When Russell T Davies officially departed Doctor Who n 2010, the choice for the next showrunner was fairly obvious. Steven Moffat. After all, Moffat had already written some of the best episodes of Davies run, and fans were salivating at the prospect of his increased involvement in the show. Four seasons later, reactions to Moffats tenure as showrunner have been mixed, to say the least. Hes proven that hes capable of churning out such classics as the epic two-parter The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang and the instantly classic The Day of the Doctor. At the same time, though, fans have been forced to endure such dreck as the overly-convoluted Silence arc of Series 6, not to mention the annoyingly inconsistent characters (Clara in Series 8, anyone?) and the frivolous overuse of the same plot elements and tropes. As Moffat moves into his fifth season as showrunner, rumblings have already begun as to who will replace him when he ultimately decides to depart. Rumours have circulated, speculation is rampant, but one thing is clear: The answer is nowhere near as clear-cut as it was with Davies departure, leaving Whovians everywhere pretty worried for the direction of the show after the Grand Moff takes his final bow. This list compiles the top 10 choices for the new showrunner of Doctor Who.To be clear, this factors both the likelihood of the selection as well as whether or not the respective choice would be any good. Off we go, then!
10. Steve Thompson
Why He Should: Um... hes friends with Moffat? Also, he wrote the best episode of Sherlock, The Reichenbach Fall, which is something. Why He Shouldnt: Of all the names on this list, Thompson is most likely the one to garner the most fan backlash. His writing for Sherlock has been somewhat stellar, but hes also responsible for two of the worst episodes of Moffats run - Series 6's dreadfully dull The Curse of the Black Spotand Series 7's overly pointless Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS. Series 8's Thompson and Moffat-penned Time Heist was somewhat of an improvement, though, but theres nothing, as of yet, in Thompsons Doctor Who repertoire to indicate that he would be a good showrunner. The only thing keeping him in consideration? His close relationship with Moffat. Speaking of which...
9. Mark Gatiss
Why He Should: Gatiss and Moffat are the only two writers currently writing for Doctor Who who were around for the first season of the shows revamp. A self-proclaimed massive Whovian, Gatiss has written several episodes over the shows eight series run, including the wonderfully realised TV movie An Adventure in Space and Time, which aired as part of the shows 50th anniversary celebrations last year. He also co-showruns Sherlockwith Moffat, so it would make sense that Moffat would want to hand the show over to a friend, and Gatiss extensive experience writing for the show would instill some confidence in his showrunning ability. Why He Shouldnt: For as much as Gatiss has written for Doctor Who, he has yet to churn out an objectively great episode. If Series 8's Robot of Sherwood is an indication of anything, its that Gatiss prefers pulpy storytelling with an emphasis on one-liners and gags, rather than telling stories of any real substance. Although his writing for both Doctor Who and Sherlockhas been consistently solid, Gatiss just doesnt seem to have the writing chops to sketch out an entire season-long arc and produce multiple quality episodes that this coveted showrunner role would demand of him. With that being said, keep on acting Mark! Game of Thronesis made ten times better with your presence.
8. Jamie Mathieson
Why He Should: Mathieson was easily the best new writer that Moffat brought onto the show for Series 8. Both of his offerings, that's Mummy on the Orient Express and Flatline, were among its highlights. Flatline showed that he could generate original ideas and flesh them out satisfyingly, while Mummy was a display of his ability to put a fresh twist on a classic tale (both of which are skills necessary for a good showrunner at the helm of a beast like Doctor Who). Also helping his case is the fact that Mathieson has no prior involvement with the show. His selection would therefore be the breath of fresh air that Whovians have been gasping for. Why He Shouldnt: Simply put, showrunning is a very difficult job. Mathieson has no prior experience with the role, and doesnt even have extensive experience writing for television (his previous credits include a handful of episodes of Being Human... and thats just about it). Going forward, Mathieson is probably best utilised in the same role Moffat was prior to Series 5, as a one-off writer to keep things fresh. Then, after the next showrunner, who knows?
7. Gareth Roberts
Why He Should: As far as experience with Doctor Whogoes, Roberts is second only to Gatiss on this list. He has consistently churned out quality episodes, and shows a certain deftness when it comes to balancing the dramatic and comedic aspects of the show. Additionally, Roberts has been a consistent writing partner for both Davies and Moffat, and who didnt love the pairing of James Corden and Matt Smith in Series 5's The Lodger and Series 6's Closing Time? Why He Shouldnt: For as much fun as Roberts writing is, he has a tendency to cop out when it comes to endings. Closing Time came way too close to the clichéd love conquers all ending, and then there was Danny Pinks ridiculous flip at the end of The Caretaker. Much like Gatiss pulpy style, Roberts writing probably wouldnt translate too well to a showrunning role.
6. Chris Chibnall
Why He Should: Whats interesting about Chibnalls writing for Doctor Whois that it seems to have regressed over the years. His first work, Series 3's 42, is an intensely-paced episode with a real-time gimmick that makes it hugely addictive to watch. Dinosaurs on a Spaceship is also an extremely fun episode, although it does have a strangely dark ending. Broadchurch, Chibnalls major piece of work outside of Doctor Who(though it also stars our beloved David Tennant) has been a hit, with an American remake in the can and a second UK series on its way. Chibnall therefore does have the showrunning experience that would make him a sensible choice for the BBC. Why He Shouldnt: As aforementioned, Chibnalls work on Doctor Who has seemed to get worse over time. His two parter, The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood, is all too forgettable, while The Power of Three seeminglyforgot to have an ending. Whovians are not too fond of his work, and the fan backlash over his appointment would most likely be the fiercest reaction to anyone on this list (barring Steve Thompson). Hes also hard work at work on series two of Broadchurchand a possible second season of Gracepoint, so Chibnall appears to be fully booked up for the foreseeable future, at least.
