10 Sci-Fi Plots We're Sick Of Seeing

It's like we're caught in a time loop...

By Chris Allcock /

BBCIt€™s easy to see why Steven Moffat claims to loathe the internet. It€™s not just the criticism; that all-too-familiar swarm of mindless complaints that accompany pretty much every TV show, it€™s that websites and wikis alike have given the audience an infinite capacity to catalogue, compare and contrast absolutely everything against absolutely everything else. Writers can€™t cheat, they can only choose whether or not they give a damn about the consequences. There€™s an amusing nod to this newfound omniscience in the first Doctor Who Programme Guide, released in the early 80s; producer Barry Letts explains that Atlantis was destroyed three times during the show€™s early run. With TV being produced as €œfire-and-forget€ broadcasting, such little note was taken of what had gone before that each new team believed they were the first to visit the underwater city. It€™s baffling to think that nobody thought to jot anything down, but given the show€™s budget it was probably a choice between a Dalek and a new pencil. Fifty years later, though, there€™s really no excuse. When most stories are €œbroken€ by teams of storytellers early in the production run, you can€™t even blame one writer€™s pop-culture ignorance when they churn out a rehashed sci-fi idea that has you fumbling for €œnext episode€ on Netflix. It€™s not that these plots are necessarily bad, but that the concepts and themes have been covered countless times before. In an on-demand world, we don€™t need the televisual equivalent of frozen leftovers. Leaving aside common plots that still have surprises to offer the audience (like time travel) or act as vehicles for character growth and exploration (like, er, time travel), here are ten worn out sci-fi stories whose sell-by date has most definitely passed:

10. Everyone Wants The Baby

20th Century FoxWorking an actor€™s real-life pregnancy into a TV show isn€™t a sci-fi idea - it€™s been around since the days of I Love Lucy €“ but futuristic or paranormal trappings make it easy, and all-too-tempting, to work the newborn into your show. Alien gestations can be as speedy or as protracted as fits your shooting schedule and any after-effects can be ignored because it€™s not a human baby. The only problem is what to do with the little tyke once it€™s born €“ having an infant around is one thing, but do you really want to introduce a regular child character and risk being responsible for the next Wesley Crusher? Generally, this means that pretty much every baby conceived in science-fiction is going to be both €œspecial€ and also big news on supervillain social media. The main characters will be pursued by religious zealots, shadowy government organisations or a maniacal alien who€™s convinced that the baby€™s DNA will go lovely with a glass of pinot. As the writer, you€™ve got your reset button €“ the child can either be captured, be sent to live off-camera where they€™ll be safe, or turn into some sort of ultra-wise glowy space being once you€™re done with it. We€™ve seen so many super-powered foetuses in sci-fi that the drama€™s worn away. The audience doesn€™t automatically share the characters€™ attachment to the baby because you€™ve been treating it like a plot device rather than a person. In an age where even episodic TV can make copious use of CGI, showrunners should work around a pregnancy instead of treating it like a coupon for free drama €“ that is, unless they€™re prepared to deal with the long-term upheaval that real children bring.

9. The Seductress

Mutant Enemy ProductionsAs you might expect from a genre perceived as the stomping ground of nerdy males, science-fiction shows are not exactly bereft of beautiful women. Whether it€™s a slinky Borg catsuit or outer-space shower scene, TV producers get the channel-hopping audience engaged with copious amounts of fan-service €“ but most of the time, unless they€™re the show€™s designated lothario, the main characters are either oblivious or duty bound to ignore how attractive all of their co-workers are. Having established that the heroes are €“ mostly €“ too noble and professional to be distracted by a passing femme fatale, writers seem to love the notion that a voluptuous villain will instead use some sort of pheromone control or hypnosis to grab a position of power and have all the regular male characters acting as her panting lapdogs. It€™s a hackneyed teenage power fantasy that €“ dismayingly €“ managed to make it into this year€™s Agents Of SHIELD, a show supposedly under the eye of Buffy mastermind Joss Whedon. Initially presented as a cool and calculating vamp, the Seductress is usually revealed as a spoiled tantrum-thrower when whatever trick she€™s using is exposed. Apart from perpetuating the outdated notion that beautiful women must be tricking and seducing their way into authority, these episodes normally have nothing meaningful to say and contain little for the actors to work with. Romance-by-hypnosis is no longer risqué TV €“ it€™s just creepy and embarrassing to watch.

