If ever you should rewatch the entire run of the original Star Trek series, you may notice a few things: 1) William Shatner is often a far more subtle actor than most people give him credit for (sometimes); 2) Uhura is seven shades of awesome (usually); and 3) you'll be wanting to fast-forward through a lot of scenes - and we mean a lot of scenes (always). Often, what makes a scene cringeworthy in Classic Trek has a lot to do with the time period in which the show was made. For a show that has credited with promoting tolerance, peace, and good will towards all for decades, it can be a very racist, sexist, and downright bad show at times, and it's those moments that we'll be focusing on in this article. These are the scenes that make fans cringe, make non-fans scratch their heads, and make just about everybody ask that eternal question, 'What in the hell was that about?' As usual, your mileage may vary, and if we've missed any, we'd love to hear your comments. And if you find yourself getting annoyed or offended, just remember those immortal words from the MST3K theme: Just repeat to yourself, 'It's just a show, I should really just relax.'
20. Spock Smiles From The Cage (1965) And The Menagerie (1966)
We've been accused of nitpicking in these articles, and on this occasion, perhaps we are. After all, this scene occurs in the very first pilot of Star Trek - another one was produced, with another two scripts considered for pilots - and very little of the Star Trek lore we now know so well had yet been established. One such piece of lore was the idea that Vulcans display no emotions, as Leonard Nimoy's grinning mug above proves. When viewed with this in mind, it's a bit easier to give this moment a pass. The Vulcans smiling in Star Trek IV, however, must never be excused. What does make this moment cringeworthy for some fans, though, is that this scene eventually aired as part of Classic Trek's sole two-part episode The Menagerie - by which point Vulcans not displaying emotions had been established. Oops. Granted, Gene Roddenberry was trying to recoup the cost of the pilot by using as much of the pilot footage as he could, but they had no problem cutting other non-vital scenes, and this one also could've gone. That way, we would've been spared the sight of Spock obviously having the Vulcan equivalent of a petit mal seizure during an away mission. Good thing he got that treated.
19. The Capellans' Outfits From Friday's Child (1967)
Ah, Capella. Just as it seems churlish to cringe at something that hadn't been written into the series' bible yet, it seems equally churlish to criticise a series' costumes, especially when said series was made in the '60s. That doesn't keep us from feeling the way we do about the Capellans's outfits from the episode Friday's Child, though. For those who need reminding: the Capellans are a pre-warp culture with an incredibly elaborate set of social rules and a warrior ethic very close to that of the Klingons, who also appear in the episode - or at least, one does. But while the Klingon outfits are not too shabby for that period, the Capellans are...well, just look at them. All those lavender boas. It's like a drag queen competition at the Folsom Street Fair, only without the good dress sense. Costume designer Matt Jeffries generally did a great job, especially with the women's costumes, but this is not one of his finest hours. Special mention goes to the costumes of the Cloud Minders in the eponymous episode - most of the men in that one look like they're wearing full-length gowns. And speaking of bad costuming...
18. Rukk's Padded Outfit From What Are Little Girls Made Of? (1966)
Ted Cassidy was a ridiculously tall and quite imposing actor, which was a contributing factor to his casting as Lurch in the original Addams Family series. That menacing height and demeanor was no doubt why the producers of Star Trek cast him in the role of Rukk, the last surviving android from an alien civilization in the episode What Are Little Girls Made Of? Then they went and spoiled it by giving him a giant padded housecoat and a pink undershirt that makes him look like Bea Arthur. Honestly, it's hard to take Rukk seriously, even as he's throwing red shirts to their doom left and right, in that ridiculous get-up. Cassidy himself is wonderfully menacing in the part, and it's a tribute to his acting skills that viewers don't immediately crack up every time he comes on-screen. Even then, the sight of Rukk rushing into a room to punish Kirk makes one think he's been interrupted watching his soap operas and that's why he's so pissed off. And speaking of pissed-off androids...
