10 Things RTD's Return WON'T Bring To Doctor Who
It won't have David Tennant in it, but it will be MARVELLOUS!
Earlier this month, it was revealed that Russell T Davies' former partner in crime Phil Collinson was also returning to Doctor Who as production begins on the 14th series. It's turning out to be quite the comeback tour, so let's hope it's more Elvis Presley in 1968 rather than the Vegas years.
Collinson's involvement has, predictably, led to speculation over what other elements the RTD2 era will bring. Should we expect Murray Gold to come back to score the new series? It remains to be seen, but what should be clear to anyone who's followed Russell T's career over the past few decades, is that he's only doing this because he has a new vision.
In the past four years, Davies has written about the MP Jeremy Thorpe and his plot to have his lover killed, charted the rise of fascism in a dystopian future UK, documented the AIDS pandemic in the 1980s and has recently written a biopic of soap actor Noele Gordon. That's a varied and diverse list of credits. Whatever he's bringing to Doctor Who, it's going to be brand new.
So, in the absence of information to the contrary, let's discuss what the RTD2 era is not going to be.
10. David Tennant Full-Time
According to a "credible" BBC source, David Tennant has been cast as the 14th Doctor, making him the first actor to play two incarnations of the character. Except, he already is, isn't he? According to Time of the Doctor, between the opening of Journey's End and the closing moments of The End of Time Part 2 David Tennant is playing the 11th Doctor, regenerated with the same face.
The rumour was circulated on that 100% reliable source of political, epidemiological and vaccination information, Facebook. So it's likely bogus. If we must do a multi-Doctor story for the 60th then Tennant will be a shoe-in for a return; he doesn't miss an opportunity these days!
As the 14th Doctor, though? The perception of the show in certain quarters is that it's too inward-looking, too obsessed with the past. Bringing back a former Doctor would not only play into this, but it would make the damaging suggestion that the show's best days are behind it and what we really want is the golden age back again.
9. Christopher Eccleston in the 60th
One thing that we can be sure of with regards to the 60th anniversary is that Christopher Eccleston won't be playing any part in it. At least, not on-screen.
Whilst he's recently returned to the role for a series of Big Finish audios, it appears that the rift between him and Russell T Davies hasn't been healed in the intervening years. Eccleston's autobiography highlights a lot of what he felt to be the failures of that first series; most notably, a lack of direction and guidance on the character of the Doctor.
If that was, as Eccleston suggests, an issue with Davies' writing, then taking part in an RTD-scripted anniversary special won't hold much appeal. It's probably for the best. The Big Finish audios have proved that, stripped from that tight survivor's guilt arc of the first series, the Ninth Doctor is slightly adrift. By the very nature of being "missing" adventures, the audios are unable to push the character in a new and interesting direction.
The real tragedy of the Eccleston/RTD rift is that one of our best character actors and one of our best television writers will likely never work together again.
8. Toning Down the "Politics"
Doctor Who's too political these days, they cry! It's too woke! The political messaging is too on-the-nose!
There's not the word count to list all the political elements of the show's past, but look at some of Russell T Davies' previous work. World War Three has villainous aliens engineer a war from inside Downing Street to get their hands on precious minerals whilst talking of "weapons of massive destruction". His most recent work, It's A Sin, resonated so strongly last year, reframing the AIDS "crisis" as what it was; a pandemic that killed too many young people due to government and societal indifference.
Whilst it might be more nuanced than some of the episodes in the Chibnall era, the RTD2 era won't shy away from using Doctor Who to reflect the issues that affect us today. It's what the series has arguably done from it's very beginning. The political subtext is going nowhere with Russell T Davies at the helm. Didn't anyone watch Years and Years?
It'll be interesting to see what issues the new series will tackle. The Long Game already tackled fake news, whilst The Sontaran Stratagem dealt with smart speakers. Whatever they are, he's not short of material in the current climate!
7. The Nyssa Adventures
When Russell T Davies was announced as returning to Doctor Who, many fans highlighted a recent interview where he had pointed to Marvel and Star Wars' cinematic universes as fertile territory for the series to explore. Talking of a limited series for the 10th and 11th Doctors and The Nyssa Adventures, it's probably best to take it with a pinch of salt.
Whilst rumours have begun to emerge of an anthology series featuring past Doctor Who characters, it's likely that we won't be seeing many classic series companions. To be polite, modern television is a lot more realistic and less stagey than it was during the original run and a lot of those actors haven't done much contemporary work.
If there are to be spin-offs, which is highly likely, they won't be focusing on characters last seen 40 years previously. If anything, they'll spin-off from elements of the mythology. Look at the success of The Mandalorian compared to the ambivalent response to The Book of Boba Fett. We're more likely to get a Time Agency series than the continuing adventures of Nyssa of Traken. Even The Vinder, Bel and Tigmi Show is a more likely proposition.
6. Torchwood
On the subject of spin-offs, some fans are hoping that the return of Russell T Davies may herald a return for everyone's favourite sci-fi shagfest, Torchwood. It won't. The series went off-air back in 2011 after the deeply flawed and overlong transatlantic co-production Miracle Day. Despite a cliffhanger ending, no one wanted another outing for the team.
