10 Times Star Trek Was So Bad It Was Good

Star Trek is always enjoyable but it's not always good.

By Bowen Revill /

There’s a lot of Star Trek. It’s been on the go for 50 years and except for one or two relativity short hiatuses, the franchise has been active for most of that time. If you watched it twenty-four hours a day it would take over three weeks to watch all of Star Trek. And a lot more is Trek due to be added to the cannon in the coming years (what a time to be alive!).

Advertisement

With the sheer volume of entries, it’s hardly surprising that there are a few duds. You just can’t hit a home run every time. Often, it takes a bit of time for a Star Trek series to find its feet. The Original Series, The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, Voyager, Enterprise and Discovery all have a couple of ropey initial seasons, but they grow in quality as they develop. On top of that, there’s the old curse which plagues the odd-numbered movie entries.

While some entries represent landmark events in television and film, others fall far short of that. But there’s always something to enjoy. In amidst the hundreds of episodes and a baker’s dozen movies, there are some instalments that are elevated to one of the most enjoyable categories of entertainment, they are so bad that they’re good.

Here are ten instalments that are so terrible that they transcend the meagre sum of their parts and become as enjoyable as any of their lauded counterparts.

10. Stardust City Rag - Star Trek Picard

Hard to believe that one of the newest instalments of Trek appears on this list but here it is. Now, this episode is by no means a laughable disaster, but there are points at which you’re left wondering what hell is going on. In a delightfully over the top sequence, Captain Picard dresses up as a camp, pantomime, French pirate; complete with a hammy accent, eye patch and beret. In this getup, he attempts to pass himself off as a black-market people trafficker. Pretty dark content matter for such a ridiculous scene.

Advertisement

We’ve seen Picard undercover before, as the gruff smuggler, Galen, in TNG’s Gambit. Even in this straight performance, it was strange to see Picard acting so out of character. In this new episode, it was so over the top that it was confusing to watch. It didn’t fit the tone of the show or the character and came out of nowhere, but it was hilarious to see Stuart hamming it up.

Strictly the episode wasn’t so bad it was good, some of it was good, some of it wasn’t. Whatever else it was, the episode was overshadowed by Patrick Stewart as the camp, French pirate. That moment was so bad it was brilliant.

What the hell were they thinking?

9. The Way To Eden - The Original Series

Space hippies. Oh yes, authentic space hippies. It’s colourful, cloying and it's creepy. It’s terrible and it's memorable.

Advertisement

The space hippies are determined to find Eden and are convinced that they know where it is. They’re so desperate to get there they steal a shuttle and make a dash for it. Unfortunately for them, the Enterprise crew are in no mood for joyriders and put a swift stop to their shenanigans.

Once aboard the Enterprise, the hippies quickly put a band together, recruiting Spock on the Vulcan lute. While everyone is distracted by the sweet, sweet music, the hippies take over the ship and take it to Eden. Eden looks pretty cool; unfortunately, every square inch of it is secreting poisonous acid.

It couldn’t have been more of its time. It also couldn’t have been more on the nose.

Hippies following a charismatic leader, seeking a paradise that is fuelled by acid. There’s actually some depth to the analysis but the delivery is silly, the characters are annoying, and the social commentary seems at best lost in the plot and at worse unintentional. It’s unforgettable though.

8. Unexpected - Enterprise

Commander Tucker visits an alien ship to help do a bit of ‘engineering’. He shags the first alien female he sees and she gets him pregnant. By the time he finds out, the alien ship is long gone. In a series as frequently joyless as Enterprise, this bit of silliness is a breath of fresh air.

Advertisement

It’s fun to see a man burdened with the consequences of a one night stand. The gender role reversal doesn’t last long as the crew enthusiastically abandon their aimless wandering and, relieved to have something to do, track down the alien ship so they can dump the offspring on the mother and restore the patriarchal status quo.

Commander Tucker wasn’t the first sci-fi man to end up in the family way. Lister, Red Dwarf, Anyone? He ended up with twins (he dumped them on the mother too). If you’re not careful it could happen to you!

Practise safe sex people.

7. The Royale - The Next Generation

Camp, cheap, silly, self-aware and a joy to watch. In this early episode of TNG, the cast, the writers and everyone were just having fun. The stakes weren’t high, the message wasn’t deep, even the characters were just going along with it and enjoying their crazy, crazy job as space adventurers.

Advertisement

In an era of entertainment when the drama is always dialled up to eleven, where it’s always life or death and where the audience is always on edge, it’s relief to watch something easy going. The Royale delivers this flawlessly. The crew get trapped in a casino, which aliens created based on a description from a trashy novel. Riker, Data and Worf must act out pulpy novel’s story in order to escape. Data wears a cowboy hat and throws some dice, they enjoy themselves, we enjoy ourselves.

This one has ‘so bad it’s good’ baked into it. The plot literally centres around the crew acting out a bad novel. Turn off your brain, relax and enjoy!

6. Move Along Home - Deep Space Nine

Deep Space Nine got off to a pretty shaky start. Those shakes were more like tremors in Move Along Home. The crew are forced to be the pieces in a board game where the stakes are ostensibly deadly, while Quark is forced to be the game player. Who wouldn’t love that? It’s very much like The Original Series in the wacky peril of its concept.

