Dexter: Ranking Every Season From Worst To Best

By Liam Hoofe /

With Dexter season 8 having been a monumental disappointment so far perhaps now is a good time to take a look at the show's other seasons and remember exactly why we love the programme so much in the first place. Dexter has been one of the best shows on television for the last seven years, providing us with some of televisions most shocking and memorable moments. Season eight still has three episodes in which it can redeem itself. A few major plot twists and some huge surprises could make fans forget all about the rubbish we've had to endure so far, however I say this more in hope than expectation. Here's my ranking of each of Dexter's last seven seasons;

7. Season Five

Remember that really exciting episode in season five? Me neither. Following on from season four€™s explosive finale was always going to prove a difficult task but fans couldn€™t begin to imagine just how unimaginative it could be. Season five saw Dexter save a woman, Lumen, from a life time of torture. Having helped her get away from her captors Dexter decided to help Lumen catch and kill those who had wronged her. Cue the entrance of Jonny Lee Miller as Jordan Chase, the head of a gang of rapists and murderers. The whole thing was very uninspiring and a lot of people I know lost interest in the show during this season. The season€™s finale had a moment of excitement when Deb nearly caught Dexter and Lumen killing but other than that, the whole thing was just a bore.

Advertisement

6. Season Three

I recently decided to re-watch every episode of Dexter in preparation for the final season. Half way through season three I thought to myself, am I going to miss anything if I just skip the rest of this season? The answer of course, was no. Season three wasn€™t necessarily bad, it certainly had its moments (Masuka kidnapping Dexter is one of the show€™s funniest moments) but it was just terribly forgettable. Miguel was not a great antagonist, not in comparison to those we€™d been given in the first two seasons and the whole tree surgeon thing was just silly. In terms of development, season three saw Dexter get married and Quinn arrive on the scene, another two reasons why this season is ranked second to bottom on this list.

5. Season Six

When people talk about the worst seasons of Dexter they often cite season six and in all honestly, this baffles me. Whilst it might not hold up to the superior ones it was certainly entertaining and in my opinion the ending of this season was even more shocking than that of season four. What made this season so enjoyable for me was The Doomsday Killer and his graphic murders. Colin Hanks has been received quite negatively by many of the Dexter faithful but I found him to be a thoroughly enjoyable antagonist. His most memorable moment of course being when he killed his sister and made her look like the Whore of Babylon, one of the most chilling moments in the shows history. The show had other positives as well; whilst the Nebraska episode annoyed a lot of people I actually found it wickedly funny and thought it made a welcome change. The school reunion episode also offered some funny moments, Dexter€™s hammer time dance being a particular highlight.

4. Season Seven

Season seven was a success for a number of reasons: Dexter was in some serious danger of being caught by LaGuerta, it continued on perfectly from a great cliffhanger and most importantly the show had an impending sense of doom, one that made the show feel like it was coming to an end. Basically it was everything season eight has failed to be so far. The tension in the final few episodes of season seven are some of the tensest in the show€™s history and whilst the ending may have been predictable, it brought everything to its logical conclusion and set us up perfectly for what should have been an explosive final season. Also we were provided with one of the show€™s most memorable antagonists in Issak and his premature death was one of the show€™s more touching moment.

3. Season Two

The second season of a show is often key in terms of making or breaking a fan base and Dexter was one of the shows that got it bang on. Following on from the Ice Truck Killer the show went down a different route with Dexter trying to hide his life more from Rita by joining a narcotics anonymous group. This ended badly when he met Lila, a recovering addict with a fetish for fire and serial killers apparently. Added to this Sergeant Doakes was hot on Dexter€™s tail and through this we got to uncover more of Dexter€™s past and discover how he had become the man he is today. The final few episodes of this season are some of the best in the show and the explosive (literally) finale makes this the third best season of Dexter.

2. Season One

The season where it all began. Dexter burst onto our screens in style in season one in what has turned out to be one of the show€™s finest years. So what was it that got us all hooked in the first season? A lot of it personally was down to the cat and mouse interactions between Dexter and The Ice Truck Killer. The excitement continued to build as the episodes went on and the show hooked in its audience perfectly with some clever writing and excellent plot twists. The season also lacked the one thing that season eight is lacking and that is humour. Remember when Dexter€™s voiceovers were hilarious and when Masuka was actually laugh out loud hilarious? That was part of the reason many people loved the show and its absence has been noted by everyone in the final season.

1. Season Four

Choosing between this and season one for the top spot was an extremely difficult task but the chilling performance of John Lithgow and perhaps the most memorable moment in the show€™s history just tipped it for me. Season four was fantastic for many reasons but the one thing it is most memorable for is it€™s antagonist, Arthur Mitchell aka, The Trinity Killer. Admired by Dexter at first, Mitchell lived a seemingly ordinary and at times charitable life but as his story unravelled it was clear all wasn€™t well for the seasoned serial killer. Lithgow€™s performance achieved mass critical acclaim and rightfully so. His chilling portrayal left a chill down many peoples spines and his final act in the show, killing Dexter's wife Rita is perhaps the most shocking in the show's history.