10 Most Hated Doctor Who Episodes
Those controversial episodes that had fans declaring "Doctor Who is dead!" (again).
The format of Doctor Who is both a blessing and a curse. Open-ended, anthological, and with a rotating team of writers: the show has the freedom to explore a tremendously large variety of topics, settings, and genres, in a way that is practically unmatched by any other show.
But while this ability to regenerate week after week is a draw for fans (and a crucial factor in the show’s longevity), it can result in wildly inconsistent episode quality.
As various writers and showrunners attempt to leave their stamp on the history of Doctor Who, some of their visions and ideas are, let us say, less-than popular with fans, and some episodes are just unbearably awful.
For this list, we aren’t looking at episodes that are boring, or objectively "the worst" (although some are certainly considered as such) but rather those which stirred a visceral, outraged reaction from a significant number of fans.
So, join us for this collection of canon-altering bombshells, controversial stories, and, of course, “BENNIIIII”.
10. Arachnids In The UK
Arachnids in the UK is not as bad as some make it out to be. We'll get to the controversial points in just a moment, but beneath those, the episode is semi-competent, and had the potential to be among the best in Series 11.
That is, until it trips face-first onto concrete in the final 20 minutes.
First, let's tackle TrumpLite™. Robertson is a lazy and under-developed political allegory about as subtle as a grizzly bear at a birthday party, which allows the protagonists to take weak, kudos-winning shots at him throughout the episode. Trump is the easiest target for criticism currently walking the Earth, and yet this episode feels too scared to rock the boat, and somehow misses its planet-sized target.
This episode also features the most oft-referenced example of Thirteen's inconsistent and poorly thought-out moral code. At the end of the episode, Robertson mercy kills a spider with a bullet - granted, he doesn't do this with an ounce of compassion, but the Doctor's response of "Guns are bad, let’s lure them into a suffocation chamber instead" is a big oof, as is Ryan busting moves to "Sheffield's sickest grime station" as he uses Stormzy to pied-piper the spiders to their agonizing deaths.
Congratulations, you pitted the Doctor against Trump, and she somehow came off looking worse.
9. Nightmare In Silver
There’s a lot to love about Neil Gaiman’s sophomore story, but even the episode’s keenest defenders (this writer included) can see that his original vision was significantly derailed.
The end result is a script that struggles to cram in a busy plot, a major villain, and some heavy series arc plotting into a single episode. Without a doubt, it should have been a two-parter.
Much of Nightmare In Silver’s polarising reputation stems from the inclusion of Angie and Artie, the two children under Clara’s charge as a nanny. These children are perhaps the true antagonists of the story, as they are irredeemably annoying throughout (granted, this is more a fault in the writing than the acting, but still).
This episode is also controversial due to Gaiman’s reimagining of the Cybermen, which sees them dressed up like an Iron Man parody, capable of patching out any and all faults in their design. Not only is this the biggest departure from the original vision of the monsters in the show’s history, but the suspension of disbelief required to accept that the Cybers can install an app to make them immune to getting shot is a little much.
Lastly, we'd be remiss not to mention what is possibly the Doctor’s worst line of all time, which closes out the episode after Clara leaves the TARDIS:
"Impossible girl. A mystery wrapped in an enigma, squeezed into a skirt that's just a little bit too tight."
It's very icky, to say the least. It doesn't even sound like something the Doctor would say. A strange inclusion indeed.
8. Hell Bent
Hell Bent had the unenviable job of wrapping up the trilogy, coming hot off the heels of the acclaimed Face the Raven, and the undisputed powerhouse that is Heaven Sent. But unfortunately, in the eyes of many, it really didn’t stick the landing.
After arriving on Gallifrey for the first time since saving it in The Day of the Doctor (and the last time before Chibnall blew it up again), the Doctor uses Gallifreyan technology to extract Clara from her timestream at the moment of her narratively satisfying death. He then shoots and kills an incarnation of The General, who had actually been an ally to the Doctor, before referring to regeneration as being like "man flu".
It's no wonder this episode has tons of detractors.
In the end, instead of returning Clara to the moment of her death - which would've saved the episode and given us a deeply emotional scene - Clara flies off with Ashildr, a character who sold out the Doctor to the Time Lords. The Doctor allows this to happen at the expense of his memories of Clara, leaving him alone having just spent the last four billion years grieving for her. This is the worst trade deal in the history of trade deals, maybe ever.
