10 TV Shows That Ran Way Too Long

Shows they should've taken around the back of wood shed, Old Yeller-style.

By Grace Murray /

For every unfairly cancelled critical darling whose ghost will haunt its network while its fans have access to forums and Tumblr, there€™s a show which is apparently deathless. Whereas Firefly might be equated with the funny and mysterious stranger and a party whom you know you€™ll never see again, the floundering TV juggernaut is the equivalent of that old friend whom you had to invite and who then proceeds to get embarrassingly drunk in the corner. As much as it pains television networks to admit it, some shows have a sell-by date. It€™s not a curse which affects all shows which pass some arbitrary milestone; some long-runners successfully reinvent themselves over and over again and survive for years without a permanent dip in quality. A few, on the other hand, were never that good in the first place. The shows in this article are those for which the process of agonisingly slow decomposition played out in front of our eyes until the network finally put its zombiefied former hit out of its misery, a few years too late. These ten shows deserved better, so try to remember their glory days as we relive their falls from grace. Any TV executives reading, take note: sometimes less is more.

10. Friends

Number of seasons: 10 Number of seasons it should have had: 8 The last scene of Friends almost makes it all worthwhile. Leaving Chandler and Monica€™s apartment for the last time, the gang decide to go out for one final coffee, at which point Chandler gets the bittersweet last line of the series: €œWhere?€ Even with the knowledge that the end is all it€™s cracked up to be, one can€™t help but think that the impact of that final scene wouldn€™t have been diminished had seasons nine and ten never aired. It was in those years that Friends scrabbled around to find another way to delay Ross and Rachel€™s inevitable reunion and came up with Joey€™s newfound romantic interest in Rachel, which was uncomfortable to watch after almost a decade of their well-defined sibling relationship. The series had also outgrown its original premise of twenty-something single life in New York. Monica and Chandler were stuck in the rut of the sitcom married couple, Ross and Rachel were raising a child, and Joey and Phoebe were in danger of becoming little more than bundles of quirks. How much did they really have in common anymore? Friends is down here at number ten because it retains a certain charm even when it was almost completely tapped out of ideas, but seasons nine and ten threatened even that. With prior notice and removal of the superfluous storylines, season eight could have been the time to end on a high.

9. Alias

Number of seasons: 5 Number of seasons it should have had: 2 Alias, J.J. Abrams€™ classic espionage TV show starring Jennifer Garner and Victor Garber as a father-daughter double agent team, ran for the relatively limited time of five seasons and still managed to go rather spectacularly off the rails. Unlike most examples on this list, Alias had a definitive shark-jumping moment in the third season premiere, which revealed a two year time jump and the introduction of the much-hated third point of the love triangle, Lauren. Her later transformation into a cartoonish villain was in equal parts clunky and viscerally satisfying. Meanwhile, Alias attempted to replace its central conflict €“ Sydney€™s attempts to bring down criminal organisation SD-6 €“ with Abrams€™ patented brand of confusing sci-fi mythology. By the end, the show which was once a flimsy excuse for exhilarating fight scenes had been forced to consign its immortal-via-chemical-vat big bad to a deep and dark tomb just to finish him off. At least an earlier cancellation would have spared us that.

8. Gilmore Girls

Number of seasons: 7 Number of seasons it should have had: 6, if you€™re generous The sweet-natured comedy-drama about a mother and daughter living in a twee Connecticut town lost its way sometime in the college years. The series began its descent when the once-saintly and mature Rory broke up her ex€™s marriage with an affair, then stole a yacht and dropped out of college to sponge off her grandparents, all of which were treated with the same weight as a toddler€™s temper tantrums. At the same time, the interminable €˜will they won€™t they€™ relationship between her mother Lorelai and Luke Danes met increasingly ridiculous obstacles, including the sudden introduction of Luke€™s twelve year old daughter. The final nail in the coffin came in late season six, when the original creators had a less than amicable parting with the WB. Luke and Lorelai€™s relationship was clumsily ended to fuel the repetitive plotlines of season seven, by which point most of the audience had checked out. It was a sad, undignified end to a once surprisingly original series, which could perhaps have been redeemed had it been granted an earlier departure date.

7. Battlestar Galactica

Number of seasons: 4 Number of seasons it should have had: 3 The first two seasons of the rebooted Battlestar Galactica were rightfully critically acclaimed and are still ranked with some of the best of science-fiction television. The subsequent two seasons are far more divisive, with most agreeing that there was a drop in quality somewhere in the third season which then continued to affect the show until its series finale. Season three started well as it built on the shock of the second season finale, in which the Cylons occupied New Caprica, with an effective series of opening episodes which packed in action and moral debate. The first four episodes garnered all four of BSG€™s Emmy nominations for the season, which belies the numerous filler episodes which succeeded the Occupation arc. Then the show inexplicably killed Starbuck in its third season finale and resurrected her for similarly opaque reasons, only to gradually undo her character development throughout the fourth season. Wherever you€™d place Battlestar Galactica€™s shark, it was certainly cleared with reckless abandon, and season four was a superfluous addition to a weakened series. A shorter run would have placed it unquestionably amongst the televised sci-fi greats.

