TV is a complicated and fickle business. It can be hard, at times, to judge what shows will and won't succeed. Sometimes the networks air something that's sure to be a flop, only to have it succeed wildly. I mean, who would have thought that a cartoon about yellow-skinned people would go twenty-five plus seasons? But there are some shows... certain shows... ones that are clearly a bad idea from start to finish. Shows that were doomed to cancellation the moment they were conceived of. Shows that should have never made it past the pilot stage. This is a list of 10. Now it's important to note that all of these actually aired in the real world. One of them, creatively bankrupt though it was, actually got several seasons. Most died after a handful of episodes or, indeed, just one. Let's have a look...
10. Small Wonder (1985 - 1989), 94 episodes
The exception that proves the rule. Most of the shows on here were cancelled after one season, and in one case, after one episode. Everything about the premise to this show is horrible. In brief, a scientist makes an android and decides to take it home and "raise" it as a child. Because there's no way that could ever go horribly wrong. The next 93 episodes were variations on "How can she be more human?" and "Will the nosy neighbours find out she isn't?" Yet despite the stupid premise (and a really horrible theme song that exemplifies everything wrong about mid 1980s television), the show dragged on for four seasons. I have no idea how this happened, and it speaks very poorly of American TV show audiences. On the other hand, I suppose that it does prove that, despite all wisdom to the contrary, sometimes it is worth taking a stupid premise and making a TV show out of it. You never know when you might hit gold.
9. The Secret Diary of Desmond Pfifer (1998), 9 episodes
You know what the world really needs? Historical sitcoms. But unless your name is Rowan Atkinson, Tony Robinson, Hugh Laurie or Stephen Fry, you should never, ever attempt to do them. Especially if you're an American. Welcome to this abortion of a TV series. Controversial from the start due to perceived racial insensitivity and the belief that people were laughing about slavery, the shows woes continued by being aired on UPN, something that assured about six people would watch it. I'm really not sure why anyone thought this was a good idea for a TV series, especially since the series finale would, almost by definition, have to be something of a downer. Then again, I'm sure they would have had "wacky" high jinks featuring Lincoln and Booth in a chase scene with Yakity Sax playing under it.
8. Thanks (1999), 6 episodes
Okay, clearly historical sitcoms are a bad idea. But that didn't stop someone from trying again! Only this time they ditched the whole Civil War/slavery/Lincoln-as-sex-fiend bit and instead thought, "Puritans! That's what America will laugh at!" The result was Thanks, which was once allegedly given a two-word review: "No thanks." I think there was actually some decent potential here, but it was lost in all the dross and stupidity. Had it been done in a very limited, Blackadder-esque style where each season was a different era, and the seasons were short, it might have succeeded. Instead we got this, and how anyone thought this series would have any sort of legs is beyond me.
7. The Charmings (1987 - 1988), 21 episodes
So a historical comedy, eh... not so much. But TV executives had trod this territory before... sort of. They'd taken medieval fairy-tale characters and transported them into the modern era in a series called The Charmings. Yes, it was Snow White and her family living in the modern world and dealing with modern things, like bored and annoyed audiences! I actually have vague memories of watching this series when it aired and recall a lame joke about Tupperware. That is the only memory I have of it, and I know I watched a lot of the series. How anyone thought this was a good idea, or how it would sustain itself more than a few episodes, is beyond me.
6. Homeboys In Outer Space (1996 - 1997), 21 episodes
You know what the world really needs? Science-fiction sitcoms. But unless your name is Craig Charles, Chris Barrie, Robert Llewellyn or Danny John-Jules, you should never, ever attempt to do them. Especially if you're an American. This really was scraping the bottom of the barrel. It's like someone at UPN saw Red Dwarf and thought, "Can we black that up a bit? Oh, and in the process, let's excise all the funny parts." I remember watching this show back when it aired, which says less about the quality of the show than it does about what a weird time the mid-1990s were for me. Despite the overall horribleness of the show, I will say that it did manage to attract an impressive list of guest stars, including John Astin, Gary Coleman, James Doohan, George Takei and - at least according to Wikipedia - Anthony Hopkins. What the heck?