17. Harry Mudd's Robot Wife From I, Mudd (1967)
There's already one hell of a lot cringeworthy about the episode I, Mudd - Harry Mudd himself, for one thing, who's only a few steps up from Neelix on the annoyance scale. There's also the sheer bat-poop craziness of watching the Enterprise crew outwit the logic of the androids who have taken them prisoner - apparently they're so used to being captured by androids by this point that they prefer to treat it as a light-hearted game rather than as a real threat. But then there's Mudd's android replica of his wife Stella, the sort of stereotypical shrewish wife that had a lot of traction on television programmes in the '60s and '70s. It's meant to be funny, of course, but it's only funny in the same way that Foster Brooks playing a drunk is funny, or that Dane Cook is funny. They were probably rolling in front of their television sets back in 1967 when Harry finds out at the end of the episode he is stranded on the planet with 500 replicas of Stella (provided they were still watching, of course), but it's got the feel of a Scooby Doo laugh these days. Not that Star Trek was ever averse to having characters laugh at a dumb jokes at the end of an episode, but this wasn't the most egregious instance, nor the most cruel. That honour, such as it is, is reserved for the next entry on our list...
16. The Endless Laughing Scene From The Galileo Seven (1966)
Something else that becomes apparent after watching all of Classic Trek is that Spock is the butt of a lot of jokes, and not just from McCoy. It's as if Vulcans are not well-liked - at least the series Enterprise got that part right. But rarely is this so noticeable as at the end of The Galileo Seven, in which Spock's first command goes very, very badly before he commits a desperate act that saves the lives of his remaining crew. When they get back to the ship, Kirk commends him on a job well-done, McCoy tells him that it was a brave act that he committed...oh, wait, wrong show. That's how people who actually like him would treat him. Here's the scene in its entirety. Take a look at these assholes:No wonder Spock looks so stoic all the time. It's not because he's having to suppress all of his emotions, it's that he's having to suppress the constant urge to throw open every airlock on the ship and let these people be blown out into the cold void. Nearly thirty seconds of uninterrupted belly laughing and being pointed at (by Uhura, of all people) will do that to a man.
15. Sulu's Plant From The Man Trap (1966)
We could make some sort of joke about Sulu's favourite plant being a man's hand stuck inside a pink puppet, in an episode called The Man Trap, but that would be unnecessary and maybe even vaguely homophobic. But honestly, how did we not know he was gay after this? Anyway, we're well aware that Star Trek was operating on a tight budget, and the only sensible way to depict an animate plant in a '60s sci fi series was with a hand puppet. Heck, even Next Gen did it once in The Most Toys, and that wasn't even a plant. But Beauregard - yes, that's the plant's name, Beauregard - is the sort of creation you'd expect from a series trying to save money towards the end of its run, not in the very first aired episode. Of course, this was also the episode that featured a costume recycled from the movie of The Time Machine, so we shouldn't be so surprised. Still, this is pretty awful, and it tends to make non-fans titter like fools. It wouldn't even be so bad if the thing didn't have so much screen time. Shame they couldn't replace Beauregard with new CGI effects for the Blu-ray releases. And speaking of elements we wish could be replaced with CGI...
14. The Reveal Of Balok From The Corbomite Maneuver (1966)
The saddest thing about The Corbomite Manuever is that, up until the last five minutes, it's a tense, enjoyable episode. The Enterprise is confronted with a menace that seems absolutely unstoppable and which is bent on their utter annihilation. Balok, the alien commander of the vessel (pictured above), is genuinely creepy. Then, the whole thing turns to crap when Kirk and company beam aboard the ship, discovering that the alien above is a puppet (again with puppets) and that Balok really looks like...like... ...um, yeah. Actually, that's more horrifying. And he's a drunk, besides, immediately offering the crew some Tranya. Just a shame the audience can't have some as well, or maybe something else that'll erase the memory of this reveal - like a Pangalactic Gargle-Blaster. Or a gun. Would that this were the only 'surprise' reveal in Classic Trek that makes you want to slap yourself in the forehead (or better yet, the writers' faces), but there's another one of these beauties in the next season...
