Most TV villains have an eye for the spectacular, and a brain for the nefarious. It's kind of in their job description we watch TV to be entertained, and we can't indulge in appropriate displays of boo-hissery if the villain isn't evil or ambitious enough. After all, there's got to be something at stake, or you might as well be watching a family dinner, where a group of people bicker over nothing in particular with no clear end-goal in sight. Sure, that works for comedy, but it just doesn't work in today's climate of big-budget, gut-punching thrillers we expect huge, overarching plans that reek of ambition, and naturally, back-stabbings aplenty. But is there such a thing as too far? Obviously we want our villains to bring a machiavellian plan to the table that's pretty much par for the course but with the desire to make their antagonist stand out, many writers can confuse spectacularly good planning with incredible, avoidable risk. Dancing on the fault lines of triumph and disaster is what gives our favourite shows the dramatic punch we expect, but sometimes you've got to just cock an eyebrow at how easily their masterstrokes would fall apart if they were just a hair-trigger out on their measurements and timings, or if a seemingly random event understandably doesn't pan out the exact way they wanted it to. So with that in mind, here's 9 plans that could've, and should've, so easily gone wrong. Hell, some of them actually did. Oh, and SPOILERS throughout, including a big one for House Of Cards's second season on the very next slide.
9. An Easily Recognisable Frank Underwood Commits Murder In A Crowded Area House Of Cards
In the House Of Cards universe, Frank Underwood has one of those recognisable faces. And so he should at the time of this risky plan, he's skulduggeried his way to the Vice Presidency, which in case you haven't noticed, is a pretty public job. So when it comes to his desire to get anonymously out and about, you'd tell him to forget about it. To his credit, Underwood is aware of this, so when he goes to meet Zoe Barnes in a public metro, he wears a hat and some glasses. Perfect, you might think, but you'd be wrong. Remember, this man's the Vice President, and he's frequenting a public place in the political heart of America odds on, he's going to get recognised if he doesn't cover the entirety of his face. Obviously he doesn't and can throw Zoe under the train, but it's one hell of a gamble if he'd been made at any point, he'd have been met with questions about what he was doing in a place where someone died. Couple this with the fact it was known in certain circles that Barnes and Underwood had a close relationship, and there'd be a question mark hanging over him which would probably put paid to his political career immediately. Hell, if somebody happened to be looking right when the metro was arriving not an odd occurrence, commuters do tend to watch trains as they come in they might've seen Barnes clearly not throw herself on those tracks, and apprehend him then and there. Seems a hell of a lot of risk, really, even if it was necessary.
8. Marcus Crassus Almost Kills Himself Spartacus: War Of The Damned
Like any good villain worth his salt, Marcus Crassus's introductory episode in War Of The Damned is set around establishing the great man's intelligence and cojones. True to form, he's introduced sparring with his hilariously-named gladiator Hilarius. From what we can see, Crassus is clearly a very competent swordsman, or at least a good deal better than previous villain Glaber ever was. Indeed, there's even an off-handed remark about Crassus's dedication to training, establishing that he puts himself through these paces every day. However, presumably stirred to action by the prospect of soon fighting Sparatcus, Crassus chooses this day to get angry with his pet gladiator, saying he can never see how good he really is because Hilarius will always hold back after all, he's not about to strike down his master and meal ticket. So to this problem, Crassus has a bonkers solution he'll offer Hilarius his freedom and 10,000 denari if he kills his Dominus, promising no guard will strike him down if he wins. Understandably, Hilarius decides to bring the pain and almost kills Crassus before he, in the first of many 'HOLY SH*T' moments of the season, grabs the sharp end of his slave's sword, wrests it from his grasp and stabs him with it. Yes, it's impressive, but it's stupidly risky too if the duel had gone a hairs-breadth differently, Crassus could've been violently impaled by his formidable quarry. Remember, Hilarius isn't an everyday gladiator Crassus only wants the best, so had to part with a good deal of money to get Rome's most decorated champion. To clarify, Crassus picked an even fight with the best of the best and almost came a cropper. If the inspiration hadn't hit him before his impending death, we would've been looking at a much shorter series where Spartacus, unburdened with an equal adversary, romped around Rome claiming flawless victory. It would've been cool, but we'd have been denied a wonderful season.