It's coming up for 11 years since Torchwood was last on TV, and it was never a massive hit. Children of Earth was certainly the high point, but it doesn't live long in the popular imagination.11 years is a long time for something to be off-air, especially in this content heavy decade. Sure, The X-Files came back after 18 years, but that show was massive in its day. Torchwood just doesn't have that same cultural cache or nostalgic appeal.
And that's before we even get to the elephant in the room, John Barrowman's inappropriate on-set behaviour. When it resurfaced in the wake of the Noel Clarke allegations, Barrowman initially played ball, making apologetic statements and staying out of the limelight. For many fans, he's still persona non-grata, which would be a huge hurdle for any potential Torchwood comeback to tackle.
5. The Same Old Format
By the time of David Tennant's third series, the rigid format of the RTD years was beginning to feel staid - present day, past adventure, alien planet, space, celebrity historical. Both Steven Moffat and Chris Chibnall have experimented with moving the format on from this, but have both fallen back on it as a reliable template.
Will Russell T Davies do the same? It remains to be seen, as we've not even had his first episodes yet! However, on launching a new series he'll be looking to do something fresh. Possible 14th Doctor and actor in both Years and Years and It's A Sin, Lydia West has said she thinks Russell will bring "a modern twist" to the series. It's what he did when he brought it back in 2005, and a lot has changed in the interim 17 years.
Whatever this modern twist is, it's not going to be the format he perfected in his first era. His successor (and predecessor, how very Doctor Who!) Steven Moffat said that he's heard some of Russell's plans, stating that he wouldn't be doing this if he wasn't going to "scare the s**t out of you". Exciting!
4. The Same Old Writers
Just because Russell is back, it doesn't mean that the same team of writers will be returning. Gareth Roberts has already asserted that he has no interest in returning to the show or the BBC, even if he was asked. Which he likely wouldn't be. What of other writers?
Steven Moffat has two or three projects currently in development and his departure still feels relatively recent. Similarly, the prolific Mark Gatiss stated his belief that Empress of Mars would likely be the last Doctor Who story he'd write. If he was to ever come back, it feels more likely that it would be as a showrunner.
So who will be writing on the new series? Perhaps a clue lies in BBC Director of Drama Piers Wenger's assertion that Russell will build on the extraordinary achievements of the Chibnall era? Will he keep on some of the great writers we've had over the past few years like Vinay Patel, Joy Wilkinson or Maxine Alderton?
Perhaps he'll be shepherding a new generation of writers who grew up with the show, or nurturing new talent as he did on his series Banana, which featured episodes by End of the F***ing World writer Charlie Covell.
3. A White Male Doctor of a Certain Age
Some of the more vocal members of the Not My Doctor brigade were quick to praise the return of RTD as something akin to the second coming of Jesus Christ. He was coming back to save the show from the perceived sins of the Chibnall era! Except, he isn't. If anything, he's going to continue in striding forward. After all, he outlined his view of progressively more inclusionary portrayals of the Doctor in his Target novelisation of Rose.
The likelihood is that we'll have another female Doctor, as we should do. Such a seismic change requires sticking to your guns. If Jodie Whittaker regenerates into a man, it'll set back a lot of the work she's done to cement the idea in the public imagination. If she regenerates into someone like Lydia West, it's no big deal, and we can finally move on from the female Doctor debate.
If Russell T Davies does cast a man in the role, though, you can bet that we're not going back to having a white male Doctor of a certain age. It's one of many reasons that Omari Douglas is a more viable option for the 14th Doctor than their It's A Sin co-star Olly Alexander.
2. A Retconning of the Timeless Child
Those furious fans who are outraged that the Doctor had the temerity to have a fictional life prior to being the actor William Hartnell are hopeful that the RTD2 era will retcon the past five years of mythology. Most notably, the reveal that the Doctor isn't actually a Gallifreyan but is instead a creature from another world in another universe.
As the man who blew up Gallifrey in a Time War to restore some mystery to the character, is it really likely that Russell T Davies will miss the opportunity to build on this new enigma? It all depends on what happens in Jodie Whittaker's final two stories of course, but the Timeless Child won't be retconned.
If anything, RTD will double down on it, pushing the show in new and interesting directions. The Doctor as an orphan without a past is as intriguing a protagonist as the damaged survivor of an intergalactic time war. The only way the Timeless Child would be forgotten about is so it can be put on the back burner as we get to know the Doctor's new companion. Rest assured, it will always be there.
1. 14 Episodes a Year
BBC funding has been frozen and the television landscape has changed considerably in the 12 years since Russell first left. It's not feasible for a show like Doctor Who to churn out thirteen episodes and a Christmas special every year. Especially if you want it to compete in a crowded sci-fi marketplace. The budgets just won't stretch that far.
The fact that the show is now a co-production with Bad Wolf may help with the budgetary issues, but it still doesn't seem like a feasible option to essentially make fourteen feature films a year. So what's the alternative? The answer may lie in Jodie Whittaker's troubled final series. Presumably Flux and the subsequent specials were originally envisioned as a ten part series but due to COVID, lockdowns and other obstacles, it was restructured.
This model of a six-part miniseries followed by three specials, then rinse and repeat might be the best way forward for the series. It can ensure that the effects work can finally match the ambition of the scripts, we saw proof of that in Flux. By turning Doctor Who into an "event" series it can reflect the model of similar shows and hopefully reinvigorate itself for a new audience.