It's been ten years since American television aired its first episode of The Office, a single-camera, faux-documentary sitcom that was adapted from the critically adored UK version of the same name. And in that time, one thing has remained apparent: creator Greg Daniels and his team of writers were very gifted at bringing the big laughs. They were less gifted, however, at filling up plot holes. Over the span of nine seasons, as is bound to happen in any long-running sitcom, there were some drastic changes made to the characters. Sometimes these changes made sense (i.e. Kelly Kapoor's transition from demure customer service rep to boyfriend-crazy gossip), while other times they felt like a poorly cut-and-pasted character arc, as if employees of Dunder Mifflin were picking personality traits from a hat at the start of each week. So naturally, inconsistencies abound in Scranton, Pennsylvania. That's forgivable. The writers of the show can't possibly remember every little detail about the Dunder Mifflin Universe, after all. But some of these are discrepancies even Kevin Malone would have caught. And although the series finale attempted to explain away some of these glaring disparities (like why they never showed the audience what Jim wrote in that note to Pam at the Christmas Party), there are still a handful of unanswered questions that could have used a little extra screen time. Or a more rigorous editing process. Starting with...
10. Does Michael Scott Actually Have An Older Brother?
It was a throwaway line in the Season 2 episode Email Surveillance. Michael Scott, after realizing his secret plan to gain open access to his employees' work emails isn't really so secret, says in a talking head scene:
"The problem is that when people hear the term 'big brother' they immediately think it's scary or bad. But I don't. I think, 'Wow, I love my big brother.'"
The only other mention we ever hear about this supposed sibling is in the very first episode, when Michael tells Pam that the special filing place for Corporate memos is the trash bin. That joke, he insists after getting harangued by his supervisor, was his brother's. We know a lot about Michael's family after 9 seasons. We know his parents are divorced and he deeply despises his stepdad, Jeff. We even hear from Michael's mother, briefly, after he calls her to tell her he's getting married...again. (Even though he actually isn't...again.) With that kind of detail you'd expect to at least hear his brother mentioned at any other time, if not see him drop by the office at some point.
9. How Did Pam Become A Volleyball Superstar?
The Season 4 episode Job Fair is a wellspring of inconsistencies, which will be expounded upon later. For right now, let's focus on Pam. In the episode, a small group of representatives from Dunder Mifflin venture off to Pam's old high school to attempt to lure kids into an internship with the company. Once inside her former gymnasium, Pam strolls down memory lane, recalling how she used to pretend to have PMS to get out of playing volleyball. Yet, just one season later, in a crucial plot point in the episode Company Picnic (well, as crucial as a plot point about a company picnic can be), we learn that Pam is a superstar volleyballer. She's so much better than every other person at the Scranton branch, in fact, that when she injures herself in a match against Corporate, the rest of the team has to stall for an excruciatingly long time so Pam can get checked out by a nearby hospital and hopefully return to win the game for them. Pam herself explains her volleyball prowess coyly, saying: "Maybe I played a little in junior high. And in high school. Maybe a little in college. And went to volleyball camp most summers!" If she loves the sport so much--and is so damn stellar at it--why would she NOT want to destroy her classmates in high school gym class?
8. To What Extent Does Oscar's Homosexuality Define Him?
The only character besides Kelly Kapur to have changed so much that they're practically unrecognizable from Season 1 to Season 9 is Oscar Martinez. A major reason for this, at least retroactively, is that Oscar's homosexuality was hidden from the office until Michael "accidentally" outed him in Season 3. Of course, his sexuality isn't his only defining characteristic: he's also a rational intellectual, a condescending know-it-all, and the frequently exasperated moral compass of the Scranton branch. But while those traits remain more-or-less constant, his homosexuality is often amped up to the extreme, resulting in some truly cringeworthy scenes. Going back to Season 4's Job Fair, for instance, Oscar can be seen wasting time, casually shooting hoops with Daryl. It's no big deal. Gay men can be good at sports. But later, in the Season 6 episode Happy Hour, when Oscar is trying to subtly flirt with the only other openly gay man in the office (warehouse worker, Matt, brought in solely as a romantic interest), the two of them shoot hoops together, only this time Oscar looks as though he's never seen a basketball before. And talks about "hoops" as though it's the first time he's ever said the word. It's a significant moment because, depending on the scene's intentions (or lack thereof), this could either mean that Oscar simply loses himself and his personality whenever a love interest is near, or the producers of the show just wanted to "turn up" Oscar's homosexuality for some cheap laughs.
7. Why Does Everyone Randomly Hate On Jim?
Charles Miner comes in with a predetermined hatred of the young salesman simply because he showed up one day wearing a tuxedo. What about his work performance? Sure, there are a few ill-timed moments that make Jim appear as though he's slacking on the job, but we've been told consistently that his sales numbers are as good or better than his coworkers. So does Charles just hate left-field classiness that much? Then there's anytime Jim's put in charge of something in Michael's absence. His idea to combine several of the employees' birthday parties into one big party due to their close proximity on the calendar. Even though all employees say they hate the awkward celebrations and tell Jim (albeit with mixed signals) that they'd be onboard for the joint birthday party, they immediately turn on him when the party lacks individual significance. And sometimes they're just being unrealistically petulant, as when Dwight schemes to make Jim (then co-manager) create an Employee of the Month incentive, then tricks Jim into giving himself the award, complete with a self-aggrandizing cake. And without giving it a second thought, everyone starts throwing verbal haymakers Jim's way. They actually believe Jim Halpert, who they've known for years, would be so egotistical as to do something like that. This all only makes sense if there's some deleted footage in which Jim Halpert walks up to each person in the office and slaps them in the face.
