Game Of Thrones: 10 Smartest Changes HBO Made From The Books
It really wasn't all bad you know.
Let's face facts, seasons 5 through 8 of GOT were not as good as 1 through 4.
The decline in quality is largely due to the show being forced to work without any original source material.
It's not entirely the show's fault, the book kept getting delayed and Martin tried to keep as much of it as secret as possible to prevent spoilers forcing more improvisation. Also adapting A Feast for Crows (often thought of as being the weakest book in the series) and A Dance with Dragons would haven been an unenviable task for anyone.
Unlike the first three books the story takes place across multiple locations that don't interconnect with one another and the timelines jump around a lot. There was also a huge amount of focus given to characters whose stories went nowhere (looking at you Sam!) whilst some key characters seemed largely forgotten like Sansa. That's before you meet all the new characters that keep being added throughout like Aegon Targaryen.
There was too much ground to cover and a lot of altering was required in order to fit in with the narrative the show had been telling.
Having said that, there was still fun to be had in the later episodes: some of the best action in the entire series, twists and revelations as well as key moments with devastating emotional impact.
Let's focus on the good times, and of course spoilers ahead, duh!
10. The Finale
No, it wasn't to everyone's taste but the endings to long-running series very rarely please everyone.
You can pull at those loose threads all you want, but season 8's final episode stood out as its best. It was full of the emotionally driven performances and bittersweet moments that the rest of the series had been lacking.
It also felt more in tune with Martin's style of storytelling, obviously we don't know how the books end yet, but the show's creators were informed of the important mile stones. How they get there was up to them.
Inevitably it will be fun to see what changes are made in the books and how much so. Characters achieved what they wanted, just not necessarily in the manner they expected and helped to bookend the entire series marvellously.
Sansa did get to become a queen, Jon went back to serve at The Wall and Arya went on her gap year.
You may have rolled your eyes at Bronn and his brothel fixation and maybe you expected Bran, with his god-like powers, to do something more remarkable than become king, but the good far outweighed the bad.
The important thing is we got a largely satisfactory ending.
9. Drogon Versus The Lannister Army
It took seven seasons to get here, but we did get it. In season 7 we finally got to see Dany ride a dragon into battle unleashing hell.
Admittedly it was also one of the earlier examples of the show completely dismissing the timescale and geography all carefully set out in earlier seasons. Dany and her forces come charging over the horizon out of nowhere, but you can't say you were bored by it.
In the books the dragons' raw power has yet to be fully realised, only managing to kill off a few would-be heroes whilst Dany has barely started to ride them.
This was a roaring good time, pun intended; we had seen the dragons burn people up before but this was the first time we saw the high levels of carnage they could achieve, wiping out a large chunk of the Lannister army.
However, we also got to see the power of the Scorpion arrows, meaning Cersei's forces weren't completely powerless. It's all very OTT and gruesome foreshadowing what comes later.
8. Blowing Up The Great Sept Of Baelor
We all knew Cersei was going to be annoyed after her nude and public shaming at the hands of the fanatical Sparrow and his followers. Hell hath no fury like an annoyed Cersei.
At the end of her appearance in A Dance with Dragons she only just finishes her walk of shame so her game plan is still a mystery. Though her internal rage is made apparent so it won't be good for whoever ends up on the receiving end.
In the show her revenge comes in spectacular fashion. By this point viewers were used to seeing subtle and complicated plans unfurl over long periods of time which is what helped make this all the more stunning.
No one could have predicted that the Lion Queen would blow up an entire building in the middle of Kingslanding, largely full of innocents, just to eliminate some of her enemies. Who are we kidding, of course she would.
It was shocking to see so many key characters cop it all at once too and proved how far one of the maddest monarchs would go to protect her own.
7. Jon's Big Reveal
A lot of viewers might have been expecting this twist, ever since the first series in fact, but it was nice to have it officially confirmed within the confines of the show. For a long time both book and series have been baiting the fans with the secret of who Jon's mother was.
The book has been especially good at downplaying it and we still don't know if this is how things will turn out.
But on the small screen Jon Snow, long thought to be Ned Stark's bastard son, is in actual fact his legitimate nephew: Aegon Targaryen, son of Rheagar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark, rightful heir to the Iron Throne. His identity was kept a secret in order to protect him from Robert Baratheon who hated the Targaryen bloodline and wanted it wiped out.
Naturally Jon becomes aware of this at the worst possible time: after he's sworn fealty to his aunt Dany Targaryen, with whom he's also fallen in love. Ruh roh.
Aegon does appear in the books too but has nothing to do with Jon. He is supposed to be Dany's exiled brother, having managed to escape the rest of his family's fate. Only Tyrion and a few others know his secret identity.
6. Hardhome
Forget Season 8's undead battle at Winterfell, this is the real deal and easily the best thing in Season 5. Its intense, ominous and ends, as GOT is want to do, on a note of mild success with signs of impending doom.
Jon and some of his rangers arrive at Hardhome in order to try and save the trapped inhabitants from the Night King's army.
Of course it doesn't go smoothly; this is GOT after all.
