10 TV Hoaxes That Fooled Everyone

No, The Simpsons and Futurama didn't predict the pandemic.

By Jack Pooley /

Despite everyone having all the world's information readily available at their fingertips and in their pockets, the ubiquity of the Internet and social media in our lives has also made it shockingly easily for even smart people to be hoodwinked by hoaxes and "fake news."

Advertisement

In an overwhelming sea of information, it can be difficult to separate the fact from the fiction, and while that certainly be used to harmful political ends, it can also be exploited somewhat more fancifully in the world of pop-culture.

Any sufficiently popular TV series is destined to be saddled with fans who, for whatever reason, want to interrupt the flow of news with their own manufactured nonsense.

Whether these hoaxes pre-date the modern Internet entirely or have taken full advantage of our congested, oversaturated news feeds today, pranksters managed to convince potentially millions of fans that these non-truths were sheer fact.

From hoaxes about "lost" episodes of classic TV shows to claims of impending lawsuits being filed against beloved series, and even TV that eerily "predicted" the current global predicament, these 10 claims are all impressively, frighteningly convincing bull...

10. There's A Lost Episode Where Chandler Dies - Friends

These days, any half-talented video editor can repurpose existing filmed footage to create a convincing hoax, as YouTuber Dogfood proved in 2016 when he released clips from a supposedly "lost" episode of Friends.

Advertisement

For years, rumours had been doing the rounds among the fanbase that an episode called "The One Where Chandler Dies" was shot but ultimately canned.

Per its title, the episode would explore a hypothetical scenario where Chandler (Matthew Perry) dies and the five remaining friends would then learn to cope with his demise.

In a credibility-straining twist, Chandler would also appear throughout the episode as a ghost, watching how his friends try to move on with their lives.

Dogfood decided to bring the idea to life through his cleverly crafted hoax video, taking clips from various Friends episodes, re-editing them, and even adding some passable visual effects to further sell the illusion.

Proving the ease with which a lie can be sold to the masses via social media, the video quickly went viral, with more casual Friends fans failing to recognise the recycled footage, truly believing it to be a discarded episode.

As easily noticeable as the fakery is to the most die-hard Friends fans, Dogfood is to be commended for putting so much effort into the ruse and ultimately fooling so many.

9. Pedro Pascal Quit The Show Half-Way Through Season 2 - The Mandalorian

In the lead-up to the release of The Mandalorian's second season, a devastating rumour began to pick up traction online, that the man behind the armour himself, Pedro Pascal, had actually quit the show mid-way through filming season two.

Advertisement

This hubbub was largely due to infamous YouTuber Grace Randolph, who claimed that Pascal quit the show due to spending so much of his screen time with his face under a helmet. Randolph further claimed that Mando would be replaced by Boba Fett for season three.

Given that Randolph has over 930,000 YouTube subscribers alone, the rumour quickly went viral and was parroted as "fact" by the masses. Even when members of the cast and crew refuted her claims, Randolph refused to retract them.

With it being no secret that Pascal wasn't always playing the Mandalorian underneath the armour, it seemed plausible enough to fans that a creative disagreement could've led to his departure.

And so, for much of season two many were left wondering whether Disney was indeed on damage control duty.

But of course, there was no secret to be kept - Pascal took part in production of the entire season and is back for the currently-shooting third season. Phew.

8. Yelp Sued Matt Stone & Trey Parker For Slander - South Park

South Park has never shied away from courting controversy over the last near-quarter century, so when it was reported in 2015 that online review site Yelp had filed a $10 million lawsuit against the show's creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker, there wasn't much reason to second-guess it.

Advertisement

The report claimed that Yelp filed suit in response to the season 19 episode "You're Not Yelping," which makes fun of Yelp's popularity and influence in the online sphere, characterising the site's reviewers as malicious and entitled.

