9 Upcoming 2016 TV Shows That Are Already Doomed To Fail

These shows haven't got a chance.

By Brian Wilson /

With so much unique television being created by innumerable television networks, it's only natural that certain shows won't last long. These days, we're in something of a Golden Age of television writing, with amazing shows airing or just having aired, like Breaking Bad, Mad Men and the first season of True Detective. But those shows are the cream of the crop. 2015 was filled with disappointing television debuts like Steve Coogan's Happyish, Craig Robinson's Mr Robinson and ABC's Office-esque The Muppets. With a little bit of analysis and foresight, however, the negative reaction to these shows probably could have been predicted, and the same goes for 2016. Like every year, 2016 is set to give viewers a whole host of new televisual choices. While some of these things will likely be brilliant (there's been a very positive reaction to the first episode of 2016's The X-Files reboot) there are certain new shows that won't fare quite as well. From yet another Stephen King adaptation to Chris Evans' impossible task of saving Top Gear, here are the upcoming 2016 TV shows that are already doomed to fail.

9. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow

The deluge of superhero television shows must surely end sometime...right? Well, maybe not yet, but DC's newest portrayal of men and woman in funny costumes being melodramatic is surely a sign of things to come. The show is a spin-off from Arrow and The Flash, and involves a man named Rip Hunter travelling back in time (to the present day) in order to band together a team of superheroes. In essence, it's The Avengers of television shows (I know, I know, The Avengers is Marvel). So how can it fail? Well, waning popularity isn't the only reason shows fail. Reportedly, the network helming the show (The CW Television Network) massively underestimated the budget of the show (that's what happens when you've got a bunch of heroes instead of just one). Several sources have reported that The CW Television Network are concerned by the idea of a second season already, knowing that the show's budget will only get more expensive as it progresses. You can't blame them, really. It's a bit easier to try and budget when you've only got one or two costumed heroes running around using CGI-heavy superpowers, but ramp up the number of unique abilities and introduce time travel, and things get a little more pricey. If things are too expensive, it's entirely possible they may choose to cease the show.

8. Bordertown

Stereotypical, racist humour in 2015 €“ what can go wrong? Animated show Bordertown is created by Family Guy writer Mark Hentemann and executive-produced by Seth MacFarlane. It tells the story of two families living on the United States/Mexico border. A quick look at the trailer is all you need to determine this show's fate. Forgetting the fact that Seth McFarland hasn't really been involved in the creation of a new, successful animated show since American Dad! (The Cleveland Show managed to struggle on for four seasons despite fan and critical negativity by virtue of it being a Family Guy spin-off) it just doesn't look that funny. In fact, the show looks like all the worst parts of Family Guy, with dumb, racist humour and fart gags. When the official trailer for your TV show has more than seventy-five percent dislikes on YouTube before the show has even aired, you know things aren't going to go well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjXjqC-1Kvg

7. The Shannara Chronicles

Produced by MTV (uh oh), The Shannara Chronicles is an upcoming adaptation of the fantasy/science fiction series written by Terry Brooks. It depicts the adventures that take place throughout the history of the Four Lands. So why's it doomed? Well, as mentioned, the show is airing on MTV. It may have become something of predictable joke to bash MTV, but that's not without good reason. The network has a history of airing terrible shows, and it also has a history of inadvertently crushing genuinely decent shows that somehow wind up on its network (case in point: Zach Stone Is Gonna Be Famous, written and starring American comedian Bo Burnham). The truth is, the MTV audience (in general, I won't make any sweeping judgements) just aren't looking for sophisticated sci-fi or fantasy shows when they tune into the channel. On top of that, fans of the books are somewhat confused by the fact the show is an adaptation of the second book in the series, not the first. When even fans of the source material are riled, well...good luck, Shannara.

6. Game Of Thrones Season Six

All right, all right...drop your pitchforks for a second and let me explain. When I say that season six of Game Of Thrones is doomed, I don't mean that it's going to get cancelled because of poor viewer ratings. What it is going to do is disappoint a lot of people, and sadly that's inevitable. We knew this would happen all along, many of us just tried not to think about how soon it was coming. What little source material from George R.R. Martin's A Song Of Ice And Fire series there was left has essentially been used up. Season five received the most mixed reaction that the show has ever experienced, and why? Because there was barely any source material left to use, leading to bouts of disappointing writing. Leaving the writers to come up with new, off-book material lead to some of the weakest, most middling and frankly filler-quality material in the show's history. Transplanting Sansa into the role of Ramsay's sexually and physically abused wife, for example, drew criticism for its blatant attempts to be shocking. And the moment fans have been talking about since the season ended was basically the last major scene left to adapt from the books, so season six really will be mostly new territory. Across the show's history, the writers have yet to prove they're able to write new material as strong as book material. In season five, they proved they mostly couldn't. Season six, then, is doomed for this reason. It's entirely likely that the writers will chase the kinds of things they think the show is €œabout€ which they did with the new stuff in season five (shocking violence and twists, not strong, intelligent characters and plot).