5. Cavemen (2007), 13 episodes
So somewhere a few years ago, someone said, "You know those Geico TV ads with the hipster cavemen living in modern times? We should totally make a TV series out of that!" That someone should have then been dragged out into the street and devoured by a rabid platypus. Since that didn't happen, a pilot was made, and a TV series was launched. Surprisingly, it wasn't horrible. I actually found it reasonably entertaining, but I wasn't surprised when it was cancelled. The public weren't really behind it, as obviously they weren't going to be, and the writer's strike in 2007 finished off any chance it had of being at all successful.
4. Cop Rock (1990), 11 episodes
Launching about a month after a musical TV series set at a high school (...hey... naw, it'll never catch on), this particular show, with an impressive pedigree, premiered to what The Simpsons once described as "angry yawns" in 1990. I'm truly baffled as to how anyone thought this should would be a success. Did they really think that inside every fan of police procedurals there was a fabulous Broadway fan just waiting to come out? How did they think this premise would sustain itself? Why did this even get to the pilot stage, much less get onto the air? These are questions humanity must answer if we are to learn from this mistake.
3. Rob (2012), 8 episodes
For reasons unclear to me, people keep paying Rob Schneider money to do things; things other than, "Please go away and leave us all alone." Since people keep paying him money, he keeps getting to do things. Most of those things, to be fair, are Adam Sandler related, but occasionally he ventures out on his own to give us such gems as Deuce Bigelow: Male Gigolo (best review, as near as I can remember: The title rhymes! That's funny! It has Rob Schneider. That's not), and Deuce Bigelow: European Gigolo (best review: ...well, this). In this TV series, Schneider plays an OCD-suffering man who marries into your stereotypical Latino family. "Hilarity" ensues. This is the kind of concept that would have been considered extremely racist with a loud black family. With Latinos, it's slightly less racist, though that's like saying the Nazis were slightly less racist than the Klan. And really, that's all you need to know about this show. It stars an unfunny lead actor who plays racist stereotypes in many of his movies, and in this show, marries into a whole family full of such things.
2. Allen Gregory (2011), 7 episodes
This show holds a special place in my heart. No, not for being of high quality or anything silly like that. But rather because my negative review of it was quoted on Wikipedia, even if the quote was mangled slightly. As a TV critic, that's when you know you've accomplished something. Why anyone thought a TV series about an overly-intellectual seven-year-old who wanted to have sex with his 80-something school principal would be a success is beyond me. The show had quite a lot of talent wasted on it, including the likes of Jonah Hill and Will Forte. Why they, or anyone else involved in the project, thought this was a worthwhile venture is also beyond me, but then again, I have an IQ higher than that of the average slime mold.
1. Heil, Honey, I'm Home! (1990), 1 episode
So if I told you there was a sitcom out there that featured the happy home life of Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun living next door to Jewish neighbours, you'd assume I was referencing some kind of Family Guy cutaway. Well, Family Guy hasn't ever done that cutaway. And there's a good reason for it. Because someone actually made this as an actual TV series that was actually aired on TV. I just tried to watch the first episode, which you can see on YouTube. I made it less than five minutes. It's intended as a satire of banal American sitcoms of the 1950s and 1960s, and I can see how it might have worked for a five minute sketch on some comedy show. A comedy show like, say, Monty Python. Who did, in fact, do a Hitler sketch. The most baffling part of this isn't the fact that it got green-lot, got a pilot, was picked up, and had the first episode aired, no, the most baffling part is that SIX OTHER EPISODES WERE MADE. That means someone actually wrote out that much material for this TV series. It's an astounding achievement in its own way. So that's our take on 10 TV shows that should never have made it past the pilot stage. What ones would you add?