8. Everyone Gets Possessed While You€™re Out

Paramount StudiosIf you€™re the hero of a sci-fi show, it€™s probably not worth ever going on holiday. Quite apart from the zany antics that€™ll ensue on your supposedly-relaxing vacation, the odds are good you€™ll arrive back home to find everyone acting€ strangely. The clues will be subtle to begin with €“ your spouse acts oddly distant when you try and snuggle up for your welcome-home present and the family dog growls at your approach. Gradually, you€™ll become aware of whispered conversations that stop as you enter the room, or meetings taking place without you. And just why is that one room suddenly off-limits, anyway? Your paranoia growing, you try to access records of what happened while you were away, only to find them destroyed or locked behind top-level security. At this point, you€™ll probably be reunited with the one person who€™s noticed something weird is going on. Bonus points if they€™ve been hiding in the ventilation ducts. Eventually you€™ll figure out a way to release everyone from their possession, but not before they€™ve started hunting you down €“ and while you can€™t hurt your friends, they€™re certainly happy to slaughter you. At the last second, you force your way into the forbidden room and discover, to your shock, the repentant writer of this uninspired and unwelcome conspiracy episode. As an allegory for the Cold War and the fear that those you loved could be brainwashed or subverted by an invisible menace, this type of possession plot was once very powerful. These days, it€™s a story that€™s easy to spot from a mile away. With the rise of arc-based sci-fi providing us with genuine conspiracies and betrayals, this is one plot that can be safely put to bed.

7. Everyone Loses Their Inhibitions

Warner Bros. TelevisionOn paper, having your characters resort to their baser instincts €“ or just act drunk and horny €“ must seem like a fantastic idea. You€™ll be using your regular cast on regular sets, but you€™ll get to see them playing off each other in a whole new way. It€™ll stretch the actors, it€™ll provide a few laughs and you€™ll get the comedy pay-off of everyone being socially awkward when it all wears off. Especially if two of the characters had sex, ha ha! Burn that paper. The theory may be sound, but this is one plot that€™s always so terribly executed it€™d probably be best if humanity just cut its losses and forgot the idea even existed. One of the most infamous examples is The Naked Now, the second episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation which decides to flat-out duplicate an Original Series plot. Recycling material from a show you€™re being unfavourably compared to is a daft enough idea at the best of times, but having your cast act out of character when you€™ve barely established who they are on a normal Tuesday? Madness. More recently, writers have tried to put a darker spin on the notion by gradually stripping away the moral safeguards that characters place upon themselves. Whether it€™s the Doctor declaring himself Time Lord Victorious or Walter Bishop battling his own psychosis, these moments are far more effective - they€™re revealing genuine traits that the characters must struggle to suppress every day, and not just because the plot of the week demands it.

6. Endlessly-Growing Space Plants

MGMWhether it€™s a mutual appreciation for Little Shop of Horrors or just terror at having to mow the lawn every week, sci-fi writers seem to share a particular affinity this story. Someone brings back seemingly-innocent plant spores that proceed to grow ridiculously quickly, clogging up all the passageways with vines and sucking the power and/or life out of the surroundings. Perhaps there€™s some shared Writer€™s Guild trauma involving Harvard and an ill-attended spider plant? Whatever the reason, this plot crops up a lot, normally with minimal variation. On rare occasions the organism might be intelligent but mostly it€™s just a big ol€™ plant. It€™s quite common for episodic sci-fi to have a handful of €œproblem solving€ stories where the threat is purely scientific €“ Stargate SG-1 got a lot of mileage out of these. There€™s normally a ticking clock to ramp up the tension, something like a self-destruct that€™ll prevent the plant from getting into the water supply, and it gives the science-types a chance to show off their smarts while the other characters are running around with flamethrowers and jumbo cartons of Roundup. Still€ it€™s a plant. You are essentially watching 45 minutes of very aggressive gardening. The universe is full of amazing possibilities that sci-fi has barely begun to explore and we€™re watching grumpy soldiers hacking away at asparagus. Let€™s try for something more imaginative €“ if I want to see someone assaulting a salad, I€™ll watch Come Dine With Me instead.

5. The Bedford Falls Experience

Liberty FilmsFor the unfamiliar: Bedford Falls is the setting for seminal schmaltz-fest It€™s A Wonderful Life. While strictly a fantasy film, Frank Capra€™s classic managed to popularise an idea that would go onto become a staple of sci-fi €“ what would the world be like if the protagonist never existed? The film€™s source book draws more inspiration from A Christmas Carol than from scientific notions, but the idea€™s survived for over sixty years because it€™s such a common and intriguing consequence of science-fiction. When considering time travel and the grandfather paradox, the main character rarely understands the consequences of their actions until they return €œhome€ and see a world without a place for them. When multiverse theory captured the public€™s imagination, sci-fi was on hand to depict alternative realities where the main cast had never met or even been born. It€™s A Wonderful Life is still shown every Christmas €“ and that€™s part of the problem. Whether it€™s Back to the Future or Sliders, there€™s very little about the idea that sci-fi hasn€™t already covered, often superbly. We€™ve seen the full spectrum of what-ifs, from a world that€™s happier because Ebenezer Scrooge is dead to a universe that€™s crumbling without the Doctor to save it. As a sci-fi or fantasy fan it€™s almost impossible not to have seen this plot a dozen times before, and as great as Bedford Falls may be, I€™m getting a little tired of visiting.