Hell Bent is Moff at his Moffiest, taking what had the potential to be his magnum opus, and Moffing it all up by not allowing Clara to just die. Shame.
7. Let’s Kill Hitler
We’ll start with a positive: this is probably one of the funniest episodes of NuWho, and is a genuinely enjoyable little romp in isolation. Unfortunately, it’s also the story that marks the beginning of the nosedive in the Eleventh Doctor era’s key story arc, and it also wastes its potentially intriguing setting.
We're introduced to the character of Mels, Amy and Rory’s best friend in the whole wide world, who knows all about the Doctor. However, she hasn’t shown up at any point until just now, not even at the Ponds’ wedding. Considering they are meant to be nigh inseparable, it’s a little hard to see the character as anything other than a late insert. She could've even been introduced earlier in the series, but for some reason, this was decided against. Her identity is played as a huge mystery, but her sharing a name with the baby born last episode means that every single viewer knew exactly who she was before the episode’s "big twist" reveal.
The episode doesn’t even get better once River shows up properly. Let's Kill Hitler has an issue which only gets worse as time goes on, and that is the continued flanderization of River Song. In Silence in the Library, we see a smart, capable love interest for the Doctor, who has a bit of a flirty streak, but is also tough and serious when the moment calls for it.
Sadly, at this point in the Moffat era, River had been almost entirely reduced to a walking innuendo.
6. In The Forest Of The Night
There aren’t many episodes on this list that are here purely because they're boring, but that’s a testament to just how dull Series 8’s In The Forest Of The Night truly is.
Any episode that features a cast almost entirely comprised of children was going to be a risk, especially with the show’s history of writing every child ever as rude and irritating. This episode does not bump that trend, and the premise of the story is so incredibly boring that it drags the whole thing down even more.
With all of London covered by a forest, Twelve, Clara, and Danny must work to solve the case, facing down foes such as a poorly CGI’d tiger... and that’s it. Precious little happens here and the episode doesn’t even justify it with much character work, leaving the best scene on the cutting room floor. Nice one.
Oh, and let us not forget the slightly problematic elephant in the room, either. In The Forest of the Night features a child called Maebh, who hears voices in her head and is on medication to help her cope with them. Upon hearing about this medication, Twelve is horrified, and aggressively states that ‘"You people never learn", and that when a child is talking, it should be listened to, sending a rather unwelcome message to children to not take their medication.
Even worse, this stance is vindicated when it turns out that Maebh abandoning her meds and tuning into the voices in her head saves the day. It doesn’t take an expert to work out why this is a terrible message to send in a family show.
5. The End Of Time
And now we arrive at what will undoubtedly be the most controversial placement on this list. It's true, this episode is adored by many, but it has its critics in equal measure.
Yes, Ten's swansong is deeply emotional. Yes, Tennant puts in a career-best performance. And yes, Bernard Cribbins was a truly wonderful man who has our bottom lip trembling every time he's onscreen. But we're not here to talk about the strengths of the episode, and in fact, that's where The End of Time's high points, well... end.
This is the regeneration episode that betrayed the fabric of the show, kicking Smith and Moffat in the shins before donning a brown trenchcoat and melodramatically sauntering out the TARDIS doors with a wistful stare into the middle distance. RTD wanted to do something different with regeneration, and when it works, it bloody works, but with Ten's issues and vanity left unresolved at the end of the episode, the series was left hamstrung, with the next incarnation being villainised by his predecessor before he'd even appeared onscreen.
The End of Time is coded like the end of the show, and does nothing to prepare audiences for the incoming change at the point where, following the most popular Doctor of all time, they needed their hand held the most. RTD could've had his cake and eaten it too, showing a Doctor who doesn't want to change, but has to redeem himself in the end (see Twice Upon A Time), but instead, we're forced to sit through an RTD victory lap.
There's also the stuff with the Vinvocci, Joshua Naismith, and the Immortality Gate, all of which feel like afterthoughts. Even the much-hyped return of Rassilon boils down to a far-too brief exchange between him and the Doctor, before he's blasted back into the abyss for the next five years. It's all oddly half-baked.
4. The Tsuranga Conundrum
To its credit, The Tsuranga Conundrum tries to do something interesting with its villain of the week, by making the Pting a tiny adorable alien who wants to eat the ship not because he’s evil, but because he’s hungry. A strong concept... executed very badly.
