With numerous detectives plying their trade on television these days it is important to cut through those that are simply in it for the money and focus on those who are good at what they do. That means we will have no space for charlatans like Horatio Caine on the gratefully cancelled CSI: Miami who was mainly successful due to cheesy one liners and an over reliance on those who worked under his reign of terror. Many on this list are not detectives in the common sense of the word, i.e. employed by the police, but probably have more success than their counterparts because of their avoidance of pesky things like rules, laws and regulations. While some people will disagree with the people on this list, it's entirely open for debate - if you want to drop a comment then I'm happy to spend hours discussing whether one dead body would have been in safer hands in one investigator rather than one of my choices. We start however, with one not so smooth talking French Officer...
5. Elise Wassermann - The Tunnel
Played by Clémence Poésy, the very very serious French detective certainly gets the job done but probably does it with less tact than required. Starring in The Tunnel, a brilliant crime drama concerning a terrorist targeting both France and Britain - starting with a corpse on the exact midpoint of the Channel Tunnel - which leaves Wassermann and British counterpart Karl Roebuck chasing dead ends. No pun intended. As mentioned, she has pretty much no social skills even going so far as suggesting the police may never find a missing mother's daughter because they have no leads as to her whereabouts. The reason for the crushing truth? Wassermann believed that one lie lead to another and would rather be honest instead of "playing the game" as Roebuck suggests. Essentially living in her Calais office, Wassermann certainly shows a dedication to the job looked up to in admiration/confusion by her junior colleagues who question her lack of humour and rigidity in regards to police regulations. In summary, Wasserman is probably not the most tactful, but the honesty is refreshing compared to her contemporaries who rely on crushing optimism in the face of cold hard facts. Thats in good complement to the dedication she brings to the job and her ruthless search to find any and all leads in search of answers.
4. Patrick Jane - The Mentalist
Played by Simon Baker, Patrick Jane is technically not a detective but rather a consultant for the California Bureau of Investigation who started his work after his family were brutally killed by mysterious serial killer Red John. He is also not a detective in the traditional sense of the word, he is a former TV psychic using his powers of deduction to solve murders happening within California. Thankfully, he has admitted his psychic skills were a complete fraud and thus looks down on anyone else who claims to have true psychic skills. That, you might appreciate, has annoyed an awful lot of people that sought to help the CBI in its investigations but hey things get done eventually so where's the harm? While Jane does get results he does it by putting his co-workers in dangerous situations by simply not telling them what his plans are - to the deep annoyance of superior Teresa Lisbon. In the world of TV this all works, whether it would in real life is a mystery. That system also rubs up suspects the wrong way who, rather than tutting, would much rather pull out various weapons and decide to bring the pain. It's also to be seen whether he would still have the urge to carry on solving crime if Red John finally got collared. But now into its sixth season the show seems to give Jane no luck in catching the master criminal so maybe that question will never need to be answered.
3. Sherlock Holmes - Sherlock
"A consulting detective, the only one in the world." Or at least that's how the world's greatest detective decides to describe himself and who are we to complain about one of the sharpest minds? We're only interested in the modern Benedict Cumberbatch Sherlock Holmes, which is probably the best Sherlock by far - only Robert Downey Jr. comes close and even then falls short. Not as aware of female love interests, it could be seen that he inspired Elise Wassermann's tendencies through being too attached to his work and oblivious to the flirting of those who work alongside him. Using the smallest details to deduce an entire web of crime, he frequently alienates those around him especially DI Lestrade who is regularly humiliated and belittled by Holmes. Although would Holmes still be as effective without aid from his "friend" - if such a term could be used - Dr John Watson? Watson takes care of the menial tasks including making sure Holmes has somewhere to live and something to eat, as well as making sure that the police don't completely shut them out of ongoing investigations. On this list, I don't think anyone goes close to matching Sherlock's detective skills and whether anyone will it remains to be seen but the only thing he lacks? Social skills, by not rubbing people up the wrong way could his life be so much easier? Don't think anyone could answer that.
2. Chief Clancy Wiggum - The Simpsons
The best and brightest to leave the Springfield Police Academy, Chief Wiggum's success at solving any crime is probably best described as "striking it lucky". How nothing major has happened under his watch is probably just strange coincidence more than strong police work, even going so far as arresting Sideshow Bob for trying to flood the town when it was actually Bob's brother Cecil who tried to destroy Springfield. But, remembering this a list for the top TV detectives, it is important to remember that Wiggum actually discovered who "kidnapped" Bart in the episode Pranksta Rap. By listening to a phone call made by Bart he discovered popcorn was being cooked in the background and could identify the specific brand of popcorn being made: "Chintzy Pop". Following a quick visit to the Kwik-E-Mart he is informed that the only people to buy that cheap, nasty stuff is him and Kirk Van Houten. After raiding Kirk's apartment they find the not so kidnapped Bart and Kirk goes to prison, making the dear Chief a hero - for a while anyway. Thankfully Wiggum is assisted by his faithful officers Eddie and Lou otherwise god knows what would happen without their courteous negativity and constant questioning.
1. Edmund Reid - Ripper Street
Now last but not least we take a trip back in time to the late 19th century where we meet Inspector Edmund Reid, a man haunted by the death of his daughter in a steamer ship disaster whilst trying to maintain order on the streets of Whitechapel. Reid is also unique to this list in the fact that he was a real person in the real world. Spooky isn't it? However, some things have been changed to make good TV and that's the Reid we will focus on i.e. the character played by Matthew Macfadyen. Going back to the tragedy of his and his wife's only daughter, the damage it did him thankfully didn't affect his police work even when they separated thanks to a lead on the whereabouts their daughter wound up as a dead end. Indeed the desire to do right by those around him has lead to a warped moral compass, from hassling Joseph Merrick - the Elephant Man - to testing new Detective Constable Flight's competence. It does however, achieve results with or without Detective Sergeant Bennett Drake - a man who prefers violence as a form of diplomacy. That leads on to an interesting question: would any if these detectives be as successful if they didn't have the support they did? Sherlock has Dr Watson, Chief Wiggum has Eddie and Lou plus Elise Wassermann has become increasingly reliant on the support given by British counterpart Karl Roebuck. If you disagree with anything you've read please leave a comment and we'll debate for hours!