6. Is The Truth Behind Andy Bernard's Name A Joker-esque Fiction?
Andrew "Andy" "Drew" Bernard is a sympathetic guy in the first few seasons. Sure, he has serious temper issues, but it's hard not to feel bad for the guy, as he clearly will do almost anything for acceptance. That may stem from some parental issues, as we eventually learn that Andy has a younger brother, Walter Jr., who is the clear apple of his father's eye. In fact, for the first six years of his life, Andy was named Walter Jr., until his brother was born, at which point his parents transferred the name to someone who they felt "better exemplified the Walter Jr. name." Except, is his father even really named Walter? When they're first introduced in the Season 4 finale, "Goodbye Toby," Andy calls them "Andrew and Ellen." Which would make Andy...Andy Jr.? Or does he falsely provide their names here as a bit of self-defense against any future Walter/Walter Jr. discussions that he may have with his coworkers? In which case, why would he bring the Walter Jr. thing up later and invite his coworkers to a gathering (Season 8's Garden Party) where his brother was sure to be?? OR does Andy change his parents' names on a whim, swapping them out to amuse himself? ...WANNA SEE HOW I GOT THIS SMILE??
5. Why is Phyllis Such An A-hole? And Why Does No One Besides Angela Call Her Out on It?
Widely considered one of the The Office's greatest filler episodes, Cafe Disco implemented a new room to be used as an extension of Dunder Mifflin's Scranton Branch. Borne from the buyout of the competing Michael Scott Paper Company, which then left its "offices" empty when its employees merged back into Dunder Mifflin, Cafe Disco was set to be a terrific new addition that would house different types of shenanigans. Michael Scott had a vision for this dance house/coffee bar and, though it takes some time, the entire office grows to love it. Even Angela. Yet, as all great single-episode sitcom manufacturings eventually do, Cafe Disco goes away. Immediately. It's gone the very next episode and never spoken of again. A room that made such an enormous impact on his children--err, employees--wouldn't have simply been left to fade away. Michael Gary Scott holds onto his accomplishments, no matter how small, and makes monuments of them. He would take every chance to coral the gang together for a dance party or some coffee talk. Then again, it's not entirely out of logic's reach to think that he just forgot about it, basking in the euphoria of his job well done without focusing that proud sentiment on any one thing in particular. But couldn't the writers have given it at least a cursory nod later in the series?
3. Why Wasn't Michael At The Panel Discussion For The Documentary?
One of the greatest elements of the series finale was the panel discussion with the cast of the show-within-the-show. Held in Scranton, the Q&A with fans of the "documentary" acted as a reunion for characters who had spread across the country, providing ex-Dunder Mifflin-ites Andy, Darryl, Stanley, and Toby a reason to return to Scranton. Two former co-workers remained conspicuously absent from this panel discussion, however: Michael Scott and Holly Flax. Now, Holly was only a temporary replacement for Toby, and her ailing parents gave her a reason not to attend. But Michael, who shows up later that same week to be the surprise best man for Dwight's wedding, has no such excuse. Yes, Michael Scott had left Dunder Mifflin two years earlier, and on a realistic level, Steve Carrell's surprise cameo probably paid off better this way. But Michael Scott would not have missed an opportunity for all that fanfare. That's way too much attention for him to avoid. And the argument that two years away from Dunder Mifflin would have changed his personality and perspective that much just doesn't fly. So what's the real reason he wasn't there? And does it involve his older brother...?
2. Who Started Working At The Office First, JimOor Pam?
This is the chicken and egg dilemma that has yet to be resolved, hanging over Scranton, Pennsylvania like a massive, unsolved Rubik's Cube. In Season 4's Launch Party, Jim and Pam continue their hot streak of adorableness by recalling the exact moments they knew they loved each other. For Jim, it was his very first day at Dunder Mifflin, when the cute receptionist said to him, just before walking him over to his desk, "Enjoy this moment, because you're never going to go back to this time before you met your desk mate, Dwight." But hold on, because a couple of seasons earlier in The Secret, Jim confides in Michael that he had a crush on Pam when she first started. This means Jim had already been working there. So which is it, then? Who actually started first? Who is the egg??
1. The Boom Mic Operator is That Hunky? Really??
No. No. No. The realm of believability was exited the moment that Brian the boom mic guy revealed himself. A gentleman that handsome would not be paid to hold a microphone on a stick for eight hours a day. What's this guy's deal? Honestly. Did he take a job as the boom operator because he secretly hoped the producers would take one look at him and give him a part in another show that required some superiorly handsome extras? And did that NOT work? Because it definitely should have.