10 TV Characters They Wanted You To Forget

Moriarty's first Sherlock appearance was supposed to be forgettable.

By Scott Banner /

You could have the most emotional, exciting, and compelling story in the history of all stories, but without characters that an audience can connect to, it would mean very little. What is the point of a strong narrative if no one cares about who the events of the story are happening to?

Advertisement

The goal for every story is to create wonderful characters with which audiences can form strong connections, whether this is in a good way, with a protagonist viewers truly want to see win, or with villains that people crave to see get their just desserts.

However, there are occurrences throughout such stories that, for a certain amount of time, writers need characters to be forgotten completely. WhatCulture has already delved into what this looks like on the big screen, but what about on TV?

Here, a character could be gone for years before showing up again to make their dramatic, comedic, or fan service-led return, though that's not to say there aren't occasions where the forgotten character would return within that same episode. Ranging from nameless background characters to the lead role of an entire series, making certain characters disappear can bring with it a wealth of rewards when they return.

10. Ser Barristan Selmy - Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones boasts a cast of characters unlike any other TV show. From the north to the south of Westeros, beyond the Wall, and across the Narrow Sea, there were almost countless developed characters with stories that viewers genuinely cared about. In this sense, it was relatively easy for one character to get lost in the intertwining stories.

Advertisement

When Joffrey Baratheon took the Iron Throne as his own, one of the first things he did was relieve Ser Barristan Selmy of his duties as Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, essentially sending him into exile.

Barristan the Bold was a swordsman and warrior of legendary prowess, and in doing this Joffrey both deprived himself of a strong and reliable ally, and allowed his enemy to gain one. This however, didn't become apparent until Selmy returned to the show sporting a full beard across the Narrow Sea in season three.

A mysterious hooded figure was revealed to be Selmy when he saved Daenerys from an assassination attempt, before pledging his sword to his new Queen. By this point, no one was expecting Barristan the Bold to ever turn up again, as even book readers were forced to second guess themselves as the show went on.

9. Sean - Scrubs

As part of JD and Elliott's on again off again story throughout the entire eight-season run of Scrubs (no one counts season nine, right?), there was pure, unparalleled jealousy when they were apart. Dr. Reid resented Jamie during her short fling with JD, and Dr. Dorian was insanely jealous of arguably Elliott's most serious boyfriend yet, Sean.

Advertisement

What started initially as just a petty grudge ultimately turned into a full on rivalry. JD convinced Elliott to leave Sean for him just as they were supposed to move in together, before deciding that he didn't actually want her anyway.

This was when Sean disappeared. With no further relationship with Elliott, there were no stories for Scott Foley's character, and so he left the show to be forgotten essentially immediately. He wouldn't be seen again until five years later, returning completely out of the blue in what must have been nightmare fuel for JD.

While dropping Sam back with Kim, JD was monologuing about how nothing could get in the way of his and Elliott's car sex on the way home, unless of course, Kim was dating 'Elliott's stupid ex-boyfriend'. This wouldn't have been so funny if it didn't come out of absolutely nowhere.

8. Gina - Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Ask any Brooklyn Nine-Nine fan and they will tell you that one of the highlights of the entire show was the annual Halloween Heist. After Jake, Holt, and Amy won the first three respectively, they came together once more to break the tie and determine the ultimate winner.

Advertisement

Up until this point, said winner was to be declared an amazing detective/genius, but Gina Linetti had other ideas. Far from being a detective, she planned to prove herself as an amazing human/genius.

Her strategy revolved around having everyone forget about her, not only the audience but her colleagues at the Nine-Nine as well. She bowed out of proceedings early after apparently knocking her teeth out, and then planted the seeds of doubt about Terry's involvement from start to finish. This was done perfectly, as no one expected to see Gina rock up at the end with the victor's plaque.

Everyone ran to the interview room to confront Terry, and even Hitchcock and Scully who had been with him the entire time turned on him, only for Gina to reveal herself from behind the two-way mirror. It was a work all along, and just as wonderful and convoluted as most Halloween Heist victories proved to be.

7. The Bird Man - BoJack Horseman

In the first few episodes of BoJack Horseman, the titular character got himself into relatively harmless hjinx surrounding his autobiography and arguing with navy seals in the supermarket, but before too long the show became unbelievably heavy and far darker than before.

Advertisement

A lot of things happened throughout the series that were tough pills to swallow, particularly coming from a protagonist you were supposed to be rooting for. Two of the worst things he did involved young women who looked up to him as a role model, Penny and Sarah-Lynn.

He took advantage of Penny's vulnerability, and dragged Sarah-Lynn on a months-long bender that ultimately killed her. There was a crossover of the two incidents when BoJack and Sarah-Lynn essentially crashed a group therapy session, with the former confessing to everything he did with Penny, almost as a boast. He drunkenly gave her full name and even told the group to look her up.

Towards the end of the series, with BoJack getting his life back on track and teaching at Wesleyan University, he was yet to suffer any real consequences for what he did to Penny and Sarah-Lynn. That is, until Paige Sinclair tracked down the Bird Man from that fateful 12-step meeting from three seasons before. The information given by the nameless character allowed the reporter to piece together huge parts of the story that would ultimately force BoJack to face up to every sh*tty thing he ever did.

6. Jim - Sherlock

There have been numerous different iterations of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's legendary detective over the years, but it being brought into the modern day by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss was truly unique. Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock was exceptional, and of course, he had to be matched by an exceptional villain.

Advertisement

The first two episodes of the series merely hinted at the existence of Moriarty, without actually featuring the consulting criminal. This was saved for the first season finale, in which the villain would reveal himself and confront both Sherlock and Watson.

