How I Met Your Mother: 10 Ways The Finale Totally Lived Up To Expectations

By Sam Shepherd /

On March 31st, How I Met Your Mother came to an end after a nine year run to contend with Friends and Cheers for a place in the sitcom history books. Many theories had been circulated throughout its airing as to the identity of The Mother, the mysterious figure about whom the whole story was meant to concern, while we watched Ted go through doomed relationship after doomed relationship, struggling to find the happiness that he so clearly deserved. From Karen and Natalie before the show's beginning, to Robin, Victoria, Stella, Zoey, Jeanette and countless others, Ted has been searching for a woman to be the mother to his children for nine years, and a year ago, at the end of Season 8, we finally saw her - Tracy McConnell - buying a train ticket to Robin and Barney's wedding, where she would meet her future husband. Since then, throughout Season 9, we have been given glimpses into their future, rightly giving the fans more than just the story of how Ted and The Mother meet, and showing how they fall in love and revisit the place where they met in 2013. But now it had to come to an end, full-circle, with the couple finally meeting for the first time, ending the story that Ted has been telling his children in 2030 all this time. Whether you liked the twisty finale or not, it's undeniable that How I Met Your Mother delivered on its nine year wait to see Ted and The Mother finally together, and wrap up all of the story-lines that occurred along the way, giving everyone of the main characters a solid end. As we had already seen in the series, Marshall ends up a Supreme Court Judge with Lily by his side and (at least) three children, and the other characters are all given final, life-long stories in this final double-episode. And here, in chronological order, is how it delivered on everything else...

10. Robin And Barney Divorce

Of course they did. The whole of series 8 was geared up towards them getting married, and the whole of series 9 actually WAS their wedding, so this could feel like a slap in the face to some fans (especially with the speed at which the show covered their broken down relationship and divorce) if it weren't for the fact that their marriage facilitated Ted finally meeting The Mother. But when you look at the show realistically, of course Robin and Barney got divorced. She's always put her career in front of her relationships, apart from the time when she tried it the other way around and Don broke her heart. So I guess she learned her lesson. And Barney is the serial womaniser, and it would take a lot more than just Robin to break that habit (as you know, assuming you watched the finale). Aside from gags such as the doppelgängers, How I Met Your Mother has always included an air of realism in its portrayals of relationships, etc, that other shows haven't. Lily left Marshall for six months, Ted got left at the altar, Ted cheated on Victoria (who, as it turned out, then leapt at Klaus), etc. So of course Robin and Barney wouldn't work. Not unless they were willing to give up everything that made them who they were to begin with.

9. The Series Regulars & In-Jokes

How I Met Your Mother has always relied on its long-term fans. Sure, if you pick up odd episodes not knowing about the show then it can be entertaining, but what the show has really depended on are the fans who get the in-jokes, fans who remember The Pineapple Incident or the impromptu flight to Philadelphia way back at he beginning of Season 1. And Season 9 has delivered on all of them. And the finale was no exception to this. We had all of the regular tropes of the show - Ted discussing destiny with the woman at Farhampton station, multiple drinks at MacLaren's Pub, etc - and so many of the in-jokes. Listing them all would take an age but in just this double-episode we had references to "Have you met Ted?", Canada-bashing, Ted and Robin's "Major Pleasure", sci-fi references, an epic high-five, Barney's 'guys' for everything, the Cockamouse, Halloween costume jokes, Robots vs Wrestlers, Barney's Perfect Month (again featuring Jim Nantz), The Playbook II and Ted's middle name. And if you look closely, you can even see Marshall subtly pay Lily the dividends of their Long-Term Bet that Ted would end up with Robin when Ted and Tracy are married and at MacLaren's. The finale definitely delivered to its long-term fans, showering viewers with in-jokes and references to previous episodes all the way through, as even Ted and Tracy discuss their intertwined lives with the yellow umbrella.

