reboot, where the "controversy" surrounding its existence overshadows the show itself.

That it feels like an original series that was basically retrofitted to be a Grease spin-off doesn't do it any additional favours. Good luck to those involved, but it's tough to see this one working out.

2. Casting Mel Gibson - The Continental

Way back in 2017, it was announced that a TV spin-off of the John Wick franchise, The Continental, was in the works. And easy though it was to sniff at the show airing on Starz and then moving to Peacock, what might actually sink it is the head-scratching decision to cast Mel Gibson in a major role.

Advertisement

The series, which will focus on a young Winston in the 1970s, has cast Gibson in a part many are assuming to be the show's primary villain.

Either way, given Gibson's massively problematic standing in the industry, it's a casting choice that's immediately going to turn off large swaths of viewers.

While there are of course many who couldn't care less about Gibson's views and troubled personal life - he is, after all, an acclaimed actor and filmmaker - his presence will nevertheless bring a tidal wave of undesirable press to the project and possibly place an inescapably dark cloud over it.

Given the many, many A-list actors who would surely jump at the chance to star in a John Wick series, deferring to a majorly contentious actor with a toxic reputation seems like a recipe for disaster, no matter how good the show otherwise is.

1. Making A Show Nobody Asked For - Echo

Maya Lopez aka Echo (Alaqua Cox) was first introduced to the Marvel Cinematic Universe in 2021's Hawkeye series, but before it had even aired Disney announced that a spin-off series focused on the character was in development.

Advertisement

By the time Hawkeye finished airing, many questioned whether Echo was an interesting enough character to have "earned" her own series, and a year on, the general sentiment among Marvel fans seems to be, "Who asked for this?"

Exacerbating the disinterest is a number of reports that the series, which wrapped shooting in August, was a troubled production, backed up by Disney's recent decision to delay its release by around six months, from this coming summer to December.

Echo was a fine character, but is fine really enough for people to tune in for a show centered around her?

One suspects Echo will have the lowest viewing figures of any MCU series to date, and Disney were rather silly to put these plans in motion before they even knew how audiences would respond to the character.

Advertisement