Advertisement

The cast just doesn’t seem bought into it, as everything seems a bit awkward as they move through the stages of the game. The most cringe-worthy bit is when they’re all forced to play hopscotch while singing a nursery rhyme. While the characters are supposed to be uncomfortable with it, the cast seems pretty embarrassed too.

As the unwilling game player Quark really shines, simultaneously revelling in it all and fearing jeopardy they’re all in. Quark in a tight spot is always a joy to see.

Games are fun. That’s what this episode is. It has absolutely nothing else going for it. But it is fun.

5. Star Trek V: The Final Frontier

What’s better than aliens? God? How about both? That’s Star Trek V.

Advertisement

The odd-numbered Star Trek movies hold a curse. While it’s only a superstition, there’s not much evidence against it. Generally, the even-numbered entries outshine the odd. The story in Star Trek V is actually similar to The Way to Eden. Some hippy types follow a flawed leader on a quest to find Eden and in this case - God. It doesn’t work out, but we all learn a valuable lesson, which we quickly forget.

This is an example of the crew just having a great time. It’s terrific to see the strong and natural rapport between the actors on screen, there are plenty of intentionally comedic moments that land really well and the silly central story just adds to the fun of the whole thing. ‘What does God want with a starship?’ Who cares, let’s just have fun.

4. Masks - The Next Generation

Season seven of The Next Generation drips with quality. It’s clearly got the budget it needs, the acting is outstanding and the storytelling is exceptional. Masks has many of these qualities but at the same time, it’s just a bit out there. But in its weirdness, it’s glorious.

Advertisement

The Enterprise comes across an ancient archive floating through space. As they begin to investigate, the archive starts to transform the ship into a stone temple and Data takes on the personas of a sun god and her followers. The best part comes at the climax when Picard, acknowledging that he doesn’t know what he’s doing, puts on a moon god mask and in a pseudo-romantic exchange with Data, talks the sun god to sleep and saves the day.

It was all bit ambitious and as a result a bit crazy. But it’s not just good because it’s bad, there are some genuinely great things about it too. Brent Spiner puts in a stellar performance as a Data who has been overtaken by multiple personalities. He switches between charters seamlessly and makes all of them real. The other performances are great too. Everyone plays it straight and as such you really buy into the bizarre events which unfold.

3. Spock’s Brain - The Original Series

The episode is absurd, the delivery is ridiculous and it’s one of the most enjoyable episodes of Star Trek ever made.

Advertisement

As the Enterprise is cruising along, minding its own business, an alien beams aboard, knocks out the crew and steals Spock’s fantastic juicy brain. Fortunately, Spock can go without it for a while; not for long though, so the crew embark on a mission to retrieve it before it’s too late. The entire concept is hilarious. Some of the most entertaining aspects include Spock being operated by remote control, and in this manner, accompanying the crew on the quest to retrieve his brain. Then, when it is successfully retrieved, Spock uses the brain to provide instructions on how to reinstall the brain.

This is all made even funnier by the fact after season two, the fans campaigned hard to keep the show on the air. The studio listened and commissioned a third series. This was the first episode. After all that hard work and dedication, this is what the fans got.

Spock’s Brain went down in history as the worst of the worst Star Trek, but it’s infinitely enjoyable in its absurdity. Like Troll 2 and The Room, it transcends the sum of its terrible parts and is elevated to that lofty status of, ‘so bad it’s good’.

2. Threshold - Voyager

Tom Paris invents traswarp drive (that guy is like a swiss army knife), enabling the crew to travel anywhere in the universe in literally no time at all. Paris undertakes a successful test flight in a shuttle and the crew are optimistic that they will be home in no time. Unfortunately, the test flight does have some side effects. Paris transforms into a lizard. Then he kidnaps Captain Janeway, who also transforms into a lizard. They mate. Then have three lizard children. The crew retrieve them, turn them back into humans and promptly forget about the whole thing (including the lizard children who they abandon on some planet).

Advertisement

Forty-two minutes of pure, uncut, full-strength ROFLcopter.

Paris and Janeway mate and no one ever mentions it again! Not even an awkward glance. Not even a bit of gossip on the lower decks.

The Doctor turns them back into humans without breaking a holographic sweat. Why didn’t they use the transwarp to go home, all become lizards, then have The Doctor turn them all back human? It would have been easier than being stuck with each other for another five years. Missed a trick there.

1. Star Trek: The Motion Picture

Snooze fest! Too long, slow-paced, bloated story, no tangible villain and visually beige. But, aside from all those problems, this isn’t a bad movie at all. It’s not what people expected and it’s not what the studio was hoping for. Star Trek: The Motion Picture was hot off the heels of Star Wars, that’s what got it greenlit, and that’s what everyone wanted.

Advertisement

What they got was pretty much the complete opposite to Star Wars. This is a ponderous movie, which takes its time to tell its story and which pays service to its fans. Fans who had waited ten years for it and never seen Star Trek on the big screen, or a big budget. The charters are given space to re-establish their dynamics and the threat is studied, reasoned with and understood rather than shot down. These are good things.

Yes, Star Wars is great, but a movie doesn’t have to be like Star Wars to be great.

Star Trek: The Motion Picture is flawed, it does drag on a bit, the colour palette is like an anaesthetic for the eyes, but these flaws are part of it, part of its charm and alongside being good for its flaws, it’s also just good.

Advertisement