10 Most Unexpected Doctor Who Moments
The twists from Who that made us say WHAT.
When it comes to Doctor Who you have to expect the unexpected.
Every series has been jam packed full of twists and turns that have made us question everything we thought we knew about everyone's favourite time-travelling Time Lord.
But as the years have gone by and more episodes are aired, it has become easier to spot what the big reveals are going to be. The Doctor is The Timeless Child? Pretty predictable to be honest.
And of course there have been some events that could have been epic and unexpected, had the BBC not told us about them in advance. John Simm returning as the Master for example, could well have been one of the best cliffhangers to any Who episode ever, had there not been a 'leak' months before the Series 11 premiere.
However, no matter how clever Whovians are, there are still some brilliant moments from the revival era of the show that come as a complete surprise to the audience. Twists that absolutely no-one could have foreseen coming. Scenes that changed the fabric of reality and made everyone sitting at home put on their best David Tennant voice and say: "WHAT."
Oh, and before you go any further ahead, remember, spoilers.
10. Captain Jack Is The Face Of Boe
Series 3 is often overlooked, which is a shame because it packs some real punches. After the ongoing thread of 'Who is Harold Saxon' (more on that later), fans were left puzzled over another mystery.
How did The Face Of Boe know about The Master and Professor Yana? It seemed as if the show was going to leave that key plot point unresolved, until a scene right at the end of the finale, Last Of The Time Lords, explained all.
As fan-favourite Captain Jack Harkness departs the Tenth Doctor and Martha Jones, he tells them that during his stint with the Time Agency, he had a very interesting nickname: "The Face Of Boe they called me."
Cue shocked expressions from everyone, including The Doctor and Martha. It was such a clever reveal that stunned audiences and what it makes it better, is that all the signs were there but nobody was able to join the dots.
The Face Of Boe was said to have lived for millions of years and watched the universe grow old- and even calls The Doctor an old friend. Jack is immortal but still ages, and would know all about The Master and Yana.
For years, showrunner Russell T. Davies has stated that this all just a theory but during a recent watch-along of New Earth, he seemingly confirmed that the two are the same person.
9. The Tenth Doctor Is Shot
Death is perhaps the only certainty in Doctor Who. Every incarnation of The Doctor must meet their end at some point, and when that is exactly, usually becomes very apparent when the actor announces they're leaving.
But back in 2008, David Tennant was at the height of his popularity, so the idea of him regenerating was unthinkable. Which is what made the The Stolen Earth's cliffhanger so good.
Series 4 had teased us with the return of Rose Tyler and every fan's dream seemed to be coming true when Ten and Rose were finally reunited in the penultimate episode. But just as they approached each other, a Dalek appears, fires his weapon and The Doctor is killed.
As Tennant begins to regenerate, the credits roll on one of most unexpected finales to an episode ever, which left audiences everywhere speculating whether Tennant was leaving and who his replacement would be.
Of course the answer would be that the Doctor technically regenerated but kept Tennant's appearance. But nevertheless, few Who moments have garnered more widespread interest than this one.
8. Oswin Is A Dalek
Prior to Series 7, it had been announced that Jenna Coleman would be Matt's Smith's new companion and that she would make her debut in the Christmas Special, after the first batch of episodes.
So it was a big surprise when Coleman suddenly appeared in the series opener, Asylum Of The Daleks, as Oswin Oswald, the sole-survivor of a crashed starliner, with a knack for hacking. At first it looked as though they were just introducing Coleman early and she would become a regular companion later, as had been done with Catherine Tate's Donna Noble.
But then the real unexpected surprise happens. Oswin was in fact converted into a Dalek but still believes she's human, thus explaining how she survived for so long on a planet infested with insane Daleks, and why she's able to corrupt their memories.
It's a real sucker-punch reveal and one that devastates the Eleventh Doctor and the audience. There were to be many more twists and turns regarding Clara Oswald, but none of them were as shocking and fantastic as the first.
7. The Origins Of The Timeless Child
It was mentioned earlier so let's dive into it some more. Series 12's finale, The Timeless Children, really divided fans. Some love it. Some hate it. And some REALLY hate it.
Regardless of your opinion on it, no one can deny that they didn't predict who exactly the timeless child was- and this isn't about it being The Doctor, because that had become fairly obvious. Instead, let's focus on the origin story of the child and its connection to Gallifrey and the Time Lords.
It turns out that a Gallifreyan explorer discovered a child with the ability to regenerate endless times, and after much experimentation, was able to harness the power of regeneration for herself and her people, thus creating the Time Lords. The child's memories were then wiped and it grew up to become The Doctor.
It's a twist that is quite problematic, and is still to win over large parts of the fan-base. But put that aside, it's a moment that is is wholly unexpected. The origins of the Time Lords have always been shrouded in mystery and it was thought that it would stay that way. This revelation, for better or for worse, was very unexpected.
6. The Eleventh Doctor Dies
If the Doctor's regeneration in The Stolen Earth was unexpected, then Eleven's death in The Impossible Astronaut was mind-blowing.
Ahead of the Series 6 opener, it had been teased that a major character was going to die, but who? Could it be River Song? Again. Rory Williams? Again. Or Amy Pond? Again. But as it turned out, the unthinkable happened. It was The Doctor himself. Except this time, there was no regeneration.
After a mysterious figure in an astronaut suit kills The Doctor for good, fans were left reeling over this shocking moment, although they all knew deep down that there was no way the title character would stay dead for long.