As in the battle of Winterfell, the undead attack, only this time you can see what's happening and Jon actually gets to do something: an epic sword fight where we learn that Valyrian steel works just as well as Dragonglass at dispatching White Walkers.
This event was only a mere mention in the books, still dark and desperate but reduced to a series of letters between Jon Snow and Cotter Pyke as well as hearsay.
Any doubts anyone had about the threat of the White Walkers were quickly cast aside.
5. Jon's Resurrection
When Jon was betrayed and killed by his brothers of the Night's Watch it was a huge shock especially after all he had been through helping to save hundreds of innocents from the forces of the undead.
They couldn't possibly be killing off another hero, not before we learnt the significance of his heritage or before the White Walkers made their big attack, but that seemed to be exactly what they did.
People may have been suspecting his return but thanks to Kit Harrington's insistence that he was not going to be in the show anymore everyone was left feeling uncertain.
Thankfully every GOT viewer heaved a sigh of relief when Melisandre rocked up and wove her spells bringing him back from the big sleep. Even then they kept viewers guessing right up to the last possible moment as to whether her spell had even worked.
We still don't know his fate in the books, it's only implied that he's been killed, so for all we know he may end up walking it off, they're made of sterner stuff up North. Permanent death does seem unlikely, for the same reasons mentioned above, how he returns to world of the living though is anyones' guess.
How they love to torture us.
4. Zombie dragon bringing down the wall
This was worthy of an '80s heavy metal album cover: Pure awesomeness and pure fan service.
When we first saw the sheer size of The Wall and realised what it was defending the Seven Kingdoms from we all knew it was going to come crashing down but the question was how?
Luckily the show's creators knew how to pander to the fans and delivered one of the most insane moments in the franchise's running.
After fighting the undead, Dany's dragon Viserion is killed by the Night King and promptly turned into his very own, brand spanking new, zombie dragon.
Riding said dragon he leads his army to The Wall and unleashes a storm of blue fire, destroying everything in its path, including Castle Black.
Obviously the books haven't even come close to doing anything like this, Dany's only just started to fly one of them herself. However given the power of the dragons and how Martin likes to torture his heroes it seems unlikely someone won't be pitted against one of the winged terrors at some point. Maybe it will be Dany required to take down one of her own children?
Say what you will about the lack of subtlty in the later episodes but they know how to raise the stakes.
3. Hold The Door Please, Hodor
Nooooo, it's still too soon, if you weren't moved to tears by this then you have no soul.
All Hodor wanted was to serve House Stark faithfully and maybe have the occasional cooked breakfast.
He's been a loyal guardian to Bran, helping to carry him all across the North, braving the undead, harsh cold and thunder all so Bran could find the Three Eyed Raven.
Until this point the reasons why Hodor could say only his name had been a mystery. The reasons for their cause are almost as tragic as the final outcome.
A slight time travel element was being introduced at this point in the series (which was promptly forgotten in later episodes) and Hodor's destiny and purpose were all set in motion.
Seeing as this episode was penned by Martin and Hodor's story is still a mystery in the books it does feel likely there may be some similarities in the book.
Was he always meant to sacrifice himself in order to save Bran? To "Hold the door" right up until Hodor Hodors his last Hodor? Time will tell.
2. Arya Versus The Freys
The Red Wedding was an upsetting affair for fans, a huge number of good guys and key characters got betrayed and massacred at the Twins, all because Walder Frey felt slighted.
We were left waiting and wanting for revenge, big emphasis on the waiting.
Then we got it.
Both of Arya's attacks on House Frey were unexpected and satisfying, managing to utilise her new skills and training as an assassin courtesy of the faceless men. Arya disguised herself as a serving girl before revealing to Walder that she had carved up and served his sons inside meat pies before cutting his throat.
He was forced to look up at a Stark, smiling at him, as he dies and that's before she uses his own face to become head of the Frey household and poison the remainder of his family at a feast.
There's no knowing how or even if the Freys will get their comeuppance, or if it will be at the hands of a Stark as they're unpopular even amongst their allies.
Catelyn Stark is still, technically, alive in the books and out for revenge against the Boltons and the Freys so it may well be her that delivers the final blow.
Whatever the outcome it sucks to be a Frey.
1. The Battle Of The Bastards
This is by far the best battle in the entire show, a show chock full of epic battles.
It's a total spectacle and a feast for the eyes, beautifully shot, as well as being one of the grittiest fights ever committed to screen.
Lord of the Rings never showed us characters being crushed by all the corpses a battle would naturally produce.
There's a bit of a deus ex machina towards the battle's conclusion, when the Knights of the Vale show up at just the right moment, but this is the closest thing to a happy ending you're likely to see in GOT.
Yes Rickon cops it, but the Stark Banner flies over Winterfell for the first time in four seasons! Ramsay Bolton gets his comeuppance too and it's a doozy worthy of Martin's vision.
Score one for the good guys.
Unfortunately Martin kept teasing us in the books with Stannis' march on Winterfell and left it on a cliff hanger so this battle has still yet to happen. Jon Snow may not even be a part of it due to an overdose of stabbings to the torso. So technically there may never be a Battle of the Bastards. That makes this event within the show even more special and unique so treasure it.