Game Of Thrones: 10 Biggest Casting Mistakes

Simply being able to scream through your death scene isn’t enough.

By Alexander Pan /

There are many reasons why Game of Thrones is so critically acclaimed as a TV show, but somewhere near the top of the list is the fact it's got in incredible cast. Some characters have been so perfectly portrayed that it is impossible to imagine anyone else in those roles. Seriously, can you think of anyone else who could take on the role of Tyrion Lannister other than Peter Dinklage or the role of Arya Stark other than Maisie Williams? But not even Game of Thrones is immune to making mistakes. With such a large roster of major and minor characters, it is almost inevitable that a few errors in judgement have made by the producers. Whilst some casting choices have been perfect, there have been casting choices that have been so bad that even fans of these miscast characters have been wishing for their deaths just so they could be put out of their misery. After reviewing the large cast of characters who have been introduced over the last five years, here are the 10 biggest casting mistakes of the show, and hypothetical ideal casting choices that includes anyone ranging from Z-list actors to Hollywood royalty. As this list covers seasons one to five of the show, there may be a few spoilers lurking about.

10. Robert Pugh As Craster

Why It Was A Mistake: Robert Pugh gave a not-too-shabby performance as the utterly despicable and daughter-loving Craster. The thing is, not to diss Pugh's decent take on the character, TV-Craster is a somewhat inaccurate portrayal of his far creepier novel counterpart. In the novels, Craster is meant to be a withered old man who spent his whole life in the cold north, was father to 19 daughters/wives, and was on the brink of joining Game of Thrones' overly long list of dead characters. TV-Craster on the other hand is middle-aged, well-fed, relatively clean-cut, and seemingly had enough life in him to sire more daughters and wives into his twisted little family. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Bill Nighy is known for bringing a eccentric flavor to the wide range of comedic and dramatic characters he's portrayed over the years. As Craster is meant to be incredibly unsavoury individual, Nighy would totally rock the part and bring so much more to the character.

9. Nonso Anozie As Xaro Xhoan Daxos

Why It Was A Mistake: When adapting a novel to television or a movie, some odd casting choices are generally expected in order to properly the spirit of the novel on-screen. But then there are those casting choices, such as what the producers did here with Xaro Xhoan Daxos, which make you wander 'what the hell were they thinking?' In the novels, Xaro described as an wiry and bald middle aged man who dresses elegantly, likes to flaunt his wealth, and may or may not be homosexual. He also had an interesting backstory and was characterised was a sneaky political figure who was as every bit cunning as he physically looked. TV-Xaro is a young and burly Nigerian man who dresses elegantly, is somewhat modest, and definitely likes the ladies. Beyond the obvious physical differences, Nonso was quite bland in the role of Xaro and he didn't really distinguish himself much other than being the guy who banged Daenerys' handmaiden and for being the guy that was locked up to slowly rot away in a vault. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Jeremy Irons physically fits the role far better than Nonso ever did and he is certainly talented enough to bring some nuance to Xaro.

8. Stephen Dillane As Stannis Baratheon

Why It Was A Mistake: Stephen Dillane is actually pretty damned good as the cold and pragmatic Stannis Baratheon. But for all the anger, threats, and vows of honour, TV-Stannis is sorely lacking the physical presence to convincingly back up his words. In the books, Stannis is tall, physically imposing, balding, and has a fantastic beard. TV-Stannis is of average height, average build, has some wisps of hair left, and a permanent case of 5 o'clock shadow. Aside from being physically the complete opposite to what book-Stannis is meant to look like, Dillane is also older than both his on-screen brothers despite portraying the middle son in the Baratheon family (with Robert being the eldest and Renly being the youngest). So not only is TV-Stannis mostly bark with little bite, he looks more like Robert and Renly's long-lost uncle than their sibling. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Since Stannis is meant to be physically intimidating, bald, and cold as ice, look no further than either Mark Strong or Vinnie Jones. Strong is known for portraying dark and twisted villains with a considerable physical edge. Jones on the other hand was previously a professional footballer and he used his intimidating presence to procure a steady acting career by consistently portraying violent criminals and thugs.

