Doctor Who: The Vanquishers Review - 4 Ups & 9 Downs

Let’s be honest… we saw this coming.

By Alex Cuthbert /

The Flux is over. This fun little format experiment has certainly had its ups and downs (we know all about those here), but how did The Vanquishers wrap up all those sprawling plot threads? Did Chibs finally learn how to write a finale, or did we just witness the biggest mess of a conclusion since Game of Thrones?

Advertisement

We had a lot going on at the end of last week: Swarm and Azure had just killed off Tecteun before she could achieve anything; The Sontarans were back for revenge, allying themselves with The Grand Serpent; Kate Stewart was back in the fray; our companions were trapped in the past; and we had Vinder and Bel both making unlikely alliances. That sounds like a lot to wrap up in an hour...

There’s lots to talk about this week, so we’re going to need to jump from point to point faster than Chris Chibnall frantically trying to resolve a plot. Don’t worry, you’ll be alright, we’re all used to how that feels by now…

13. DOWN - Cliffhanger Schmiffhanger

Another episode, another cliffhanger resolved instantaneously.

Advertisement

Last week, we saw The Doctor facing imminent disintegration whilst her friends prepared to defend themselves against a horde of Sontarans. We knew, as per previous weeks, these cliffhangers would be swiftly dealt with, but this week there didn’t even seem to be an attempt to prolong the tension.

The Sontarans in the tunnels are dealt with by Yaz, who opens a door that leads to ‘rays of death’, which promptly zap the Sontarans. This is a fine enough resolution, which was at least seeded last week, but it happens so quickly that the threat they are under barely registers before it is dealt with.

As for The Doctor, she escapes by ducking and then running away to the other side of the room whilst Swarm and Azure lose interest. That’s literally it. Boy, Swarm and Azure sure do like telling people they’re going to kill them and then not following through, don’t they?

12. DOWN - Triple Threat

After a brief chat with the Ood (who, despite being in cahoots with The Doctor, has just sort of been left to wander around), The Doctor rips off her conversion plate just as Swarm places a hand on her. As it turns, this has a truly remarkable result. The plate has the ability to split the main character across three plots simultaneously - this is the greatest stroke of luck in the history of strokes of luck.

Advertisement

The subsequent scenes contain some of the worst editing in the history of the show, and are incredibly disorientating. It’s barely explained to us what is happening, and what little context we get is drowned out completely by a mess of noise - so much so that we missed this on our first watch. The end result? The Doctor is still on The Division ship and has failed to escape, but she’s also in the side plot, because it wasn’t overcrowded enough already.

Later, we discover that The Doctor isn’t just teleporting about, but in fact has split herself in three and exists in three places simultaneously. Just as we get used to this, two of The Doctors meet each other, spending a portion of the episode together. The problem is, unlike previous stories with identical Doctors such as Journey’s End and The Almost People, the episode makes no attempt to distinguish these two versions, and also almost never has both of them in one shot, making every scene with both of them in more than a little confusing.

11. DOWN - A Crowded TARDIS

And you thought three companions was too many…

Advertisement

Try ten.

The Doctors gang this week consists of: Yaz, Dan, Vinder, Bel, Joseph Williamson, Karvanista, Kate Stewart, Jericho, Claire and Di. If that sounds like too many characters to possibly give anybody any screen time, that’s because it is, and everyone suffers for it. We’ll cycle through some of the biggest victims of this overcrowding now, quick-fire style:

Yaz and Dan do almost nothing for the entirety of this episode, being relegated completely to the background. Dan should be pretty used to this, given he hasn’t been relevant since episode two. He actually has less bearing on the plot of this series than Di from Liverpool, which is hilarious.

Joseph Williamson is no longer needed, and is immediately sent through a door that removes him from the plot. At least he gets a Hollywood Handshake for his trouble. We suspect some of his scenes may have been cut, as we never did see Dan’s flash-forward from Once, Upon Time come to fruition. Bit shoddy, that.

Vinder and Bel are completely robbed of a suitably touching reunion, being given around thirty seconds for the moment their entire story has been building towards. Vinder is also conveniently cut off before he can explain who The Grand Serpent actually is. On the bright side, I think we’re all glad that they didn’t turn out to be The Doctor’s parents.

