There's a lot to recommend Game Of Thrones. George RR Martin's A Song Of Ice And Fire books have provided any number of memorable characters, shocking plot twists and a living, breathing world that's somewhat like feudal Britain with more boobs. The TV show has any number of memorable actors, even more shocking plot twists, and a living, breathing world that is filmed in the British countryside, with added boobs. Besides the boobs, there's the complex morality which will introduce a character as a straight-up villain before asking the audience to sympathise with them (and they usually succeed, too); the cinematography has more in common with, well, cinema, than television, with blockbuster budgets being thrown at the screen. It's become a bonafide cultural phenomenon, breaking out of any sort of nerdy genre ghetto to appeal to a hugely wide audience who have been inured to fantasy locales with the likes of Lord Of The Rings and Harry Potter books and their ensuing films adaptations. HBO are probably funding everything else on their channel with the subscriptions that show has brought them. The show is almost universally beloved by critics and audiences alike, and rightly so. But it does have some glaring issues that tend to be overlooked, but deserve to be challenged. Like some of the accents. And the...choices in adaptation. Here are ten problems with Game Of Thrones nobody wants to admit.
Advertisement
10. Peter Dinklage's Accent Isn't That Good
Besides having a name that's apparently perfect to sing along with the show's theme tune, Peter Dinklage's performance as Tyrion Lannister is one of the main draws for Game Of Thrones. The character is a fan favourite, the disgraced son of House Lannister who makes the best of his situation by having hard-to-parse loyalties and lots of sex with prostitutes. Dinklage is a heck of an actor. That's not exactly a revelation: he's been a jobbing performer for decades, with small parts in films like In Bruges, Elf, and now bigger roles in the likes of X-Men: Days Of Future Past will attest to his acting ability. His performance is what really brings the character to life. Which is all the more impressive when you consider that the strength of his performance manages to transcend the terrible British accent he's putting on as Tyrion. Surrounded by lots of actual Brits, his attempts at sort of pan-United Kingdom speech pattern pale in comparison.
9. Some Actors Are Better Than Others
Peter Dinklage is a heck of an actor, and he's part of a heck of an ensemble. Besides being a generally great and engrossing fantasy series, Game Of Thrones also serves a vital public service as it keeps Britain's actors, both established and up-and-coming, in regular paid work. Until they get unexpectedly killed off, anyway. Sean Bean was great as Ned Stark for the Sean Bean amount of time he stuck around, Dinklage remains dazzling despite the accent, and basically every member of the Stark and Lannister family is an actor working at the top of their game. Charles Dance as Lord Tywin Lannister sets the bar pretty high, with Lena Headey and Nikolaj Coster-Waldau as the incestuous brother and daughter pairing ably reaching it. Some of the actors struggle to keep up, however. Daenerys Targaryen is a fan-favourite character, but Emilia Clarke doesn't get to do a whole lot with the role, mainly resigned to looking misty-eyed; some of the other younger actors have the same issues as, well, all child actors; and does Kit Harington do a whole lot else besides looking angsty in the snow? Is that acting?
8. Killing People Off Is Kinda Cheap
One of the most celebrated aspects of Game Of Thrones is how ruthless the show (and the books) are with bumping off major characters. The blood-strewn Red Wedding set the standard for how confident the series is in just suddenly, brutally removing vast swathes of the principal cast, so audiences can never be quite sure where they stand. It's often listed as one of the show's great strengths. Whereas character deaths can be predicted on more mainstream shows, thanks to predictable storytelling and actor's contracts being completed, it feels like anybody could disappear from Game Of Thrones at any time. Death is brutal and unpredictable, just like in real life! Except, well, for one thing, Game Of Thrones isn't real life. Like, at all. People being bumped off at any second is a somewhat radical notion, but sometimes it feels like cheap shock tactics rather than smart storytelling, to the point that now fans kind of expect unexpected demises.
7. The Pacing Sucks
George RR Martin is a gifted author in many ways. The fictional continents of Westeros and Essos are very real on paper, and the show brings them to life in a really cool way. Most of the characters he creates are more complex than your average fantasy heroes and villains, which are carried over (for the most part) to the screen. Much of the plotting, backstabbing, and intrigue is top-notch. His pacing, meanwhile, sucks. It sucks something hard. His sprawling, epic world means that the focus has to switch fairly regularly between the principal cast, and the more characters that are brought into the fold, the more time has to be split up. Which means that for long spaces of time, nothing really happens. With the Game Of Thrones TV show, that's gotten even worse in the fourth season, which tries to bide time between Martin writing books by adapting half of A Storm of Swords, and some elements from A Feast for Crows and A Dance with Dragons. Which makes everything take so long and is so boring.