13. The Reveal Of Korob And Sylvia From Catspaw (1967)
1967's Catspaw is another genuinely tense and interesting script - and why shouldn't it be? It was written by Robert Bloch, the man who gave us the novel Psycho, and a long time correspondent of H.P. Lovecraft. Bloch's own stories are often influenced by Lovecraft's mythos about the Old Ones, and this story is no exception, given Spock's references to what he sees when he tries to link his mind to those of the aliens Korob and Sylvia. So imagine our surprise (and mortification) when the aliens are finally revealed not to be multi-tentacled beings so alien to our senses that they can barely be looked at, but this: Yeah, that can barely be looked at, all right. Honestly. What is it with this show and puppets, anyway?!
12. Kirk Channels His Inner Mobster From A Piece Of The Action (1968)
There's never been a piece of scenery that William Shatner didn't feel the need to at least take a nibble on, but an episode sending Kirk and Spock to a world modeled after the Chicago mobsters of the 1920s must've looked like a smorgasbord. Granted, Shatner will give us many more examples of Acting! for this list, and the very premise of the episode is cause for alarm (see #5), but for now, we're more concerned with Shatner being taken over by the ghost of Edward G. Robinson (who, as it turned out, was still alive at the time). We should point out that this episode cannot be taken seriously. It's the closest that Classic Trek gets to playing something for laughs and succeeding, but as usual, Shatner can't be reined in, and so we get his mobster accent fairly early on in the episode, before it's even been established that Kirk is enough of a history buff to know what he's saying. (Actually, come to think of it, does the episode ever establish that? He's certainly flummoxed by having to drive a car, in one of the episode's genuinely funny scenes.) When Shatner does that accent, it's rarely funny. The one time Spock does it, though? Hilarious, and we couldn't tell you why.
11. Trelayne From The Squire Of Gothos (1967)
Fans have come to think of Trelayne as a proto-Q - it's very easy for all of us (and even writers such as Peter David) with the clarity of hindsight to recast this adolescent superbeing as some sort of teenager from the Q Continuum. Or maybe it's just the fact that William Campbell's performance as Trelayne is so over-the-top that it reminds of the calm, understated performances of John DeLancie. Is there anything about this episode that isn't cringe-inducing, though? From the 'Tally ho!' message that the Enterprise receives to the comical 'boing!' sound effects Trelayne's machine makes when it's destroyed, there seems to be no escape from the crazy here. And the irony is that, according to IMDB, Roddy McDowell was originally intended for this role but was decided against because they didn't want the character to appear gay. Whew! Good thing they spared us from that, right? Campbell is so much more butch! Nothing embarrassing there at all!
10. The Indians In The Paradise Syndrome (1968)
A few readers may have wondered why our Star Trek: The Next Generation list didn't include the Indians in the seventh season episode Journey's End. The reason is threefold: 1) we forgot it; 2) it was boring; and 3) Classic Trek was much, much more insensitive to Native Americans than TNG could ever hope to be. In The Paradise Syndrome, the Enterprise must save a planet which is inhabited by just about every stereotype about Red Indians (as the First Doctor once called them) that one can imagine, minus the rain dances and that 'wah-wah-wah-wah!' thing they supposedly do with their mouth and hand. Upon seeing them from afar, Spock points out that the natives have characteristics of the 'Navajo, Delaware, Mohican' tribes, even though they have no such damned thing. The Mohicans weren't even a real tribe, to start with. Way to go, Vulcanian. Sure, there's some business here about the race known as the Preservers, who may have transplanted a tribe of Indians (Native Americans, whatever) to the planet eons ago, and that might explain why they look as they do. (Sadly, it also explains the existence of Chakotay in Voyager, but more about him another time.) But how does that account for the startling dearth of Native American actors in the cast? Did they all intermarry with Italians? All in all, this makes The Paradise Syndrome painful to watch - and that's even without Kirk's shouted 'I am Kirok!' which is a cringe onto itself. And speaking of racism...