Finally, and perhaps most egregiously: the absolute disrespect that this episode showed to our girl, Kate Stewart. Chibnall brings back this fan favourite to have her stand around in some tunnels for the whole episode, say nothing of any worth, and have her hero moment overshadowed by Vinder. It’s almost as if she was bought back for pure nostalgia, but Chibnall wouldn’t do that, would he? I mean it’s not like he’s done this before…

10. UP - The Interrogation

Okay. Let’s all take a breather and look at something this episode did right. The first real highlight of the episode comes when The Grand Serpent takes The Doctor in for interrogation. Fun as Craig Parkinson is, it isn’t him that makes this scene great, it’s Jodie.

Advertisement

The Doctor immediately takes control of the situation and becomes the interrogator, belittling The Grand Serpent and getting under his skin, all whilst cracking a few jokes - this may just be the most Doctor-like scene of the series. Watching The Grand Serpent get torn down like this is incredibly satisfying, and is exactly the way you’d expect the Doctor to deal with an arrogant, pretentious character. We also get a fairly flimsy explanation of The Grand Serpent’s motives, but it’s better than nothing.

The Doctor is then saved by herself, and whilst we complained about this earlier, this is the one scene where this really works. The Doctor’s flirty interactions with herself are pretty funny, and the scene isn’t shot in a completely confusing way, unlike the rest. We will, however, knock off a few points for Thirteen subjecting her interrogator to his own torture device - this seems just a tad against her moral code. More on that later…

9. DOWN - CHOCOLAAAATE

This scene was horrible, just horrible.

Advertisement

There is a fine line that must be walked with the Sontarans. Yes, they’re comic relief, and this is what makes them such fun villains, but this should not come at the expense of their credibility, especially in a series finale. This is a balance that Chibnall nailed in War Of The Sontarans. Unfortunately, he didn’t manage it here.

The entire planet is under threat, there are three planet-ending armies in orbit, and The Flux is fast approaching, and yet time is devoted to this silly scene in a corner shop. It feels completely out of whack with the scope and stakes of the episodes, and the central joke, unlike the comedy in the rest of the series, really doesn’t land. It was bordering on cringeworthy.

8. UP - (Doctor) Who Let The Dogs Out?

If there’s one character we could rely on to bring their A game this week, it was Karvanista. Craig Els has smashed it this season, and managed to display a surprising amount of emotion this week despite being buried deep within a hairy dog mask. Massive props.

Advertisement

First, we get a scene in which Karvanista and Thirteen have an open chat for the first time, with Karvanista revealing that his memories of The Doctor are intact, unlike hers, and that once upon a time they were very close, hinting that he was a companion to her. He also tells The Doctor that he is implanted with a chip that will poison him if he reveals the truth about the past. This scene is given room to breathe and as a result the emotional beats all land, and given the set-up it provides, we reckon we haven’t heard the last of this pooch.

We also get the soul-crushing reveal that The Sontarans have killed every single Lupari, leaving Karvanista as the last of his kind. Whilst we never saw any of the other Lupari on screen, the idea of doggy-genocide is still very upsetting, and the intensity radiating from Craig Els’ eyes really sells this for us. Later, Karvanista gets his big moment by removing the Sontaran’s protection from The Flux, and we were right there cheering with him.

Best new character of the series? He’s a strong contender for sure.

7. DOWN - Rambling And Technobabble

This episode does a lot of explaining away with paper-thin science mumbo-jumbo. Whilst this is hardly a new thing in Doctor Who, it does become a problem when the plot hinges so heavily on it.

Advertisement

There’s also a lot of nonsense talk in this episode, particularly from Swarm and Azure, who don’t make much sense at all for ninety percent of the run time. We’d like to focus on one scene in particular for this point: The conversation between Thirteen and Azure aboard the Division ship.

This scene seems to think it’s a lot smarter than it is, but in reality it goes nowhere and provides no insight or plot development. Azure essentially tells The Doctor: “I’m super evil and I don’t understand why you’re good” - the Doctor, in turn responds by saying “Yeah, well, I’m super good and I don’t understand why you’re evil”.

We don’t really understand either, Doctor.

