8 Most Cowardly Times TV Writers Copped Out

Written yourself into a hole? Why not troll the audience on your way out?

By Edward Owen /

Cliffhangers are as constant as the Northern Star on television. It's not really a surprise €“ they offer writers an extremely effective way of keeping their audience captivated. If you've seen your favourite character forced into a seemingly-impossible situation come episode close, you're going to want to see how it turns out. After all, the usual rule is that protagonists don't tend to die no matter the odds. So when a scriptwriter puts a character on the chopping block, you're naturally intrigued. Unless the show€™s Spooks €“ at which point you accept it as a natural development and debate how exactly that poor unfortunate soul is going to bite the dust €“ hinting at a character's imminent demise is big news, and treated as such by the writers and the audience. Even when the character sucks, their departure's guaranteed to make waves on the show. Ditto with game-changing revelations. It's not in a TV show's nature to stand still, but they usually guard against truly transformative plot developments under the logic of if it ain€™t broke, don€™t fix it. So when a show does dramatically shuffle the deck, it's only natural that interest gets piqued. How will they move on from this groundbreaking news? What will be the repercussions of what's happened? There's a million questions to be answered, but one thing's for certain €“ the landscape has irrevocably changed. Or has it? Much as we'd love for our favourite shows to stay consistently awesome, sometimes the writers put themselves in a hole when constructing the perfect cliffhanger. Sadly, some inescapable cliff-hangers prove even inescapable for the writer, but unlike the average, confused viewer, the guy with the pen has a unique power €“ they can bend the rules to get themselves out of a jam. Sometimes it's utterly brazen, and other times the writer just thinks they're being really goddamned clever. Yet either way up, the audience is left feeling confused and gutted at the cheap solution offered up. So with that in mind, I've compiled a list of the eight cheapest writer cop-outs in TV history. Read on, and find out more. It'll probably p*ss you off.

8. Doctor Who - The Meta-Crisis Doctor

If Steven Moffat's clearing up your narrative loose ends, you know something's gone wrong. Such was the case with Russell T Davies. Though he should forever be held in high esteem for bringing Doctor Who back to our screens, the guy liked to throw out cliffhangers like confetti and it was only a matter of time before his pen was writing cheques his brain couldn't cash. Things came to a head in The Stolen Earth, when RTD baited the audience by throwing us the biggest off the lot €“ he casually killed the Tenth Doctor. Well, it seemed that way, anyhow. It was hard-hitting at the time €“ David Tennant was and still is universally beloved as the Doctor. We didn't yet know he was leaving the show, so when a Dalek popped up and shot him, it made for one hell of a blindsiding moment. Choosing a successor in the TARDIS often carried more pomp and circumstance than a Royal Wedding, only with more Zoe Ball €“ in today's internet-saturated age, how could we not have heard anything? Hastily, journalists drew up their likely candidates, theorising that tomfoolery aside, Hugh Grant would be the frontrunner. But tomfoolery is par for the course in Doctor Who, so a sizeable contingent of Whovians remained sceptical, probably too hurt by the time RTD indulged his inner Superman and rewound the Earth in The Last Of The Timelords. But still, we thought that if he was going to execute a rug-pull and throw off the inevitable, it would involve some sort of mind-blowing gambit. Instead we got the Meta-Crisis, where RTD took the artistic licence of Timelord biology and rode it off into the sunset. Whatever we were expecting, I don't think it involved growing another Doctor out of that spare hand. Whovians will accept a lot of plot conveniences €“ Doctor Who is ostensibly a kid's show about an old man in a box pimp-slapping history and sci-fi until it cries uncle €“ but for a sizeable majority of fans this was particularly cheap. Turning one of that year's most talked-about TV moments into a contrived way to give Billie Piper a happy ending? For shame Russell, for shame.

7. The Walking Dead - Season 3's 'Finale'

As George A. Romero never tires of pointing out, zombies should only ever be half the story, if that. The real dramatic meat comes in the human response to such a massive societal change, and what they'll do to survive when no external pressures to play nice remain. After all, once you've got over the initial shock and roaming, dessicated corpses become as much a part of the scenery as the rolling grass fields, you need to take the show somewhere. That somewhere is human drama. To its credit, the show walked this line superbly and aided by some stellar source material slowly shifted the goalposts. Season One was about finding sanctuary away from the walkers, Season Two was about dissent in the camp and season three was about relations with other groups of survivors, embodied in David Morrissey's increasingly unhinged Governor. We saw him deteriorate from a brutally pragmatic leader to an eyepatch-wearing lunatic, and come the finale he was ready to strike. Frankly, we couldn't wait €“ the on-page Prison assault was one of the comic series' highlights, and it made good narrative sense to have the Governor go out with an end-of-season bang. But of course that wasn't what we got. What we got was a skirmish between the two camps, followed by the Governor's army getting cold feet before they all got gunned down by the man himself. Sure, that was a bit unexpected, but to have them meander through the prison before deciding 'screw it, it's not worth it' wasn't the bullet-soaked tragedy-fest we were hoping for. It simply gave the Governor too long a shelf life €“ while Morrissey was excellent in the role, his continued existence in season four smacked of rehashing old narrative ground and holding the narrative back. Granted, new showrunner Scott M. Gimple made up for this with the barn-storming firefight of season four's mid-season finale Too Far Gone, but in many people's minds, he was half a season too late. If I were a smartarse, I€™d say he was Too Far Gone. Then I€™d kick myself in the shin for ever typing that line.