The suit apparently claimed that the episode presenting Yelp's critics as racist, terrorist freeloaders was grounds for libel and slander, to which Stone and Parker allegedly replied:

"We have given Yelp and their lawsuit only one star... It is our personal opinion that Yelp could do a much better job by not suing us for ten million dollars."

As easy as this all is to believe, neither the lawsuit nor Stone and Parker's response were real - they were concocted by fake news cesspool NewsExaminer to harvest clicks and nothing else.

Yelp themselves soon enough responded to the story to clarify that, as fans of the show, they weren't suing South Park:

"The rumor about a Yelp lawsuit is entirely untrue and was started by a satire site that has received far too much media credibility... We have no interest in legal action against the fantastic team that makes the South Park magic happen."

7. The Original Female Lead Was Replaced For Not Being "Sexy" Enough - Seinfeld

For the pilot episode of Seinfeld, actress Lee Garlington was cast as the show's apparent female lead, a waitress by the name of Claire. But of course, from episode two onwards she was replaced with ultimate mainstay Elaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus).

Advertisement

In his 2012 Seinfeld Reference book, Dennis Bjorklund claimed that Garlington was dropped from the show in favour of an actress with more outward sex appeal, as was then canonised as fact among much of the Seinfeld fanbase.

But this conflicts with most other accounts of season one's production. NBC executive Warren Littlefield claims Claire was ditched because, as a waitress, her different social status to the other characters would be an awkward fit.

Jason Alexander claimed she angered Larry David by re-writing her own dialogue, while Jerry Seinfeld insists that the producers simply wanted "someone who was more involved," whatever that means exactly.

Whatever the true reason, the oft-repeated notion that Garlington wasn't attractive enough to be a Seinfeld lead has basically been rubbished by everyone not named Dennis Bjorklund.

6. It Had TV's First Interracial Kiss - Star Trek

Even people who couldn't give two figs about Star Trek might be aware of the widely repeated factoid that the original series made history by featuring the first interracial kiss on television.

Advertisement

In 1968's season three episode "Plato's Stepchildren," Captain Kirk (William Shatner) and Uhura (Nichelle Nichols) share a kiss, which while drawing little attention at the time became a groundbreaking touchstone for Black-white relationships in media in subsequent years.

Today it's held up as the first interracial TV kiss, a claim that for all of its iconography in pop-culture simply isn't true.

The first interracial kiss occurred a decade earlier on The Ed Sullivan Show, when Shatner of all people kissed an Asian actress, France Nuyen.

There are numerous other examples that predate Plato's Stepchildren, even one from an earlier Trek episode itself, when in the season two episode "Mirror Mirror" - aired over a year before Plato's Stepchildren - Shatner kissed Filipino-European actress BarBara Luna.

It doesn't really undermine the power of the scene - for such an iconic and widely-viewed TV staple to broadcast such a progressive, whispered-about ideal to the masses - but it sure wasn't the first show to ever do it.

5. That Totally Convincing BBC Ghost "Documentary" - Ghostwatch

If you're looking for a scary movie to watch this Halloween or any other, you could do a hell of a lot worse than Ghostwatch.

Advertisement

Aired on the BBC on Halloween night 1992, Ghostwatch was presented as a supposedly real live TV special in which BBC reporters investigated a house in London allegedly haunted by paranormal entities.

The genius of Ghostwatch is its absolutely convincing style, adopting all the presentational techniques you'd expect from a real BBC documentary, and even roping in real TV presenters including Craig Charles and the inimitable Michael Parkinson.

With its subtle, ambiguous approach to the supernatural shenanigans taking place within the house, and airing back in 1992 as it did, Ghostwatch held a fearful British nation firmly in its grip, enough that the BBC received 30,000 complaint calls.

In the weeks that followed, Ghostwatch's disturbing nature was the source of controversy in the media, and the BBC even faced lawsuits from those who claimed to be adversely affected by its persuasive pseudo-authenticity.

But of course Ghostwatch was pure fiction, albeit so thoroughly ahead of its time in exploiting the audience's belief that anything presented as "news" would be effortlessly accepted as such.