The supporting cast in this episode is perhaps the weakest of the series, and neither of the B-plots are remotely entertaining. Firstly, we have the under-developed side plot involving a pilot with a heart condition, and secondly, we have Ryan and Graham performing midwife duty for a pregnant man. At this point, Ryan projects his insecurities regarding his own father walking out on him, and pressures a man who clearly isn’t ready to be a father into keeping a baby he planned to put up for adoption. Ryan is played as the hero for this... for some reason.
Another reason this episode is hated is because it spends the first half of its runtime pointlessly treading water. The Doctor wakes up in a hospital bed after being injured by a sonic mine, and attempts to take control of a situation that is, at that point, under control. This results in an awkward and embarrassing climb-down for the Doctor that makes her look incompetent, and serves no purpose whatsoever.
This never feeds into any story arc - it just damages Thirteen, and takes authority away from the character.
3. Love & Monsters
You knew it was coming.
Once upon a time, Series 2’s Love & Monsters might have taken the top spot here, but in recent years, it’s slipped down the list. Besides, plenty of fans are starting to come around on this strange little 45 minutes of telly. It's something of a relic, a product of its time.
The first Doctor-lite episode of NuWho follows Elton Pope and his friends as they attempt to track down the Doctor with the help of Victor Kennedy - a character who might just hold the title of the worst villain in almost 60 years of Doctor Who.
A mixture of juvenile writing, the casting of Peter Kay, and the decision to let a literal child design the monster of the week culminates in a monstrosity of a final act, that derails what is otherwise a charming story about a group of wanderers finding purpose in each other. Nowadays though, all we can remember is Peter Kay waddling around in that disturbingly small loincloth.
The Abzorbaloff might be the main reason for the intense hatred this episode receives, but we would be remiss to not mention that ending. You know, the one where the Doctor ‘saves’ Ursula by subjecting her to an eternity of suffering and captivity as Elton’s slate sex toy. Did RTD even realise how bleak an ending this was, all for him to justify Doctor Who’s weirdest joke ever? It still makes us shudder.
2. Orphan 55
Orphan 55 is a frontrunner for the worst Doctor Who story of all time, and that's thoroughly deserved.
There is not a single element of this story that holds up to scrutiny, be it the ropey script, choppy editing, or the most god-awful supporting cast ever pulled together in the show: a thumb-sucking love interest, Jay from The Inbetweeners, whatever Hyph3n is, and, of course, BENNIIIIIIIII. Even the main cast is unable to elevate this dumpster fire, try as they might.
The episode then ends on the 'twist' reveal that the dead planet on which the resort sits is in fact Earth, and the Doctor warns that if humanity doesn't alter its planet-pillaging course, then we're all doomed.
On its own, this isn't an issue - many Doctor Who episodes have political messages - but the problem is that the message is not woven into the story properly, and the speech that the Doctor gives is both extremely surface-level, and extremely patronising, feeling more like a slap on the wrist than a compelling argument.
Aliens of London - in a jab against the Iraq war - gave us an early-noughties UK government justifying a false flag war with unsubstantiated claims of weapons of mass destruction, and that whole political allegory is ten times more subtle than Orphan 55, despite featuring giant, green, overweight, flatulent aliens. Go figure.
1. The Timeless Children
Surprise!
We're kidding. As if any other episode could hold a candle to The Timeless Children in terms of the sheer outrage it caused.
Perhaps in an attempt to respond to comments that Series 11 was flat and uninteresting, Chibnall decided to make his mark and shake up the status quo in Series 12. For the most part, this resulted in a much stronger series, with some decent intrigue to sink our teeth into. That was, until the finale rolled round, and The Timeless Children dropped the canon bomb that sent Doctor Who fans into hysteria, by revealing that William Hartnell was not the first Doctor.
Ballsy move, but surely Chibnall must've known that this was not going to go down well. Sure enough, it didn't, and it proved to be a point of no return for many fans, who turned against the show en masse. Perhaps because the fallout from this episode was so bad, it was barely touched on again, save from some unresolved babbling about the Doctor's time at Division. And honestly, we'd be surprised if it ever was touched on again - it'll just be one of those weird tidbits (like the Doctor being half-human), that everyone chooses to ignore.
The episode made a second ill-judged move too, one that often passes under the radar of fan vitriol: the re-destruction of Gallifrey, which happens earlier in the series but is never undone. This reveal is completely unnecessary, goes absolutely nowhere, and the Doctor seems relatively unfazed by it. All this pointless plot does is undermine the arc of the revived show and nullify the traumatic journey the Doctor went through, including that triumphant resolution in The Day of The Doctor.