12 Things That Make No Sense In BoJack Horseman
The plot holes and mistakes hidden within the critically acclaimed show.
In the animated world of Bojack Horseman, one must sometimes suspend their disbelief and just accept that some things are perfectly plausible. Like how anthropomorphic animals exist as modern-day people with normal jobs and normal lives and almost normal bodies.
These wacky adventures of a horse who was in a very famous TV show have been a must-see for the past six years and gave us wonderous episodes that made us laugh, made us cry, and also made us think about how we as individuals treat those closest to us.
The end of the streamed series has given time for further pause and reflection on a show that has previously generated more than most - but that's not to say certain plot points survived when held up to additional scrutiny.
The 12 below may be up for debate, but don't remotely derail the overall quality of the episodes in which they feature. The show is still full of things that are really funny and equal parts heartwarming and heartbreaking, but that doesn't mean that this hit Netflix series isn't also full of things that make no sense.
12. Herb Kazzaz's Murder
When Bojack Horseman's old friend Herb Kazzaz dies from a peanut allergy caused by a car crash, his final wish was for Bojack's Horsin Around co-star Sarah Lynn to find what he had labeled "Herb's gold". This leads Bojack and his other costars to follow clues from their past, and discover that the hit tv show creator's death may not have been an accident.
The main piece of evidence they discover is a long voicemail left on Herb's answering machine, explicitly stating that his brakes were replaced and should not fail him unless sabotaged, leading the group to believe that his death was in fact murder.
But in the end, Herb's death is chalked up as a real accident. "Herb's gold" is revealed to be a personal memoir that was deemed so terrible, it would have ruined his reputation. However, the voicemail that Bojack and the others heard just doesn't fit in with the rest of the story. If there was no foul play, then why did Herb's brakes fail him, even though it was stated very clearly that they would not? Did someone actually sabotage the brakes, or was it just shoddy repairs? We may never know.
11. The D In Hollywoo
The largest and one of the first permanent changes Bojack created in his world occurred when he was so drunk off of Absinthe that he stole the d from the Hollywood sign to give it to Diane. Instead, he just rebrands the entire town into fabulous Hollywoo for the rest of the series.
Mr. Peanutbutter then stole the large sheet of metal and gave it to Diane, taking all the credit too. It was then helicoptered back, but before it made it back to its hilltop spot, a barrage of fireworks shot the helicopter down right into the L.A. prison, most likely killing the pilot. But despite the probable ease to just put the letter back, or even just make a new one, the sign is never fixed.
While the real-life reason most likely was to avoid having any copyright issues with making jokes about Hollywood, in the world of Bojack Horseman it just comes off as the laziest a city has ever been in fixing a beloved landmark.
10. A Halloween Store, In January?
After Todd got close to Mr. Peanutbutter working as his chauffeur in the first season, the pair end up becoming close friends, along with becoming business partners, working on ideas proposed by Todd that they never really follow through on, ending up just burning away Mr. Peanutbutter's money. The first real idea they had and went through with was building a Halloween store open in January, but only January.
Apparently this store idea would actually have worked if the pair followed through on the idea and didn't forget about it, leaving a hollowed-out storefront that doesn't even have a floor built-in.
Instead, Halloween in January ends up being a comedic cutaway for the show, claiming the faces and bones of anyone who wanted to find some spooky dishware and instead accidentally fall into a pit, including Andrew Garfield and Jimmy Fallon. Then it is never brought up again, despite somehow still operating for years without anyone questioning it or starting multiple potential lawsuits for the people that keep falling into this unfinished store.
9. Bojack's Tesla
When Bojack became an Oscar nominee, he also became incredibly depressed. His life had been leading towards this moment, and yet he felt nothing. Despite how Bojack felt, he started up a huge party at his house where all his "friends" could enjoy the spoils of being famous with him. Some of these rewards he enjoyed included a giant chocolate Oscar as well as a brand new yellow Tesla that he requested to be put inside the living room.
