Doctor Who: Ranking The New Series Arcs From Worst To Best

By Joe Gardner /

Honourable Mention: He Will Knock Four Times (2009 Specials)

Not strictly an 'arc', as it didn't belong to a full series and only got a proper mention once thanks to a conveniently placed psychic, but 'He Will Knock Four Times' nonetheless serves as the ominous saying that haunted David Tennant's final few episodes, beginning with Planet of the Dead. His out-of-character behaviour in the following story The Waters of Mars was something of an unspoken response to this, given that he was reticent to stick around and help the doomed inhabitants of Bowie Base One, knowing that his own 'death' was around the corner. The foreshadowed knock itself was a poignant surprise; heavily, deliberately implied to be the Master responsible for the four knocks, given his disposition for trying to off the Doctor and the nagging drumbeat he constantly hears in his head, it instead turned out to be Wilfred Mott - Donna Noble's grandfather and loyal friend to the Doctor - who heralded 10's departure, politely knocking from within a radiation chamber to be set free, not initially knowing that by doing so the Doctor would have to regenerate. Beautiful.

7. The Impossible Girl (Series Seven)

A classic piece of Steven Moffat misdirection dominated the beginning of Doctor Who's seventh series. Amidst all the hype of 'Every Dalek Ever' featuring in opener Asylum of the Daleks, newly announced companion Clara Oswald (played by Jenna Coleman) quietly snuck into the story unnoticed - six episodes earlier than anyone expected. The reveal was successfully kept a secret until broadcast and then, just as it was beginning to sink in, she died! The new companion is dead, a whole half-series before she is even meant to turn up? How could this be? And so began the arc of the impossible girl. Clara Oswald appeared once again in The Snowmen €“ the mid-series Christmas special €“ and then died a second time. From then on the Doctor knew he was involved in something unprecedented for a companion (except for Rory, Jack, River and Amy but let's not mention that). Unfortunately, the arc itself was barely existent, and in its absence Clara wasn't really able to develop as a character; the writers were presumably too busy wondering who she was to worry about such things. There was little development of the mystery itself beyond the series 7B opener The Bells of St. John, and the arc was relegated to an occasional throwaway comment in the odd episode. While the finale certainly delivered in bringing the story to fruition (who wasn't blown away by that classic Doctor montage?), its relative absence during most of the preceding series is the reason why this one gets last place. Sorry Clara.

6. Torchwood (Series Two)

Another series arc that was barely an arc so much as an occasional throwaway line of dialogue; Torchwood seemed like little more than producer Russell T Davies' cynical way of promoting the imminent spinoff series of the same name €“ although why anyone would want to make children aware of a show that regularly employs gratuitous sex and usage of F and C bombs is beyond me. The alien-fighting institute is first mentioned by name in David Tennant's debut story The Christmas Invasion, then its inception is seen at the end of Victorian horror story Tooth and Claw. And then... that's it. Torchwood gets a fleeting mention here and there, but it has no impact on the stories which mention it and isn't really thought about by anybody until the finale rolls around and we finally see what Queen Victoria's brain child has become. This style of threading episodes together with a seemingly throwaway line actually worked a lot better with the preceding series' 'Bad Wolf' meme, because that time around it was abstract, subtle and a little bit spooky. But more on that later. The word 'Torchwood' being shoehorned in amidst discussions about Cybermen and blackholes doesn't quite constitute an arc, although at least it didn't result in an under-developed companion.

