12 Worst Things That Ever Happened To BoJack Horseman

The times when BoJack's worst enemy wasn't himself.

By Scott Banner /

Over the course of six seasons, 76 episodes, and a LOT of shaking your head in disbelief at just how low BoJack Horseman can sink as a person, the titular horse proved to be one of the most hated characters in the entire show. And rightly so.

Advertisement

The list of heinous things he has done to people over the years is far too long to list here, though he even had the gall to tell Diane that no one suffered because of his actions more than himself. He was responsible for a young woman’s death, yet he still played the victim card.

That being said however, his life was never easy. Right from the very beginning, BoJack Horseman would be forced onto a path in life that would make it impossible to become a well-functioning member of society, and things carried on throughout his years.

Yes, much of what BoJack did were his own actions, that no one else is responsible for, but there were also times that he was dealt an impossible hand. It often seemed like the whole world was against him, and even without his own self-sabotage, BoJack was the victim of some pretty horrible things himself.

12. The BoJack Horseman Show

Back in the 90s, he was in a very famous TV show. After 'Horsin’ Around', BoJack was more than happy living off that reputation, and lazing around Hollywood enjoying the life while never actually having to put any more work in. Princess Carolyn had other ideas however, as her aspirations to become an agent resulted in a determination to get BoJack more work.

Advertisement

This came in the form of 'Mitch’s Life' by Cuddlywhiskers. The two met, and agreed to make an edgy TV show, completely different to the generic nonsense pumped out to appeal to Middle America. When the network execs had no notes on the pilot table read however, BoJack and Cuddlywhiskers felt they played it too safe, and retreated to the latter’s home to "stick their dicks in the script".

And thus, 'The BoJack Horseman Show' was born, one of the biggest professional mistakes BoJack ever made. To make sure people knew this wasn’t another 'Horsin’ Around', the very first scene was BoJack taking a dump on a 'Horsin’ Around' VHS tape. Emily was about the only person who used to love the show, and even that was only because she could laugh at how bad it was.

BoJack was now no longer just the horse from 'Horsin’ Around'. The only problem is that everyone loved the horse from 'Horsin’ Around'. Would he have continued being happy in Hollywood had he never took that meeting with Cuddlywhiskers?

11. The Release Of 'One Trick Pony'

Diane Nguyen was brought into BoJack Horseman’s life as a ghost writer for the autobiography he just couldn’t write himself. He had to work closely with her, and they grew to be very good friends. You could argue that this was the healthiest relationship BoJack ever had in his life.

Advertisement

However, on the release of the book, their friendship took an absolute battering. After BoJack tried to kiss Diane, she found it too weird to work so closely with him, and finished the book with what she already had. This turned out to be something of a scathing summing up of their six months together, rather than an actual biography.

BoJack was understandably pissed off, however he did not handle it in the best way. He ripped Diane to shreds, demeaned her and called her work sh*t, saying it would never see the light of day. Of course it ultimately did, and he was utterly humiliated.

The release of the book was actually one of the best things to happen to BoJack, because it earned him a Golden Globe and made him relevant enough to be cast as Secretariat. However, none of that mattered when he was so empty inside after losing someone so close to him, losing her respect, and not speaking to her until they reconciled awkwardly over three months later.

10. Kelsey Was Fired From Secretariat

Secretariat was a movie that BoJack Horseman had wanted to make for 30 years. It was just about the only career goal he ever had, and it should have been the pinnacle of his working life, however actually making the movie was a nightmare.

Advertisement

The studio decided to make wholesale changes to the story that BoJack cared so much about, including removing the emotional climax of the whole thing. BoJack convinced director Kelsey Jannings to steal away and shoot the scene without the producer’s knowledge, and even though they nailed it, she was sacked.

This had a devastating knock on effect. She was replaced with Abe, who didn’t care about the movie like Kelsey did, and after a misunderstanding with BoJack, stalled production so that the star couldn’t go to New York for the summer and work on a play with Jill Pill.

His disillusionment with Secretariat after Kelsey was fired, and the fallout of breaking up with Wanda, became too much for BoJack, and he escaped LA to New Mexico. The film was finished without him, as the incident with Penny in New Mexico almost ruined both of their lives. Had Kelsey kept her job, none of this would have happened.

9. Charlotte Was Happily Married

There is a long list of regrets and ‘what ifs’ in BoJack Horseman’s life, going all the way back to his childhood. One of the biggest however, came in the form of Charlotte, someone who he could have seen himself living a happy life with.