7. The Governor Welcomes Andrea Back The Walking Dead
While TV's Philip Blake proved to be a divisive character among the Walking Dead fandom, he must be respected as the first true antagonist Rick and his group faced. He wasn't morally conflicted like Shane he was a bad man who enjoyed being bad, and wanted to put an end to Rick and his Prison-based group. In the midst of these two warring factions, infuriatingly, was Andrea. It's no secret Andrea wasn't liked by the viewers with her barely thought-out umming-and-ahhing and ridiculous penchant for excusing the Governor's psychopathic mores with cookie-cutter truisms, what the writers thought was an engaging display of moral conflict just ended up getting on everyone's wick. However, when she went over to the Prison, we thought she might've hardened up and picked a side after so much waivering. Alas not she soon travels back to the Prison and reunites with the Governor, who's well aware of her poorly-thought-out moral conflict and departure, but still needs her as a go-between to establish negotiations with his enemies. So far, that's a pretty solid play from the Woodbury chief he's willing to tolerate one potentially mutinous subject because of her strategic value. But what he then does beggars belief he takes her back into his bed, where obviously, by virtue of needing to sleep, he'll be unguarded. Remember, this is a woman who's having second thoughts about her new beau, and has been over to the other side to discuss it. The Governor knows this, but still elects to stay with her instead of keeping her safely under guard while trying to discern her loyalty. If Andrea had followed through on Carol's grand plan to kill him in his post-shag sleep, Philip would've had no-one to blame but himself. There's keeping your enemies close, then there's allowing them to sleep with and next to you there's a difference, and fortunately for the Governor, he didn't find this out the hard way, because much like everything else, Andrea couldn't even do this right.
6. Emile Danko Throws A US Senator From A Window Heroes
It's safe to say that Nathan Petrelli is something of a turncoat. Despite being an evolved human himself and originally believing them to be an extension of God's will, after his family's plans to synthetically give humans evolved abilities fails, he blows the lid off this species living any sort of a normal life by unveiling their existence to the President. Consequently, he sets up a taskforce to capture any folks who showcase similar abilities and put them in places they can't do any harm. Heading up this snatch operation is one Emile Danko, who reports directly to Petrelli as the Senator in charge. What with this being a drama (and at this stage of the game, a good one), it's never quite as simple as that, especially with Nathan being evolved himself. So over the first season, Danko steadily unravels, seeking to execute superhumans and butting heads with the boss he slowly becoming more suspicious of. This culminates in the episode Shades Of Gray, when the former Homeland Security agent puts two and two together (Tracy Strauss's testimony and the fact everyone else in Nathan's family has powers) and comes to the conclusion that Nathan must have powers. To test this, he shoves the Senator out of a window to see if he can fly. Just for a second, imagine if Danko had been wrong. He doesn't have categorical proof of Nathan's evolved status, just a lot of clues that point to a likely conclusion. But that's all this conclusion is likely. There's still room for doubt Tracy recanted her earlier statement and Nathan's mother said she doesn't know if abilities are hereditary and even if there wasn't, Danko can't even be 100% certain that his boss acquired flight as an ability, and not something else. If he'd been wrong and there was sizeable chance he could've been Danko would've just thrown a US Senator from a window, and would be going to jail incredibly quickly. Luckily for him, Nathan exonerated his underling by having the good grace to fly off, and saves the unhinged spook a long, long spell in prison.