7. The 2 Actors Who Played The Mountain

Why It Was A Mistake: The producers actually made the right choice initially before subsequently messing it up. There isn't much to the character of Ser Gregor 'The Mountain' Clegane other than being incredibly tall, incredibly big, and incredibly scary. The first actor, Conan Stevens, had to drop out due to scheduling conflicts and the role was recast with Ian Whyte, who was soon replaced with Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson. Whyte's short stint as the character was nothing more than standing around trying to look scary and failing. Björnsson may certainly have the physical size of The Mountain down but his limited acting ability and youth proved to be detrimental to the character. Not only is Björnsson's line readings wooden and stiff, but he is only in his 20's and thus far too young to be the The Hound's older brother. The youthful Björnsson looks more like a massive and cuddly teddy bear than the brutal murder and rapist that the character is meant to be. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Conan Stevens, the original actor who played the Mountain was absolutely perfect for the role. He had the physical presence needed, he could convincingly fight, he was of an appropriate age relative to The Hound, and he was just straight up intimidating to watch.

6. Enzo Clienti As Yezzan Zo Qaggaz

Why It Was A Mistake: Yezzan zo Qaggaz is only a relatively minor character in the novels but he carries an enormous physical presence. The richest man in Yunkai is gratuitously described as having yellow eyes and being so morbidly obese that he can't physically stand. He also happens to have some disease that renders him unable to control his bladder, thus giving him a permanent smell of urine that not even the strongest of perfume can mask. With a character looking like that, he wouldn't have to say anything and he'll still be the most memorable thing on-screen. The producers didn't think having an obese character in the show was a good idea so they decided to cast the normal looking Enzo Clienti as Yezzan. Clienti was perfectly fine as TV-Yezzan, but the major talking point of Yezzan was his looks and the producers inexplicably decided to get rid of that one defining characteristic. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Without a doubt, Gerard Depardieu is perfectly suited for the role. Despite becoming far more well-known in recent years for his overweight appearance and his antics than his work, his appearance would actually work in his favour for this part. Not only that, Depardieu was actually nominated for an Academy Award so you know he can bring that extra something special to the role of Yezzan.

5. Ed Skrein As Daario #1

Why It Was A Mistake: Daario is characterised as a sweet-talking, hunky killer who basically becomes Daenerys' bed companion and bodyguard. If Han Solo were given the 'dark and gritty' treatment, Daario is the bastardised result. When TV-Daario finally made his first appearance, it's kind of hard figure out why the producers thought Ed Skrein could fit into Daario's blue-haired shoes. Instead of bringing Daario's flamboyant dress sense, Skrein looks like Legolas' less pretty twin whom the family ostracized and never spoke about. Skrein's boy-band looks wouldn't have been so hard to accept had he managed to bring a good take on the Daario character (which he didn't). Skrein's Daario basically consists of giving out long, hard gazes and a series of smirks that are more akin to creepy than charming. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: The producers actually managed to right this wrong when they cast the dashing Michiel Huisman as Ed Skrein's replacement. Not only does Huisman physically embody Daario far better than Skrein ever did (but still minus the blue hair, split beard, and colourful clothing), but he manages to bring the right balance of roguish sell-sword behaviour with the right kind of charm that makes his face infinitely less punchable.

