Doctor Who: William Hartnell’s 10 Best Episodes

By Max Beeman /

Many fans new to Who tend to overlook some of the classic Doctors. Chief among the overlooked is William Hartnell since not only are his episodes are not only in black and white, but a good chunk of them are 'lost.' However, the William Hartnell episodes were trailblazers €“ they created the guidelines of how the show should be, and they created who the Doctor is and what he stood for. Though the Doctor has changed through his 11 generations (or 12 if you count John Hurt), his moral code was created in the first four seasons, and he always abides by it. Being 50 years old, some episodes are slightly worse for wear than today €“ for example, they've really taken a hit on acting, and effects €“ but it is worth the watch. And what better way to celebrate 50 years than to to go back to the start? So join me now as I go through William Hartnell's 10 Best Episodes. WARNING! This may contain spoilers. Decades-old spoilers,but spoilers nonetheless.

10. An Unearthly Child

Advertisement

Episode: Season 1, Episode 1

Companions: Barbara Wright, Ian Chesterton, Susan Foreman

Advertisement
The show starts out with the Doctor and his Granddaughter, Susan Foreman. Susan is trying to live a normal life by going to school in England. Her teachers Ian Chesterfield €“ sorry I mean Chesterton €“ and Barbara Wright notice how peculiarly Susan has been acting in school, and decide to check up on her after hours. They find that Susan lives in a garbage dump, along with an old man living a police box. Thinking that he locked Susan away inside they barge in and find that it is "bigger on the inside!" The old man, the Doctor, tells them that they cannot go back to their homes anymore, and he dematerializes the TARDIS. Since the TARDIS had a faulty directional circuit when the Doctor stole it, he cannot control where or when he lands, so he must wander through eternity aimlessly, gaining and losing companions along the way. Within the first episode the show has established not only who the Doctor is, but also the grand theme of the "lonely wanderer." Even though the Doctor essentially kidnapped Ian and Susan, he later finds that he needs a companion on his journeys. What makes this episode great is not the story-line, but the establishment it brought. Any episode today directly ties back in with "Unearthly Child" for the sense of adventure that it created. In all honesty the story with the cavemen is one of the most boring episodes in the series, but it is definitely worth the watch to find out what the first Doctor was like.

9. The Space Museum

Advertisement

Episode: Season 2, Episode 7

Companions: Barbara Wright, Ian Chesterton, Susan Foreman

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands on the planet Xeros, where the Doctor and his crew find a "Space Museum" containing artifacts such as a Dalek. The TARDIS apparently skipped a time track and they find their future selves on display in an exhibit. Time then reverts to normal and the crew determines that they must do all they can to change the future. This episode brought forth the idea of time being a dimension in the show, it also challenges the idea of time travel and what can be re-written. Throughout the entire episode the crew is conflicted with the idea of fate, and how to change it. The Doctor rarely goes into how it worked out in the end and regarded it as "time and relative dimensions!" in more modern terms we can understand that that really means "wibily wobily, timey wimey!" Though the show doesn't have a strict rule of how the science of time travel works, the show stays true that minor events can be changed, however certain things will never change, no matter how hard you try to prevent it.

8. The Celestial Toymaker

Advertisement

Episode: Season 3, episode 7

Companions: Steven Taylor, Dorothea "Dodo" Chaplet

Advertisement
Certain episodes have been "lost" in the BBC archive when they wrote over the tapes to save money. However, the audio from the episode, the script, and a few pictures allow certain episodes to be "reconstructed". Hopefully, the BBC re-discovers those episodes like they did with "Web of Fear," but until then the reconstructions are all that are left of the lost episodes. Even though it is tasking to watch, certain episodes are definitely worth it. The Celestial Toymaker starts with the TARDIS landing in the 'celestial toy-room' where the Doctor is rendered invisible. The TARDIS crew meets an immortal being named the Celestial Toymaker. Apparently, the Doctor has met the Toymaker before, and he has pulled him back for another game. The Toymaker reveals his game, that the Doctor must solve a puzzle in the exact same time that his companions get through their games, or they will be his subjects for eternity. The Toymaker also makes the Doctor unable to speak so he is unable to help his companions, Steven and Dodo. In a battle of wits, the Doctor and his Companions struggle against the Toymaker for their freedom. One of the things that's amazing about the show is the locations they go to. This episode is great because with each part it begins with a riddle, so as the episode goes on you can try to solve the puzzle along with Steven and Dodo. The Toymaker is a great adversary, since he always stays one step ahead from the Doctor (at least it seems that way up until the last part). The Doctor and the Toymaker are equal to each other in intelligence, making the Toymaker's game even more fantastic to watch. The lack of video does hinder the quality, but if you have time it is definitely worth the watch.