5. Who Is River Song / The Death Of The Doctor (Series Six)

This arc couldn't be more different than the previous two; for his second series Moffat seemed to fancy attempting an American style arc-heavy run. The problem with that is that this is Doctor Who - a show whose standalone nature is part of its appeal, which is also why it didn't quite work for me. The River Song mystery was tantalisingly set up all the way back in David Tennant's final series, and was mused upon by the Doctor and Amy in series five but nothing more then. Finally, with the blistering two-part opener to series six, the question was ready to be tackled. Mysterious, one-eyed women appearing in the walls, children that can regenerate like Time Lords and Amy being a slimy doppleganger all this time! THIS is how you do an arc, Russell. Pay attention. However, it is the episodes that don't address the arc that let this series down. The first half of series six was onto a promise €“ dull pirate runaround aside, there was development upon development and the surprise death of the Doctor at the very beginning of it all hung over Rory and Amy like a bad smell, while the younger version of the Time Lord was blissfully unaware of it. But then came Demon's Run and Hitler, and it all went to pot. At the close of mid-series finale A Good Man Goes To War, Amy and Rory's baby (who turns out to have been River all along) is kidnapped by the Silence. The Doctor parts ways with a promise to find baby Melody and viewers are left with a long break in which to wonder if he succeeded. It isn't the Doctor's ultimate failure that is the problem here €“ he's broken plenty of promises before. Its' the fact that Amy and Rory don't seem to care. They can never see their baby again because they've crossed paths with adult River too often €“ they've essentially suffered the temporal equivalent of a miscarriage and they're off gleefully running around having adventures, neither of them eliciting a single hint of sadness. Barely any further mention is made of their loss following Let's Kill Hitler and it's actually quite unsettling to see supposedly loveable characters not displaying a shred of concern for their trauma. And then came the finale; and the attempt to tie up a million loose ends in one 45 minute episode. Series six introduced two things to New Who: the mid-series split and the single-part finale, and neither did the series many favours.

4. Missing Planets (Series Four)

This one fared a little better than the blandness of Torchwood earlier in Davies' era of Who, because it actually formed the basis of several episodes. Eschewing his previous tactic of repeating a single term over the course of the series, series four introduced several little ongoing mysteries simultaneously; the Medusa Cascade got the occasional mention and sounded suitably ethereal, as did the Shadow Proclamation, ATMOS and the disappearance of bees. However, it was the abundance of disappearing planets that stood as the heart of Davies and Tennant's final full series of Doctor Who. The Adipose breeding planet was the first to go, and that gave Mrs. Foster and her legions of fat babies motive to come to Earth and convert us lot into Adipose. So far, so good €“ a story arc actually having influence over the individual story. Then came The Fires of Pompeii and the wayward Pyroviles were playing the same card as their planet was also gone. All the while, the Doctor fleetingly wonders why the bees have disappeared and that strange old Cascade draws ever closer. Make what you will of series four's two part finale; for some its a whimsical celebration of four successful years of new Doctor Who, for others its a bloated mess of too many plot-threads, redundant characters only present for fanservice and convenient reset buttons abound. At the very least, unlike Moffat's series six head-scratcher of a finale, every element gets adequate treatment and is fully resolved by the end. The Shadow Proclamation is where the Doctor goes to try and work out where the planets have gone, the bees have disappeared because they saw the bad things coming and went home (bees are aliens €“ well, not all of them), the planets have been stolen by Davros and the Medusa Cascade is the galaxy where he has taken them. All present and correct.

3. Mr. Saxon (Series Three)

I'll get this out of the way now; The Last of the Time Lords is the worst single episode of New Doctor Who ever made. Sorry. I know it has its fans but that's just how I feel. The Master as played by Dick Dastardly, ear-scraping cheesy pop-songs aplenty, Gollum-Doctor and the worst Deus Ex Machina resolution since God Himself first came out of a machine. I shudder to even type it. If you're still reading then, a) thank you for putting up with that little rant, and b) I don't think the arc that preceded the aforementioned crime against television was at all half bad. Just because the payoff wasn't to my taste, doesn't mean the set-up wasn't either. There was a real ominous undercurrent to series three as we gradually began to work out who this Saxon character was €“ the Face of Boe's dying message hinting at more Time Lords near the start of the series was spine-tinglingly exciting and there were some curious and creepy developments with Martha's parents being utilised by this seemingly omnipotent, malevolent character in his quest to trap the Doctor. Plus, the idea that the finale takes place only a single day after the Doctor and Martha Jones first set off on their adventures is a nice touch. Then there's the end of Utopia; far and away the best entry in the three part finale. Upon every rewatch I still get that gobsmacked chill I got the first time around; sure, we'd all worked out who Saxon was by then, but it was still a knock for six to hear Derek Jacobi say that line; 'I. AM. THE. MASTER!'