Advertisement

When he got incredibly high with Todd and Sarah-Lynn trying to write a better book than ‘One Trick Pony’, he imagined what his life would be like. He would be sat in a swing chair with Charlotte in Maine, and playing in the lake with his daughter, Harper. He would have been happy if he had chosen this life.

After Herb’s funeral, Charlotte told him to come visit when he was next in New Mexico, and in the wake of Secretariat falling apart, and his break up with Wanda, he escaped from LA with nothing but Charlotte on his mind. With her, outside of the tar pit that was LA, he could have been happy. When he got there however, he found that she was married with two kids.

She had her own happy family, and BoJack missed his opportunity. This sent him spiralling somewhat, and when his advanced were rebuked by Charlotte, he almost slept with her daughter, Penny. This was one of the worst decisions he ever made.

8. He Wasn't Nominated For An Oscar

A lot of the third season of BoJack Horseman focused around his campaign push to be nominated for an Oscar for Secretariat. BoJack put a lot of stock into thinking that this would be the validation he needed, and would make him happy, at least for a time.

Advertisement

When Mr. Peanutbutter read his name out at the Oscar nomination ceremony, he at first felt the same as before. It took Ana a while to convince him that he deserved it, and when the message finally got through, there was a potential path to happiness for him. Finally, he was being recognized.

However, BoJack was never actually nominated for an Oscar, he just didn’t find out about it until mid way through his huge celebration party. He was surrounded by dozens of people, but as soon as they heard he wasn’t nominated, they all left, just like Diane said they would. She said there would be no one there when BoJack killed himself, and even Ana left him in the wake of such devastation.

This sent BoJack to Sarah-Lynn and a bender that lasted until the Oscars themselves. He ruined a lot of relationships, and was agonizingly close to his rock bottom. Fuelled by the pain of having this nomination cruelly swept out from under him, BoJack potentially ruined Penny’s life all over again, and was the cause of Sarah-Lynn’s death.

7. Making Philbert

For the most part, BoJack Horseman was a terrible client for Princess Carolyn. However, there was one time, when PC really needed a win, that BoJack helped out for no other reason than to give her a break. This was agreeing to do Philbert, something he actually had no interest in doing himself.

Advertisement

The show took its toll on BoJack, both physically and mentally. Initially, he tried to use Philbert’s character as an excuse to justify the awful things he had done in his life before Diane knocked him down a few pegs, and when he injured his back while filming a motorcycle stunt for the show he got addicted to pain killers.

The set of Philbert looked literally exactly like his own home, he was incredibly similar to his character, and even when the show wrapped for season one, he continued wearing his Philbert costume. This, and his addiction to drugs made him paranoid, and he didn’t know when Philbert ended and BoJack began.

He started taking the character home with him, in that he thought there was a conspiracy to bring him down. His mind couldn’t separate the show and real life, and when Philbert was supposed to strangle Sassy in the script, BoJack lost control. He really strangled Gina, and nearly killed her. He probably would have if Mr. Peanutbutter hadn’t pulled him off her.

6. Hollyhock's Letter

Throughout the ups and downs of BoJack’s life and BoJack’s career, there was only one person that he genuinely never wanted to let down. Anyone else could have left him and he would have survived, but Hollyhock was unlike anyone else. She was much of his motivation for trying to stay sober.

Advertisement

However, when she met Pete at a party, the same Pete who was with BoJack and Penny at the prom when Maddy got alcohol poisoning, she learned some truly horrifying truths about her brother. This was made even worse by the truth about Sarah-Lynn’s last days coming out.

She wrote him a letter in response to everything that happened rather than actually speaking to him. Deep down BoJack knew it would be the end of their relationship, so he held off reading it. Until he did, she was still a part of his life, but eventually, when he could no longer hear her voice on her voicemail message, he read it.

It was never revealed exactly what Hollyhock said to him, but it was clearly what he feared. He dropped the letter to the ground, devastated by what he had read, headed back into the party he left to call her, and drank. He had just lost the one thing he could never stand to lose.

5. He Was Manipulated By Angela Diaz

Though it was the first acting job he ever got in Hollywood, 'Horsin’ Around' made BoJack Horseman a star. As a tandem with his best friend Herb in the director’s chair, the show was unstoppable. Until Herb’s name made it into the media in a manner the studio didn’t like.

Advertisement

He was outed as being gay, and since Angela Diaz was trying to sell the show to Disney, she didn’t like the image the publicity gave off. She wanted to fire Herb, but knew that she needed BoJack to stay, and that he wouldn’t let it happen.

