10 Worst CGI Moments In The Arrowverse
These moments were spectacles for all the wrong reasons...
The Arrowverse has been a juggernaut of television for nearly a decade now. In that time, it has brought together some of the most popular superheroes in DC's history, showcasing them across Arrow, The Flash, DC's Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl, Black Lightning, Batwoman and Stargirl.
Since the first of those arrived on screens in 2012, we've been entertained with some impressive and boundary-pushing sights. However, not every larger-than-life moment ended up having the larger-than-life feel that they were supposed to. One of the primary reasons for that is the sometimes-dodgy CGI.
Look, at the end of the day we must remember that we are talking about television here. No matter how ambitious the shows are, it would be ridiculous of anyone - and downright unfair - to expect blockbuster-quality special effects from a TV series (y'know... unless you're Game of Thrones) simply because they don't have anywhere near as big a budget.
But that hasn't stopped us all from noticing some of the times when the Arrowverse shows were perhaps a little too ambitious and couldn't quite get the desired results. On that note, let's take a look at some of those times when the CGI stood out for all the wrong reasons...
10. Batwoman - The Scarlet Knight Takes Flight
Batwoman's pilot episode was a solid opening to the show. A little flat when compared to some of the other Arrowverse offerings, sure, but solid nonetheless. One thing that let it down, though, was the CGI used in the titular character's debut.
The battle in the episode's climax between Kate and Alice looked great, but it was the shot of the newly-arrived Batwoman posing over Gotham City that looked really odd.
Not only did the Batwoman in question look more like a stunt person than Ruby Rose, the angle they were positioned at didn't match the angle that the background was filmed from and the odd way that the cape blew didn't fit either. Given that the green-screening used wasn't half-bad, the awkward angle undercut the grandeur of the shot (and, indeed, the moment).
9. The Flash - Atom Smasher Goes Up
WWE Superstar Edge made a memorable impression when he rocked Central City as Atom Smasher in the Season 2 premiere of The Flash, being a convincing threat to the mere mortals around him and even the Scarlet Speedster himself. Unfortunately, when Atom Smasher grew, the good old CGI was called on.
When the transformation took place, the character's limbs ballooned exponentially in a cartoonish fashion, his fingers became long and sharp without any realistic definition and his skin had an incredibly soft and plastic look.
It wasn't all bad because the shots were short and sweet and the Earth-2 villain looked fine (if a little stilted) whenever he had fully grown - and the transitions between CGI Atom Smasher back to Edge were seamless, so that's more than enough reason to go easy on this one. That said, maybe it would have been best if his transformations took place off-screen.
8. Arrow - The Flash Saves The Arrow
In the early days, Arrow was known for its grounded and realistic approach. For that reason, it never needed to rely on CGI all that often because the vast majority of the show wasn't anywhere near as ambitious as it or the Arrowverse would eventually become.
That's why it came as a bit of a shock whenever CGI Flash sped his way into view to save Oliver from a couple of high-speed boomerangs in the first of the annual crossovers.
There was a difference from the typical computer-generated rendering seen on The Flash, as this Scarlet Speedster wasn't quite as shiny as that one. He did, however, possess an awkwardly pointed and - for lack of a better term - hard-looking jaw.
Barry's rescue undoubtedly made for an awesome moment, but the model spinning into the shot over the top of a very real Stephen Amell drew our attention for the wrong reasons - and the slow-motion only highlighted that.
7. The Flash - Barry Vs. Solovar
The Flash did a fantastic job with Gorilla Grodd, making him look every bit as formidable as his comic book counterpart while using him sparingly in dimly lit sewers so that the occasional visual shortcoming wouldn't be obvious.
Unfortunately, it was impossible to do that in the third season when Barry travelled to Gorilla City in broad daylight and battled a giant white gorilla in front of a coliseum full of them.
Honestly, Solovar himself looked great. Not quite as good as Grodd - who, in this same scene, had some great King Kong-esque CGI - but great nonetheless. The problem was just how overpowering the CGI in this scene was and that made all of the shortcomings stand out.
Barry's computer-generated double was called upon throughout and so the stilted CGI Flash flailed around on-screen while CGI Solovar did an equally bizarre stilted run throughout the battle. And whenever the real Flash appeared on-screen, the blurred outline of the green-screen around him undercut the realism of what they were trying to achieve here.
6. The Flash - Barry Battles His Past Self
It's well-documented how The Flash's computer-generated double is occasionally more video game character than live-action superhero, so can you imagine how seeing two of them went down with fans?
During the second season, Barry decided to go back in time to get advice from his archenemy Eobard Thawne. To do that, he needed to take his past self out of the equation. And naturally, a brawl between the two ensued... a very, CGI-heavy speedster brawl, that is.
In all fairness, the graphics themselves are fine. It's just the lingering shots on the two Scarlet Speedsters' faces (which, to be fair, really do look like Grant Gustin) that let it down because they highlight that they're not real people.
Couldn't they have just used less ambitious shots and relied on Gustin and a body double instead? And if they really wanted to use the CGI speedsters, couldn't they have just avoided close proximity with the models' faces?