9. Starfleet's Racist Report On Talos IV From The Menagerie (1966)
And what is it with Starfleet and Vulcans, anyway? Sure, we know from the series Enterprise that relations between Earth and the Vulcans were not always warm and cordial - anything but, in fact. But even by Kirk's time, the enmity that Starfleet feels towards one of the founding member races of the Federation runs so deeply that they can't keep their racism out of their official reports. The image above is the actual text of the Starfleet report on Talos IV, the planet visited in The Cage and then revisited for the two-parter The Menagerie. It's doubtful this was ever meant to be looked at in such detail onscreen in 1966, apart from the all-caps statement that NO ONE WILL EVER VISIT TALOS IV. But what's really interesting (and mortifying) is that Spock is referred to as 'Half-Vulcan Science Officer Spock' - twice. As if 'Half-Vulcan' were his rank. That's almost as offensive as finding out that Starfleet refers to Uhura in their paperwork as 'Mulato Communications Officer Uhura' or something, even if it were true. To be fair, though, they probably do refer to her as 'Constantly Singing Communications Officer Uhura,' for good reason...
8. Uhura Singing From Charlie X And Conscience Of The King (1966)
Please, don't get us wrong: we love Lieutenant Uhura, just as we love Nichelle Nichols. Not as much as Gene Roddenberry did, if Shatner's tell-all book is anything to go by, but there you go... And the producers must've loved having an accomplished vocal performer in the cast so that they could have her bust out in song whenever they felt the need. Seemingly, though, they eventually came to the same conclusions that we did: we'd prefer to see her doing awesome things like taking over Chekov's station or holding her own in combat on Triskelion than singing; and that her singing absolutely brings an episode to a grinding halt. It only happens twice in the first season, but neither instance is brief. In Charlie X, Uhura is doing a jam session with Spock in the recreation lounge, and when Charlie Evans comes in, she starts making up lyrics about him on the fly. This embarrasses him, and he uses his super powers to take away her voice (much to Spock's amusement, if the image above is any indication). And in Conscience of the King, when Lieutenant Riley calls up to the lounge because he's bored and requests a song, Uhura serenades him with that old standard 'Beyond Antares.' He responds by gagging and collapsing. He's been poisoned by this point, but still, both reactions are reasonable ones to Uhura's singing, we think.
7. Garth Of Izaar Freaking Out As Kirk From Whom Gods Destroy (1969)
Starfleet doesn't have the greatest track record with its captains in Kirk's time, does it? They get obsessive, go native, go power-mad, or simply go insane - and that's just Kirk. (Though it could apply to Archer and Janeway, as well...) Seriously, though, between Tracey getting drunk with power in The Omega Glory, Decker going all Captain Ahab in The Doomsday Machine, and Garth of Izar simply going insane in Whom Gods Destroy, you do have to wonder whether there's something in all that Starfleet training that isn't meant for weak-minded individuals. It also makes you wonder how Harriman ever got so far... Whatever it is, not only does it make the captains crazy, it makes them overact in a cringe-making way, as well. That's the only possible explanation for this scene, in which the shapeshifting Garth of Izar, posing as Kirk, is unable to get the Enterprise to drop its shields and beam him aboard:Yes, we know it's not Kirk we're watching, but it's really rather hard to tell, since this is what Shatner does when he's playing Kirk anyway. This is only one instance, though, of an ongoing problem...
6. Altered States of Kirk
Any time, and we mean any time, Kirk is possessed, or replaced by an alternative version, or mind-controlled, or what have you, what subtlety Shatner is capable of goes right out the window. Were we to list every instance in which Shatner's dialing it up to 11 makes us want to cover our eyes, we'd have a whole 'nother list on our hands. Instead of listing them all, then, let's go with the most egregiously cringey examples. There's the Dark Kirk formed by a transporter accident in The Enemy Within:There's the mind-controlled Kirk fearing he's lost control of his ship in And The Children Shall Lead:Then, we have the mind-controlled Kirk made to act like a horse, as well as dance, slap himself, and (gasp!) kiss a black woman in Plato's Stepchildren:And finally, just to beat said horse to death, here's the mirror universe version of Kirk:(Sorry, this was the only version available. Cute video, though, eh?) In short, Shatner is a very subtle actor - except when he's not. Then he just makes you want to bury your head in a bucket of sand until the pain goes away.