5. Walt Blows Up Tuco's Place Breaking Bad
Admittedly at this point Walt is the furthest away from a villain on this list (you could argue he's more of an anti-hero), but seeing as Breaking Bad chronicles his descent into child-poisoning, multiple prisoner-whacking and just outright villainy then it'd be remiss not to include one of his crazy plans. And what could be crazier than his first step into the Heisenberg persona? At the time of Crazy Handful Of Nothin', Walt is still just dipping his toe into the drug world, and come across is first set-back in the shape of Tuco, a local drug kingpin who beats up Jesse and steals the blue sky meth he had to trade. Walt's on a hiding to nothing here if he doesn't retaliate, it sets a worrying precedent, but if he does, he risks the wrath of a psychopath. So faced with a Hobson's Choice, the White Paterfamilias chooses to make a statement by lobbing some fulminated mercury during a meeting in Tuco's office. The offending chemical spectacularly ignites, wrecking the office and leaving the gangster visibly shaken but very much impressed with the apparently out-of-his-depth chemistry teacher. Now with a new-found healthy respect for his business partner (who happens to be holding the rest of the fulminated mercury), Tuco lets Walt leave unmolested and with the money recovered. Obviously it's a cool scene, but it could've all played out very differently. Remember, Tuco isn't the most stable man around that's kind of the reason Walt's in his office in the first place and is known to take copious amounts of drugs. You can't help but feel his decision-making abilities can't help but be impaired, and if you combine that with a criminal's desire to save face and establish themselves, it was highly likely Tuco could've graphically punished Mr. White then and there. Sure, he can't kill him Walt's product is simply too good, making him a valuable asset but that doesn't stop him from torturing him later down the line, when Walt isn't holding a bag of highly explosive materials. It's lucky for the future druglord that Tuco's really quite forgiving. Also, if there had been anything else in the room that was slightly explosive a very real possibility for a group of tooled up gangsters that explosion could've also claimed Walt's life, along with everyone else in the room. Hell, if Walt had dropped the bag during the shockwave, they'd have probably had to scoop his remains off the floor with a shovel.
4. Habib Marwan Crashes Airforce One, Hopes The Football Survives 24
Aside from sounding like a ridiculously awesome name for a sport, the nuclear football is a suitcase the President carries at all times, containing the launch codes for the USA's nuclear stockpile. Basically, if the Americans decide to blow up the world, they're going to need the nuclear football or the President can't sanction the action. What with it effectively being a doomsday device, it's provided fertile territory for thriller plots, and 24 tangoed with it during Day 4. Just to remind you of Day 4, the antagonist du jour was Habib Marwan, and his massively intricate plan involved setting up several distractions to mask his true purpose getting his nefarious mitts on the aforementioned football. To accomplish this, he captures and threatens to execute the Secretary of Defence, instigates several near-meltdowns at nuclear power-plants and has an accomplice take down Air Force One with a fighter jet, the logic being that the football will still be intact and usable provided he can get to it before one-man murder conga Jack Bauer. Sure enough, he manages to extract a code before scarpering, and the plot rolls on. It must be noted that Marwan's plan relied on a tremendous amount of luck, seeing as it entirely hinged on whether the football could survive being shot at by a stealth fighter and a violent crash. Granted, it's in a pretty durable case, but that's still asking a hell of a lot if the plane had gone down differently or we weren't relying on necessary plot-logic, there's every chance the football could've been compromised by sheer force and errant wreckage. Plus, shooting down a plane isn't a controllable variable, and if its descent had differed slightly, there was every chance it could've landed too far away from Marwan, and much closer to Jack for recovery. Luckily, because we need the plot to kick in, this doesn't happen, and it's a good job really 24 needs 24 episodes, and you can bet it wouldn't have gone on that long if the terrorists' ace-in-the-hole had been compromised as it so easily could have been.
3. Charles Augustus Magnussen Admits He's Got Not Proof Sherlock
Why is Charles Augustus Magnusson so feared? Well, that's an easy one he's a master blackmailer who's able to make even Mycroft Holmes quake in his boots. He holds everyone to ransom with a huge vault of secrets known as Appledor, and forensically knows and not through Google glasses, as Sherlock originally thought everyone important's weakness. It's believed that he keeps the aforementioned vault under his Bond villain house, which doubles as an impenetrable fortress and basically confirms that his man does indeed mean business. Indeed, he means business so much that even Sherlock seems briefly overwhelmed by him, and in true Bondian style he gives our two erstwhile heroes a tour of his house-lair before showing them what Appledor is nothing. Well, it's not nothing, but it's not the vault that Sherlock was expecting. Instead, it's just his own personal mind palace, where he sifts through reams of data before finding what he wants and disseminates it through his media empire. As he tells Sherlock during his gloat about using one long plan to bring both Holmes boys under his thumb, holding the evidence can be risky, so he immediately destroys it after he's remembered the juicy bits. Sorry, what? Basically, in the midst of acting out his villainous scheme, Magnussen admits he's a blackmailer without proof, which is to say he really isn't a proper blackmailer at all. Needless to say, Sherlock reacts to this new information by shooting his adversary through the head and, by extension, his mind-palace thus ending the thrall Magnussen had over all his enemies. The day is saved, entirely because Magnussen handed Sherlock his one glaring weakness on a platter. Frankly, the guy really needs to go back to planning school, because this isn't how you do it.