4. Smithers Was Originally Supposed To Be Black - The Simpsons

It's still commonly stated today that The Simpsons' Mr. Smithers was originally supposed to be one of the series' few Black characters, seemingly exemplified by the fact that Smithers' skin has a darker colour in his debut appearance in the show's third-ever episode, "Homer's Odyssey."

Advertisement

This seems like a reasonable enough assumption, and one largely transmuted into fact by the public, despite the fact that it's not remotely true.

Smithers' darker skin in his first appearance was actually the fault of colour stylist Gyorgyi Peluce, who animated the character with the incorrect skin colour. This was corrected for all future episodes.

Simpsons animator David Silverman later stated that Smithers was always intended to be "Mr Burns' white sycophant," and the writing staff generally felt that making Smithers a "Black subservient character" wasn't a good idea.

Silverman ultimately excused Smithers' changing pigmentation as a fading tan from a recent holiday in the Caribbean.

Making a character of Smithers' position and overwhelming passivity Black would open the show up to even more controversy than it's faced in recent years, so it was most certainly a smart change.

3. Ernie Was Going To Die In The Early 1990s - Sesame Street

Shortly after Jim Henson's untimely 1990 death, a rumour spread like wildfire - as fast as it can in the pre-Internet era, at least - that one of Sesame Street's Henson-voiced characters, Ernie, was going to be killed off in an upcoming episode.

Advertisement

The cited rationale was that nobody could fittingly replicate Henson's Ernie voice, and it would also provide a unique forum for the show to teach children about death.

The scuttlebutt in the press reached enough of a fever pitch that The Jim Henson Company even received panicked calls from fans concerned about Ernie's welfare, and amid rumours that an Ernie memorial episode had already been filmed, college student Michael Tabor even mounted a "Save Ernie" campaign.

As such, The Jim Henson Company and the Children's Television Workshop had to assure fans that Ernie wasn't going anywhere, releasing an official statement to that effect:

"Ernie is alive and well, and we have no intention of anything happening to him or anyone else."

Over 30 years on they've kept their promise, honouring Henson's legacy portraying the character rather than writing out one of Sesame Street's most beloved icons.

2. They Predicted The Pandemic - Futurama & The Simpsons

This one's a two-fer.

Advertisement

Shortly after the COVID-19 pandemic began to spread around the world, an image was posted online claiming that a Futurama episode contained the message "All time travel to the year 2020 is strictly prohibited" in its opening titles sequence.

Given that Matt Groening's animated shows have a tendency for cannily predicting the future, this image was taken at face value by many, that he had once again hinted at future chaos to come.

But of course, the image was Photoshopped by a zealous fan and is therefore total bull.

At the start of the pandemic, a similar hoax was also fabricated for The Simpsons, where a four-panel image recycled frames from two different episodes to suggest it had also predicted the pandemic, even adding the text "Corona Virus" into one of Kent Brockman's news broadcasts.

As much as The Simpsons in particular has so impressively held a mirror up to modern society, it's not that prescient.

1. Marilyn Manson Played Paul Pfeiffer - The Wonder Years

Classic coming-of-age series The Wonder Years follows the adventures of teenager Kevin Arnold (Fred Savage) and his friends and family, including his charmingly nerdy best pal Paul Pfeiffer (Josh Saviano).

Advertisement

But ever since the mid-90s, when shock rocker Marilyn Manson rose to fame, there have been persistent rumours that Manson, real name Brian Warner, played Paul as a young man himself.

Given the physical resemblance between the two - namely their respective angular jaws - it was easy to believe at a quick glance, though despite the easy means for a quick Google search to prove otherwise, the lie is still widely perpetuated today.

Saviano has been answering questions about his identity from inquisitive fans for a whole quarter-century, and yet, the lie continues to stick.

But considering recent allegations levelled against Manson, Saviano's certainly got a strong incentive to set the record straight once and for all.

Advertisement