Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best
The premium cable laugh factory's greatest successes and biggest flops.
HBO, the American premium cable behemoth, is probably best known for its dramatic output, with the likes of The Sopranos, The Wire, and many, many more already in the pantheon for all-time great weighty telly. But while the network may specialise in tales of life, death, betrayal, and all that serious stuff, it’s been no slouch in terms of laughs over the years.
From sitcoms, to sketch shows, to cutting edge 21st century content, HBO’s funny business has run the gamut, bringing in creatives from around the world, and fostering relationships with the best writers and performers around.
What’s more, they’ve all but reinvented the wheel several times, with some of their shows pioneering the format of the sitcom, the freedom granted by improvisation and single camera filming, and the simple ability to say and do what you want on a premium channel with no advertisers breathing down your necks.
It’s not all been plain sailing - as we’ll see, HBO’s bold approach has left the door open for some duds - but from the sigh inducing to the side splitting, here’s our view on HBO’s comedy output.
62. Ja'mie: Private School Girl
For a while, Chris Lilley seemed like he could be the next big thing in TV comedy. His shows We Can Be Heroes and, particularly, Summer Heights High mixed cringe humour with great characters and genuine heart. There were problematic elements (Lilley, a white man, plays most of the main characters, regardless of their background), but the show was empathetic, often sweet, and most importantly funny.
Then he did the same thing again and again. Ja’mie: Private School Girl isn’t quite his nadir, but it’s a fundamental misstep. Lilley takes one of his lesser characters from Summer Heights High, builds a whole show around her, but makes little effort to add any depth or character development across the interminable six-episode run.
That would be just fine if the jokes were on point - but they’re decidedly not. Ja’mie is a spoiled brat who’s abrasive and unpleasant, and that’s it. Lilley falls into the trap of refusing to allow his co-stars to do anything other than feed him cues - he wants every laugh for himself, and in this instance, they’re few and far between.
61. Angry Boys
The repetitive nature of Ja’mie: Private School Girl was the most obvious issue, but by no means was it the only problem. To wit: its direct predecessor, Angry Boys, in which Lilley plays half a dozen main characters, none of which are particularly interesting, though several of them are memorable for the wrong reasons.
Off the back of Summer Heights High, Lilley was understandably feeling untouchable, and accordingly makes some decisions that one could (very charitably) describe as daring. He plays an American rapper, donning full blackface and spouting lazy observations about the tendency for hip hop artists to exaggerate their street cred.
He portrays a Japanese housewife complete with an accent that was somehow cleared for international broadcast. He dips into the hoariest corners of the sketch cliche book, devising an old lady character who - get this - isn’t au fait with political correctness and says outrageous stuff.
Angry Boys lasted a punishing 12 episodes, and while it was by no means completely bereft of laughs, it was a true slog to get through, leaving a sour taste in its wake.
60. Little Britain USA
Little Britain’s heyday is just over 15 years in the past, but it feels a lifetime ago. The sketches by David Walliams and Matt Lucas feel regressive and lazy nowadays, and even the show in its absolute prime would be a hard watch, not least for some of the distasteful and often downright objectionable shock tactics they stooped to for laughs.
And Little Britain USA is not the show in its prime. By 2008 the pair had milked their characters for all they were worth (which wasn’t a great deal in a lot of cases), and accordingly had no choice but to hit the reset button across the pond. Vicky Pollard went to brat camp. Daffyd Thomas attended a US university. Lou and Andy went on holiday - the explanations were as simple and lazy as that.
The show continued to pull numbers in the UK, but the USA - presumably the target audience here - weren’t too fussed. The trip across the Atlantic put the final nail in the coffin for Little Britain as a series (though it returned for a few specials long after any remaining good will had fizzled out), so we can thank it for that at least.
59. The Mind Of The Married Man
In 2001, as HBO truly entered its pomp, the commissioners made the bizarre decision to pick up a regressive and lame comedy with a name that tells you everything you need to know from the off. It’s a show about marriage from the perspective of a man - finally, what we’ve all been waiting for: a male-led sitcom.
TMotMM clearly had an eye to becoming the boys’ version of Sex And The City, but in place of relatable characters, clever plots, romantic stories a viewer could invest in, and a groundbreaking perspective, you had a trio of oafs who grumble about their wives, who were unsurprisingly given very little to do in their meagre screentime.
There’s nothing you haven’t seen on network sitcoms for decades, only with adult content because it’s on HBO. Mike Binder stars, writes, directs, and clearly steers every aspect of this tedious and trite show.
It managed a full two seasons, for the most part picking up venomous reviews. Unfortunately we still see sitcoms of its ilk, but rarely as brazenly ugly as this one.
58. Life's Too Short
Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant’s once-lucrative creative partnership came to a stuttering end with this unoriginal, faux-edgy mock doc starring Warwick Davis as himself. Davis, who has dwarfism, is happy to be the butt of the joke and does his level best to keep the show from feeling exploitative, and his performance is to be praised.
