10 Dumbest Decisions Made By Game Of Thrones Characters

You know how to break everything, Jon Snow.

By Tyler Rigby /

One of the main messages that Game of Thrones endeavours to get across is that actions have consequences. This is the same in both George R.R. Martin's source material and David Benioff and D.B. Weiss' television adaptation.

Advertisement

The titular Game of Thrones is played through intelligence, and if you miscalculate one wrong move, you'll end up dead.

On the other hand are characters just being plain stupid, which many of them have been across all eight seasons of the fantasy epic.

Some of these characters are cerebral geniuses that should really know better, and some are just not known for their brains at all, making mistakes often. Either way, the actions on this list had dire and fatal consequences that prove your decisions can be the difference between life and death.

From choosing to marry someone too quickly, to deciding to trust someone you know you shouldn't, or even something as simple as mentioning a piece of information that shouldn't have been shared, there are a variety of dumb decisions across the Seven Kingdoms, and all involved paid for them.

10. Littlefinger Handing Sansa Over To The Boltons

This one does depend on how much credit you're giving Littlefinger. After Sansa forms an alliance with Petyr Baelish, the mercurial former Master of Coin chooses to essentially sell the young Stark girl to the Boltons so she can marry Roose's newly legitimised son, Ramsay.

Advertisement

Where the stupidity comes in is Baelish apparently had no knowledge of Ramsay, somehow implying that the vicious Bolton had failed to garner a semblance of a reputation during his time at the Dreadfort. Baelish hands over one of his greatest bargaining chips and allies to a man he claims he hasn't heard of.

Some may think he did know how sadistic Ramsay was, but there is not concrete evidence for that in the show. After Sansa escapes her new tormentor, any fragile trust she had for Baelish was destroyed and irreparable, which led to his own demise when he tried to cause a rift between Sansa and her sister.

Whatever excuses you try to make for Baelish's decision to hand Sansa over to the Boltons, it directly started a chain of events that ended in his own execution, and for someone so clever, that was pretty dumb.

9. Oberyn's Arrogance During The Trial By Combat

Oberyn Martel made an impact on Thrones' fourth season as the charismatic and vengeful Prince of Dorne, who hated the Lannisters. After a season of toying with everyone in the capital, Oberyn made a choice to defend Tyrion in his Trial by Combat which allowed him to face off against his sister's killer Gregor Clegane.

Advertisement

Oberyn had waited years for this moment and was sadly over confident in his approach. He made the decision not to wear a helmet during his duel and taunt the crowd as he showed off against the much slower Clegane.

After Oberyn seemingly has the upper hand, Oberyn decides not to finish off Clegane but to attempt to force a confession out of him for what he did to his sister Elia and if Tywin Lannister instructed him to do so.

Oberyn wastes too much time in the end, as Gregor lulls him in and catches him off-guard, crushing his head into a pulp on the ground.

He should have killed Clegane when he had the chance.

8. Bran Revealing His Location To The Night King

After Bran Stark travels beyond the Wall with the Reeds, Hodor and his direwolf Summer, he finds refuge with the Three-Eyed Raven and the last of the Children of the Forest. The Three-Eyed Raven promises to teach Bran how to use his various abilities so that he can one day become him.

Advertisement

All seems to be going well for a time, Bran becomes slowly stronger and stronger under his mentor's tutelage. Unfortunately, Bran's impatience with his progress and rebellious streak causes him to use his powers without the Three-Eyed Raven present. He locates The Night King and his army, but is shocked when the leader of the White Walkers can also see him as well.

The Night King touches Bran, which brands him and reveals the location of the Three-Eyed Raven's lair.

The leads to the subsequent deaths of the Children of the Forest, the Three-Eyed Raven, Summer and Hodor, all because Bran wouldn't take his training slowly like he was supposed to.

As Meera adequately put it, Bran dies in that cave as well, as he is forced to absorb all the Three-Eyed Raven's knowledge at an accelerated pace, leaving Bran an emotionless husk of his former self.

7. Jaime's Rescue Attempt In Dorne

Jaime is often referred to as the dumbest Lannister, and although he doesn't make as many mistakes as that implies, this was particularly stupid. After Cersei charges him with the task of retrieving their daughter Myrcella from the Water Gardens of Dorne, Jaime enlists Bronn and travels south to do just that.

Advertisement

As far as a plan, it ends there. The duo coincidentally run into some Dornish soldiers and swiftly kill them and steal their armour before simply walking into the Water Gardens.

Walking around aimlessly, they managed to find Myrcella, then Jaime takes her by the arm and tells her that they need to go.

That's it.

One of the most famous men in the Seven Kingdoms crossed enemy territory and tried to kidnap a girl that was promised to the future ruler of the region, and he's surprised he got caught?

It's honestly a wonder he got as far as he did.

6. Theon Siding With His Father

Theon Greyjoy had a complicated upbringing and as a result, struggled greatly with his own identity. Torn between his biological family in the Iron Islands who he hadn't seen since he was a child and his adoptive wardens the Starks, Theon never found a sense of belonging with either side.

Advertisement

After Robb Stark is named King in the North and marches south to face a war with the Lannisters, Theon suggests he travel to the Iron Islands to enlist the aid of his family.

After arriving, he is met by the cold reaction of his father Balon who chastises him for being subservient to the Starks. He reveals his plan to pillage and raid the coast of the North and offers Theon the chance to join him or retreat back to his new family.