2. Hannibal Stages A Crime Scene With The Police Outside Hannibal
Recently, Hannibal showed his penchant for risky plans by waiting until an armed Beverly Katz could see him before he physically incapacitated her in an unseen (but heard) confrontation. aside from this, his other actions suggest he's no stranger to risk in season one's Potage, he smuggled a body from a crime scene and cleaned it up with investigators outside and Alana Bloom upstairs, and in the most recent episodes is shown serenely working at the FBI, even though he's aware their most gifted criminal profiler knows he's a murderer and is plotting to bring him down. Yet ballsy as those two plans are, it has nothing on what he did to frame Dr. Chilton in Yakimono. Let's recap following Will's release, Hannibal knows the FBI is onto him because he so precisely fits the profile of the Chesapeake Ripper, and that the now-free Will Graham has moved Jack into treating the good doctor as a suspect. Fortunately for Hannibal, he's got a unknowing patsy in Dr. Chilton who also fits the profile to a tee, and has mind-blasted a not-actually-dead Miriam Lass into believing said murderer was the unfortunate doctor. Hannibal plants this thought into Jack's mind to the extent that he send some police around to check on him, but before Chilton can get to the door, the besuited cannibal drugs him, and tells him when he wakes up, he's going to want to run. Lo and behold, when Chilton wakes up and finds himself in an orgy of evidence, including the dismembered corpse of Eddie Izzard, which obviously makes it look like he's the guy the FBI were after and forces him to run. But here's the question how did Hannibal placate the police at the door, and move that much evidence into an already-under-surveillance house? Doing so couldn't have been an inconspicuous affair he's moving large amounts of gore, as well as a hospital bed and props into place. If just one person had realised what he was doing, or he'd caught the glance of an errant policeman, Hannibal would be behind bars and outed as the Chesapeake Ripper in the most awkward of circumstances. Clearly, the fact he wasn't points to an insane amount of luck and chutzpah.
1. Cersei Gets Robert Drunk For A Hunting 'Accident' Game Of Thrones
Of all the plans on this list, this is possibly the most audacious, seeing as it's a bonafide regicide (which would also be a great name for a rap group). Come the time of this dastardly plan, chief villainess Cersei Lannister is in something of a pickle the Hand Of The King Ned Stark has found out her children were born of incest, and is going to tell the King. However, in a typical Ned Stark move, he tells Cersei to her face what his exact plans are, allowing her to launch a gambit of her own killing her husband before the truth can ever come out. How she manages this is incredibly risky knowing her cuckolded husband is a drunkard who's about to go hunting, she gives her cousin (and the King's squire) Lancel Lannister stronger wine than usual, knowing Robert will chug it down and thus become stupid. And it all goes to plan, with the King ending up more blasted than usual, missing a swing at a giant boar and getting gored for his trouble. It's an audacious move because it looks like an accident, and it means she can tip the game of thrones back into her favour by getting her hellspawn Joffrey installed on the throne. Granted, it's a masterful bit of manipulation and probably the cleverest thing Cersei has done, and will ever do but it's insanely, staggeringly risky. Taking into account the utterly random nature of a hunt and the fact that even when he's even if he's truly gazeboed and fat, Robert is still capable of swinging a weapon as only a renowned war hero can, there was an extremely high chance that the King could've returned from his hunt un-tusked. However, though she must be aware of this, Cersei doesn't even leave the capital covertly she stays exactly where she's always been, and pins her fate to a wing, a prayer and a boar. She must've been the luckiest and most relieved woman in Westeros when she found out her bonkers plan actually worked. Know of any more ridiculous villain plans? Comment below!