10 TV Cancellations We're Still Not Over
The shows most deserving of a revival...
There's nothing better than sitting down to a new TV show, ready to invest your time into a sprawling, multi-season epic. Be it a sitcom, drama, or a slice of science-fiction, the feeling of getting into a show and watching the characters grow and the plot unfold is second to none. So, when a show is cancelled, out of the blue and with no satisfactory conclusion to the story you've been watching, it can be close to heartbreak.
Now there are of course some fair reasons for a show's cancellation, be it because of low ratings, expense or the inability to settle on where the series is going, but none of these do much for the people at home who have invested so much in a given story.
The more annoying reasons - behind-the-scenes feuds, scheduling conflicts and cancellation to make way for a new show - also don't do much to ease fans' minds.
The following list will have a look at some of these TV shows - those cancelled before their time, and all having caused something of an uproar in their respective fandoms.
10. Vinyl
From the minds of Martin Scorsese, Terence Winter, Rich Cohen and Mick Jagger, it seems as though Vinyl was almost guaranteed to succeed. Though the first season ran for ten episodes, and HBO were so happy with the pilot that they confidently green-lit a second season, the show was unfairly cancelled, leaving fans (and Scorsese) heartbroken.
The show followed Richie Finestra (Bobby Cannavale), a record executive on the seventies New York music scene. With a slew of staggering performances, primarily from Cannavale, Ray Romano, Olivia Wilde and Juno Temple, and an engaging premise rife with sex, drugs, rock 'n' roll and music history, Vinyl was only just getting into the swing of things when HBO gave it the axe, stating that it was too cost-heavy and not generating enough viewers.
Scorsese seemed more upset by this news than anyone, claiming the decision was "tragic" and that he wished he had had the opportunity to be more involved with the show as it evolved. Us, too, Mr Scorsese. Us too.
9. Deadwood
One of the ultimate examples of TV shows cancelled before their time, Deadwood ran for three seasons before HBO had it cancelled.
There are a number of reasons floating around about why it was axed, from the high costs of the episodes and the set design to HBO's acquiring of True Blood, which they believed would draw in more ratings, but one thing that is for certain is that the series had way more left to give.
Following the titular location in South Dakota, the show documents Deadwood's rise from small, lawless camp to small, lawless town, and features Timothy Olyphant and Ian McShane as a clashing sheriff and businessman. Complete with tales of betrayal and the inclusion of real-life historical figures such as Wild Bill Hickok and Wyatt Earp, Deadwood has gone on to be regarded as one of the greatest shows of all time.
Shortly after its cancellation, showrunner David Milch agreed to make a two-hour film to finish up the show's story, but despite this being proposed in mid-2006 the film didn't find itself hitting fans' screens until 2019.
Deadwood: The Movie ended up being a solid venture, but it doesn't take away from the fact that the show was robbed of further seasons.
8. Angel
Although Season 5 of Angel was arguably the show's best run, and the ambiguous ending was a stroke of brilliance, it's sad to see that it wasn't allowed to continue.
The most frustrating part of its cancellation is that it really could have been avoided. According to producer David Fury, Buffy/Angel creator Joss Whedon pushed the network for an early renewal, but the WB Network didn't take to the idea and scrapped the whole thing. Fury has gone on record to say that Angel would almost definitely have been renewed if Whedon hadn't tried to force it.
Whedon himself likened the cancellation to a "healthy guy falling dead from a heart attack" and said that he was devastated. Fans were also massively unhappy, and letter writing campaigns, food drives, online petitions and the lobbying of other networks were all organised to bring it back.
Both Buffy and Angel's stories have been continued in the epic but bizarre Dark Horse comics series, but that's really not enough given how much promise the show had for future seasons.
7. Firefly
Another Joss Whedon creation, Firefly is the ultimate when it comes to thinking about shows which were cancelled too soon. Running for only one season, the show incorporated genres like sci-fi, western, fantasy, war and dystopia into a rush of fast-paced, exciting and endlessly inventive adventures.
Running for only 14 episodes, the show amassed a wide and passionate following, and after its cancellation a number of petitions and letter writing campaigns were put into place. Whedon has stated that he was broken up by the cancellation, and that he had planned for the show to continue for another seven years.
He didn't fully despair, as he began working on a film script in hopes of finishing the show. Attempts to have other networks acquire the series all fell through, so Whedon put forward his script, which led to the film Serenity being released three years after Firefly's cancellation.
Like Deadwood, the film was a solid and entertaining effort, but knowing that Whedon had such big plans for what was still to come makes the cancellation hurt even today, 18 years after the news first broke.
6. Daredevil
Between 2015 and 2019 Netflix ran a series of Marvel TV shows, only to have them all cancelled in rapid succession. None of them hurt quite as much as Daredevil, mind, given how much of a breath of fresh air Charlie Cox was to the role after the dismal Ben Affleck outing.