This car ended up being part of an emotional sequence where Bojack enjoys his night of being a superstar while being more alone than ever before, ending when he accidentally reverses the car into his pool, nearly drowning in the process. While he is saved by Mr. Peanutbutter, his Tesla, unfortunately, seemed to be destroyed from being half-submerged in water.
But it ends up being ok despite being electric, so somehow Teslas are waterproof in Bojack Horseman's world because by the season finale we see Bojack driving off in that same vehicle and even gets it all the way to Michigan. Evidently animated Elon Musk is able to make cars that are truly future proof.
8. Sarah Lynn's Injuries
When Bojack meets Sarah Lynn after not talking to her for eight years, he's totally ecstatic, and she's psychotic. After being broken up with by superstar Andrew Garfield, she decides to commit random violence and stabs herself with a rusty civil war bayonet.
Sarah Lynn recovers from her stab wound, comedically playing off the wound as something that just needed duct tape to fix. But her wounds looked like something much more fatal than what they ended up being, especially for an animated show that tries to stick in a world of realism. Later Todd even states explicitly that their world is not a cartoon, but real life. And yet she remained fine after stabbing her organs with a rusted bayonet that would at least cause some sort of infection.
Later in season three, Sarah Lynn survives a car crash she gets into while painting her toenails and talking to Bojack over the phone. And because she was stone sober by that point, her survival can't be explained away by drugs. Her body seemed to be nearly indestructible, at least externally, until she died from a drug overdose at the end of season three.
7. Elefante's Survival
When Bojack and Mr. Peanutbutter engaged in a massive egotistical competition to win over Diane, mostly by buying more and more expensive things, Bojack bought the restaurant, Elefante. Afterward he never really interacted with the restaurant, until he accidentally fired the main waiter who took most of the staff with him.
Bojack and Princess Carolyn tried their hardest to ensure a decent review from a critic who happened to be there that night, promoting the only staff member left to the head chef, and even recruiting some of the other dining guests to be waiters. The critic was still unpleased, even with the food coming out decent, assumedly ending the restaurant.
But in season five, Elefante is seen to still be running, even keeping some of the staff members from that night, yet the whole restaurant shouldn't be operational. Even if the first critic was just a small online critic with no real power over the realm of food, surely one with power or some sort of real inspector would have show up and shut the place down. Todd's ex-girlfriend, who is an inspector, even says as much during the same episode, and somehow the iconic restaurant lives on.
6. Ethan Around
Bojack and Bradley, aka Ethan from Horsin Around, never really spoke to each other when they worked together, or even after the show until Bojack finds out there was going to be a sequel show made without him, called Ethan Around. Bojack tries to get into the show and then abandons it when he felt he was too famous to work in a sitcom again.
But after Sarah Lynn's death, Bojack actually did want to do the show. He even spent quality time with Bradley, working on lines and giving his character Ethan the best comedic lines, showing one of the only real bonding moments we see between the pair.
Everything was going fine until Bojack had a panic attack after talking to a little girl that reminded him too much of Sarah Lynn, and he left the show. And then he never calls his costar again, leading to the show never even being produced due to losing its big-name star. We don't know what happened to Bradley, and we also don't know why Bojack never even apologized to him when he was making amends to people in season six, including other cast and crew members of Horsin Around.
5. Bojack's Pool
Bojack Horseman's house is the most recognizable location from the show, due to it being one of the main locations throughout the series, where most of the cast spend a lot of their time. But something about his home seems impossibly sturdy, aka his seemingly indestructible pool.
Not only has this pool taken beatings from multiple parties, but it also has had the d from the Hollywood sign and an entire Tesla thrown in there, not even mentioning Bojack's massive boat, the S.S. Escape from L.A., which was docked inside the pool with somehow no hassle at all, or any massive strain placed on the wooden patio surrounding the pool.