5. Arrow - Roy Harper's Dodgy Apparition
Arrow's 100th episode landed in the midst of the Invasion! crossover so the writers came up with an elaborate scheme to have the Dominators trap the cast of Arrow (and Legends of Tomorrow's Sara and Ray since they debuted on the show) in a dream sequence. Admittedly, this was a brilliant way of celebrating the milestone because it also allowed former cast members to return.
Whenever Oliver left the dreamscape to return to reality, he emotionally bid farewell to what was a pretty perfect dream only to be greeted by a wall of his loved ones reciprocating the emotion as some inspirational quotations from each one of them played over the top.
While the likes of Katie Cassidy, Susanna Thompson and Jamey Sheridan were able to return, Colton Haynes - who portrayed Roy Harper - could not. And thus, a stand-in was used while Roy's face was super-imposed over the top of it - and, well, needless to say it didn't look right.
The angling of Hayne's super-imposed head just doesn't match in any way with the body double and it is quite off-putting, especially since we were supposed to be concentrating on the emotional moment.
4. Crisis On Earth-X - CGI Supergirl
Supergirl has taken flight a lot in the five years that the show has been on the air and over the course of those five years, the production team have used multiple methods to bring it to life.
For up close shots, they tend to have Melissa Benoist do some great wirework on a green-screen and then add her into the skies of National City. This approach has had various degrees of success over the years, but more often than not, it looks great.
The other method didn't really make its presence felt until Supergirl moved to The CW and that's the complete CGI model of the Girl of Steel.
Much like The Flash's CGI double, she's particularly used whenever the show requires her to fight with another super-powered threat. That's passable provided we don't see her face, but it's hard to deny that CGI Supergirl didn't stick out like a sore thumb in the Crisis On Earth-X crossover whenever the Arrowverse heroes did their annual money shot side-by-side.
While the animated Ray was protected by his golden glow and Killer Frost's ice entrance had distance working in its favour, the CGI model of Supergirl couldn't rely on either. Though the hair flowed better than it did in previous instances, it didn't look like hair and the texture of the body looked like soft plastic. It might have been passable if it wasn't levitating above real people - something that made it stand out for all the wrong reasons.
3. Supergirl - The Showdown With Malefic
The scope of last season's Crisis On Infinite Earths crossover resulted in every one of the Arrowverse shows holding back throughout the year. Thus, shortcuts were taken (Killer Frost's voice echo was dropped while Black Canary's Cry was heard rather than seen) to avoid anything costly. Unfortunately, Supergirl didn't take any shortcuts with this one.
A strange scene, it features an unusually poor Martian render as Ma'alefa'ak threatened J'onn and the D.E.O. only to be outsmarted by the Girl of Steel. Then as he shoots at Alex and Brainy, Kara protects them by whooshing in front of the bullets only to slide out of view.
This one became a bit of a viral sensation, with people hating on how poor the effects are.
In all fairness, it's not that bad and is only made same that much worse by the fact that the scene's quick cuts and rushed pacing give you whiplash so it's nearly impossible to understand what's going on if you watch it without context. And because of that, the dodgy CGI stands out more... especially when Kara's CGI double freezes in mid-air and then slides off-screen.
2. The Flash - Firestorm's Journey Into The Wormhole
The Flash's Season 2 premiere may have skipped forward a few months in time, but it did take a moment to pick up exactly where its predecessor left off. Unfortunately, not all of the impressive special effects from its predecessor came with it.
As the Scarlet Speedster tried to close the wormhole, Ronnie Raymond and Professor Stein knew he'd need a nuclear-like blast to help seal it. With that, they re-merged as Firestorm and flew into the hole in the sky. But the shot of the super-powered duo heading into it looked really peculiar.
The Firestorm body (complete with burning hands and hair) looked as epic as ever, but the computer-generated version of Robbie Amell's face looked more like it belonged to a PS2 game. It was also disproportionate to the body and very awkwardly placed onto it.
To say it took away from the epic and poignant moment would be a tad dramatic (not-to-mention a lie), but it was a very strange, jarring sight. Couldn't they have had Amell fly on some wires behind a green screen and CGI'd that in instead?
1. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow - Captain Nazi
Legends of Tomorrow is arguably the most ambitious of the Arrowverse shows (hey, travelling through time will do that for you!). A lot of the time it pulls that ambitiousness off in a practical manner, using clothes, vehicles and set redesigns to recreate the look of a particular time period.
And then there's times like this when they just throw caution to the wind and create a hulking CGI monster because why the hell not, right?
While this paid off in instances like the unforgettable Beebo vs. Mallus fight, it was much less successful in the opening of Season 2 when Captain Nazi was introduced.
The result of a serum that turned Baron Kreiger into a giant musclebound, well, hulk, the character's look left a lot to be desired. The rendering gave the monstrous Kreiger a soft and shiny look that made him look far less realistic, but that wouldn't have been so bad if the animation wasn't so off.
Bouncing around in an awkward stilted fashion, Captain Nazi mowed through people without even touching them and the fact that this strange, strange creature even managed to undercut a show as tongue-in-cheek as Legends really does say it all.