12 Sci-Fi TV Shows Let Down By Terrible Endings

At least Lost didn't end with a furry friend being kidnapped by the feds...

By Cathal Gunning /

What is it about sci-fi in particular that makes it either great or terrible fodder for TV, with little room in between the two extremes? Maybe it’s the fact that the television series format is perfect for slow burn mysteries and sci-fi is a genre which requires plenty of exposition and world building in order to build stakes and develop believable characters. Maybe it’s the fact that the limited budgets of TV mean sci-fi is more likely to end up looking laughable on the small screen than in the multiplex.

Advertisement

Whatever the cause, as often as sci-fi series delight genre fans with treats like Star Trek, The X-Files, or Stranger Things, there are countless well-intentioned creators whose sci-fi series end up disastrous flops. And more often than not, an embarrassing ending is central to the failure of a show.

Sure, some of these series were already pretty middle of the road before their ignominious finales rolled around. But some of them were genuine classics and no one wanted the grand revelations of their final episode to leave viewers let down by the hours they committed to them. In any case, here are set of a dozen sci-fi shows which unfortunately fell short when it came time for their denouement.

12. Invasion

Debuting in 2005, Invasion may have been plagued by some of the worst timing in television production history. The show, the first of many hoping to replicate the success of Lost which debuted a year earlier, concerned the titular invasion by unseen aliens during a catastrophic storm off the coast of Florida.

Advertisement

The problem was 2005 played host to Hurricane Katrina, a very real tragedy which left Americans none too eager to follow a fictional national disaster. As a result, the series which had originally been intended to run for five seasons was cut down to a single season, twenty two episode run.

As a result the cause of the eponymous invasion and the many mysteries of the aliens it harboured, hinted at throughout the short run, remained unexplained. What could have been an enigmatic cliff hanger became the show’s official ending and frustrated fans turned to unsuccessful petitions in order to learn what it all meant.

11. The Prisoner

You didn’t think we could possibly forget this one, did you? The Prisoner’s trippy finale was so widely and unforgettably derided that decades later The Simpsons would go on to parody its answer-free mindf*** in the season twelve episode The Computer Wore Menace Shoes—and get original show creator and star Patrick McGoohan to do a quick guest spot, too.

Advertisement

Of course, it wasn’t always that easy for fans to find McGoohan, since the creator went into hiding for weeks after the initial broadcast of The Prisoner’s surreal ending for fear of being tracked down by furious fans.

So, what did the show do to earn such ire? Well, after setting up a strange allegorical village wherein our hero, a British spy, is mysteriously imprisoned, the show’s final chapter saw him escape—only to leave viewers with more questions than before. Involving a massive conspiracy, gorilla masked henchmen with our hero’s face, and a deflating security balloon, the show’s closing scenes were utterly inscrutable and left curious viewers fuming as it became clear that none of the show’s mysteries would be answered any time soon.

10. Blake's 7

This one is sure to be controversial, as Blake’s 7 is almost as beloved amongst its fanbase as the OTHER British sci-fi adventure show of the seventies (P.H.D in a Tardis ringing any bells?). The show was more serious and adult than any incarnation of the good Doctor, though, following the titular guerrilla fighter and his motley band of resistance recruits as they attempted to overthrow the galaxy’s fascist overlords from the comfort of their aptly-named ship the Liberator.

Advertisement

It’s an edgy premise that produced a few seasons of classic politically charged sci-fi, fusing tense action and charming team chemistry with strong allegorical underpinnings. What could go wrong?

Well, you could take the central theme too far and off almost the entire cast in the closing episode in order to reinforce the cynical attitude of the series so far. That’s Blake himself dead, Vila joining him on the coroner's slab, and Avon facing down a hail of bullets. More Butch and Sundance than Doctor and companion, then.

9. Lost

J.J Abrams’ calling card for a career as a major Hollywood talent in the world of cinematic sci-fi, Lost probably needs no introduction a decade and a half after the show’s enigmatic debut. The stylish, dark mystery had a conceit genius in its simplicity and bolstered by an ensemble cast free from weak links.