2. Bad Wolf (Series One)

The one that set the precedent; the 'Bad Wolf' arc of Christopher Eccleston's single series was both exciting and mysterious, and subtle enough not to be at the detriment of standalone stories (unlike the River arc of series six). Many times the term was so embedded in the background of an episode that we barely even knew it was there; and it took the Doctor's sudden, concerned flashback in Boomtown to really point them out to us. This was skillfully done, because it is the very nature of the arc itself; a message littered through time, almost in the subconscious of the Doctor and Rose and therefore, vicariously, the viewer. It doesn't so much unfold as it does sit there gestating through the course of series one. It is graffitied onto the TARDIS by a troublesome kid, used as a name for a military chopper in 2012 Utah and is the name of a television company in the year 200,100. The point is, the people using those words have nothing in common with one another. This adds to the spookiness of the concept as Bad Wolf seems to be an omnipotent force, corrupting the conversations and activities of people throughout Earth's history (because Eccleston's Doctor is more or less Earth-bound for his entire run) in little ways, haunting the Doctor all the while. One of the best moments in the arc's run comes in the final episode; The Parting of the Ways. When the Doctor asks the Dalek Emperor what the words mean, he chillingly responds that he has no idea, they are not his doing. One more excellent twist just as we thought we had it figured out. And of course, the real culprit is just as spooky, incongruous and omniscient as the arc itself; Rose Tyler, possessed by the heart of the TARDIS and wielding the power of a God. Equipped with Billie Piper's natural, well-spoken accent and glowing white eyes, Bad Wolf becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as the words can only come into being if they themselves lead Rose to creating them in the first place. What a marvelous end to a blistering debut series.

1. Cracks In Time (Series Five)

Steven Moffat had a lot to prove when he inherited Doctor Who in 2010, and he clearly knew it. Adopting the formula of Davies' series for his first year €“ a straight run of 13 episodes, some standalone stories and some two-parters €“ he also decided that the story arc should stay too, and his was the best of them all. Not a repeated, largely meaningless term that only applied to the finale, nor a too-heavily focused, convoluted mess of ideas that largely fell by the wayside, the Cracks in Time arc is simultaneously a series-long story in its own right and a series of developments just subtle enough to allow the various episodes to be enjoyed by themselves. In short, it was a triumph. It's exciting; things change throughout so that Amy Pond gets an entire, three-episode mini-arc of her own later in the series as the crack erases all memory of her deceased husband Rory. We gradually learn more as we go, rather than having it all dumped on us at the end; the Weeping Angels are scared of the crack? Wow. It was caused by the TARDIS exploding? Holy cow. It can erase people from time but time travellers alone will retain memory of them once their gone? Interesting. In fact, this latter plot twist served a greater purpose for the show as a whole; the Earthlings of the Whoniverse had gradually become somewhat jaded by the notion of intelligent life beyond the stars - they see it every other week (to the point where they readily leave London at Christmas time in anticipation of another invasion). Moffat wonderfully restores some semblance of wonder and mystery to the world as we can now assume that many of these incidents have likely been erased by the ever-present cracks, thus forgotten about, and as such the people of Earth can go back to being actually surprised when aliens turn up. Amy can't remember the Daleks, after all, and nobody remembers a giant Cyberman traipsing around Victorian London either. Ultimately, of course, this all builds up to possibly the most perfectly crafted, moving series finale in the show's history. Everything comes to a head in an epic, celebratory romp spanning across time and featuring every monster the show has ever had (or at least the ones who's costumes were still knocking about in the BBC wardrobes). The beginning of the Moffat era came to a beautiful close, and although it was all up and down from there, at least we got one masterpiece out of it.