6. Sherlock - Cheating Death

Nobody ever believed Sherlock Holmes would really die, but The Great Game's finale cut it mighty close. For all intent and purposes, it really did look as if the World's Greatest Detective had bitten the dust/pavement. Yet as the emotionally resonant coda made clear, this was not so. Sherlock was alive and watching John mourn at his fake grave from a distance. Roll credits. Then came what's now become known as 'The Great Hiatus.' The show took a break for two years so its stars could have a crack at Hollywood, and this plot thread was left dangling. Forums were set alight with theories on how Holmes cheated death, and naturally we all expected a clever, Moffat-tastic explanation as The Empty Hearse rolled up. Yet what we got was odd to say the least. Unable to resist their inner trolls, Stephen Moffat and episode writer Mark Gatiss chose instead to bait the fans by transferring their feverish hypothesising onto the guilt-wracked Anderson and the Sherlock fan club. Cue bungee jumps, Derren Brown and a bizarre shout-out to slash fiction, each one dismissed as €“ in Inspector Lestrade's words €“ b*llocks. When we were eventually given an excellent idea as to how Sherlock managed to dupe John, this theory was also thrown bodily under the Anderson imagination bus (which also sounds like a fantastic kid's TV show). I'm not complaining to harshly €“ the skits were cheeky, irreverent, and entertaining but you can't deny it's a bit cowardly too. While palming off the series' cliffhangers with something ridiculous has become a Sherlock trademark €“ remember Staying Alive? €“ dismissing something so thought-provoking with the logic of 'just bloody well accept it, it's Sherlock Holmes' is something of a kick in the crotch. Or teeth. Or wherever you fancy being kicked, you perverts. Admittedly this might pan out in a different way and we could still find out what truly happened in the series finale, but at the moment we're in severe danger that Moffat just might dispose of this golden goose without so much as a second glance. For something which inspired verbal wars online, that's definitely a shame.

5. Downton Abbey - Anna, Bates And Mr. Green Offscreen

Downton Abbey is an odd show. You can watch runs of episodes where precisely naff-all happens €“ Carson's and Mrs. Hughes' sizzling sexual chemistry notwithstanding €“ before Julian Fellowes decides to throw a bomb into the mix. If the man cooks as he writes, I'd advise you avoid every fifth dinner party lest you be smashed around the face with chillies. Anyway, back to Downton. Setting up the main plot of season four, Eastenders' Nigel Harman turned up and raped Anna. It was harrowing and upsetting, and lit a fire under what had threatened to be a pretty tepid season downstairs, focusing on what Anna's husband Bates would do when €“ not if, obviously €“ he found out. As befitting a man who's done hard time, Bates isn't a stable fellow (to describe him in Hugh Bonneville-esque terms), and he certainly went through the emotional wringer alongside his wife. He was mystified and saddened when she withdrew from him, before uncovering the (half) truth and putting on a murderous glower. By the end of the series he pretty much knew who'd done it and we were looking forward to some sort of resolution. But if you know Downton, you know it doesn't work like that. Much like Lady Mary's upstairs love triangle, the whole thing sort of petered out and was resolved €“ unforgivably €“ with an off-camera scene when Bates was implied to have killed Mr. Green. No dramatic resolution or anything €“ just that nebulous Downton-esque form of plotting, where anything potentially violent gets swept under the rug and masked with a frenzy of 'gollys' and an incredulous, withering look from Maggie Smith. Weirder still, any loose ends concerning the rape plotline were tidied up at Christmas when everyone who knew about the whole sorry saga agreed they could live with it. It's a shame really €“ Harman can do good villainy when pushed, and Bates' actor Brendan Coyle is an intense screen presence when given something to work with. Well, I say he does €“ it's mainly just his eyebrows. But my, what intense eyebrows they are.

