How I Met Your Mother: 5 Great Things From The 200th Episode

By Richard Church /

This week How I Met Your Mother reached the very difficult milestone of 200 episodes. This feat is incredibly hard for a television show to reach, especially in this age where reaching a third season is an accomplishment in itself. An episode as momentous as a 200th has to be special, honouring everything that came before in a way that is true to both the series and characters within it. How I Met Your Mother's 200th episode, aptly titled 'How Your Mother Met Me', absolutely did just that. For nine long years Carter Bays and Craig Thomas have dangled the questions of who The Mother is and how exactly Ted met her in some entertaining, and often times frustratingly exasperating, ways. With The Mother introduced in the closing moments of Season 8, a lot of expectation was put upon Bays, Thomas and the writing team to make her live up to the hype, but the biggest expectation of all fell onto Cristin Milioti. After all, she had to bring The Mother to life and make audiences fall in love with her, recognizing why out of all the women Ted's dated she would be his one and only. Season 9 has had its ups and downs so far, but 'How Your Mother Met Me' delivered the best episode of the season, arguably the series. Let's take a look at 5 things which made this episode one of How I Met's best.

5. The Emotion

Right from the start of the episode, the emotion started off with a bang as it took on a surprisingly somber tone. It started with the usual cheer any How I Met episode has, but all it took was one look from The Mother as she heard the worst news of her life to turn that cheer around. This scene in particular was strong because audiences only saw The Mother's shocked face and heard one sentence of the conversation, her saying "Yes, this is she", before cutting to her home as she finds the present her deceased boyfriend planned on giving her. This death hung in the air and provided much of the emotional backbone of the episode, driving The Mother's story. The emotion didn't let up and climaxed with the great scene where The Mother finally breaks her silence to Max about her need to move on. It was a heartbreaking scene as she acknowledged this feeling, but couldn't follow through without feeling as if she's betraying his memory. Needless to say this was a surprisingly emotional episode for such a tremendous milestone. If there is one thing How I Met Your Mother has excelled at though, its giving its audience very well done emotional stories which strike a chord without being too preachy or beating the dead horse.

4. The Callbacks

How I Met has always been effective at calling back to old jokes or running gags and the 200th episode was no exception. It was littered with references to the past as it brought audiences up to speed on The Mother's story. Perhaps the best one was discovering The Mother not only had a run in with Mitch, The Naked Man, but she was the very first exception to his "2 out of 3" rule. There were other callbacks which were equally as notable, such as Ted and Barney's brief run as bartenders where they renamed the bar Puzzles and Ted's corny Shellfish joke. These moments served not only as levity for an emotion filled and somewhat depressing episode, but reminders of the past and what had come before. Even through its ups and downs, How I Met has been mostly consistent with its history (though whoever thought St. Patrick's Day was in April needs to check a calendar) so it was very pleasing for long time fans to see that amount of callbacks within the story.

3. Connecting The Dots

Perhaps the most frustrating thing about How I Met Your Mother aside from the nine years its taken to tell the story is the constant near misses between Ted and The Mother. They were fun and cute at first, but have become somewhat tedious the longer the show has gone on for. Fans were at least told where Ted would meet her at the start of Season 6, leading them to believe it would be at Punchy's wedding only for the writers to throw a twist that it was in fact Barney's. It has taken a long time since then to actually get to the wedding (the show's not even there yet either!), but the episode went a long way to connecting all the dots and seeing the near misses from The Mother's perspective, including a couple viewers didn't even know about, namely the green dress. Fans had long wondered about Ted's run-in with a woman at the St. Patty's bar, believing her to be The Mother and theorized the team would re-shoot that scene so it would be Milioti Ted bumped into, but they kept the scene as it is, adding The Mother to a conversation at the other end of the bar. The writers went to great lengths to connect all the dots they could on Ted and The Mother's journey to meet each other which once again delivered payoffs for long time viewers.

2. La Vie En Rose

The final few minutes of 'How Your Mother Met Me', as mentioned previously, really climaxed on the emotional front with the unexpected proposal The Mother faced. Viewers saw firsthand how reluctant she was to move on from Max as she spoke to an empty sky asking if it was okay. Even with his 'permission' she still couldn't come to terms with the possibility of moving on, heading to the Farhampton Inn for a room and serenading herself to 'La Vie En Rose' while, unknown to her, Ted listened next door. These minutes made viewers really connect with The Mother. It's no surprise Cristin Milioti's rendition of 'La Vie En Rose' was extremely touching and well done as she's a Broadway performer. What was also funny was Curtis' knowing smile as he handed her the keys to her room. His few appearances have been fairly comedic as he always worried over Ted's single status at such a romantic place as Farhampton and his friend's wedding. Using Curtis as a secret matchmaker was not only clever on the writer's part, but a surprising payoff to his constant worry. One can wish the writers had gone one step further by having Ted poke his head around the balcony to speak to her, but the scene was admittedly perfect as it is.

1. The Mother

Throughout the season The Mother has made sporadic appearances, popping in and out of the story at random. Recently she's appeared far more regularly, but fans still didn't know her all that well. Future Ted's of course talked about her hobbies and interests, but he's admittedly a biased and somewhat unreliable narrator so audiences have only his word and her few appearances to go on. 'How Your Mother Met Me' delved deep into who she was and what has led her to Ted. What is surprising about her journey is how it is juxtaposed against Ted's own. Ted has been a hopeless romantic constantly in search of 'the one' since the series began. The Mother, however, is convinced she already met her ideal man in Max and believes she won't be able to recreate that love with anyone else. Their beliefs throughout the series have been at such polar opposites it is very interesting thematically. One has to wonder what it is about Ted that not only makes her fall for him, but to eventually say yes to his proposal when she said no to Louis'. Throughout the series fans have waited for the moment where Ted meets her, but, thanks now to this episode's explanation of her back story and character, audiences can't wait until the moment The Mother meets Ted and finds her happiness. Only eight more episodes remain until How I Met Your Mother ends and the journeys Ted and The Mother have been on are complete. Let's hope it has all been worthwhile.