Coming face to face with crime lord Wilson Fisk, Matt Murdock must embrace his calling as a hero and clean up Hell's Kitchen. What followed was three seasons of brilliantly constructed superhero action fun, with the last aired season being the strongest of the bunch and promising big things for Murdock and Marvel's TV universe.
But it wasn't to be. Daredevil was cancelled after its third season, but rumours have been swirling ever since that a revival may yet be on the cards.
Given the fact that Charlie Cox was devastated by the cancellation and that the writers had a good plan for Season 4, it would be great to see it come back.
5. Sense8
Where to start with Sense8? When it came along, it was a shock to Netflix subscribers. With a diverse cast, a unique sci-fi-esque plot and a daring ability to perfectly tackle themes of identity, sexuality, politics, gender and religion, Sense8 ended up quickly wowing audiences and gained itself a second season.
Following a group of strangers across the world who are inexplicably able to connect to one another's thoughts and actions, the show's premise demanded further seasons. Unfortunately, it was cancelled during Season 2 due to low ratings, leading to fan outcry online.
In response to the backlash, a two-hour finale was commissioned to tie up the storylines of the many characters. Though the finale was mostly very good, in that it concluded some of the protagonists' stories, it nonetheless felt rushed and out of place with the rest of the show, and featured enough sub-plots, character interactions and revelations to fill another season or two of episodes.
Unfairly cut down despite being one of the most daring and intelligent dramas on TV, Sense8 was finished. It deserved better.
4. Hannibal
Like so many other cancelled shows, Hannibal found itself beaten by low ratings despite its brilliant plot and characters. Following FBI criminal profiler Will Graham and his interactions with psychiatrist/serial killer Hannibal Lecter, the series acted as a solid and critically acclaimed addition to the numerous adaptations of Thomas Harris' novels.
It was axed after its third season, which ended on a literal cliffhanger and saw fans begging for a renewal, and since 2015 there have been many discussions about the show's revival elsewhere. Amazon Video and Netflix have both been approached to pick the show up for a fourth season, but as of yet none have taken the bait.
Though the most likely to see itself back onto our screens at some point (outside of Daredevil), Hannibal currently remains without a network to back it. On the plus side, the brilliant Mads Mikkelsen has stated numerous times that he's interested in coming back to the role, so fingers crossed someone makes a move and give us more stylish carnage to admire.
3. Agent Carter
Running for only 18 episodes over two epic and satisfying seasons, Agent Carter follows Peggy Carter as she navigates her life as a government agent and deals with the loss of Captain America.
A fast-paced and brilliantly acted show with enough narrative and character potential to last multiple future seasons, viewership fell too low (especially when compared to Agents of SHIELD) for ABC Studios to keep it going.
Despite being a refreshing addition to the MCU, Agent Carter never really found its audience. It was briefly rumoured that Netflix was going to swoop in and save the show from its predicament, but a statement was eventually released denying this because of the existence of other major Marvel projects on the platform.
Maybe this one is another job for Disney+...
2. Santa Clarita Diet
Without question one of Netflix's most inventive, bizarre and hilarious original series, Santa Clarita Diet gained a big following during its three season run. Starring Timothy Olyphant and Drew Barrymore, the series incorporated horror with dark comedy and got bigger and better with every passing episode.
After Sheila (Barrymore) goes through a series of changes and begins to eat people, her husband Joel (Olyphant) must get to the bottom of what's happening to her, battling ancient cults and befriending severed heads as he goes.
Like many of Netflix's cancellations over the years, the decision seems to have been made because the show was getting too expensive.
To make matters worse, the third season ended on a massive, game-changing cliffhanger. The fan outcry was as excepted - angry and demanding answers - but all Netflix ever divulged was that they weren't willing to put the money into the series anymore.
1. Freaks And Geeks
The show that launched the careers of Linda Cardellini, Jason Segel, James Franco, Seth Rogen and Martin Starr, Freaks and Geeks aired for one season in 1999. Produced and written by Judd Apatow, the show detailed the high school life of Lindsay Weir (Cardellini) as she befriends a gang of slackers.
Funny, touching, relatable and brilliantly acted, Freaks and Geeks showed promise as the next big thing on television, but found itself on the chopping block after the network had trouble with scheduling. Due to poor time slots which found it overshadowed by Who Wants to Be A Millionaire, Freaks and Geeks never hit the right audience and was cancelled after just twelve episodes.
To add insult to injury, it was also announced that the writers and NBC had different visions for what the show would be. NBC apparently didn't understand the appeal of doing a show about teens in high school, and all of these issues culminated in it being cast aside.
After its cancellation, a fan campaign kicked off which eventually forced NBC to release the remaining episodes and end the season as planned. After that, Freaks and Geeks was left to pick up a vast cult following, and these days it often makes its way on to lists detailing the greatest shows of all time.
Not bad for a show that didn't get a chance to live its full potential.