4. South Park - Eric Cartman's Dad

During South Park's early years, one of the biggest questions ran thus €“ who is Cartman's father? All the other boys seemed to have one, except for everyone's favourite fat sociopath. And although the parental character void was well and truly filled by Cartman's Mom (who contrary to her unassuming appearance was possibly the sickest and most sexually depraved characters on the show) the question remained. Even the endless parade of 'your mom' jokes can grow stale eventually, and to their credit Matt Stone and Trey Parker seemed prepared to answer one of the show's biggest questions inside the first season with the episode 'Cartman's Mom Is A Dirty Slut.' The provocative title gave us the whole episode in a nutshell €“ all the menfolk of the town with whom Liane Cartman had had relations were lined up and hinted at as the father. Whether it was a Native American chief, Mr. Garrison, Chef, the entire 1989 Denver Broncos squad or even Jesus, just about everyone got a turn in the sun as the potential Cartman paterfamilias. Cartman was subjected to a DNA test by South Park's resident Marlon Brando lookalike Dr. Mephesto, but because the test cost money Cartman and the boys needed to collect it, the question was stretched across an episode. Then they went one further, with the narrator promising us that that next week we would see who exactly was Cartman's father. Up to that point it was all fine €“ the episode had given us a more tender look at Cartman's psyche (if such a thing is possible) while keeping up the laugh rate with an endless precession of Ms. Cartman's dance partners. But then came the next episode €“ 'Terrance and Phillip In Not Without My Anus'. This episode had precisely sod all to do with the previous cliffhanger, and €“ in a rare exception among this list, the writers knew it. Instead of giving us dramatic resolution, the show moved onto an adventure starring Canada's favourite farting comedians and their attempt to thwart Saddam Hussein's invasion of Canada. What with the April Fool's Day airdate, we all should've seen it coming. But still, while you've got to give Parker and Stone credit for utterly committing to the April Fools bit, there was still a question to be answered and the show put off the Cartman cliffhanger until the next episode €“ 'Cartman's Mom Is Still A Dirty Slut.' Yet this was where the cop-out happened €“ after weeks of baiting the audience, Parker and Stone decided to throw a collective screw-it and refused to tell us the elusive gentleman's identity. It was first done in a subtle (by South Park standards) way as a similar 'Who Shot Dr Mephesto' mystery took over when the good doctor bit the bullet just before giving out the fabled results. But as time went on it was made clear that the writers had no intention of telling you the answer to the question which they'd hooked you in with, with Cartman going so far as to yell that he didn't want to know at the camera and the ever-present whodunnit narrator. When he eventually did get an answer, it was intentionally half-assed one which raised further questions €“ Liane Cartman was in fact Cartman's dad (because apparently, she's now a hermaphrodite), and now the mother is unknown. Sure, it was a clever cop-out as cop-outs go, but it remains cowardly because the writers knew that whatever they came up with couldn't possibly sate audience demand. So taking a route Sherlock would years later, they instead satirised that demand and ripped the p*ss out of their audience with something self-referentially bizarre and anti-climactic. It was clever but gutting, and a first peek at how far the South Park guys would go in their quest to troll the audience. But still, this one smarted €“ we wanted something good, and instead they went with farting Canadians. I know the episode's got its fans and we eventually learnt that Cartman's dad was eventually Jack Tenorman, father of Scott, but at the time, this was brutal.

3. Being Human - Edgar Wyndham's Disappearing Act

Come season three of Toby Whitehouse€™s cult supernatural drama, it was all starting to look a little shaky. The show€™s breakout star Aiden Turner imminent departure to Middle Earth and elf-romance hung over the place like a bad smell €“ we all knew his John Mitchell was going, so it was just a matter of when, where and how. Though Damien Molony€™s Hal capably filled next season€™s vampire void, there was still worries about the show€™s future. It€™d been renewed, but was there any point in watching it without its brightest star? After all, Mitchell€™s conflict with Herrick was the most substantial log on Being Human€™s dramatic fire €“ shorn of Turner and the forever underrated Jason Watkins, what would we do? Well, Toby Whitehouse had an idea, and that idea involved a chap named Edgar Wyndham. And for the twenty-odd minutes in which we got to see him, he was awesome. Audaciously parking himself in the midst of the series€™ emotional finale and proceeding to kick all sorts of arse, he was the great villain the show needed going forward €“ all-powerful, mythos-expanding, and representative of a bigger threat. Yet when season four began, he was gone. He was demoted to a cursory line about how George went apesh*t and tore him apart, and that was the end of Edgar Wyndham, the man from Head Office/Del Monte. It was an incredible shame, and precisely what the then-fragile Being Human didn€™t need. If you€™re going to reshuffle a show, it pays to keep at least some cards in play, and while Wyndham was eventually and effectively replaced by Mark Gatiss€™ Mr. Snow/Rotten Mycroft (oh come on, you know it to be true), it could be argued that it was too little, too late. Shearing away what seemed to be an excellent villain during the show€™s newly unsure, feet-finding period was inevitably going to turn off some fair-weather fans. It was a crucial nadir between the Wolf-Shaped Bullet and the Old Ones taking over, and a nadir that might€™ve been avoided if only they€™d kept Wyndham on-scene, at least as a stopgap villain until Mr. Snow turned up. It might be going a bit far to say the seeds of the show€™s cancellation were beginning to be sown with this cop-out, but it sure as hell couldn€™t have helped.