5. Parallel Earths
Another example of an entire continuum of cringes rather than a single cringey moment in Classic Trek comes with the idea of parallel development. For a budget-conscious show like Trek, it was a great idea to imagine worlds out there that evolved so similarly to our own that the differences are minimal. Sliders got a whole series out of a similar concept. At first, it looked like Classic Trek could pull it off, as well. Despite its other flaws (we could have included 'Blah, blah, blah!' on this list), Miri is not a bad episode, despite being set on a world not too different from ours. But then the show's producers went a bit overboard with it all, and by the time second season rolls around, it feels like every planet out there is the same as our Earth - and if it isn't, then by god, there's a representative of the Federation who will, to borrow a phrase, make it so. The most egregious examples of this are Bread and Circuses and The Omega Glory - and in the category of worlds made into our own on purpose, Patterns of Force. (We mentioned A Piece of the Action, which also fits this latter category, earlier.) In Bread and Circuses, the Enterprise finds an Earth on which Rome never fell. In one of Spock's stupidest statements ever, he says the parallel between the two worlds is so complete that the dominant language is...English. Fascinating, Spock. Not Latin or Greek, then? Sigh. The Omega Glory treats us to a world where the Yangs (actually, the Yanks) lost the battle against the Kangs (the Communists, naturally), and the holy word of the Yangs happens to be (gasp!) the Pledge of Allegiance, and their holy document is (double gasp!) the Constitution. Written in English. Word-for-word the same as ours. The premise is so face-palmingly bad that it's a wonder the episode was ever made, And then there's Patterns of Force, otherwise known as the Nazi episode, in which a Federation cultural observer remodels a culture on the Nazi model because it was so efficient. But let that phrase sink in: the Nazi episode. Of Star Trek. When the premise of an entire episode is enough to make even a die-hard fan skip it, the phrase "cringeworthy moment" loses all meaning, somehow, doesn't it?
4. The Feminine Computer From Tomorrow Is Yesterday (1967)
This entry is again several moments rather than just one, though this time they're from a single episode - although they do constitute a symptom of an overall problem that makes Classic Trek so difficult to watch (as we'll talk about in #1). A subplot in Tomorrow Is Yesterday involves the Enterprise's computer, which has just been reprogrammed, and the results do not make the men folk happy:While this is still funny in its own way, it does raise several unsettling and uncomfortable questions, enough to make our laughter equally uncomfortable. Why would the computer technicians of a planet dominated by women think that this is a good example of a 'personality'? Why would anyone program a computer to giggle - is that an error message or something? And why should Kirk be so annoyed at a female that's fawning over him? Oh, right, because he's not the one making the first move, that's why. Of course, it's not like Next Generation did any better, with their female-dominated society on Angel One. But perhaps the most cringeworthy element here is that the women of Cygnet XIV managed to introduce Lwaxana Troi onto the Enterprise two decades early.
3. Adam's Jams From The Way To Eden (1969)
The quickest way for any series to create a cringeworthy moment for future generations is to give in to the fads of the time and do something to appeal to the young'uns in the audience. The tastes of said young'uns are by definition mutable, so what appeals to the youth in one decade will by necessity be seen as cheesy by those in the next. That's what makes it so hard to watch a third season episode of The Man From U.N.C.L.E., for instance, though they all seemed like good ideas at the time. It's hard to imagine that anyone saw The Way To Eden as a good idea, though. While all the instances of future hippy-speak are bad enough, not to mention the brief and bizarre recasting of Chekov into an 'establishment' figure, it's the constant singing by Adam, played by the late Charles Napier of Silence of the Lambs fame, that makes this episode particularly difficult to sit through. Sure, the jam session with Spock in the rec lounge later in the episode is almost bearable - at least, compared with previous jam sessions held there - and if that were the only time Adam sings in this episode, this entry would be much further down the list, if it appeared at all. But Adam never stops singing, the songs themselves are dumb, and it gets well and truly annoying:No wonder Hannibal Lechter killed him so brutally - poison fruit was too good for him.