His pool isn't even on land it's just on some wooden stilts holding the house precariously over the L.A. cliffside. So it doesn't seem likely that it could take on such a tremendous strain. Also, the deepness of this pool has seemed to be nearly impossible to guess, with said tesla being almost submerged in it, yet all exterior shots of the house make the pool look barely four feet deep. Whoever is Bojack's renovator clearly does not get enough credit.
4. Todd's Prison Time
Todd involves himself in a plethora of wacky adventures outside of Bojack's couch, starting with his first-ever monetary venture with Princess Carolin in which they created an overelaborate scam turning Bojack's house into David Boreanaz's house, inevitably ending with the young entrepreneur going to prison for the better part of a week.
Fortunately, before he was almost executed gang-style in the L.A. prison, the D from the Hollywood sign fell from a crashing helicopter into the prison, releasing most of the prisoners into the wild, including the loveable couch surfer.
After Todd escapes prison he continues to work for multiple sometimes successful companies and involves himself with all sorts of famous people. Yet every time he got a job as a CEO or multimillionaire or hot new model, no cops or lawyers or janitors or businessmen ever seemed to run a background check into Todd's past, which if they did they would blatantly see that he has a prison record. Thus, by sheer luck, he has been allowed to work in many places where he probably shouldn't have been able to, due to being an escaped convict which is still illegal, even in Hollywoo.
3. Bojack Is Henrietta?
Alzheimer's appears in season four of Bojack Horseman, greatly impacting Bojack's mom, who progressed so deeply that she sees Bojack as one of her old maids Henrietta. It turns out this maid is actually the woman who gave birth to Hollyhock and who was greatly affected by Beatrice taking her away to give her a chance to have her own life.
While the revelations that came from finding out who Henrietta was seemed to wrap up the mystery of Hollyhock, it never seems clear why Bojack was viewed as this maid to begin with. Even in the episode dedicated to showing his mom reliving her life inside a dementia filled mind, the episode never clarifies why Bojack and Henrietta share the same spot in her mind.
Perhaps that is just to show how much Alzheimers can change someone, even the people closest to you, and the mystery of why Bojack was unrecognizable to his own mother could be explained away in an in-depth discussion, yet the show on its surface does not engage in that conversation.
2. Sarah Lynn's Overdose
The end of season three starts off on an insanely depressing note when Bojack convinces Sarah Lynn to go on an epic bender with him, despite her coming up on almost nine months of sobriety. The pair end up getting high for months, ending their trip in the planetarium where Sarah Lynn dies after overdosing from a strand of heroin called Bojack.
But it should have been impossible for her to have even found that strand of heroin in Bojack's glove compartment. Because while it was discovered that the drug came from ex Horsin Around star Goober's drug operation hiding behind an orca stripper park that's fun for the whole family, his entire operation was busted by the cops and the drugs were taken away.
In fact, Bojack never personally touches a single packet of the drug. Diane is the one given the heroin and probably gave that packet to the cops. So it makes no sense for the heroin to show up in his glove compartment. Did he steal a packet when the cops freed them from Goober? Was the drug available elsewhere? Did he get it from Diane? Either way, the mysterious heroin just seemed to appear when it shouldn't have.
1. The Nurse Drugged Hollyhock
Hollyhock, the second daughter figure to overdose because of Bojack, wasn't actually hurt by him. Because it was his mom this time who was at fault for the overdose. In her dementia twisted desire to make the young horse thin, like how she was taught as a child, Beatrice makes Hollyhock coffee and secretly puts in Fat B Gone pills every morning while they lived together in Bojack's house. The father-daughter pair weren't able to notice what was going on until it was too late.
But there was another person living in the house who should have noticed, and that was the nurse assigned to looking over Beatrice. She essentially lived with everyone and should have been there to watch the old horse make coffee since she had been shown attempting to cook food before and accidentally burning it. The bear was there for that instance, so why wasn't she there to make sure she didn't get hurt making coffee, where the growling nurse surely would have noticed that there were drugs being added in.
Instead, she seemed complete unobservant of the poisoning of Hollyhock, allowing Bojack to lose the one good thing he had going for him.