Of course they were right and moments later a younger Doctor shows up unaware of his fate, and by the end of the series, The Doctor is still alive and well. Nevertheless, this was a truly unexpected plot point. Twists like these are usually saved for episodes towards the end of a series, so putting it at the beginning of the opener was such a fantastic way to catch everyone off-guard.
5. Amy Is A Ganger
Continuing on with the sixth series, there were plenty more twists to come following the shocking opening episode.
A lot of you were no doubt expecting to see the the twist that River Song is actually Melody Pond, aka Amy and Rory's daughter, on this list, but let's be honest, by the time that reveal came in A Good Man Goes To War, pretty much everyone had guessed that that was the case.
A good twist nonetheless but the show had made it far too obvious.
So let's instead focus on the previous episode, The Almost People. The story had revolved around factory workers fighting off duplicates of themselves called Gangers, and all was thought to be well and good when the surviving humans and Gangers escaped in harmony with each other. But as it turns out, the story was all in service of the main series plot.
It is revealed that Amy has been a Ganger since the start of the series, having been kidnapped by The Silence in order for them to capture her newborn baby. It's a stunning twist that completely alters how you re-watch the first half of the series.
Looking back you notice all the signs and everything makes perfect sense. The sign of a great unexpected moment.
4. Dalek's Emerge From The Void Ship
There are some moments in TV and Film, where you can't help but let your inner fanboy scream with delight. Perhaps the best example of that in Doctor Who, is the very last scene of Series 2's penultimate episode, Army Of Ghosts.
During the series we were re-introduced to classic Who villain, the Cybermen, and it was no secret that they would be returning for the finale. So when the titular ghosts morphed into millions of metal men, it was a cool, albeit predictable, moment.
But then the penny drops. The peculiar void ship in the basement of Torchwood, has nothing to do with the Cybermen. Instead, Rose and Mickey are left confused and horrified when four of the deadliest creatures in the universe emerge: The Daleks!
Never before in the show's history had the two greatest Who villains met face-to-face, so the mere tease of this sent fans into overdrive. There was no reason to believe that the Daleks would be coming back for the second series of the revival after their inclusion in the first, which makes it all the more impressive that they kept this secret under wraps.
A true jaw dropping moment, emphasised brilliantly by Murray Gold's music, that sets up one of, if the not the best, Doctor Who episode of all time.
3. John Hurt Is The War Doctor
2013 celebrated 50 years of Doctor Who, so everyone was expecting big things from Stephen Moffat and the BBC, but no one could have foreseen this.
After a very muddled and confusing Series 7, the finale, The Name Of The Doctor, promised to answer some questions. It somewhat delivered on that, but the only part anyone really remembers is the ending.
We learn that during the Time War there was another Doctor, who committed such an atrocity that future incarnations chose to forget him. And most surprising of all, The War Doctor was played by the legendary John Hurt.
In recent years we have learned that this was a very last minute addition to the episode, with Moffat intending for Christopher Eccleston to return for the 50th Anniversary. But when he declined, he came up with the idea for there to be an additional secret Doctor, that existed in between the 1996 TV Movie and the 2005 revival. An ingenious solution that worked a treat.
It's a truly unforgettable moment, one that completely restructured the Whoniverse.
2. Ruth Is The Doctor
Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Seven years after the revelation of The War Doctor, we were introduced to another unknown incarnation of the Time Lord.
This twist came completely out of nowhere. The Jodie Whittaker/Chris Chibnall era had produced very little in the way of game changing, extraordinary moments but ahead of Series 12's Fugitive Of The Judoon, audiences were told to expect something big. And when John Barrowman returned as Captain Jack, everyone assumed that was the end of the surprises.
But no. During the story we get our expectations subverted again when we learn Ruth, not her shifty partner, is the titular fugitive. We get little clues throughout about her true persona before the Doctor digs up a TARDIS and Ruth is revealed to be none other than The Doctor herself. Cue blown minds everywhere.
This was a truly outstanding and unexpected moment in Who history. While the pay-off of where exactly Ruth fits into the timeline is underwhelming, the initial reveal is simply jaw-dropping. Bold, brilliant and Doctor Who at its best.
In a series of a lot of lows, we at least had this fantastic high. Take a bow Chibnall. Probably the only time anyone will ever say that.
1. All The Master Reveals
Ok so this is a bit of cheat, merging three moments into one, but it's impossible to separate these magnificent twists.
Despite all these moments being pretty much the same on paper, each one of them were truly unexpected and filled everyone watching with equal parts excitement and dread.
Firstly in Series 3's Utopia, The Master is reintroduced through Professor Yana, before the gut-wrenching reveal that he is also the enigmatic Harold Saxon, the newly-elected Prime Minister.
Secondly in Series 8's Dark Water, the mysterious Missy reveals herself as the rouge Time Lord, completely revolutionising the show's lore by confirming that a Time Lord can change gender through regeneration.
And thirdly, the shocking ending to Series 12's Spyfall Part One, saw The Master return again, this time masquerading as secret agent O.
Every time The Master returns, it's mindbogglingly brilliant, largely because of the outstanding acting quality of Derek Jacobi, John Simm, Michelle Gomez and Sacha Dhawan. They may not be the best villain The Doctor has faced, but is certainly the most entertaining, and all of these jaw-dropping revelations go a long way in helping that.
Here's to the next incarnation of The Master and their great unexpected introduction.