5. Anthony Horowitz
Why He Should: The main reason that Horowitzs name is on this list is because earlier this year, there was a rumour circulating that Moffat was departing after Series 9 and that he was going to choose Horowitz as his successor. Horowitz denied the rumour, but it inevitably got Whovians thinking. His past writing shows that Horowitz has a wide range as a writer, with the young adult Alex Rider book series showing an adventurous side, the under appreciated Diamond Brothers book series showing a humorous side, and the masterful Foyle's War showing a dramatic side. This variety would translate perfectly to Doctor Who and Horowitzs selection would be a brilliant move on the BBCs part. Why He Shouldnt: Unfortunately, Horowitz has himself stated that the rumour was false. He also is currently writing the screenplay for the Tintin sequel Prisoners of he Sun, and has other projects underway, so he would most likely be too busy to take on showrunning duties. As a fun piece of trivia, Steven Moffat wrote the screenplay for the first Tintin film, The Secret of the Unicorn, but was unable to perform any rewrites because he had to return to writing Doctor Who. Could the same happen with Horowitz? Time will tell.
4. Neil Cross
Why He Should: One word: Luther. The Idris Elba-starring cop drama was one of the most underrated shows on TV prior to the conclusion of the third series. Cross wrote some of the most compelling character drama with John Luther, the protagonist, and the intense, and sometimes even scary, nature of the show would be brilliant to see transported into Doctor Who.Cross would also certainly bring prestige to the show in the way Moffat did, after a bounty of award nominations and wins for Luther. Why He Shouldnt: As great as Luther has been (seriously, watch it), Cross writing for Doctor Who has been met with mixed reviews. The Rings of Akhaten was extremely divisive (come on people, the speech at the end makes the whole episode worth it), while Hilewas a formulaic, if somewhat frightening, offering. Since this track record is shaky, the BBC should be wary about selecting Cross as showrunner. Also, Lutherwas thankfully just confirmed for a two-part miniseries, so Cross focus will be on that for the near future, anyway.
3. Toby Whithouse
Why He Should: Its not much of a stretch to say that Whithouse and Roberts are the two most similar writers on this list. Both writers enjoy their comedic escapades (Whithouses Vampires of Veniceis an extremely funny episode), but Whithouse has proven to be more adept at writing intriguing, psychological episodes. Series 6's The God Complexis a hugely underrated examination of the Doctors psyche, and Series 7's A Town Called Mercy is an interesting, albeit tired presentation, of the Doctors guilt over the Time War. Seeing an entire season planned out by Whithouse could be an extremely involving watch, and would fall in line with Moffats more introspection-heavy Series 8. Why He Shouldnt: There really arent many obvious downsides to Whithouses selection. His continued involvement with the show makes his selection fairly likely. Why is he ranked third on this list? The next two selections would be less likely choices, but theyd also be far more dynamic.
2. Catherine Tregenna
Why She Should: The mantra that Doctor Who needs more female writers has practically become a cliché at this point. Although JK Rowlings name has been thrown around a couple of times, Tregenna is reported to be the one chosen by the Grand Moff to write for the show's upcoming ninth series. Doctor Whohas never been the best when it comes to writing female characters, as Russell T Davies came close to competently writing companions, only to ruin it by turning them into deus ex machinas at the end of their respective series. Moffats shown improvement, but considering where he started, thats not really saying much. Clara is still way too inconsistent of a character. When a female Doctor is inevitably cast, Tregenna would be the best choice to write her, as she has a background in writing for Torchwood. Her selection would also help dispel some accusations of sexism that have been lobbed at Doctor Whoin more recent years. Why She Shouldnt: Simply selecting a female showrunner does not guarantee quality. It would be best to assess Tregennas chances after her episode in Series 9 is released, to see how well she can write for Doctor Who.Her lack of experience is really the only reason as to why she would be a questionable pick. Other than that, Tregennas appointment would be met with mostly unanimous acclaim. Why is she not number one? Lets explore...
1. Neil Gaiman
Why He Should: Gaiman is among the brightest minds working in the business right now. The first episode he wrote for Doctor Who, The Doctor's Wife, is easily one of the best episodes of NuWho, while his second escapade, Nightmare in Silver, managed to make the Cybermen scary again, even if the episode as a whole is quite uneven. Both episodes are wild fun, and visually stunning, and Gaimans track record outside of Doctor Whois practically flawless. His novels, highlighted by American Gods, are all fantastic, and fans are drooling at the prospect of a Sandmanmovie. Gaimans creativity and ingenuity would blend spectacularly with what Doctor Who can offer, and his selection would undoubtedly make the show feel fresh again. Why He Shouldnt: Gaiman is essentially the British Guillermo del Toro. The man is incredibly busy as of right now, and seems to prefer working on multiple projects at once, rather than just focusing on one project for a lengthy period of time. Also, his maniacal writing style may grow tiresome over the course of a season, but Whovians would still be no doubt thrilled to see his creativity at work. The overriding verdict? Very unlikely, but it would certainly be an exciting move. What are your thoughts? Who would be your choice to take over after Moffat? Someone on this list, or a dark horse?