Gotham Season 5 Premiere: 5 Ups & 2 Downs From Year Zero
Gotham's final season begins in an epic fashion - marking the beginning of the end for the series.
Contains spoilers from Gotham Season 5, Episode 1.
With its curtain call in sight, Gotham returned to screens for its final season, and delivered a premiere episode that signified that the best is yet to come for the Fox series.
Aptly titled Year Zero, the episode takes place three months after the events of the fourth season finale, which saw Ra's Al Ghul and Jeremiah Valeska initiate their plan to cut Gotham off from the rest of the world. With the city now referred to as No Man's Land, a few lone survivors do what they can to ensure the safety of the civilians that were unable to escape from the wreckage.
Jim Gordon carries the burden, communicating with the government who have well and truly turned their backs on the people left in Gotham City. Bruce and Alfred keep vigil at Selina's hospital bedside, and Tabitha vows revenge on Oswald for the murder of Butch.
While Gotham found its footing in its third season, the series has significantly improved ever since. Year Zero demonstrates that the show still has a lot more to give and, save for a few caveats, is one of Gotham's finest hours yet.
Ups...
5. No Man's Land
The fact that Gotham managed to reach its fifth season is a huge achievement, and is all the more appreciated considering the Batman-prequel series' fate was up in the air for months - with cancellation thought to be a certainty.
There's no doubt that Gotham's producers would've hoped for another couple of seasons for their show, so that viewers could see Bruce naturally mature and become Batman over time, but having the opportunity to write a final chapter of the story is a blessing nonetheless - especially in today's day and age.
Choosing a narrative for the final season was undoubtedly a tall task for the showrunners. To ensure the show went out on a high, the accompanying story would have to be big and bold - which is why the No Man's Land arc is the perfect choice.
The concept is genius, and not once does it feel imposed upon, or contrived. Executive Producer John Stephens' does a wonderful job with the script - especially in regards to establishing this brave new world that our remaining Gothamites find themselves living in. Everything is up in the air, and the city is in need of a hero now more so than ever, and while Jim Gordon is doing all he can - it's safe to say that it's time for Batman to come in and save the day.
4. The Tone
Following on from the previous entry, one of the greatest things about Year Zero is how quickly it establishes Gotham's new tone - which is one of melancholia. The opening segment does much of the work, signifying that the end of days is very much nigh.
Not only does the tone of this No Man's Land narrative intensify everything for the show's central characters, but it also intensifies things for the viewers, as it's pretty clear from the offset that the story is preparing for its final instalments - and thus, we must prepare to bid adieu to this great series. There are certainly pangs of emotion, as we watch our heroes rally the people for one last fight - one last hurrah, as it were.
The dynamic between all of the central heroes also feels very different, in that there's more at stake this time around, and every character's actions possess a sense of urgency. There is an intensity that wasn't present in any of the previous seasons, which makes everything feel so final.
3. Tabitha's Death
While there are very few low points in Year Zero, one of the more stronger moments sees Tabitha Galavant murdered at the hands of the villainous Oswald Cobblepot. In a series like Gotham, death doesn't often mean anything, as it's very possible to resurrect the victim (or have the actor who portrays said character show up as the evil twin, but that's a matter for another day). However, there is something really significant in the series' decision to kill Tabitha here - it was Stephens' way of highlighting that this is really the end for the show.
Tabitha has overcome odds after odds, villain after villain, and managed to avoid death on numerous occasions thanks to her excellent fighting skills. Having her become nothing more than a casualty of war is genius on Stephens' part, as it highlights how - in a climate such as this one - anyone is expendable, and that no one is safe.
Tabby has been one of Gotham's stronger characters over the years, and Jessica Lucas has portrayed her exceptionally well, which makes her exit extremely hard to watch. Unlike the recent death in The Walking Dead - which happened under similar circumstances - Tabitha's demise does not feel contrived, but rather feels like an important piece of the show's conclusion.
2. Jim Gordon's Characterisation
There have been plenty of unforgettable portrayals of Jim Gordon over the years, from Pat Hingle to Gary Oldman, and each of them have brought something unique to the comic book character. Ben McKenzie is no different. The actor has done a superb job at bringing the future police commissioner to life, and whether you love or hate the Fox series' originality in regards to the Batman mythos, there's little denying that its version of Gordon is one of its greatest attributes.
While Gordon was very much the protagonist when Gotham began, the series has diverged over the years, becoming more of an ensemble piece, with multiple protagonists as opposed to one. While the ensemble vibe is still very much present in Year Zero, the show is once again heavily relying on Gordon, and it's all the better because of this fact.
It's more clearer than ever in this episode that McKenzie embodies this role, and while we'll be sad to bid farewell to every aspect of Gotham, losing one of the greatest portrayals of Batman's police commissioner will be something fans will particularly struggle with.
1. Gotham Is Back
It's been quite some time since Gotham was last on the air, which likely had something to do with the ambiguity surrounding whether or not the series was to be renewed. Moreover, after it was given a final season order at Fox, the significantly trimmed length meant that we had to wait to mid-season for the series to return. Well, you can all breathe a sigh of relief, as the Batman-prequel series is (finally) back on our screens.
Year Zero is an incredibly strong opening episode, and is significantly aided by the fact that almost every one of Gotham's central characters features in some capacity. We have Gordon, Bullock and Lucius Fox working around the clock at GCPD to get some more supplies into the city, meanwhile Alfred and Bruce tend to Selina in hospital. We also see Oswald reigning over the city from City Hall, while Babs and Tabby open a sanctuary for women in their nightclub. It's a very impressive instalment, with each character having been delegated a significant portion of screen time.
Gotham has been a mainstay of television for almost five years now, and its recent return marks the beginning of the end of an era, as after the next 11 episodes air, we'll be forced to say goodbye to the hideously beautiful world of Gotham City forever. For now, though, we can simply enjoy the fact that Gotham is back for another exciting run.
Downs...
2. Ed Nygma's Frustratingly Repetitive Sub-Arc
With it being Gotham's final season, it's clear that the writers have gone all out in making the central characters become more and more like their comic book counterparts. Not only that, but they've also come up with some great sub-narratives for the villains, which is why Ed Nygma's sub-arc is extremely frustrating in comparison.
Making only two brief appearances in Year Zero, Ed is seemingly being affected by his split personality disorder once more. Throughout the episode, he discovers that he's getting up to no good while he's supposed to be asleep, which implies that Good Ed has once again taken control of his body while Bad Ed sleeps. While the changing of personalities is a decent enough storyline for the character, it's a bit annoying considering the show has already explored it on numerous occasions in the past.
Unless there is a twist coming which sees The Riddler's odd behaviour have nothing to do with Good Ed, then it's hard to see the point in revisiting a storyline - no matter how good it was the first time, or the second time - at this late stage in the game.
1. Jeremiah Valeska's Absence
Considering Jeremiah Valeska was one of the founding fathers of Gotham's brave new world, it's rather disappointing that the character doesn't feature in Year Zero. That's not to say that Stephens didn't write around his absence well, because he absolutely did, but it's safe to say that fans had expected the character to feature rather heavily this season, so no matter how good the writing, Jeremiah's absence was noticeable.
Cameron Monaghan was utterly sublime in his portrayal of Jeremiah's crazed twin brother Jerome, and he's just as compelling as the cooler, more suave Jeremiah, which is why many of us are looking forward to seeing what's next for the psychotic character. We did learn that Jeremiah is still in the city, as his pal Ecco pays Gordon a visit during Year Zero, but we've yet to learn of what his plans for Gotham are.
What did you make of Gotham's final season premiere? Tell us in the comment section below.