6. Smallville

Number of seasons: 10 Number of seasons it should have had: 5 It€™s rare for a series to devalue its own premise to quite the same extent that Smallville utterly exhausted its central idea. With its ending already confirmed and seemingly limitless time to kill before it reached that point, Smallville used its vast comic book heritage to fill ten seasons with cameos, in-jokes, and an awful lot of repetition before Clark Kent finally became the Man of Steel. The natural conclusion to the series actually arrived in 2006, when Jonathan Kent succumbed to a heart attack in the midseason finale of the fifth season. Smallville handled his death with a surprisingly amount of subtlety, but preserved Clark€™s immaturity by burying the emotional fallout under endless freak of the week plots in the second half of the season. The series was then forced to stall Clark€™s character development for years while the plot proceeded as if he had become Superman already, introducing the Justice League in season six and moving entirely to Metropolis shortly afterwards. A more streamlined version of Smallville would have ended at the fifth season finale, and in an ideal world, it would have inspired a live-action Superman show to succeed it. We can dream, right?

5. The Office (U.S.)

Number of seasons: 9 Number of seasons it should have had: 7 NBC has hardly had a sterling few years, so it€™s unsurprising in a way that The Office managed to somehow outlive the contract of its star. Steve Carell went on to more lucrative Hollywood ventures at the end of the seventh season and simultaneously provided a get out of jail free card for the writers had they wished to end the series, but instead the show transferred its focus to Jim and Pam and blunted its rapier wit in the process. Romance has its place in cringe comedy, but in seasons eight and nine, The Office struggled to balance the two. The show managed to craft a suitable ending for Michael Scott, in which he moved to Colorado with Holly, but lacked the confidence to move on convincingly without him. It was increasingly apparent in the eighth season that the series was spinning its wheels until it figured out its next move, and the ninth season rejuvenation of the documentary format was by turns inventive and gimmicky. The finale was an emotional hour, but The Office had already watched its perfect ending sail on by, two years earlier.

4. Glee

Number of seasons: 6 Number of seasons it should have had: 3, if you€™re generous It€™s almost difficult to remember the absolute hysteria which surrounded Glee€™s first season back in 2009. It was an immediate hit and praised for its irreverent humour, diverse cast and refreshingly cynical take on high school drama. The second season was more inconsistent, and by season three the quality of any given episode was completely unpredictable, although its finale did give us an emotional farewell to several original members of the New Directions. Season six will be Glee€™s last, in part due to the passing of main cast member Cory Monteith in July 2013. The series has also become a shell of what it once was, drifting between its old stalwarts in New York and its derivative younger characters in McKinley High without the sense of excitement which accompanied its first season. Glee would not have been missed had it ended with graduation, and even then it wasn€™t the same show which captured the zeitgeist so perfectly in that first year.

3. The X-Files

Number of seasons: 9 Number of seasons it should have had: 7 Much like The Office, The X-Files suffered from the loss of one of its stars, but David Duchovny€™s departure from the series at the end of season seven deprived it of its bedrock: the chemistry between Mulder and Scully. The lively dynamic between the believer and the sceptic has been mined by other genre shows since The X-Files pushed it to the forefront, and the loss of that core relationship shook the show€™s confidence in its storytelling. The X-Files also relied upon the unsolved mysteries of its complex mythology, but seasons eight and nine offered only murky answers and several muddled arcs which left fans exasperated rather than intrigued. Even Duchovny€™s return to the cast as a recurring character couldn€™t revive the flagging franchise, which has since limped through two unspectacular films as well. Apparently Chris Carter has yet to learn the meaning of the phrase €˜quit while you€™re ahead€™.

2. How I Met Your Mother

Number of seasons: 9 Number of seasons it should have had: 7 How I Met Your Mother is now unfortunately infamous for its unsatisfying finale, which essentially tore up years of character development and foreshadowing in favour of a conclusion which pleased no one. The ending, unchanged from 2006, maintained an inflexible commitment to much older versions of the regular characters which was a poor reward for almost a decade invested in their lives, and threw away the goodwill amassed by Cristin Milioti€™s heart-rending performance as the Mother. The show€™s final years also stretched its flimsy premise to the limit. It became a running joke that Ted€™s children were essentially held hostage to their father€™s reminiscences, and in-story, Robin and Barney€™s relationship was treading water while Lily€™s character began to skew towards grating rather than opinionated. When in doubt, the series revisited Ted€™s doomed relationship with Robin, in order for Ted to move on for the umpteenth time. In hindsight, How I Met Your Mother had been on a road to nowhere for quite some time, and its ending was immutable since season two. At least an earlier cancellation might have dulled the pain.

1. Dexter

Number of seasons: 8 Number of seasons it should have had: 4 If ever cancellation would have been the better option, the end of Dexter€™s fourth season was the moment to make that choice. Back then, John Lithgow€™s terrifying Arthur Mitchell had revitalised the show, but it also unfortunately revived the audience€™s faith at the same time and therefore condemned us to watch Dexter€™s glacial descent into inanity. The show had always had its ridiculous hallmarks, including the overuse of the Ghost of Harry, the utter incompetence of the Miami Police Department, and Dexter€™s unnecessary voiceover. They had become more noticeable in the meandering third season, but in the second half of the run, as Dexter began to lose its grip on its pacing and plausibility, its exaggerated mode of storytelling seemed risible. Reviews became lukewarm and eventually derisive. Moreover, if you€™d hoped for an ending which would remain morally ambiguous while still punishing Dexter for his misdeeds, season eight did not in any way deliver. The lumberjack scene has already earned its place in TV history as one of the most bizarre conclusions to any television series, let alone one which was once critically acclaimed. It€™s so ridiculous that it almost justifies Dexter€™s survival, but it€™s sad that a show which was once effortlessly self-assured has ended up a poster child for the benefits of cancellation. Some shows are built to be long-runners; Dexter was assuredly not.