4. Gemma Whelan As Yara Greyjoy

Why It Was A Mistake: From the moment the character was shown on-screen, it was hard to look past the fact that the producers unnecessarily changed Asha's name to Yara and the fact that Yara is absolutely nothing like how Asha was characterised in the novels. Asha Greyjoy is described as a beautiful woman who is can fight, f**k, and banter with the best of what Westeros had to offer. She combined the fierceness of Linda Hamilton's Sarah Connor with the free-spiritedness (and none of the social awkwardness) of Lizbeth Salander. When comedian Gemma Whelan was cast, eyebrows were justifiably raised and all those doubts were unfortunately met. Not to dismiss Whelan's efforts, but whilst her take on Yara is certainly dark and off-beat, she just doesn't have the seductive and intimidating presence that Yara/Asha was in the books. It is difficult to buy Whelan as a bold warrior and even more difficult to believe that she can turn on the sex appeal whenever she wants. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: Speaking of Lizbeth Salander, Rooney Mara seems like the perfect fit for a character who is bold and menacing but can be seductive whenever she needs to be. Running a close second is Ruth Wilson, who can most certainly infuse Yara with the off-beat dark beauty that she normally brings to each of her roles.

3. Ciaran Hinds As Mance Rayder

Why It Was A Mistake: In the novels, Mance was characterised as something of a middle-aged Pied Piper of the Wildings. This was due to the character's influence in uniting of all the Free Folk using his considerable charm, intelligence, and his much-lauded lute playing skills. In the show, there was no reference to the character's musical ability, he is gruff and unsubtle, and he looks like he'll rather stick a knife between your eyes rather than engage in a civil conversation. Hinds was admirable in the part and he did bring a sort of leader-like physical presence to Mance on-screen. However, the portrayal felt thuggish and unfitting of a character who primarily uses his charisma and cunning rather than his imposing presence. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: There were reports that The Wire's Dominic West was actually offered the part of Mance Rayder before Hinds was cast. If West's portrayal of Jimmy McNulty was anything to go by, he could've easily brought the charm and intelligence to Mance that the role required. Had West still declined the role, then the incredibly charming (and frightening) Mads Mikkelsen would be a welcome alternative. The suaveness and intelligence that Mikkelsen brought to Hannibal would perfectly suit Mance Rayder.

2. Sibel Kekilli As Shae

Why It Was A Mistake: The character of Shae was altered considerably for the TV show. Originally in the novels, Shae was literally nothing more than a prostitute who slept her way through rich men and Tyrion was nothing more than another conquest. TV-Shae however was recharacterised to an exotic prostitute with a mysterious past and had slowly developed genuine feelings for Tyrion. Naturally, this gave TV-Shae a somewhat clumsy but far more dramatic arc that required someone who could convincingly portray Shae's journey from prostitute to genuine lover before knocking it out of the park with the character's final betrayal of Tyrion. Unfortunately the producers cast Sibel Kekilli, whose line delivery is forever stuck on 'awkward' or 'unsure'. Kekilli may have looked the part (and had enough acting chops to win a couple of German Oscars), but her performance here was just so one-note and so wooden that any scene beyond some dirty pillow talk seemed like it was well out of her ability. When it was time for Shae to kick the bucket, fans everywhere breathed a sigh of relief at the prospect of a Shae-less show. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: This is a tough one since TV-Shae is so different to book-Shae but the experienced Katie McGrath or Eva Green could easily tap into the character's inner turmoil whilst looking hot.

1. The Three Sand Snakes

Why It Was A Mistake: The show usually gets away with casting actors and actresses who look nothing like their book counterparts because the actors and actresses are so good most of the time. For the Sand Snakes however, each actress' performance was comical at best. Not only did each actress look nothing like the exotic and tanned women described in the books, but their 'acting' consisted mostly of childish arguing and some hammy expository monologues. Each character had so little development that each actress could've swapped roles and you wouldn't have noticed. But the worst offender was the actress' inability to convincingly capture the Sand Snakes' fighting ability. Instead of holding their own in their moment-to-shine showdown with Jaime and Bronn, it just looked and felt like grown men beating up on three girls. Who Should€™ve Been Cast: This is a difficult one to tackle since the problem is split equally between the poor writing and the lack of screen time to really judge each actress. Yes the acting was bad, but the writing for the whole Dorne storyline was so bad for Season 5 that not even someone with Meryl Streep's talent can't salvage something from the material. Let's give each actress the benefit of the doubt this time and recast the writers instead. If things don't improve in season 6, then let the casting debate re-commence.