8. The Show's Situation Ends

The two things you really need for a sitcom are just that - a situation and some comedy. And at the end of the show, the situation has to end. With Cheers it was Rebecca leaving, Woody getting elected and Cliff and Norm getting new, better jobs. With Friends it was Chandler and Monica moving out of their apartment with their new kids, with Phoebe already married off and Rachel possibly moving (maybe with Ross) to France. And with How I Met Your Mother, it was pretty much everything. Obviously the final series filled us in on most of the characters' lives up to 2030, but the finale filled in the gaps. We saw Lily and Marshall leave their apartment, Robin and Barney divorce (causing Robin to barely see anyone in the group again as she jets across the world), Ted marrying Tracy and moving out to his house in Westchester and Barney finally giving up on his womanising. But more on that one later. It would be a terrible end if the final episode just left the gang sitting in their booth at MacLaren's ready for another legen - wait for it - dary night, the same as most of the series before, so things had to be shaken up. And this was always built into the story - Ted would finally meet Tracy and we'd speed forward to 2030, the time when he's been telling his kids this story all along. The situation had to end.

7. We See The Mother In The Gang

Throughout Season 9 we've been given some beautiful flash-forwards from the present day to see Ted and Tracy together, a lot of which have been set once again at the Farhampton Inn, including Ted's proposal at the lighthouse, and the touching moment in episode 19, Vesuvius, in which Tracy tells Ted not to become a man who lives in the past, and Ted starts to cry. But we'd only rarely seen her as a part of the gang, completing the 6-some that this show has always been heading towards. Once again, the finale delivered. We finally got to see the dynamic once Ted and Tracy found each other, with Tracy joining them at MacLaren's as well as having the gang over to Ted and Tracy's house (above). Of course, this is nothing like the Season 9 that some fans were hoping for a year ago, possibly documenting the first year of Ted and Tracy's relationship rather than mostly focussing on the weekend they met, but it gave us enough of a glimpse into the new group to make it count. And even after the divorce, Robin was still around for the big moments, and we got the whole group together for Ted and Tracy's wedding for one final group shot.

6. Barney Has A Satisfying Ending

After divorcing Robin, we saw Barney return full throttle to his pre-Nora state of womanising and staying out all night. Until Ellie came along. And we finally got the touching moment from Barney that had never quite come when he was with Robin. Sure, he promised never to lie to her, but that was after all the deception that led to his proposal and their rehearsal dinner, just to name two, as well as inflicting the Ring Bear (who was, undeniably, adorable) on their wedding without talking to her about it. Barney was still Barney, just turned down a little bit. But it took a lot more than Robin to break Barney, and that turned out to be Ellie - his daughter - the result of Barney's one-night-stand with Number 31, the final score in his Perfect Month. We know nothing more about the mother, and we have no way of knowing whether she and Barney then entered into a relationship or simply shared custody of Ellie, but we do see how parenthood changes Barney: basically into a normal bloke. But it was beautiful. From his tearful rendition of a speech he had earlier mocked to his subsequent advice that two girls in MacLaren's go back home to their parents, Barney finally, truly changed into the compassionate man we always knew he could be. And who was the mysterious Number 31? Some fan theories have pointed towards it being an ex-lover such as Abby or Quinn (there was even a Twitter trend during the show that 31 would turn out to be Robin), but apparently that's not information we (or, rather, Ted's children Penny and Luke) need to know. Perhaps they already know, or perhaps it really doesn't matter because she and Barney never had a subsequent relationship. That's not the important part. The important part is that Barney had a proper send-off, possibly the only satisfying send-off that such a character could have - he finally grew up.

5. We See Ted & The Mother's Future

We'd already seen some of it, as mentioned earlier, but the finale properly delivered on Ted and Tracy's future together. Even only through glimpses, we saw her telling him about her pregnancy with Penny, thus postponing their big wedding, we see them together at a future Halloween where Tracy has embraced Ted's hanging chad costume with her own counterpart, we see Ted's re-proposal and then we see them get married. And after this, we see a short series of pictures from their future lives, bringing up their kids and enjoying nights out together, just being happy.
So we saw Ted happy finally. Something we've been missing for nine seasons, as he enters into each relationship with the audience already knowing it will somehow fail (some more spectacularly than others - cue Jeanette flash-back). And he finally gets the wife and children he envisaged when he recklessly bought his Westchester house, getting his children interested in architecture and meeting a woman just as bookish and crazy as him. Until...

