Arrow Season 5: 4 Characters That Absolutely Cannot Die (And 5 That Can)

Time to break up the OG Team Arrow?

By James Hunt /

The CW

On Arrow, death hasn't always meant death, and there's actually something of a noticeable correlation between the quality of the show, and whether or not supposedly 'dead' characters have stayed in the ground.

Advertisement

Season 1 was a solid introduction to this darker, more grounded superhero world, which came along as an alternative option to the superhero offerings on the big screen, and received a big emotional payoff with the death of Tommy Merlyn.

Season 2 took the series to its peak, with a blistering battle against Slade Wilson that was extremely personal for our hero, and the conclusion was driven (in part) by Wilson killing Moira Queen.

Advertisement

Season 3 is when things got trickier. They used death early on, a plot device to drive the entire season, and it backfired. The show became engulfed in misery, and Sara's death was later reversed for Legends of Tomorrow. Oliver and Thea were both seemingly killed as well, yet neither perished.

Season 4 setup a major death in the premiere, and then had to write itself to the point of Laurel being the one in the grave - which mostly meant writing Laurel into the sidelines before it happened. And, well, she too is coming back.

Advertisement

Death needs to mean death in Arrow; it needs to have real stakes, and real emotional payoff, without losing characters too valuable to the series. Season 5 is a chance to get back to making that work, and these are the characters whose deaths the show could handle, and those it couldn't.

Can't Die...

4. Oliver Queen

The CW

This one pretty much goes without saying, but is still worthy of addressing (and not just to avoid all the 'er, what about Oliver?!' comments.).

Advertisement

It raises the question of whether Arrow would ever really kill off its hero, or if there's a future of the show without Stephen Amell. And, well, the answer to both is a pretty solid no at this stage.

Arrow flirted with making us think it'd killed Oliver in Season 3, and no one really bought it, and nor did it particularly help the show along. Since then it's had him face more life or death situations, but he's always came out on top, because he's the hero. It's his show. And Stephen Amell is the star, one who has continued to grow into the role (regardless of how the show has dipped in quality, Amell gets better and better).

Advertisement

It'd almost be interesting to see Arrow without him, but it wouldn't even take a single episode to realise that it can't work. This story began with Oliver Queen, and it'll eventually end with him too.

3. Curtis Holt

The CW

Curtis was a breath of fresh air when he was introduced last year. Smart, funny, and awkward, he's very similar to the character Felicity was when everyone first fell in love with her.

Advertisement

However, there is more to him than just being Felicity-lite, and that's a key part of why he needs to be kept around. There's a lot more to come from Curtis, as the show explores his progression into being a crimefighter, a fully-fledged member of Team Arrow, and eventually the superhero Mister Terrific.

Actor Echo Kellum brings some needed moments of levity, but early indications also suggest that he'll be able to hack it in the vigilante world too, and we're only just getting to know his character: at some point down the line killing him off might be a viable option, but in Season 5 it'd just be a waste.

Advertisement

2. John Diggle

The CW

One of the problems with Arrow recently (not a comparatively major issue, but still enough to be noticed) is the sidelining of John Diggle. The show has continued to expand its cast, with Team Arrow getting bigger and bigger, and as a result of that Digg has often been pushed to the sidelines (in fairness, it was worse in Season 3 than 4, but now he's gone off from the team entirely).

Advertisement

The issue with that is Diggle is a big part of the show's heart. He's been there since the beginning, and is an important character in keeping Oliver on the right path, while being a highly competent crimefighter in his own right - also, no one does the 'surprised by superpowers' thing better than David Ramsey, and that alone makes him worth keeping around.

He may not always have the biggest part to play in things, but he guarantees a strong performance and an emotional core that helps keep the series grounded.

Advertisement

1. Thea Queen

The CW

When Thea was apparently killed by Ra's al Ghul in Season 3, it didn't seem like the worst option in the world. The show had struggled with really nailing down her place on a packed team, and her death might've worked then. Fast forward a few months, and Thea's arc was really struggling. Stuck in the whole post-Lazarus Pit bloodlust cycle, the character was wearing thin.

Advertisement

Since that arc ended however, Thea has soared as a character. She's become a valuable member of the team, had a couple of other strong angles, and took part in one truly excellent fight scene - all while being the quip-happy sidekick Green Arrow needs. Whether it's a surprising pop culture reference or a bit of snark, Thea is the go-to character for it, and has actually become one of the most enjoyable to watch on the show.

The show has already dealt with Ollie losing his family members, and after Laurel's death there's not much that can be gained from killing Thea off, but there's a lot to potentially lose.

Advertisement

Can Die...

