10 Small Details You Only Notice Rewatching Dexter
What are the killer hints and subtle foreshadowing that only seem obvious on a second viewing?
Dexter was a TV series that ran for eight seasons between 2006 and 2013. With the character and original concept based off a novel by Jeffry P. Freundlich (under the pen-name Jeff Lindsay), the series garnered praise throughout most of its run with a few notably poorly-received seasons sprinkled in.
The series follows Dexter Morgan, a blood-spatter analyst for the Miami Police Department who is also a serial killer. The entire premise is that he kills only those who deserve death, channelling his urges (which he refers to as the "Dark Passenger") into something that could be construed as useful to society instead of harmful.
While it should be obvious, from here on out there will be heavy spoilers for plot points throughout the entire series as these are in no particular order of significance or chronology. If you have any intention of watching the series and haven't done so yet, please don't read any further.
Whether the series should have ended before it did - or what should have been changed about that final episode - is not what we are going to look at. Instead, we'll try and find the small details that the show put throughout all eight seasons that we probably didn't pick up on first time round.
10. Return To Sender
Initially, Dexter's preferred method of body disposal is to take them out on his boat to an area called the "Underwater Graveyard". This is a deep drop-off in the ocean where he weighs their body parts down with stones in order to prevent them resurfacing.
One of Rita's children, Cody, has a goldfish named Bob who sadly passes away. Dexter assists him in flushing the remains down the toilet, only for the body to resurface shortly after.
In the very same episode, the last victim that Dexter has killed and disposed of is found on land and he is part of the team investigating, essentially being stuck trying to throw colleagues off the trail of a murder that he himself has committed. In reality, the Ice Truck Killer has retrieved the body and deliberately placed it in order to taunt Dexter.
You could also argue that Bob the goldfish appearing back in the toilet bowl is reminiscent of a later time when divers discover the underwater graveyard in its entirety and Dexter is forced to switch to disposing of bodies in the powerful Gulf Stream, relying on the current to drag them far away from detection.
9. The Getaway
The main antagonist of the fourth season is Arthur, the Trinity Killer, who shares some characteristics with the BTK killer in the real world, and is portrayed in a chilling and excellent performance by John Lithgow. In the season finale, "The Getaway", Dexter's secret life has been discovered by Arthur and Dexter has likewise realised who Arthur is.
When Arthur is finally captured by Dexter and knows he is about to be killed, they have a discussion that centres around their similarities and differences. There is one key line that is often overlooked because of a major point and twist that is revealed almost immediately after this scene, but here is the line that Dexter speaks : -
"So what's the alternative, Arthur? Leave? Disappear? Fake my own death and start over again?"
For fans who suffered through the seasons following this one and endured what has been largely touted as the worst final episode in any television series ever, they will recognise that this largely sarcastic line reflects almost exactly what Dexter ends up doing at the very end of season eight.
This line is often overlooked in favour of "it's already over" which is followed by Dexter discovering that Arthur has already murdered Rita.
8. Remember The Monsters?
The final ever episode of Dexter was the twelfth of season eight and to say that it has divided opinion would be kind. Dexter's foster sister Debra has been a mainstay through the entire series and her relationship with him became an increasing focus as the episodes passed. Also working in the same police department, her foul-mouthed rants and her brash personality made her a memorable character throughout.
By the end of the eighth season, she has been shot and is taken to hospital. While there, she suffers a stroke and slips into a coma. Dexter unplugs her life support and manages to get her body onto his boat where he takes her out to sea and disposes of her body in a rather touching scene.
Although it may be blindingly obvious to some, while this is similar to how Dexter disposes of other bodies, there is a very stark distinction between this and his normal methods. While his murder victims are placed into black bin liners, Debra is wrapped in a white sheet before being dropped overboard.
It may seem sensible to not treat his foster sister in the same way as just another body to be gotten rid of, but the polar opposite colours hammer home how differently he feels about this disposal.
7. Left Turn Ahead
In the penultimate episode of season two, one of Dexter's co-workers has found out his true identity as "The Bay Harbour Butcher." Sgt James Doakes has been suspicious for a long time and eventually found enough evidence, but Dexter has captured him and locked him up.
He is very close to accepting Doakes' advice to turn himself in, spending one last day of freedom with Rita and her children and daydreaming about what would happen if he were to confess his crimes to Debra.
In the end, none of this comes to pass, as the cabin where he is being held is blown up and Doakes passes away. Instead of Dexter's whole secret life being unravelled and his secret exposed, it is now assumed that it was Doakes who was the serial killer all along.
During one of their exchanges however, the Sergeant tells Dexter that this "darkness" inside of him will harm Rita, her children and Debra if he doesn't turn himself in. Obviously, Doakes does not live to see this prophecy come true but Debra and Rita both die as a result of their association with Dexter and Rita's children are left abandoned in the end, much like Dexter himself was.
6. Easy As Pie
In season three, episode seven Dexter is finding himself conflicted when he is considering killing someone who Harry would deem as "innocent", but is suffering due to cancer. He struggles with the morality of being able to execute killers without any remorse, and his seeming inability to perform murder as an act of mercy to a dying woman who is in pain and has asked him to do so.