7. Planet Of Giants

Advertisement

Episode: Season 2, Episode 1

Companions: Barbara Wright, Ian Chesterton, Susan Foreman

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands in a jungle with giant dead insects. Ian, Barbara, Susan and the Doctor later find that they are actually on earth, and have shrunk to about an inch. The group separates, and meanwhile a scientist talks about a new insecticide he created named DN6 telling an industrialist that it is far too harmful to insect life and cannot be used yet. The industrialist, Forester, kills the scientist to take DN6 for himself. The TARDIS crew discoverers his crime and seek to bring Forester to justice, while also trying to revert themselves to normal size. In a "Honey I Shrunk the Kids" scenario, the crew must travel by drainpipe, escape the dangerous forces of a cat, and go through the excruciating task of operating a telephone. There is no better word for this episode than "fun". Today we don't have as limited resources as back then, so it's incredible just seeing how they shrink the characters down to size with massive matchboxes and giant sinks. The dual plot-line of the story also makes it far more enjoyable to watch.

6. The Chase

Episode: Season , Episode 8

Advertisement

Companions: Barbara Wright, Ian Chesterton, Vicki, Steven Taylor

After their first encounter on Skaro, and the Doctor foiling their plans in "the Dalek Invasion of Earth", The Daleks find the Doctor as their greatest foe and decide to EXTERMINATE him. The Daleks discover how to travel through the time vortex, enabling them to chase the Doctor and finish off their greatest foe. If you really just want to watch one episode to see how the William Hartnell years were, this would be the best episode to watch by far. This story goes through several locations, such as a haunted mansion, a ship, the Empire State building, as well as a movie set where they're filming a villain's plot to kill a damsel in distress using a sawmill. This grand story contains several other mini-stories adding to the experience, and is also the last episode we see from Barbara and Ian. With the Dalek's time machine containing a functional directional circuit, they talk to the Doctor about returning to their time, even though their time in the TARDIS would be the best years of their lives. The Doctor reluctantly lets them leave with his only words on the subject being, "I will miss them, yes I shall miss them," marking one of the first depressing scenes of Classic Who. There's worse, trust me on it.

5. Dalek's Master Plan

Advertisement

Episode: Season 3, Episode 4

Companions: Steven Taylor, Katarina, Sarah Kingdom

Advertisement
The Daleks team up with several leaders of galactic governments, including guardian of the solar system, Mavic Chen. Mavic Chen offers the Daleks an element known as Taranium €“ which took 50 years to obtain €“ in exchange for power. The TARDIS lands on the planet Kembel, where the Doctor finds a tape left from a soldier in the episode "Mission to the Unknown" containing the Dalek's plans of universal control. The Doctor, knowing his enemy throughout time, decides to take on the Daleks, yet again in the most intense story-lines of the William Hartnell years. This episode is crazy. Besides Rory, new Who rarely kills off companions. However, in this episode Katarina dies in the second part. Also, Sarah Kingdom, who would have been a wonderful companion, dies in this episode after just starting to trust the Doctor. This episode features the return of the Meddling Monk, a rogue Time Lord set out for revenge against the Doctor. His timing could not be worse with the Daleks on the Doctor's trail for their Taranium. Apart from 3 episodes, this story is also lost, but it is still worth the watch for any loyal fan.

4. The War Machines

Advertisement

Episode: Season 3, Episode 10

Companions: Dorothea "Dodo" Chaplet, Ben Jackson, Polly Wright

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands on Earth 1966, and London's post office tower has recently been built. The Doctor and Dodo go to investigate and find that it is for a global computer system named WOTAN (Will Operating Thought ANalogue) that can compute anything in the universe (it even knew what TARDIS stood for!) and would be live the next evening. WOTAN decides that humans are incapable of taking care of themselves and decides to take control over the world. It uses mind control and has humans create "War Machines" programmed to rampage and kill anyone who resists WOTAN's cause. This episode raises the idea of computers, and if they would be safe. This episode is different from the rest because the Doctor is facing a machine. The Doctor has said from the start that it would be unsafe to have such technology and that WOTAN should be shut down. Humans don't listen as always, and guess who was right. This episode is very action-packed, and the first where the army came to the Doctors assistance. The best scene in this episode is when the Doctor turns a war machine against it's creator, and sets it out to destroy WOTAN. This episode is also the first time you meet Ben Jackson and Polly Wright, who also start off as companions for the second Doctor.