That’s about all there is to enjoy here, though. Once again, Gervais, then the most powerful man in comedy, feels obliged to enhance his credentials as a guy who says what he wants, in spite of the fact no one is trying to stop him from doing so. He features heavily in the show and his presence can be felt as he giggles away at his un-PC material.
It also features endless celebrity cameos, reinforcing the notion that the creator cared more about making famous friends than quality TV. It’s derivative of Gervais and Merchant’s infinitely superior previous work, too: for all that Davis is a winning presence, he’s basically doing a David Brent impression.
57. Ballers
Remember Entourage? Well it’s back, in sports form! With the charisma machine Dwayne Johnson (who also co-created the show) in the lead role, it never sinks to the charmless depths of latter day Entourage, but neither does it reach the heights that show was once capable of. It’s consistently predictable, harmless fun that was probably a lot more enjoyable for the cast to make than it is for us to watch.
Johnson plays an ex-NFL star trying to figure out what to do with his professional sports days behind him. Not unlike Johnson himself, he essentially succeeds at everything he tries with the greatest of ease. It’s a comedy first and foremostly, so intricate plotting isn’t necessarily the show’s first priority, but the sheer lack of drama on show here makes Entourage look like a Michael Mann thriller.
The show has a warmth and easygoing appeal that makes it difficult to genuinely dislike, but the whole thing feels empty and a little pointless. As long as Dwayne had a good time, though, that’s the main thing.
56. Arliss
The Ballers of its day, Arliss too was a comedy about a sports agency that lasted a remarkable amount of time on TV despite really not being very good at all. The Robert Wuhl-starring sitcom lasted from 1996 to 2002, and was a divisive show in its time. With HBO yet to become truly established as a purveyor of great TV, the fact that some subscribers kept the network purely to watch Arliss meant that it was untouchable.
For everyone else, though, it was unbearable. Wuhl did his level best, playing an unscrupulous sports agent as the notion of the dislikable comedy protagonist became increasingly popular, but he left a lot to be desired as the star. The comedy is none more mid-’90s, full of sophomoric gay jokes and the like that have dated dreadfully.
It also made a habit of including celebrities (here sports stars) as warped versions of themselves while an HBO stablemate was doing the same thing with far more success. 80 episodes in, it finally ended.
55. Funny Or Die Presents
Sketch shows are by their nature a mixed bag, and this one was more mixed than most. Instead of giving over a timeslot to one performer or a troupe, Funny Or Die Presents… simply turned over control to Will Ferrell and Adam McKay’s website, allowing creatives of all stripes to air their material on the premium cable channel.
Some of it was great. This was the TV debut of Derek Waters’ Drunk History, one of the most enduring formats of modern comedy, and the show featured quality work from reliable hands like Tim & Eric, Zach Galifianakis, and Kristen Wiig.
There’ll always be sketches that don’t hit, though, and some of these fell flatter than flat. Most notable was Brett Gelman’s “1,000 Cats”, an extraordinarily long musical number that would have felt perfectly at home on the internet (where you could simply click off), but less so on TV, let alone on a network you specifically pay for.
11 years later, the idea of just sticking stuff from a website onto the telly seems incredibly outdated, and a lot of the content hasn’t aged too well.
54. Tracey Takes On...
For starring in the show that eventually brought us The Simpsons and much more in her career, Tracey Ullman will always be a legend, but her late ‘90s sketch show on HBO was more misfire than hit. Ullman is a gifted comic and sketch performer, and the material that works in Tracey Takes On… is as good as anything in her career, well worth revisiting.
Some of the less good stuff, though, is downright gross. The most cringe inducing is Mrs. Noh Nang Ning, a deeply troubling Asian character who runs a doughnut store. Everything about the character, from the look to the portrayal, is about as bad as you could imagine. Asian American groups protested about the presentation, but Ullman and HBO stuck to their guns, citing “satire” as the excuse.
There are decent characters in there too, and appearances from high quality comedic actors like Michael McKean and Julie Kavner, but the antiquated nature of some of the sketches makes this feel far more than 25 years old.
53. The Neistat Brothers
Casey and Van Neistat are two YouTubing brothers who’ve found fame (Casey especially) for their intimate and revealing autobiographical videos. Like most good YouTubers, they forge a relationship with their viewers, who feel more like friends as fans as the content creators invite us into their lives.
It’s a decent way to make a living, but compelling TV, it’s not. Your enjoyment of this will be very much dependent on how charming you find the Neistats. While there’s nothing objectionable about either of them, it can feel nigh on unbelievable that this is what passes for TV (premium TV at that) these days.
The series constitutes a day in the life of two guys who don’t do all that much, and don’t have an enormous amount to say for themselves. For the initiated, it’s no doubt great, and the brothers have found success for a reason, and through hard graft. For anyone else, it’s 30 minutes of watching a pair of ordinary guys strolling about.