Let me start this article by making something very clear; I am loving the new series of Doctor Who. I think Matt Smith is an excellent Doctor and regularly enjoy the humour and variation of the scripts. So prepare to be a little disappointed if you came to read an outpouring about why the show sucks. I always check the reviews and comments after each episode to see how my opinion compares with others. After analysing a lot of the general chatter, I have come to realise something. In case you arent familiar with the old Doctor Who (that is, pre-Christopher Ecclestone), it wasnt usually broadcast in the 45-minute episode format that it is shown in today. Instead, the stories were fewer and much longer in length, but split up into 20-minute parts that were broadcast weekly. Each part would normally end on a shock or cliffhanger, to be resolved the week later. While changing to the more-manageable 45-minute format was undoubtedly a wise move to accessibly bring Doctor Who back into the public eye, I reckon the show has grown enough now that it could actually benefit from returning to the old serial format for which it was originally known. So without further ado, here are 4 reasons I present to you, to explain why the serial format would now be a good choice.
1. Each Episode Would Have More Screentime
One issue that gets dragged up these days with Doctor Who these days is that the storylines tend to finish on a rather hurried and abrupt note. Indeed, Terry Pratchett has criticised the series for its tendency to tie off narratives with a spontaneous deus ex machina, or as the Doctor himself calls it, doing a clever thing. This niggle is likely one that the writers are aware of: think of the scene in The Vampires of Venice when the Doctor saves the day by just turning the evil device off! This was probably intended as self-referential humour to address past episodes. However its not something you can do a lot about when youve only got 45 minutes to wrap everything up. Even with two-part episodes, while it is easier to structure the stories, there is still an obligation to work in the big cliffhanger before the 45-minute mark. It seemed to me that the recent episode The Power of Three could have benefited from a bit more screen time to conclude the narrative thread than the five minutes it had left. If, on the other hand, the stories were written at their natural length and divided over a couple of weeks, it would only be a matter of finding a suitable advancement of the plot on which to end each instalment, and the writers would be given more of an opportunity to work towards a satisfying climax.
2. There Is A Market For Shorter-Length Serials
The serial format is flexible in the way it can be worked around; in the case of Doctor Who, it doesnt necessarily mean a return to the slower-paced style of the 1970s. Armando Iannuccis The Thick of It is an example of a 30-minute serial that the BBC produces to great success. Alternatively, The Sarah Jane Adventures, a spinoff to Doctor Who, comprised of two-part episodes in half-hour serials, in a style more faithful to the classic series. If such a style works for childrens hour and for adult comedy-drama, it really isnt much of a step to market Doctor Who to a similar format for all the family. Further proof of the success of this format may be found in the fact that most popular soaps are broadcast in half-hour slots.
3. Fewer Budget Commitments
There has been some consternation over the amount of budget the BBC allows Doctor Who for some time now, given the loss of new alien characters in season 6 and the much-protested scrapping of Doctor Who Confidential. But its a simple logistical fact that the more variation of CG environments, sets or locations required will either mean a drop in quality or a danger of budgetary constraints. If, however, the seasons were limited to about five or six stories, with more screen time and emphasis over the weeks on air, The Mill would not be pressed to design and create so much so quickly, and therefore cost could theoretically be reduced.
4. Longer Singular Stories Are Steven Moffats Specialty
If you examine most of showrunner Steven Moffats career on Doctor Who over the years, it looks highly likely that he will mainly be remembered for his singular, often extended and usually terrifying one off stories. While his individual episodes are a force to be reckoned with, especially the classic Blink, his two part stories like The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances and Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead made a huge and lasting impression on the revived series, and arguably granted him control of it. What is notable about these episodes is how the serials end on a very tense cliffhanger, only to be resolved in a rather fun and tongue-in-cheek manner. Furthermore, his other current series Sherlock comprises of three feature-length episodes per season, and is met with universal acclaim. Can you imagine a Doctor Who episode structured and filmed in a similar style to Sherlock, and then divided over three to four weeks, knowing that every week would end on a note of huge suspense with no predicting what the resolution would be? So there you have my case for serials of Doctor Who. I think Steven Moffat is right to say that the show will always have an appeal, and maybe this change would allow it to reach greater heights and win over even more new fans. I would be keen to know if anyone agrees.