6. The Fighting Fantasy Is Kind Of Unnecessary
Right now the BBC are airing Wolf Hall, a historical drama based off of Hilary Mantel's award-winning novels about Thomas Cromwell and Henry VII. They're fictionalised takes on real-life events, which eschew the soapy antics of The Tudors in favour of a fairly repressed, quiet series where power is wielded and undercut not with graphic sex scenes and violence but underhanded tactics and manipulation. The show is almost all dialogue, people discussing how they're going to get away with certain things and turn others around to their way of thinking, and it's one of the most engaging shows on TV right now. It's basically Game Of Thrones shorn of all the battles, the sex scenes, the dragons, and all of the more base fantasy tropes in indulges in. Which sort of proves that Game Of Thrones doesn't need any of those things. They're not there because they're necessary, like they naturally fit into the flow of things. They're there because that's the done thing in fantasy stories, and whilst the series mostly eschews those genre stereotypes, it sometimes falls prey to them. It's a little disappointing.
5. It's Pretty Racist, Guys
One of the other unfortunate fantasy tropes Game Of Thrones frequently falls foul of is being totally racist. Both figuratively and literally. The principal cast is almost totally lilly-white, if you ignore the amount of muck and gore they have splattered over them much of the time; the cream of the crop of British actors make up the core ensemble, with cream being the operative word. The Hawaiian-born Jason Momoa, meanwhile, got cast in the role of Khal Drogo, leader of the Dothraki, a group made up primarily of non-white actors who are violent savages who kill and rape each other for sport. Which is about one step away from putting bones through their noses and calling them jungle bunnies, quite frankly. It gets all the more worse when Daenerys Targaryen, the Dothraki Khalessi by marriage, freeing a bunch of slaves from Yunkai in the third season. Slaves she intends to take on as her members of her army. Who are mostly black and amass around their blonde haired, blue eye, white saviour. Not so good.
4. Sexposition Is Stupid
Game Of Thrones is an equal opportunities offender, however. Along with being kinda crazy racist much of the time, it finds time for a healthy amount of subjugation of women, too. Much of the hype surrounding the series when it started was its willingness to make the most of HBO's being on cable, meaning they could show as much nudity as they fancied (within reason). Ad by nudity that exclusively means tits. And sometimes vaginas! There's been plenty of full-frontal female nudity in Game Of Thrones, to the point that the phrase sexposition was coined for the amount of plot-advancing info that's delivered during scenes where the viewer is distracted by a bunch of jiggling bare flesh. Some don't stand for it. Stephen Dillane, who plays Stannis Baratheon, compared the show to "German porn from the 1970s", and Emilia Clarke has made it clear she's not doing any more nude scenes. Which is good, because they're stupid, and sexist, but would be possibly more acceptable if there were equally as many swinging dicks. Literal ones.
3. What Is Up With All The Rape
When it's not being totally sexist by making almost all of its female characters running around half-naked at the very least, Game Of Thrones is making half of its viewing audience uncomfortable by featuring so much rape. Like, so much rape. Any depiction of non-consensual sex is arguably unnecessary; but the amount in this show is just kind of insulting. The series actually features even more rape then the books, and they're not exactly shy when it comes to such abhorrent scenes. Why exactly the writers chose to change consensual copulations for violent encounters is unknown, but it smacks of a certain misogyny that there are multiple incidences of such a thing happening. Considering it's a crime that struggles for legitimacy in courts even today, and it affects a significant amount of women around the world, the blasé attitude Game Of Thrones has towards rape is a major problem. The first sexual encounter between Daenerys and Khal Drogo, the recent controversial scene with Cersei and Jamie: consensual in the books, not in the show. Changes the whole thing, and not for the better.
2. "Historical Accuracy" Is No Excuse
Westeros around 300 AC is nowhere near as diverse as 21st century America, of course George RR Martin wrote in response to an African-American fan who pointed out the troubling lack of diversity in Game Of Thrones. Westeros is the fantasy analogue of the British Isles in its world, so it is a long long way from the Asia analogue. There werent a lot of Asians in Yorkish England either. Which is obviously a lot of crap. It's an excuse that gets trotted out to explain the sexism and huge amounts of rape throughout the series, with the thinking being that in the olden days women didn't have it so great, so they shouldn't hear either right? And Game Of Thrones is mostly a fantasy retelling of the War Of The Roses, so... Except, well, it doesn't have to be like that. Martin writes like the make-up of the population of Westeros is beyond his control, like he's being historically accurate. There were also no dragons or ice zombies in Yorkish Enlgand. If you can conceive of that, surely it's not such a stretch to be crazy sexist and racist too.
1. It's Really Not That Grown Up
HBO is the home of mature television. Much like mature ratings on comic books, video games and a lot of movies, that doesn't necessarily mean that the stoytelling is grown up, or it explores themes in a mature manner. It means that it's got oodles of violence, swearing, and T&A. Game Of Thrones is certainly grown up in that respect. And there's nothing wrong with that! Trying to argue that it's in any way mature in any other terms, however? Get out of here. When you boil it down to the component parts, the target audience for Game Of Thrones is fourteen-year-old boys. The sort of audience that runs on hormones, so enjoys the amount of bare female flesh on show; the sort who think beheadings and other gratuitous violence is gnarly. There's nothing wrong with enjoying those things. Everybody's got a fourteen-year-old boy living inside of them. But implying that Game Of Thrones is implicitly a mature, grown up piece of storytelling simply because includes violence, nudity and sexual violence is like calling David After Dentist a movie because cameras were involved.