Heroes may have been one of the biggest shows in recent years to utterly fail to live up to its potential. What began with a buzz of excitement in 2006, with engaging characters, brilliant twists and a truly innovative taken on the superhero genre became a tired shell of its former self four years later. In fact, considering the how the show never reached the heights of its first season, I put it at number one in my recent article looking at TV shows that would have been great as one-season wonders. Season two of the show petered out before it really got going, thanks to the infamous writer's strike of 2007 and even more astonishingly, fans labelled it dull. A year later we had a third season that was immersion-breakingly schizophrenic in nature; heroes became villains, then heroes, then villains again. Action and spectacle took the place of any substantial story development. The show clawed back some of its success with a fourth and final season, but by then all the people that had branded Heroes the best thing on television back in 2006 were now no longer interested. Which is a shame, because while there were still flaws, it did fell like an attempt to regain its original magic. Now for better or worse, Heroes is returning to our screen for a limited 13-part miniseries next year. Perhaps the end of the mediocre Touch has finally allowed the people involved to get back to what they really want to do. Kiefer Sutherland is back for another limited series run with 24: Live Another Day this May and Tim King can get back to running his beloved Heroes. Both shows that lost their way, but had moments of brilliance too. Like 24, Heroes needs to learn from its mistakes to make its return a success. In this article I look at 10 things Tim Kring and his staff of merry writers need to do get it right!
10. Build On The Cliffhanger From Season Four
If there's one thing season four did right more than its preceding two seasons, it was putting our protagonists in a position to become the heroes they were destined to become. Claire jumping to her 'death' and miraculously surviving was the first step towards the human race becoming aware of people with special powers. After season one, we waited and waited and waited for heroes saving people from fires, rescuing victims trapped in car pile ups, stopping speeding trains and preventing criminals from robbing banks and holding the innocent hostage. All good superhero stuff. Throw in some villains and we could have explosive confrontations on the streets of New York. It didn't have to be all capes and spandex, it wasn't that kind of show. It was more a realistic take on what would happen if people with powers really did exist in our world. Too much of Heroes was taken up by people with powers hiding from the world or seeking to control others behind the scenes. Claire's actions in the closing moments of season four, while serving as a somewhat satisfactory series finale, have also liberated the show by allowing it to go in a whole different direction. To see not only how our heroes fit the world now but how the world has reacted to this 'evolution' of humanity will be a fascinating springboard for any new story.
9. No More Bad-Good-Bad-Good-Bad-Good Sylar
For that matter, give our heroes a purpose and stick to it! I'm all for character development but season three had Nathan Petrelli changing allegiances nearly every week and that resulted in a character whose motivations we didn't understand or frankly didn't care about. Sylar is another one. He was brilliant as the first season villain and his story could have ended satisfactorily there. But no, thanks to Zachary Quinto's star power, the writers kept bringing Sylar back again and again and again. What was worse, they made him a hero by making him lose his mind, then become a villain again, then, oh I don't know. He went all badass when he killed Nathan but by the end we didn't know whose side he was on. Good I think? That's what the final episodes of Heroes seemed to go with. Now I'd be surprised if this new season of Heroes gets all the cast back and as good as Zachary Quinto is, I'd be fine if he wasn't there. With such a limited run story, the show needs to focus again on core characters. If Sylar is now one of the heroes, having earned his redemption, that's fine. Just don't have him changing sides one season to the next. If they want a villain, find someone else.
8. Make Hiro Nakamura Loveable Again With A Real Purpose
Watching season one, could anyone have imagined that Masi Oka's loveable time-travelling hero Hiro Nakamura would becoming irritating? By the time he reverted to a child in season three, we were virtually clenching our teeth in every one of his scenes. Yet in the first season, fans adored his wide-eyed charm and wonder at the world unravelling around him. Perhaps it was inevitable that the darker the show got and the bigger the threat, Hiro's innocence would be swallowed up in the chaos. What the writers need to do is recapture some of that wonder he had at first, without making him so naive he becomes childish and irritating again. Learn what made him work and what didn't. Hopefully, having a break of five years since the show was on will help to make Hiro endearing once again. Giving his time travel power, the writers should be able to find some purpose to Hiro (and Ando's) journey, just like they had in season one when he tried to avert the destruction of New York, seen through his trip to the future and the brilliant 9th Wonders comic. Perhaps, giving his presence in the excellent season one episode 'Five Years Gone', the writers can take some of that character and place it into the Hiro presented in the new season five?
7. Claire Bennet And Peter Petrelli Need to Be Engaging Protagonists
Alongside Hiro, Claire and Peter were probably the two most prominent heroes from the very beginning and as such serve as our Peter Parker, Iron Man or Clark Kent on the show. The difference is that even without their superhero personas, the everyday personalities of these comic book icons are engaging enough. Could the same be said for Claire and Peter? If Hayden Panettiere and Milo Ventimiglia are going to continue their roles as the chief protagonists of the show, we need to see some development between season four and now. The character of Claire demonstrated some growth towards the end; moving out of the shadow of her father and then opening demonstrating her powers to the world; will she serve as a quasi-Tony Stark type role where her real identity and hero persona are as well-known as each other? Will she have another side to her character, or will the former cheerleader simply be Claire, hero of the people? As for Peter, with his brother dead and his father disposed of, he was finally starting to come out of their shadows to become someone in his own right. It was interesting to see how he used his role as a paramedic in season four to help save those in need. We need to see how far he has come five years later and like Claire (and Hiro) we need protagonists that are engaging week after week; heroes that we can root for to save the day!