Theon's choice is not an easy one but instead of siding with the family that raised him and treated him well, he chooses the Greyjoys, setting in motion a series of events that did nothing but hurt good people.

The youngest Stark children had to flee Winterfell, Robb was betrayed by Theon and Theon faced the incomparable torture at the hands of Ramsay Snow. As Theon once said, he had a choice, and he chose wrong.

5. Ned Trusting Littlefinger

The honourable Ned Stark had a reputation for naivety and stubbornness that lead him to make some choices that in later seasons of the show would be laughable. But in Season One, audiences didn't realise that 'doing the right thing', no matter how dangerous or inadvisable, would often result in dire consequences.

Advertisement

The worst of Ned's offences was trusting the clearly deceptive and slimy Littlefinger as a point of contact for his investigation into the death of Jon Arryn. After Robert Baratheon dies, Littlefinger makes Ned an offer that would help position him as regent and puppet master over a young Joffrey.

Ned, knowing that Robert has no legitimate heirs, sticks to his principles and insists that it should be Stannis that takes the throne. This leads Bealish to recalculate and bet on a different horse as he betrays Ned in the throne room helping to imprison the Stark patriarch.

Who knows how different the story would have turned out if he had gone over Littlefinger's head and found a way to crown Stannis on his own.

What makes things worse is Baelish explicitly told Ned not to trust him, and he did so anyway, a point he chooses to remind him of as he presses his blade to his throat.

4. Cersei Empowering The High Sparrow

After Tywin Lannister dies, there was a significant power vacuum within King's Landing. Margaery Tyrell had sunk her claws into the malleable King Tommen and Cersei's influence was fading. She had to do something to assert her control over the realm.

Advertisement

Her choice, was to arm and empower the extremist Faith Militant and their charismatic leader, the High Sparrow.

After Margaery and Loras Tyrel were imprisoned by the Faith, Cersei felt she was beginning to regain her power that she had lost when her father died. Sadly for Cersei, she underestimated the savvy and cunning High Sparrow who quickly imprisoned her also and took control of her son.

The High Sparrow's tenure in King's Landing was made entirely possible due to Cersei's naïve actions that put the zealot and his followers in a position of unquestionable power. This culminated in Cersei's most demeaning and traumatic moment as she was forced to endure her Walk of Atonement naked through the streets of the city.

She later made them all pay, but if she just thought through her actions before helping the Faith Militant, she wouldn't have had to.

3. "The Crypts Are The Safest Place To Be"

This entry takes aim at the collective stupidity of all the characters at Winterfell during the Night King's assault in Season Eight. While all the other entries on this list are intentional character driven choices that largely stay true to the situation those individuals are in, this one is on the writers.

Advertisement

It isn't outside the realm of possibility that someone in Winterfell would suggest keeping the women and children within the castle's expansive crypts during the battle. But, it is highly shocking that not a single character, from Tyrion to Jon Snow, would point out that hiding from a entity that can raise the dead in a sealed corridor filled with corpses was a pretty terrible idea.

David Benioff and D.B. Weiss are great storytellers, but they underestimated their audience if they believed that this wouldn't be everyone's first thought whenever it was repeatedly mentioned how "safe" the crypts were.

The fact that no one caught on in the show is just highly unbelievable, and one of the dumbest choices a collective set of characters make together.

2. Robb Marrying Talisa

After Robb Stark and his army needed to cross a bridge at The Twins, Walder Frey demanded, among other things, that Robb marry one of his daughters once the fighting was done. Robb agreed to these terms before going back on them when he fell in love with a field nurse from Volantis named Talisa Maegyr.

Advertisement

Against the advice of his mother and others, Robb pursued the romance and the two quickly married. Knowing he had to make right with Walder Frey, it was agreed that Robb's uncle Edmure would marry into the Frey family instead. This affair would later be dubbed the Red Wedding.

Along with the Roose Bolton, who had become disillusioned by Robb's leadership and saw an opportunity for political advancement, Walder Frey arranged a massacre at Edmure's wedding that saw the deaths of Catelyn, Robb and his pregnant wife Talisa, as well as the bulk of the loyalist Stark forces.

Robb's foolish act of passion lost him the war and the lives of his immediate family, and he is entirely to blame for the tragedy.

1. Jon And His Big Mouth

Jon Snow takes after his adoptive father Ned in many ways, and to call him a politically savvy individual would be ludicrous. There are several moments this could apply for, a notable one being Jon's refusal to lie to Cersei telling her that Jon will stay neutral during her war with Daenerys.

Advertisement

Most notorious however, is Jon's inability to keep his true parentage to himself after Sam reveals to him he is a Targaryen. He immediately tells his lover and aunt Daenerys, causing a rift between the two that was already starting to show thanks to their different receptions from the people of the North.

Then, after Daenerys pleads with him to keep it to himself, Jon tells his sisters, one of which is a political opportunist of her own. The truth then spreads like wildfire, as do the consequences.

Varys fails to overthrow Daenerys and is subsequently executed, Jon becomes distant with his queen as he deals with his crisis of identity that she can't fully relate to or support, and the looming threat to her claim becomes more feasible as he is first in the line of succession.

Along with several other mediating factors, Daenerys chooses to destroy King's Landing as she fulfils her destiny as the Mad King's daughter. Would she have gone this far without the string of consequences from Jon's honesty?

Probably not.

Jon should have learned one more lesson from his father: How to keep a secret.

Advertisement