Advertisement

A small group of survivors, their personalities at odds and backstories only gradually hinted at, are stranded on a strange island after a plane crash. With intersecting flashbacks, flash forwards, parallel timelines, and alternate realities, the show soon made it clear that its eventual explanation would something be altogether more complicated and sophisticated than the typical “It’s all a dying dream” Jacob’s Ladder lark… Right?

Well, it was certainly more complicated than that, but when the finale finally arrived on our screens critics and audiences alike were furious to find that, after years spent decoding all manner of subtle minutiae, the ending wasn’t all that far from the cliché everyone expected from its first episode.

8. The X-Files

Yeah, we’re going there—okay, so admittedly half the X-Files sizeable fanbase were happy enough with the divisive ending of the original series. But it’s hard to deny that, after almost a decade following the attempts of Agents Mulder and Scully to uncover the alien conspiracy which constantly eludes them, it wasn’t unfair for fans to expect that the series finale might be a bit more than just an ad for the then-upcoming theatrical film follow-up.

Advertisement

However, even with the inevitable cross-promotion taken into account, it’s hard to feel sympathy for creator Chris Carter, as the eventual release of the X-Files second theatrical offering brought with it few answers for the show’s long-running mysteries, as 2008’s belated sequel The X-Files: I Want to Believe was a bloated monster of the week episode with no relation to the central conspiracy at all.

So that’s what, two official endings, and none were the satisfactory answer viewers sought out?

If anyone bothered to watch the 2016 revival, feel free to tell us what new brand of non-answer that incarnation offered at its close.

7. V (2009)

Both the original eighties iteration of alien invasion miniseries V and the more recent 2009 reboot of the same property suffered from abortive early endings as their parent networks decided to jump ship rather than fund another season which might have actually—shock horror—provided some clarity and closure for fans.

Advertisement

However the 2009 reboot of the franchise is the one we’re spotlighting because of its unfortunate trajectory being a perfect example of “good show, awful ending” issue which seems to plague so much sci-fi TV. Whilst the first season of the show was a taut, tense, and surprisingly dark take on the material as the villainous V took their time seizing control of earth from under unsuspecting human noses, the second season began to delve into oddly existential questions to its detriment.

The show meandered through an interminable subplot in which the V unsuccessfully attempted to extract a human soul (seriously), only for the ending to suddenly off half the cast and reveal that the V were indeed unstoppable and their takeover of earth was an inevitability. The twist struck a low note with frustrated viewers, many of whom were relieved to hear the show wouldn’t return for another season.

6. Heroes

Poor Heroes. Was there any worse casualty of the 2008 writer’s strike?

Advertisement

The show’s first season was a ratings smash and was adored by critics upon its arrival on our screens way back in 2006. The show’s then-novel premise of ordinary people from all walks of life beginning to exhibit superhuman abilities the world over was bolstered by a fantastic ensemble cast of both relative newcomers and established talent ranging from future Nashville starlet Hayden Panettiere, Masi Oka, and Jayma Mays, to former Gilmore Girls bad boy Milo Ventimigilia, Ali Larter, and Spock-in-waiting Zachary Quinto.

However, the writer’s strike dealt the show’s second season a serious blow from which it never really recovered, and the tendency to kill off promising characters—as well as resurrecting characters willy nilly—meant stakes were often both too high and not high enough at once. Still, nothing could prepare fans for the disappointment of the eventual series finale.

A cliché big battle which kept the entire returning cast unharmed, ruined fan favourite Hiro’s long running love story, and still somehow managed to screw up the series only effective character, the villainous Sylar, the finale proved not every show deserves another shot.

You know, before the inevitable reboot Heroes Reborn a few years later, that is.

5. Life On Mars (US)

Now, the divisive ending coming from the UK iteration of this sci-fi time travel genre-mashing mystery procedural was controversial enough. But really, was there any way a show with a description as complicated as that was going to have a simple conclusion?

Advertisement

Following 2006 cop Sam Tyler when he wakes up in 1973 and must investigate both a series of crimes and the circumstances of his own inexplicable time travel, the original series wrapped up with an enigmatic conclusion which hinted at numerous interpretations without completely confirming any theories. It split audiences at the time, but boy, was it beaten by the US remake a few years later.