2. "Brain And Brain! What Is Brain?" From Spock's Brain (1968)
Bet you're surprised this one isn't at number one, right? For that matter, there are good arguments to be made for the entire episode Spock's Brain to be included at number one, as the whole thing is one 51-minute long cringeworthy moment. As we've pointed out, Classic Trek had some dumb premises from time to time, but the idea that a character's brain could be removed without outright killing him, and that he could then be wired to a remote control to move his body around until his brain can be found, at which point he can assist in the surgery to put it back in...ugh, there's no point in going on, really. With that sentence, not with life, though after watching this episode a few times, it's hard to tell the difference anymore. The crowning moment of cringiness in this episode, of course, is this line: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXDwF1Rq-oE&list=PLrHeRYbgKZfeu8nFjVCDz2_ETskSbT1JM If a YouTuber ever has the brilliant idea to do a six-hour video replaying that line again and again, our shoulders may never unknot themselves. However, this isn't what causes many of us to cringe so much when we watch Classic Trek. McCoy's casual racism against Spock, the stupidity of finding planets so close to ours that the language is the same, even bad costuming and '60s-era special effects, don't hold a candle to the continuum of cringiness that is...
1. Casual '60s Sexism
It's worth remembering that the impact of Classic Trek on science fiction entertainment in particular and on society in general has been profound. The show has made us think differently about race relations, about our approaches to war, and about our very humanity. But god, was it sexist. Mind you, it was the first show to feature a female bridge officer - two, actually, if we count Number One from The Cage and Lieutenant Uhura equally. We had women at the helm on a few occasions - one of them was Uhura, but That Which Survives even featured Lieutenant Rahda, an (apparently married) Asian woman, at Sulu's station. It also featured a number of female scientists, nearly all of them extremely capable in their fields and respected as highly as any man would be. But for every Lieutenant Uhura, there's a Lieutenant Marla McGivers. For every Number One, there's a Nurse Chapel. And for every Ann Mulhall, there's a Dr. Janice Lester. These three woman are the best examples of what makes so much of Classic Trek so uncomfortable to watch. Lt. McGivers is an Earth historian stationed to a starship, an already ridiculous idea made even more ridiculous by the idea that she should be attracted by a man like Khan, who abuses and dominates her - and she likes it. Nurse Chapel gave up a promising career in research to join a starship in the hopes of finding her lost fiance Roger Korby. When he turns out to be an android, she develops an infatuation on another emotionally unavailable man, Mr. Spock. Majel Barrett herself once said she considered Chapel to be something of a loser, and it's hard to deny it. And then there's Dr. Janice Lester, who would've been a starship captain except, as she tells Kirk, 'Your world of starship captains doesn't admit women. It isn't fair.' He admits that it isn't, but he doesn't deny the truth of it - meaning that, in the last episode of the entire series, we discover that women cannot become starship captains. Granted, much of this is down to the network suits keeping Gene Roddenberry from having more women on the ship or even keeping one as second-in-command - Majel Barrett also attested to this. But how to excuse this? How to excuse the regular sexist comments of Kirk, McCoy, and even Spock? It's not much better when they like the women, either, as evidenced by Spock's downright creepy touching of the face of one of the Vegas showgirls in Shore Leave. Shudder. 'Every seven years,' indeed. It's things like this, more than just about anything else, that makes Classic Trek so cringeworthy. If we've forgotten any moments that made you cringe - or if you feel absolutely compelled to argue with any we've listed here - feel free to leave your comments below. We'd also love to hear your most cringeworthy moments from DS9, Voyager, Enterprise, and even other franchises, like Doctor Who.