2. Dallas - The Dream Season

Ok, so I had to include it. Dallas pretty much invented the disappointing cop-out, and that is scientific fact (it really isn't, don't look that up). If it wasn't on this list you'd pretty much be licensed to pelt me with fruit. Luckily it's here, and I haven't set a troubling new precedent for What Culture writers. For those of you who don't know (and more to the point, where the hell have you been?), Dallas once committed a cop-out of such mind-blowing, balls-out cowardice that it's perhaps overshadowed the show's legacy. You see, when a TV character is killed, it's always because of two things €“ a) the writers were planning for this already-written death, and are making good on their promise, or b) the actor's thrown a sh*t-fit, cast off the humble surroundings of TV and made a break for film's glamorous hinterland, leaving the writers to pick up the pieces. Such a path is supposed to be permanent, and such was the path that Patrick Duffy trod in Dallas. While Duffy's was originally intended to be the heroic main star of the show, he soon found himself upstaged by his uproariously amoral older brother J.R., or more specifically J.R.'s actor Larry Hagman. But still, Duffy retained a large, central role in proceedings and rode the show's success all the way to the bank before deciding he needed to move on to other projects. Yet Dallas wasn't the springboard he'd hoped it would be, and after a run of TV movies and pronounced failure to break into Hollywood circles, Duffy was back to his former meal ticket. Yet there was just one problem €“ though Duffy had left, they hadn't packed up the show with him. How could they? Dallas was wildly successful, and you could bet your b*llocks to a barn dance that the producers weren't going to shut up shop because one actor left the gilded ship. So with Bobby killed off-screen (car accident, apparently), the show chugged on for its ninth season. But then Duffy wanted back in, and the studio €“ in the aforementioned act of mind-blowing cowardice €“ decided to acquiese to his request, coherent internal logic be damned. After all, if it's broke (and Dallas certainly lacked something without Bobby), you should probably fix it with little regard for all else, right? So they wrote off season nine as a dream of Bobby's wife Pamela Barnes, who woke up, strutted into the bathroom and found her beloved lathering himself up in the shower. As a result all the developed plotlines in season nine were scrapped, all for some more sweet, Patrick Duffy facetime. Sure, it was cowardly, but it was a cop-out of such bravura proportions that it needed mentioning on this list. Unlike most things and outside the Final Fantasy world, death is permanent. When you write out a character, it's usually expected that they stay dead. Yet alas, such a revelation was hilariously lost on Dallas' scriptwriters. and the moment will now live in infamy. It's so amazingly stupid you just have to applaud it.

1. Family Guy - Brian's Brush With Mortality

Yes, Dallas is probably the Citizen Kane of writer cop-outs, but modern audiences are probably less acquainted with the Inception-esque misadventures of the Ewing clan than they used to be. Indeed, possibly overtaking them on the disappointment hard shoulder is Family Guy and their attention-seeking attempt at snuffing out Brian, only to roll him back out with some time-travel jiggery-pokery. To be honest, we probably shouldn€™t have been surprised. A lot of us left Family Guy after its Conway Twitty nadir, and only check in on it now in the same fashion as an ailing relative €“ we€™ll visit them when given the opportunity, but feel pangs of sadness about what they used to be. Seth MacFarlane€™s crew have plunged the depths since season six €“ they can occasionally churn out a belter, but there€™s been many ill-advised dalliances with domestic violence and Sarah Palin€™s Downs Syndrome-afflicted daughter since the glory days. So to get some lapsed fans onside, it was only natural they€™d throw us a curveball by throwing Brian under a car, to his seeming death. As soon as those wheels hit the dog, the Internet feared the worst. Not that Brian would stay dead, but when precisely the writers would hit the reset button. After all, this is a show that pretty prominently features a time machine (and had an episode with Brian in the title later on that season), so even if Stewie couldn€™t originally go back and save his canine chum, they€™d eventually find a reality-bending way to re-establish the status quo. So when the baby genius did turn up and shove Brian out the way of his vehicular doom, there were plenty of disappointed, unsurprised sighs from the audience. It was just a shame, really €“ here was a chance for Family Guy to make itself relevant again with an act of balls-out writing bravery, but they simply couldn't face truly cashing in their chips when it mattered. Although his transition from the show's lone straight man to a faux-intellectual, hypocritical liberal douche wasn't everyone's cup of tea, Brian is a great character. The fact you know who he is and understood that last sentence makes that plain. But if icing him proved would've allowed Family Guy to shake off its middle-age staleness and rejoin the party as a cutting edge show, I reckon they should've taken it. As is, they let a great opportunity become a cheap stunt, and that's just sad.