She manipulated her star into thinking he had no choice but to cut ties with Herb. It was BoJack who held all the power in the show, but she manipulated him into thinking that if he stood up for Herb then he would be fired too, and the entire thing would collapse. He ultimately bent to her will, and let her fire his best friend.

She was bluffing, but BoJack bought the deception. In the future he would look back on this moment as a turning point in his life. The first real sh*tty thing he did, all thanks to Angela’s manipulation.

4. He Found Out He Was Manipulated By Angela Diaz

When BoJack turned his back on Herb, and let him be fired without a fight in favour of saving the show, he lost his best friend. He didn’t call him for the next 20 years out of guilt, and when he finally did try to make amends, Herb wouldn’t accept his apology.

Advertisement

What was arguably worse than BoJack being manipulated by Angela Diaz into such a betrayal was when he found out that he was manipulated. It wasn’t until he was sober, with his life in ruins thanks to the details of Sarah-Lynn’s death coming out that he found out the truth.

He didn’t have to betray Herb, and the news that Angela was bluffing sent him into a tailspin. He got blind drunk after almost a year of sobriety, he broke into his old house, something that would ultimately land him 14 months in prison, and he called Diane to tell her he didn’t think she cared about him.

This in turn sent Diane, who was in the healthiest mindset she had ever been in, into a downward spiral that saw her back out of moving to Houston with Guy. She eventually reunited with her eventual husband, but this was the last straw in her and BoJack’s friendship.

3. The Reporters

After spending six months in rehab, and re-entering the world attending AA meetings and getting a good job as an acting professor at Wesleyan University, BoJack Horseman’s life was finally in a better place. He proved that you are never too old to make positive change in your life.

Advertisement

However, while things seemed all wrapped up for him, Sarah-Lynn’s mother still had questions about her daughter’s death. There was nothing in the police report about BoJack, as he went home before calling 911 to make sure he wasn’t connected to her death, but two reporters soon started digging.

Paige Sinclair and Maximillian Banks went from Sarah-Lynn’s mother to the AA meeting where BoJack boasted about almost sleeping with Penny. From there they went to New Mexico, found out about Maddy’s alcohol poisoning and how BoJack abandoned her, and to Doctor Champ who told them everything BoJack confessed under a false veil of confidentiality in rehab.

Everything came out about what happened with Penny, and the real details about Sarah-Lynn’s death, ruining the new life BoJack created for himself. That’s not to say that he didn’t deserve to have the consequences of his horrible actions come back to him, but without these two reporters he would have been able to live out the rest of his life in some manner of peace.

2. Getting Sued By Xerox

While the first of BoJack’s interviews with Biscuits Braxby made him a hero in the eyes of the Hollywoo community, the second sent his life drastically in the opposite direction. He was now widely accepted as being at fault for Sarah-Lynn’s death, and was hated by everyone.

Advertisement

His career was over, he had to face the guilt of what he had done, and he settled with Sarah-Lynn’s family for damages of five million dollars. However, arguably the worst thing to come of this for BoJack personally was a lawsuit from Xerox.

In his interview, BoJack referenced feeling like a shadow of himself. Fainter than before. The language he used was that he felt like a Xerox of a Xerox, something that the good people of Xerox didn’t take too kindly to. The death of a young woman cost him five million dollars, but using a brand name without permission cost him 100 million dollars, plus his house.

This left him homeless, broke, and more depressed than ever before. When he was drunk, he forgot that he was homeless, and broke into his old house to watch copies of 'Horsin’ Around'. This is what landed him in prison, and his B and E swimming is what nearly killed him.

1. Having The Parents He Had

BoJack Horseman is not only one of the worst and most heinous characters in the series, but one of the most disgusting protagonists of any TV show in recent memory. However, he was never going to be a normal person given the upbringing he had.

Advertisement

Butterscotch and Beatrice Horseman had no right being parents. They never loved each other, they had a fling in something of an act of rebellion for Beatrice against her father’s plans for her, but getting pregnant was a spanner in the works.

Neither wanted to be a parent, and both openly showed BoJack their resentment towards him for ruining their lives. Butterscotch couldn’t ever work on his great American novel and hated working to support a family, while Beatrice felt that her body was ruined, and at one point she literally told BoJack she was punishing him for being alive.

She demanded greatness from BoJack to make up for all the damage he caused, but it was she and her husband that damaged their son beyond repair. They showed him no affection or empathy, and they wanted him to know that they hated him. How can anyone be expected to function as a normal adult after that?

Advertisement