But how could such a reveal be taken a level above the usual? How about the fact that this wouldn't be the first time the two shared the screen, or even interacted in the episode? It was just that in the first instance, audiences had no reason to suspect such a blink-and-you'll-miss-him character.

When Molly Hooper first introduced Jim to Sherlock, her so-called boyfriend gave Mr. Holmes his number, before the detective launched into his deductions about Jim's sexuality. At the conclusion of the episode, upon hearing the words from the still obscured Moriarty that he gave Sherlock his number, jaws dropped the country over.

5. Tommy - The Last Of Us

Most video game adaptations are a shadow of their source material, zombie stories have been done to death over the years, and Naughty Dog's recent Uncharted movie underwhelmed on just about every level. Seemingly everything was against HBO's The Last of Us.

Advertisement

However, the first nine episodes of the show have made up one of the greatest first seasons of all time. The tone was set immediately with the harrowing infection outbreak, something that will be burned into the memory of audiences everywhere. The worst part of course, being the death of Joel's daughter, Sarah.

In the sheer panic of the outbreak, Joel, Sarah, and Tommy looked to escape the city and found themselves trapped. After an aeroplane crash stopped them in their tracks, Joel and Sarah were separated from Tommy, leaving the father and daughter open to the military guard who ultimately killed Sarah.

The scene was far from straightforward, however. Though he had only been off-screen for a matter of minutes, the chaos and adrenaline rush of what happened to Joel and Sarah left Tommy in the back of viewers' minds until he showed up just in time to save Joel's life. This may have been a relief for the uninitiated, but that feeling was to be robbed from them mere moments later.

4. Birdperson - Rick & Morty

Throughout Rick and Morty, from the very first episode, crazy stories and wacky characters with stupid names have been the show's schtick. This applied to random aliens Rick was fighting, different planets and star systems, and people from the smartest man in the universe's past.

Advertisement

One such character was Birdperson. 'Pers was an old ally of Rick Sanchez, who fought side by side with him on Blood Ridge and in many more battles, appearing in several episodes of the show. The most notable was the season two finale, The Wedding Squanchers. Birdperson's wedding to Tammy ultimately became a bloodbath, with the groom biting the dust.

The post-credit scene from season three's opener confirmed that Tammy and the Galactic Federation had reanimated Birdperson as Phoenixperson, but nothing was done with the character for years. There were three years between this revelation and Phoenixperson's return to be exact.

During the season four finale, as part of the show's Star Wars homage, Tammy and the Federation were hunting down Space Beth which led to Rick crossing paths with his old friend. Phoenixperson's emergence to fight Rick on board the Death Star was still a surprise, and fans couldn't have been happier.

3. Janice - Friends

Outside of the main six in Friends, there were a handful of secondary characters, with the likes of Gunther, Mike, and Ross and Monica's parents, that proved to be defining personalities in the show. However, you simply can't mention this group without talking about one of the most iconic characters in the show, Janice.

Advertisement

After appearing in a handful of episodes throughout the first two seasons, Chandler's on again off again girlfriend had a much larger role at the start of season three. After she cheated on Chandler and went back to her ex-husband, she reappeared in the show just once a season for the remaining seven seasons.

The incredible thing is that, no matter how many times she was brought back, it was always done in a way that took audiences by surprise. In season five she sheepishly said hi to the guys after accidentally revealing she hooked up with Ross, and in season six her voice was heard on a mixtape Chandler gave to Monica, but the other five times we were greeted with that infamous "oh... my... gawd."

Arguably the most iconic of these came in season ten when she was looking to buy the house next to Monica and Chandler. Even after all this time, after so many returns, fans still forgot about Janice enough that when she returned it was comedy gold.

2. Michael Scott - The Office

When Michael Scott left The Office during season seven, the show took a very noticeable downturn. Fans can love Jim, Pam, Dwight, and obviously Creed as much as they like, but Michael Scott was at the center of everything. It was his show.

After that heartwrenching episode in which Michael left the office and his chosen family behind, he was barely ever mentioned again. Understandably, the show just wanted to move on in its new, Steve Carrell-less form instead of dwelling on what it no longer had.

This was until the final episode however, when the former Regional Manager returned for the wedding of Dwight and Angela. His appearance was one of Jim’s gutenpranks for Dwight on his big day, and it came out of nowhere. It had to come out of nowhere to be as effective as it was, and having no one mention Michael for two years helped immensely.

The emotion of this moment truly banked on audiences keeping Michael as far from their thoughts as possible. Had anyone expected Steve Carrell to make an appearance, it still would have been a great Office moment, but nowhere near the iconic scene it ultimately was.

1. Sansa Stark - Game Of Thrones

This is the second character from Game of Thrones to feature on this list, but for very different reasons. While Ser Barristan Selmy fell out of memory for a full season, Sansa Stark was forgotten about within the walls of a single episode.

Advertisement

The key to this was the Battle of the Bastards. This was something that had been built up to and anticipated for years, and it did not disappoint. The coming together of the forces of the North, and the Boltons of Winterfell was really always only about Jon Snow and Ramsay Bolton.

In a way, that was where the battle would have been lost. Jon didn't know Ramsay, and paid no attention to Sansa, who knew the Bastard of Bolton's mind inside and out. She pleaded with her half-brother to wait until they had a greater force, but after a heated argument, the battle commenced the next day with Sansa nowhere to be seen.

The fight itself is without question one of the greatest set pieces in the history of a show rich with great set pieces. Anything that happened before Rickon's death was forgotten about, including Sansa and her whereabouts. She then appeared on the horizon like Gandalf the Grey, with Littlefinger at her side, and the army of the Vale at her back to save the day. Goosebumps doesn't begin to cover it.

Advertisement