4. The Mother Dies

It turns out that all of those fan theories were right. The Mother dies. While this may be heartbreaking (and, once again, a possible slap in the face for the fans who have waited nine years to see Ted happy with The Mother), it definitely lived up to the expectations of the theorists predicting this for a while beforehand. But there has even been a fan edit in which the whole storyline of Tracy dying has been cut out, and the show simply fades to black after they meet. Which is nice n' all, but it's not how the show ends. There is something quite fitting about Tracy's death, though, as the audience has always known that they wouldn't meet The Mother until now, and so every other relationship into which Ted entered was doomed from the off, so this one almost had to be as well. So goes the luck, if you can call it that, of Ted Mosby - even after finding Tracy, his beautiful bass-playing co-nerd who gave him his two wonderful children, the relationship still had to end. And then, in the circular fashion that How I Met Your Mother has come to love, we return to their beginnings, and...

3. Ted Finally Meets The Mother (And We Find Out Her Name)

Cut back to Farhampton station, and Ted finally gets up the courage to talk to the beautiful bass player, who has already affected his life in so many ways (previously meeting the rest of the gang and helping them through their troubles). And it's adorable. They finally bond over their shared yellow umbrella and, as we now find out, their shared initials. The Mother weaves her words through the initials T M, mistaken to be for Ted Mosby, after finally reveals her name to be Tracy McConnell, saying it's "always belonged, T M, to me."
What's in a name? Well, as far as we can see here, pretty much nothing. They share initials, and that's cute, as well as both sharing the initials of the moniker "The Mother", but, just like the kids' being Penny and Luke, The Mother's name almost doesn't matter at this point, because it's what she represents for Ted - true happiness, if only for eleven short years - that the fans care about. And then Ted's story is finished, so inevitably...

2. The Kids Return

"And that, kids, is how I met your mother." This has been the only episode in which Josh Radnor has narrated his own story, rather than his now-interchangeable older voice of Bob Saget, and we finally got to see older Ted telling his story to his children. Children who are the same age as when he started his story, dashing any fans' hopes that Lyndsy Fonseca and David Henrie would appear at their current ages (now 27 and 24 respectively) with a joke about the length of the story. But there was, at least, a reference when Ted said "I kept this story short and to the point". No, Ted, you really didn't. And the kids pick up on what's obvious from the beginning of the first episode to the end of the last - Ted is still in love with Robin. And the fans' eyes all rolled - of course it was about Robin. Once again, How I Met Your Mother gives the audience a circular story, but this time across nine seasons. So after being devastated by the truth of Tracy's predicted death, we find out that the whole story about The Mother was pointless. Except, it wasn't...

1. Ted Is Finally Happy

Ted was very happy with Tracy. Happier than he had ever been, finally having what he had always dreamed for in a family. And for eleven years, Ted and Tracy lived out their lives together until, sadly, in 2024, Tracy dies. Why couldn't the show have left it at that? Well, firstly, that would mean no closure for Robin. But they could have given her Don back, or just told the story of how she grew old, lonely but successful. Secondly, that would be too fairytale for How I Met Your Mother which, as was pointed out earlier, has always given relationships more realism than some other shows. Except, growing old with the person you love is a reality, and it's certainly one Ted deserved. And he did get it. It wasn't with Tracy, but, as the kids point out, by 2030 Ted has been in love with Robin for twenty-five years. Not to say that he still wanted Robin while he was with Tracy, but given that Tracy had passed away six years earlier by the time Ted told his kids the story, he did need to move on. And, although an invention of the show's creators way back in 2005, Tracy's illness in the show was nobody's fault. It just happened. So we do finally get to see Ted happy, presumably for the rest of his life. And the kids are happy with it too. We see the blue french horn again, and Robin has dogs again, and the show comes full-circle. Before meeting Tracy, the main thing keeping Ted and Robin apart was his desire for children and her initial lack of want for, and then lack of ability to have, said children. But through Tracy, Ted got the family he always wanted. And in Robin, he got the girl. The final episode delivered on its promise, to explain how Ted met The Mother, but it also went further to show the after-years, something fans of shows such as Friends have hoped for many times in the decade since it ended (who knows? Maybe Chandler and Monica get divorced!). How I Met Your Mother's finale delivered in every way it could to give a conclusive end to its nine year run, even if a lot of the fans feel short-changed by Ted's ultimate destiny to be with Robin. But, again, it almost had to happen that way. Of course, if you really don't like the ending, then at least you can rest easy knowing that Tracy won't pass away until 2024 so, somewhere out there, for the next ten years, Ted and Tracy will be having a wonderful life together. What were your thoughts on the finale? Let us know in the comments.