Doctor Who: 5 Ways The 12th Doctor's Era Should Be Like The 3rd's (And 1 Way It Shouldn't)

Capaldi's shaping up to be a bit Pertwee-esque, so here's some handy tips if he chooses to go down that garishly-dressed path. Note: does not include Venusian Aikido.

By Chris Swanson /

One of the more interesting things about Matt Smith€™s time as the Doctor is the way that it aped the Second Doctor€™s era. This was in part due to Smith€™s fondness for that time in the series, and it was expressed in several ways. The Eleventh Doctor€™s outfit was at least somewhat reminiscent of the Second Doctor, for quite a while he had one male companion and one female (like Ben/Polly, Jamie/Victoria, Jamie/Zoe), and we even saw the return of one of the more memorable villains from the Second Doctor€™s era, The Great Intelligence, and the long-overdue, much-welcome return of the Ice Warriors. If past is prologue, we can look at Peter Capaldi€™s fondness for Jon Pertwee€™s time as the Third Doctor, and look at his very Third Doctor-style costume, and perhaps start wondering if there might be a move to redirect the series toward some more reminders of the Third Doctor€™s era. With that in mind, I€™ve decided to knock together a list of the five ways the Twelfth Doctor€™s adventures should become more like the Third Doctor€™s, and one massive way in which they shouldn€™t.

5 Ways It Should...

5. Get Away From Earth

You know what would be nice? An entire series of stories where we don€™t see Earth even once. Yes, it€™s a place that looms large in the Doctor€™s personal history, but you know what? So does Trenzalore. We can assume he spent more time there than on Earth and Gallifrey combined, and I€™ll be you money right now we never see it again. So how nice would it be to not see the Earth for a while? Or, if we must see it, how about seeing future Earth or past Earth a lot more? Better yet, let€™s get out into space. The Third Doctor had several stories set in the far-off future on various space stations and planets. He dealt with diplomatic disputes between various alien species, and regularly saved planets that weren€™t Earth. It would be nice to see a return to this. Out of 84 stories in the new series, 62 of them have taken place on Earth, most of them in contemporary times, give or take a few years. This includes every single Ninth Doctor story. Let€™s see an end to this, and return to the €œSpace€ part of €œTime and Relative Dimension in Space€.

4. Bring Back The Master

This is inevitable. We know it will happen at some point. Given the huge shadow the Master cast over the Third Doctor€™s time, perhaps it is time to bring him back. Now we don€™t need to get into a situation like we had in the Third Doctor€™s era where, for one season, literally every. Single. Episode. Featured the Master. But it would be terribly nice to see him back again provided that we see a version more like the Delgado incarnation. You see the Master was, back in the day, a Moriarty type of character. He was cool and sophisticated. He was polite where the Doctor was rude and brusque. Yes, he€™d kill you, but you got the impression he wouldn€™t do so unless he thought he really needed to. Later versions would kill you because it was Tuesday. They became agents of chaos and evil for the sake of chaos and evil. We never quite had a time where the Master was gloating about how €œdeliciously EVIL!€ he was, but, man, were we ever close. So let€™s bring back the Master, but bring him back as a much more subdued version of the character. No more lightning-riding John Simm, as good as he was.

3. Be A Bit More Scientifically-Minded

Doctor Who has never been about the science, but the Doctor himself is a scientist. This was never more visible than during his time as the Third Doctor where, while stuck on Earth, he became a scientific consultant to UNIT and was often seen doing little science experiments. This is something I€™d very much like to see back on the show. We€™ve gotten a lot of the manic, adventure side of the Doctor, but we€™ve very seldom seen what a brilliant scientific mind he has. It would be great to get back to that €“ though I don€™t mean we need to see him running little Mythbusters-style experiments every episode, but a few bits here and there would be greatly appreciated.

2. Give The Doctor Some Gadgets And Vehicles

On a related note, the Third Doctor loved gadgets and tinkering. Once he removed the control console from inside the TARDIS in order to work on it, and he rather famously had a bright yellow car named Bessie. He also had, in his last story, a chase scene that involved basically every vehicle known to man. Now we don€™t really need the Twelfth Doctor to have his own car, but it would be nice to see a return to the tinkering and gadgets. That role has largely been taken over by the sonic screwdriver, but a decreased dependence on that would be a welcome change anyhow. So let€™s see the Doctor tinkering on some major inner-workings of the TARIDS. Let€™s see him build a device that isn€™t the sonic screwdriver (and doesn€™t look all steampunky), that gets him out of some odd situation. Let€™s see a bit more of the Doctor as an engineer.

1. Bring Back Third Doctor-Era Adversaries

I€™m going to name two races that we really, really need to see back on the show. Both were introduced during the Third Doctor€™s era, and both were very interesting. Neither has been seen since the Third Doctor€™s time on the show, but both have been mentioned, and returned quite a lot in the spin-off fiction. Those species are the Draconians and the Eight-Legs, aka The Spiders from Metebelis III. The Draconians were a noble reptilian race that had a thing for warfare and were often standing in opposition to Earth. They weren€™t evil as a race, no more so than humanity, a noble mammalian race. They were generally trustworthy and honorable, and had a very unique appearance that still holds up. The Eight-Legs were a species of telepathic spiders that used mind control to seriously mess with various humans and a slave species on their home planet. They were the original 'There€™s something on your back!' species, and it would be glorious to see them return, especially as they were directly responsible for the Third Doctor€™s death. Also, it would give the series a chance to correctly pronounce €œMetebelis€. As I€™ve mentioned in other places, it would also be nice to return to Peladon, and see what€™s been happening there. It would also be great to see species like the Ogrons, and the Axons, though please not both at once. Basically anything that expands on what we€™ve seen from the Third Doctor€™s era would be quite wonderful. Except for one thing. The one thing the series should never, ever do again.

1 Way It Shouldn't...

1. Don't Stay On Earth!

Despite what I said earlier, for most of the Third Doctor€™s first few years, he was exiled on Earth, sent there by the Time Lords as punishment for intervening with various alien species including humans. Though he still frequently found ways off the planet and was eventually given the freedom to travel once more, he was still stuck there for quite a while. This severely limited the types of stories the writers could tell. One person summed it up by saying they basically a choice between €œmad scientist€ and €œalien invasion€. And, indeed, a look at most of the Earth-based stories in the new series shows something very similar. Keeping the series stuck on and around contemporary Earth was a big mistake in the early 1970s. It would be an even bigger mistake now. When a show that was frequently operating on a shoestring budget could still manage to stage stories set in the far-off future and actually attempt to make things look futuristic, and the new series, with a far healthier budget, cannot, something is severely wrong. So to the producers, I say give the Doctor his freedom. Give him the ability to really travel far, far away from Earth circa 2014. Give him, and us, some mind-blowing adventures in space. Everyone will be happier.