5. Lucifer

So many superheroes, so little time...but seriously, with so many superheroes, and so little time, who is going to commit to a show about a superhero they've barely even heard of? Lucifer is an upcoming Fox television series that's loosely based on a character created by sci-fi writer Neil Gaiman for his comic book series The Sandman. Sounds great and all (Gaiman is a brilliant, clever writer) but it's a show that's basically fighting against unwinnable odds. For a start, the premise of the plot is pretty cliché. The devil gets bored in hell and decides to come to earth. Fair enough. The hook is that Lucifer decides to help the Los Angeles Police Department punish criminals. Why? Why does that character need to be the devil? The real reason the show is doomed, however, is that there are just so many other superhero shows out there already. Gotham, Arrow, Daredevil, Agents of SHIELD, The Flash, Agent Carter...all of these are based on popular characters, or propped up by some cinematic universe. In a world with so much choice, Lucifer is destined to get buried.

4. The Magicians

Because we all wanted Harry Potter to be more sexy and €œgrown up€, didn't we? The Magicians is an upcoming fantasy series set to premiere on the Syfy channel (you know, the channel that gave us such filmic gems as 2010's Sharktopus, 2004's Frankenfish and 2009's Mega Shark Versus Giant Octopus). It's basically about a guy named Quentin Coldwater who enrolls at a college for €œMagical Pedagogy€ so that he can be trained as a magician. Quentin then discovers that the world depicted in his favourite childhood books is entirely real and entirely dangerous. Even for fantasy, the plot sounds absolutely ridiculous. Though I mentioned Harry Potter as a joke, it's at the forefront of magic-based pop culture, so it's impossible not compare the premise to J.K. Rowling's intelligent, nuanced plot. But don't take my word for it. The show's first episode had a special airing at the end of 2015 (with the first episode and remainder of the season set to start properly in January) and critical reception was mixed, with several pointing out that it appeared to be a bizarre, misjudged amalgamation of sex and Harry Potter.

3. 11.22.63

Based on the book 11/23/63 by famed horror writer Stephen King, 11.22.63 is set to premiere in February 2016. It tells the story of a teacher who mistakenly travels back in time to 1958 (how does one mistakenly travel back in time? Just one of the show's many initial hurdles) and then decides hey, what the hell, might as well stop JFK from being assassinated while I'm here. You might be thinking €œStephen King is a great writer, what can go wrong?€ but you're likely forgetting the fact that Stephen King television adaptations are historically pretty bad. Sure, there have been a few decent ones, but they're generally the kind of story that comes across as quite cheesy on screen. The recent CBS adaptation of Under The Dome started strong, but quickly went extremely down in hill both in quality and ratings, leading the show to be cancelled. On top of that, there's been a bit of internal turbulence regarding the show's creation. Initially there was going to be a film adaptation of the book, with Jonathan Demme attached to write, produce and direct the project. Demme left, however, after arguments with King over what should be included in the script. King might be a great novelist, but that doesn't mean he's a great television writer.

2. Colony

Ah, Josh Holloway€so loveable and charming on Lost, yet so unable to forge a successful career for yourself post-Sawyer. Despite a few very brief roles on shows like Community and Yo Gabba Gabba! (seriously), the actor has had a pretty pallid career since Lost ended in 2010. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like things are going to get much better. Colony depicts a futuristic, dystopian version of Los Angeles, and the military occupation that makes everyone's life a misery. The premise, in essence, is survival. That's the simple version, anyway. The plot is so complicated and so convoluted that there's just no way it's going to gain mainstream popularity. To prove my point, I'll try my best to explain it. Basically, in this futuristic, dystopian Los Angeles, there's been a military occupation by a group of people known as the Colony Transitional Authority. The Colony Transitional Authority are a subsidiary of the Hosts (also known as the Raps, a reference to raptors) who are actually aliens. Supposedly, nobody ever gets to see these aliens, as the entirety of futuristic, dystopian Los Angeles is trapped by a wall as tall as a skyscraper and hundreds of yards thick. All of this took place during a violent invasion called the Arrival. That's just a small slice of the context. Still with me? Yeah, didn't think so.

1. Top Gear

It's ludicrous that the BBC is even attempting this, but it's completely unsurprising given the sheer amount of profit the show makes (Top Gear is the most widely watched €œfactual€ television show in the world). In 2016, Top Gear is set to see something of a reboot, following the exit of Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond and James May. Radio presenter Chris Evans is set to take on hosting duties, but he's got an extremely thankless task ahead of him. For a start, much of the show's popularity relied on the chemistry between Clarkson, Hammond and May, something that it's just impossible to replicate. Though many tuned in for the car stuff, just as many tuned in to see the three presenters joke around and poke fun at one another. Over the years, their personas and relationship became the most bankable part of the whole show. Not only that, but many reacted to Clarkson's dismissal (Clarkson was fired after an incident with one of the show's producers) extremely personally, vehemently defending the host, or at the very least laughing along with him. Evans, then, doesn't just have to try and prop up a television show, he has to try and win over people predisposed to not liking him. On top of that, rumours emerged at the close of 2015 that the show was suffering difficulties behind the scenes, including key staff quitting (apparently the show's executive producer Lisa Clark is gone) and that Evans had crashed an expensive Jaguar on his first lap around a course during filming. Sounds like everything is going well.