5. Felicity Smoak

The CW

For approximately 45% of the fanbase, Felicity would be number 1 on this section of the list, and is responsible for everything wrong with the show. Then there's the other 45%, who think the complete opposite, and that Felicity can do no wrong and her and Oliver should be together no matter what. Then there's the remaining 10%, who realise Felicity is a once-great character now being ruined by bad writing, but hope things can still be turned around.

Advertisement

That's a basic outline of my thoughts on Felicity, and why she's only #5, rather than #1. At her best, she's a strong, smart, and funny character, who has great chemistry with the rest of Team Arrow (in particular Oliver). Too often though, in the past couple of years, she's had far too much focus, with 'Olicity' becoming the centre of the show, and a number of big speeches about love and truth and so on.

Given how great Felicity was in Season 1 and 2 (and she's shown plenty of flashes of that since) it'd be shame for her to leave the show, and with a 'back-to-basics' approach in Season 5 hopefully things can be turned around (regardless of whether her and Oliver are together are not, which can work but just can't dominate the show). If not, though, then getting rid might be the only option.

Advertisement

4. Roy Harper

The CW

Roy Harper hasn't been a regular character on Arrow since Season 3, when he sacrificed himself to protect Oliver. Since then, he briefly appeared in Season 4, and is coming back in Season 5 for an unspecified amount of time, though it may be a multi-episode run.

Advertisement

There are a couple of issues with that though. While it's always fun to have Roy around, it's not much more than that. Towards the end of his time on the show as a regular, he was really given very little to do except practice some awesome parkour. It looked great, but he was hardly a character outside of that.

Secondly, as a wanted man, there's a limited amount they can do with him on the show. Those two combined mean that he might be able to come back every season for a guest appearance, but it's not going to add too much to the story, and we've already had his goodbyes to the team. It might be stronger work for his character, and the show, if they were to give him a final sendoff, rather than constantly leaving with the door open.

Advertisement

3. Nyssa Al Ghul

The CW

After being something of a regular doing the third season, Nyssa al Ghul, son of Ra's, appeared only a handful of times during Season 4, although still enough to make an impact.

Advertisement

She returned to Star City to help Oliver cure Thea's bloodlust, but in return he had to kill Malcolm Merlyn (which, of course, he didn't). All of it added up to the League disbanding, which wasn't really a bad thing since they weren't exactly a compelling part of the show.

While Katrina Law has always given a solid performance, I don't really know how much more there is to explore with Nyssa. Her relationships with both Lance sisters have been covered, as has her rivalry with Malcolm Merlyn, and while she could conceivably keep on popping up every now and then to help out Team Arrow, she won't become a permanent member, and killing the character off probably wouldn't impact things too much.

Advertisement

2. Quentin Lance

The CW

In truth, it's remarkable that Quentin Lance has lasted this long. That's not supposed to be an indictment of the character, nor Paul Blackthorne (who is pretty great), but just a reflection on what's happened to him and the show as a whole.

Advertisement

His daughter has 'died', came back, died again, came back again, his other daughter's died, he's lost his job, worked with vigilantes, came close to dying himself. Heck, he was most people's favourite to be the one in the grave for most of Season 4, and it wouldn't have been surprising had that happened.

He's come through it all, just about, but it does make you wonder how much more he can survive, and what place he has on a show without either of his daughters. If he's not in the police, not a father, and isn't a member of Team Arrow, then quite how much longer he has (although I'd happily keep him around for world-weary sense of humour) on the show isn't really clear, and Season 5 could well be his last.

Advertisement

1. Malcolm Merlyn

The CW

We're going to be seeing a lot more of Malcolm Merlyn on The CW. He's signed a contract much like that of Wentworth Miller and Katie Cassidy, allowing him to appear regularly across all of the DC TV shows on the network.

Advertisement

It seems a lot of that will be centred on Legends of Tomorrow, where he'll be forming part of the villainous Legion of Doom alongside Damien Darhk, Captain Cold, and Reverse-Flash. Quite how that'll translate across to Arrow isn't clear, but we can no doubt expect Merlyn to appear and continue staking his claim for the Arrowverse's worst father.

And that's the crux of the issue as far as his time on Arrow is concerned. Being on Legends can give him the chance to explore something new, going up against different characters in different time periods, and working alongside some hugely enjoyable fellow villains. On Arrow, though, he's been the main villain, reluctant hero, turncoat, doting dad, and all the way back around, and I'm not really sure what is left to do with him, save for finally having him killed by one of the good guys.

Advertisement

Who do you think can and can't die in Arrow Season 5? Share your thoughts down in the comments.