Camilla Figg is the woman in question, who worked in the records department at the police precinct. Her friendliness with Dexter allowed him to access files and records on people that he wanted to trace or kill. She is seen smoking throughout and receives a terminal diagnosis of lung cancer. In pain and with only a month to live, she wants Dexter to end her suffering.
He eventually does, despite his mixed feelings and betraying his code, but there is an exchange between Deb and Dexter when they are discussing Camilla's predicament that reflects exactly how the end of the series plays out. Deb states that if she was ever like that she would want to be put out of her misery. She even specifies "pull the plug" at one point.
More than five seasons later, Dexter does that for her.
5. A Little Reflection
A detail that would not so much be overlooked as missed entirely is a small nod to a real-life person hinted at in a key character name from season 8.
The main antagonist of the season is a killer known as "The Brain Surgeon" who removes brain tissue from all of his victims. His character name is Oliver Saxon and he is portrayed on the screen by Darri Ingolfsson.
Whether it is a deliberate choice or not, the name bears a resemblance to noted British neurologist Oliver Wolf Sacks. While his list of achievements and contributions to our understanding of how the mind works is long and storied, there is a particular part that has found its way into the mainstream.
The 1990 film "Awakenings" starring the late, great Robin Williams is a retelling of Sack's 1973 memoir of the same name, where he documented his efforts to use a revolutionary drug to "awake" people who were in various catatonic states. While the drug was instrumental, a large focus is on how these patients now have to adapt to a world that has moved on many decades in some cases and with these portions of their life missing.
He was awarded the CBE in 2008 and passed away in 2015.
4. Get Gellar
In season six, Professor James Gellar (played by Edward James Olmos) is an expert in End Times Mythology and plays the role of the main antagonist.
While the reveal that he has in fact been dead for almost three years is initially jarring to the viewer and a clever twist, on subsequent re-watching, there are many hints that can be picked up on to make this more obvious earlier on.
Much like The Sixth Sense and Tyler Durden in fight club, once you know that the character does not really exist, it becomes obvious that they never interact with the environment or other characters. His student, Travis, (who is responsible for killing him) suffers deep psychological issues and believes him to be alive, but he is more of a manifestation of Travis' darker urges.
This plays out subtly, initially at least, where you notice that Gellar never does anything physical at all. Travis is "made" to do any kind of interaction with people including handing over money when buying things. There is also a scene in the car where "Gellar" pushes down on Travis' leg to make him run over a woman.
Watching again and knowing the truth, these seem far more obvious than first time around.
3. Sin Of Omission
We have already established a number of times how the series ends and that is with Dexter performing a mercy kill on Debra while she is in a coma. She unwillingly described the exact scenario two seasons earlier while talking to her therapist, Michelle Ross.
While in the process of their discussions, Michelle is instrumental in making Debra realise her love for Dexter - which is at least a little bit uncomfortable, as they are foster siblings. There is this exchange in "Sin Of Omission", season six, episode eight while they are discussing the latest victim of "The Doomsday Killer". Travis is revealed to be the killer in the end and the victim in question is his sister. Debra says words to this effect about the situation:
"And I think she was trying to protect him, which is what a good sister does. And then, he ends up killing her."
While the way that Travis and Dexter are responsible for taking the life of their respective sisters is vastly different, there is no denying that Deb went out of her way and risked a lot to protect her brother and he did indeed end up killing her.
2. Go Your Own Way
In the third season, we are introduced to the character of Miguel Prado who is the Assistant District Attorney. When his brother is murdered after interrupting a planned kill by Dexter, he shows the full extent to which he is willing to bend the law to attain "justice".
Dexter finds and kills the man who he had originally targeted and who everyone believes killed Miguel's brother. Miguel finds him at the kill site with a bloody weapon in hand and does not report it, happy to know that the man is dead. While they become close and Miguel persuades Dexter to let him participate in a kill, once he attempts to convince Dexter to murder a woman who does not fit "the code", Dexter becomes concerned.
When Miguel kills the woman anyway, he ends up dead by Dexter's hand. Dexter views him as a warning as to what he could have become without Harry's code.
The small detail occurs in the above named episode, where the two men and their partners are eating together. The four glasses toasting are shot from above and the two glasses filled with red wine that looks like blood belong to the two men who have killed. A small cinematographic detail, but interesting nonetheless.
1. Father Knows Best
For those who aren't familiar with the series, Dexter's main influence is his stepfather called Harry, who provided him with his "code" to control his dark urges and use them only when it was deemed appropriate. Harry's code ensured that Dexter only killed people who had themselves committed murder and only once he had irrefutable proof that this was the case. In almost all cases, Dexter follows this code to the letter, with very few exceptions.
In the ninth episode of the first season, we learn that Dexter's biological father has only passed away recently, despite being told he was long dead. He travels to the house alongside Rita and Rudy (who is both his brother and the Ice Truck Killer : - neither fact is known to Dexter at this point) in order to sort out his father's affairs.
While other key points for the first season are created, continued and moved along by this process, the fact that might be overlooked by some on first viewing is the way in which Dexter packages his father's belongings. He does so in a way that is very similar to how he wraps up his victims.
This is almost certainly deliberate and what it is meant to mean is up for debate, but it can pass you by the first time around.