3. The Ark

Advertisement

Episode: Season 3, Episode 6

Companions: Dorothea "Dodo" Chaplet, Steven Taylor

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands on a spaceship in 10,000,000 AD. They find that the spaceship is an ark to another planet since the sun was about to expand and the Earth's new-found would be unsuitable for them. Among the humans are mute Monoids who are servants to the humans. Dodo reveals that she has a cold and various people on the ship catch it, and some die from it. The Doctor finds a cure, everyone is healed and they leave in the TARDIS. Good times ensue, the end. Or is it? The TARDIS materializes in the exact same place they left in, however they land 700 years later, where the crew of the spaceship are about to arrive at their destination. In the 700 years that have passed the Monoids have created voice communicators, and now treat the humans as slaves. The Monoids plan to kill off the humans upon their arrival at the planet, and take the planet for their own. The Doctor and his crew decide that it is up to them to help the humans and stop the Monoids. This episode is great because of the plot twist. It is really fascinating to see how time plays out. Instead of just ending the episode after two parts, the writers take it a step further and create another plot. The humans on the ark treat the Doctor as though he is legend, since all they know of him are stories from their ancestors, and even though he fights for the humans to live with the Monoids in harmony, the Monoids are set on the destruction of all human life. This episode reveal that more can change through time than we imagine.

2. The Keys of Marinus

Advertisement

Episode: Season 1, Episode 5

Companions: Barbara Wright, Ian Chesterton, Susan Foreman

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands on the planet Marinus where the crew meets a man named Arbitan, the keeper of the Conscience. The Conscience is a machine that eliminated all 'evil" thought, and kept justice throughout the planet. However, Yartek leader of the Voord discovered how to resist it. The Voord are determined to take control of the Conscience and use it to their advantage. Arbitan fixes the Conscience, but needs the five keys of Marinus to turn it on. To this end, he has the Doctor and his crew set on this mission, with the TARDIS being returned to them when they have completed their task. The five keys lie at different points on the planet, and the crew are given travel dials set to teleport to the locations of each different key. Though the task seems simple, it's obviously far from it. In this episode, like "The Chase," many different stories lie underneath the grand plot. Each episode entails a problem having to be solved, or a code to be cracked. In one case the crew must overthrow a hypnotic brain like creature before searching for their key. This episode is truly adventurous to say the least, and if you started watching William Hartnell, this is the episode that you accept him as a Doctor.

1. The Tenth Planet

Advertisement

Episode: Season 4, Episode 2

Companions: Ben Jackson, Polly Wright

Advertisement
The TARDIS lands on Earth 1986 on the South Pole, and the Doctor and his companions are brought inside a snowcap base near where the TARDIS landed. The base is running a routine check of the earth's atmosphere from the Zeus IV rocket, and while doing so they find a tenth planet approaching Earth. It is discovered that this is the planet Mondas, home of the Cybermen, and the Cybermen are leeching energy from the earth in order to fuel their planet. General Cutler, the man in charge of the base alerts their headquarters of the attack. His son is then set on a mission to save the Zeus IV rocket, and Cutler himself takes charge to attack Mondas, using the powerful Z-bomb directly against orders. The Doctor is weary and advises that the only action they take is to wait out the Cybermen since their planet would suffer from too much energy and die out on it's own. However Cutler is determined to destroy Mondas and save his son, even if it means the death of half the population. This episode marks the last of the William Hartnell years, and he surely left with a bang, even though the Doctor was only in the first and last part. The last episode is lost, but it has been recovered and well-restored with animation. It's really interesting seeing the origin of the Cybermen, and though 'Rise of the Cybermen' conflicts with this, it's assumed that one day the Cybermen from both dimensions met up and upgraded together since they share the same morales, and goals. This episode is also very intense, giving us dramatic grist for the mill with a power struggle, and the conflicting morals of the base. The struggle is not only with the Cybermen but through the base on how to handle the situation, and that makes for a compelling watch. William Hartnell created a base for how the show should be. He brought a sense of adventure, and brought viewers to fantastic places. Without William Hartnell, the show would not be how it is today. Be sure to watch "An Adventure Through Space and Time" on November 22nd to see how the show started off, and if you've got any comments, please leave them below!