Truly gripping writing…

6. DOWN - Vinder And Di’s Pointless Adventure

This wins the most dumb plot of the week award. Poor Vinder is relegated to the D-plot (or is it E-plot) this time, and he does absolutely nothing. Last week, he had a plan, but it turns out that I’m reality he just completely screwed himself over and got himself trapped inside Passenger. Luckily, he has a secret weapon: Di from Liverpool, and she’s got a score to settle.

Advertisement

And that’s not all: she’s also been practicing at Lazerquest.

The amount of screen time Di gets this episode is laughably unjustified, as is the fact that she’s become an expert on Passenger Forms - no seriously, Vinder even offers her a bloody job with the alliance military, or whatever it is that he’s from.

Di, who has conveniently been spared a grisly death-by-ravager for plot reasons, leads this experienced military man through Passenger, pointing out the glowy exit button to Vinder, that she somehow knows about but also hasn’t thought to use. The two then proceed to escape this incredibly secure (and actually seemingly quite pleasant) prison and are immediately zapped back in. Luckily, Passenger doesn’t bother to do the same to The Doctor when she attempts to rescue them, and she quickly waltzes in with her TARDIS to pick them up. That was easy. Speaking of the TARDIS, did anyone notice that the doors went back to normal this episode, before the Flux was even resolved?

Di’s final scene in this series saw her dumping Dan pretty brutally, which was unexpected. She still seems to be hung up on him being late to their date, which seems forgivable given the circumstances, what with the apocalypse happening. Maybe she just realised he’s sort of useless?

5. DOWN - The Sontaran Stratagem

The Sontarans bought the thunder this episode, coming to the party armed with a fairly solid plan. That is, if you ignore the terrible science and can suspend your disbelief enough to buy that The Flux, which we’ve seen eat solar systems for breakfast, would be halted by eating up a couple of hundred Dalek and Cyber ships.

Advertisement

Yes, in this episode, The Sontarans outmanoeuvre the two most powerful and feared races in the galaxy, and do so successfully (for a moment anyway). We don’t have an issue with this, in fact, it’s nice to see an underestimated foe like the Sontarans beat the often unstoppable Daleks. There’s just one problem with this. To make this work, the plot had to ignore two very fundamental character traits for these two villains.

Firstly, the Sontarans are ruthless and bloodthirsty, but they have always been defined as honourable combatants, who resolve all conflicts on the battlefield and do not resort to manipulation. To promise an alliance then betray the Daleks is most definitely dishonourable.

Secondly, the Daleks believe all other life to be inferior, and as established in Doomsday, would never accept an alliance with another species, even if they were dooming themselves in the process.

These aren’t the only character traits thrown to one side to accommodate this plot, as the Doctor stands idly by, actively encouraging Karvanista as he commits what appears to be a Sontaran genocide. Need we remind you that earlier this season Thirteen popped off at General Logan for blowing up the retreating Sontaran forces? Bit of a hypocrite, really.

Also, on the topic of The Doctor, she also contradicts herself in this episode, by first stating that she’s seen many people allying with The Sontarans during her negotiation, then later announcing in the TARDIS that it’s very unlike the Sontarans to make an alliance.

4. UP - Going Out Like A Boss

We had a feeling this might happen, but it didn’t make it any easier. This week, something dreadful happened. We lost Jericho to the Flux. So much for that spin-off…

Advertisement

This man has been a highlight of the past three episodes, thanks to the wonderful acting of Kevin McNally, and we wish he’d have become a full time companion. But someone had to go in a high stakes story like this, and quite frankly he was the only feasible option.

His plot this episode wasn’t particularly interesting, nor did it have much bearing on the plot besides making sure he was in the right place to die, but he was still a joy to watch, and his death was scripted, shot and scored extremely well. He didn’t sacrifice himself per se, but that didn’t mean this man didn’t go out like a hero. He stood his ground, accepting his fate, he comforted his friends and even took the time to make one last cheerful quip before being engulfed by The Flux.

Rest in peace, sweet prince. You will be missed.

3. DOWN - A Waste Of Fluxing Time

Somewhere along the line, Chibnall seems to have forgotten that this series was titled Doctor Who: Flux, because this compelling narrative device has fallen completely to the wayside, playing second fiddle to pretty much every other plot. You might as well have called this series Doctor Who: The Division or Doctor Who And The Incredibly Long Expositionary Monologue.