6. Have A Worthy Supervillain
I've already touched on the use of Sylar within the show, namely that he shouldn't be the villain again. However, what the show does need to come back strong is a villain who will knock the pants of every baddie before him. We need Heroes' take on Lex Luthor, The Joker or The Green Goblin; a villain that will push our heroes to their very limits. Arthur Petrelli and Samuel Sullivan were interesting baddies but never felt like the big league. Arthur was lost in the mess that was season three. Samuel was more successful, thanks in no part to the nuanced portrayal by Robert Knepper, but his story took far too long to really get going, something a thirteen-part mini-series can hopefully rectify. Some of the best superheroes have the best rogues gallery and Heroes needs this to succeed. Taking the leaf perhaps out of Christopher Nolan's 'realistic' take on Gotham City, Heroes could adopt its brand of real world versus super powers to give us something truly remarkable.
5. Superheroes Versus Supervillain Action
We all thought this was coming in season three with the escapees in Level 5; we remember the trailers promising some thrilling confrontations to come but what we got was far more...mundane. Despite one thrilling sequence when a band of villains try to rob a bank, these big bads faded into obscurity, showing yet another example of plot threads meandering along only to be lost in favour of other bigger and bolder story lines. The best villain outside season one's Sylar was probably the very creepy puppet master Eric Doyle, played by David H. Lawrence XVII, who had the ability to control others with his very insidious gift. It was an attempt to add some real darkness to the superpower cast and it worked, but we never got other villains of this magnitude. We need a run of criminal activities expanded tenfold by an array of powers that prove to be a threat so big it takes a band of heroes of stop them. And we need some stunning fight sequences to take this show to another level, not just the skirmishes we got time to time.
4. Give Us A True Heroes-Style Take On Classic Superhero Stories
Heroes may have already given us its own take on superhero origins, translating it to the screen in a believable way. What about a homage to some of the bigger, most iconic superheroes committed to comic and screen? A hero physically altered by a genetic accident? A hero motivated by the death of his (or her) parents or a close family member. Better still, what about a hero that doesn't have powers but has found their way into this world in some fashion or another. A Heroes style Batman, Iron Man or Green Arrow if you will. Or what about a homage to some classic superhero stories? Rights permitting, there are many ways the show can take inspiration from the great superhero tales. I've already touched upon season one's 'Five Years Gone' having a 'Days Of Future Past' vibe to it...what about something else to really engage the viewers? The truth is, with films like The Avengers and The Dark Knight and TV shows like Arrow, superheroes are still big property and maybe it is the perfect time for Heroes to return. Its own tribute to the genre it is inspired from could be a great thing indeed.
3. Get Bryan Fuller Involved In Some Way
Now this mustn't come at the cost of Hannibal; that show is far too amazing to let any work on Heroes detract from what will hopefully be a season three (and four). But that being said, Bryan Fuller's involvement would be a great thing for the show. He was a driving force in season one and scripted one of the best episodes the show ever produced in 'Company Man'. There was a notable shift in style when he left. When he finally returned late in season three to write the excellent 'Cold Snap', audiences received a welcome return to form in the show that was losing its way. Heroes immediately rekindled some of that first season magic and the series found its purpose again. Was it too little, too late? Perhaps. But for those he had stuck with the show, we had hope again. If not involved to the level he was in season one, perhaps Bryan Fuller could be on hand to write a few episodes? His contribution would help to prove that the show is going to deliver something special, hopefully swaying some of those naysayers that feel Heroes has had its day.
2. Have Superhero Fresh Blood
I've already touched upon some of the main heroes. But there is no guarantee at this stage how many actors, if any, will be returning. I think to start completely from scratch would be a mistake...part of the charm of a new limited series is seeing how our favourite characters have fared a number of years down the line. After all, with 24, it's as much about Jack's story as it is about the ticking clock concept. But that being said, after such a long break, Tim Kring has the opportunity to bring something fresh to the show too. Perhaps trim the fat of some of the more mundane characters and create some new and interesting dynamics that will shake up the plot and those returning heroes. Why not give us some fantastic new powers (and a budget to go with it) that will make each episode memorable? Though it isn't just about effects, give us some new characters that we will love, that light up the scene every time they walk into the room.There have been some stunning television performances in recent years on shows like Game Of Thrones and the aforementioned Hannibal. Why not tap into some of that talent for a couple of major roles? In many ways, it can be as much a blank slate as it is a continuation. While reboots of the premise don't usually work between seasons, they certainly can when there is a gap of five years.
1. Have A Complete End-To-End Story In Mind With A Satisfying Conclusion Mapped Out
What of the most interesting and yet still frustrating elements about season finales of Heroes was that each conclusion was a set up to something more. Season one's Genesis led to season two's Generations, which in turn led to season three's Villains and Fugitives and finally season four's Redemption (concluding with the open ending Brave New World). Each was a clever motif to get audiences hooked into watching the next season, but also ultimately undermined the conclusion of each volume by immediately focusing on the next. If this is to be a limited series then Heroes Reborn needs to have a definitive ending without the introduction of another volume to come. While I get that life doesn't have such closure, it would be very frustrating to see (chapter six?) Reborn end and immediately be greeted by Volume seven... Whether there is another season / limited run after Reborn or not, at this stage, like 24: Live Another Day, this new story can serve to offer the closure that it never got back in 2010. The writers need to have a complete end-to-end story mapped out that gives us an intriguing build up and a satisfying conclusion within its thirteen-episode structure. It's far better for the show to return and end on a high then be remembered as a failed attempt to flog a dead horse. If we're lucky and the writers learn from past mistakes, we'll hopefully be in for something special. Because when Heroes was good, it was very good. For now, we'll just have to wait and see.