4. Trapped In VR

SyfyTech enthusiasts may find the public€™s lack of enthusiasm for Virtual Reality baffling, but it€™s only because sci-fi has taught us a valuable lesson: the minute you stuff yourself into a lycra bodysuit and headset for a game of virtual badminton, all hell€™s going to break loose. Sci-fi likes to up the ante and the peril by having participants wire themselves directly into the VR system while mumbling vaguely about psychosomatic consequences €“ die in the simulation and your brain€™s so astonished by the whole affair that it promptly induces a heart attack. When the safety features inevitably get turned off and characters find themselves facing down Wild West gunslingers or pirates, there can be genuine jeopardy despite the unreal nature of it all. Except€ it€™s all bit contrived nowadays, isn€™t it? As VR becomes a reality, it€™s hard to suspend your disbelief and buy that someone would build something so dangerous, let alone use it as a recreational pursuit. Even in Star Trek, some of the best uses of its holodeck weren€™t about trapping the crew with a bunch of gangsters but the occasions it was used to recreate a murder or provide an expression of a machine€™s evolving subconscious. Writers love VR because it€™s a chance to travel outside of the usual sci-fi settings to write something Western or historical, and producers love VR because it lets them shoot on the old soundstage next door. Ultimately, though, it€™s about making the choices that result in the best TV, not the easiest TV. Here in the real world, we€™re finding amazing things to do with virtual reality. It€™s about time sci-fi caught up.

3. Proud Alien Warriors

CBSMankind seems to have a soft spot for groups of burly blokes sitting around in big halls quaffing ale and bragging about how many people they honourably slaughtered before breakfast. The Klingons are undoubtedly the most well-known example of outer-space Vikings; they€™ve inspired generations of bank managers and geography teachers to spend their weekends scaring the staff of Pizza Hut by trying to slice a stuffed crust with a bat€™leth, but most sci-fi series have warrior cultures of their own. They make for layered and interesting villains who€™re just as happy fighting alongside you to defeat a greater threat as they are punching your face off because you spilt their grandmother€™s pint. And yet, for whatever reason, sci-fi writers invariably decide that what we€™d really like to see is alien warrior political intrigue €“ lots of sneaky chaps running around in the shadows and arranging assassinations and coups in-between writing up the High Council€™s minutes. These proud fighters are reduced to middle-aged loudmouths who seem to like nothing better than sitting around a table for hours on end arguing which type of floral roundabout would bring the most honour to the local parish. Even if the backstabbing and political shenanigans does end up in a great big fistfight, alien warrior politics is a tedious waste of characters who just aren€™t suited to the role. If you€™ve established that their culture€™s built around strength and honour, let them fight - preferably without having to file their tax returns first.

2. The Intelligent Virus

BBC WorldwideThis particular cliché comes in not one, but two delicious flavours of tedium €“ either it€™s a good old-fashioned fleshy virus or, in more recent sci-fi, it€™s a computer virus instead. Of course, the characters don€™t immediately realise the virus is intelligent; that€™s a revelation saved for the halfway point of the episode, where someone will utter the line €œIt€™s as if the virus is trying to protect itself!€ and anyone who€™s ever used a computer dies a little inside. Real viruses try and protect themselves, setting files to read-only and creating multiple backups €“ it doesn€™t mean the five new browser toolbars I€™ve developed are an attempt at communication. Eventually, the virus will gain the ability to communicate directly with our heroes, either by infecting so much of their victim that it can work them like a meaty marionette, or utilising a nearby computer. After our heroes convince the virus that they didn€™t mean to kidnap it, both species can co-exist peacefully and many other platitudes, the virus agrees to be transported back home or to a special computer where it can live out the rest of its days spawning pop-up ads and logging your World of Warcraft details. It€™s remarkable how often this plot rears its hackneyed head, considering how obvious and uninteresting it is. Even if the audience doesn€™t recognise the story straight away, the episode normally flat-out tells us that the virus is sentient, meaning we spend the next hour watching the main cast playing catch-up as they trudge through a story we€™ve been tired of since the 80s.

1. Bodyswapping

BBC WorldwideWhile it may not be as overused as some of the other entries on this list, there are few plots more obnoxious than the bodyswap €“ sometimes known as the €œFreaky Friday€ plot, named after the movie where a mother and daughter switch bodies by wishing really hard. If you€™re unfortunate enough to be watching a bodyswap episode, the best you can hope for is that it€™ll be played for laughs €“ the actors will have a good time mimicking one another and there€™ll be a bunch of in-jokes and sight gags as characters attempt to control unfamiliar superpowers or body parts. Even the stoniest heart can€™t resist the simple charm of Red Dwarf€™s Rimmer, at his first meal in three million years, pouring gravy over his own head. It€™s when the bodyswap is used to inject peril or drama that everything collapses €“ for instance, when the villain takes over the hero€™s body and the hero finds themselves trapped in an asylum or surrounded by thugs and murderers, escaping just in time for the inevitable €œfighting yourself€ battle at the episode€™s climax. If your best friend suddenly forgot where they lived, every shared adventure and the fact that they have a lethal peanut allergy€ well, you might not immediately deduce the truth, but nor would you shrug it off as them €œnot feeling well€. These are characters who deal with alien possession, intelligent viruses and energy beings on a daily basis - but in spite of all their prior experience, everyone has to lose 50 IQ points for this plot to work. If you have to make your characters uncharacteristically stupid to tell a story, it probably isn€™t a story worth telling.