Advertisement

After wiping out The Sontarans, Daleks and Cybermen, The Flux is dealt with by chucking Chekhov’s Passenger Form at it. The infinite matter within the passenger cancels out the antimatter of the Flux, and the universe is saved. Whose idea was this? Who gets the big hero moment of stopping the Flux once and for all? We can’t believe we’re actually saying this, but it’s Di. That’s right, Di from bloody Liverpool stopped the Flux. You have got to be kidding us. This should have been Yaz or Dan, maybe even Vinder or Bel. In fact, anyone but Di.

If all we needed to stop the Flux was infinite matter, then why didn’t the TARDIS, which is infinite in size, stop the Flux in episode one, instead of just teleporting the gang away?

But that’s not all. The Flux was never reversed, not that the plot seems to realise this. Intentionally or not, this series of Doctor Who resulted in 99% of the universe being destroyed, and trillions upon trillions of lives being lost. Most of the species and planets in the universe are gone. Considering this, everyone seems to be remarkably chill, chiefly The Doctor, who seems pretty happy-go-lucky in the scene where her and Yaz recruit Dan to the TARDIS team.

2. DOWN - The Mother Of All Anticlimaxes

This is the biggest disappointment of all, and indeed, the most nonsensical plot resolution of the bunch. Swarm and Azure were finally back in the spotlight this week, and after starting this series as a pair of very compelling villains, they completely fell off a cliff.

Advertisement

These two, after babbling incoherently for much of the runtime, as previously mentioned, decide to take the Doctor to Atropos to witness the unshackling of Time. No, not Time as a concept, Time as a physical, sentient being (but we’ll forgive you if you missed that, because it was totally under-explained). Yup, it turns out that time is conscious, and it’s a bit of a d***head, to be honest.

Remember that terrible blue CGI dust from episode three? Well, it turns out that was the real big bad all along. It’s also purple now. As a punishment for their failure, Time obliterates Swarm and Azure, though they seem to enjoy this. This is a very, very unceremonious end for these two. We guess this is payback for them unceremoniously killing the last big bad last episode - what goes around comes around. We would have liked the answer to one small question before the Ravagers bit the dust though: WHO WERE THEY? We know nothing about their species, their seemingly godlike powers, or their devotion to destroying space on behalf of Time. Also, why on Earth was Azure disguised as a human in the Arctic circle in episode one? What a waste.

Anyway, back to Time. Time has been defeated thanks to the prevention of the final Flux event (not sure why it has a segmented schedule like this) and as a result remains shackled. At this point, it shrugs and gives up, uniting the Doctor’s three fragments and wishing her on her merry way, but not before delivering a spooky foreboding monologue.

Time tells Thirteen that she is going to die soon because Russell wants his show back, and warns her of the forces moving against her, led by their master. The Doctor has no idea what this means. I mean, who could this MASTER be? Such a mystery, if only their were some clue as to the identity of this MASTER. This scene made Thirteen look incredibly dim. Give her some credit, Chris….

Weirdly, The Grant Serpent’s defeat was left until last this episode, after the big climax, and he was disposed of like an absolute chump. Just put a terrible bow on this very poorly wrapped anticlimax.

1. UP - A Tender Moment

We’re pleased to say that this episode actually ended on a high note.

Advertisement

We actually don’t mind The Doctor holding onto the pocket watch and saving it until she is ready - she’s been through a lot recently, and quite frankly, so have we. We just hope that when the time does come to tell the story of The Doctor’s missing years, it isn’t a rushed, convoluted mess.

However, the real highlight of these closing scenes was the touching final moment between Thirteen and Yaz, with the Doctor finally opening up to a companion for the first time in her era, telling Yaz the truth and confessing she was wrong to push Yaz away. This is some solid character development for an incarnation of The Doctor who has always played her cards very close to her chest, and the moment is beautifully played by Jodie and Mandip. Also, if there were any doubts that a romance was being hinted at before, it’s difficult to deny now after that lingering shared look. Looking at Jodie’s remaining episode count, it doesn’t take a mathematician to work out that this probably isn’t going to end well for these two…

Regardless, this was a nice epilogue to the dissapointment that came before, so that’s something to take away, at least.

Advertisement