2008’s American edition of Life on Mars took its hero of the same name to the same year via the same “is it a coma or time travel” conceit, but that’s where the similarities end. Primarily because, after endless episodes of police procedural which hinted vaguely at something more sci-fi, the show ended on the insane revelation that our hero was—how’s this for literalism—in hypersleep on his way to the titular red planet, and this has all been a simulation.

4. Quantum Leap

Blessed with a genius premise (“physicist Dr Sam Beckett comes unstuck in time, can bounce between bodies within his lifetime in order to help the lives of others—but can’t control this ability”), Quantum Leap was a long-running sci-fi show which touched on almost every other TV genre across its illustrious run and mostly did so with grace and panache.

Advertisement

Until its infamous final instalment, that is. In the surreal episode Mirror Image, our hero arrived at a town inhabited by characters he had encountered during earlier trips through time. After the protagonist saves a set of miners from a collapse, he’s informed by an enigmatic barman that these miners were all fellow time travelling body hoppers and the whole trippy ordeal has been a test. With that bombshell out of the way, the barman informs our nominal hero that he is actually able to control his leaps, and will be able to go home any time he wants.

Pretty perfect closer, right?

Sure—if it weren’t for the cut-to-black last shot, whose epigraph inexplicably and devastatingly reads “Dr Sam Beckett never returned home.”

3. Battlestar Galactica

This one almost feels unfair, as the series Battlestar Galactica deserves some serious kudos for trying to inject something resembling moral complexity into the Star Trek style set-up that it trafficked in. The show offered none of the easy ethical answers which Trek’s utopian reality often settled for, and the characters were by and large refreshingly well rounded and believable figures.

Advertisement

This only served to make the eventual finale all the more frustrating, though, with the once-deeply human Starbuck turned into goodness incarnate in a move which aimed for transcendence but instead hit somewhere between saccharine sentimentality and overwrought emotion. And that’s to say nothing of Roslin’s ignominious exit.

It’s an ending so bizarrely out of place that even Game of Thrones scribe George R.R Martin found it impossible to hide his disappointment, calling out the show’s clumsy deus ex machina as both a fellow writer and a fan.

2. ALF

The beloved eighties sitcom ALF may seem like an odd inclusion on this list for anyone who recalls the fluffy cat consumer as little more than a harmless Mork and Mindy meets The Muppets mashup/ rip off. After all ALF was, for better or worse, just another family sitcom which wedged an odd alien character into the mix in order to keep a tired formula fresh, 3rd Rock From the Sun style—right?

Advertisement

Indeed the series was, and the show excelled as a bit of harmless light entertainment for the most part—until its infamous closing moments. Now we do need to note that this entry felt jarring with the tone of the show mainly because it was a cheap plot designed to set up a spin-off TV movie.

But nonetheless, the fact remains that ALF ended with the eponymous alien being kidnapped by government agents bent, presumably, on experimenting on the loveable fluffball—or at worst exterminating the extra-terrestrial with extreme prejudice.

Cheery stuff for the show’s huge kid fanbase, that.

1. Dark Matter

Lasting three seasons, Dark Matter was a solid Syfy series based on the comic series of the same name by Joseph Mallozzi and Paul Mullie. The show followed an ensemble cast featuring genre stalwarts ranging from Continuum’s Roger Cross to Silent Hill’s Jodelle Ferladn and boasted a stellar premise.

Advertisement

A sextet of survivors awaken aboard a starship with no recollection of how they got there or who they are, forcing the tense team to work together in order to discover their identities—as well as how they ended up here, and who’s responsible for their predicament.

So, what was the plan behind this ragtag group of unlikely heroes, each of whom had a distinct skill and disadvantage which gradually allowed them to become an effective team, being thrown together? Well, the show’s fourth season had an answer—or at least it would have done, if the show hadn’t been cancelled after its third season ended on a tense cliff hanger, leaving fans with no answers—and in the middle of a space battle, no less!

Advertisement