How I Met Your Mother: 7 Ways Finale Went So Wrong

As it turns out, pressing the reset button on three beloved characters isn't everyone's cup of tea...

By Philip Frazer /

The nine year run of CBS's hit comedy How I Met Your Mother came to an end on Monday night and the reactions have been strong and instant. The finale promised to finally tie up the story of the friends in Manhattan and put together the final pieces in the story of how Ted Mosby met the mother of his two children. 'Last Forever' undeniably fulfilled the two criteria but did they do it in a satisfying way? The majority say no and there is plenty of evidence to support their claims. From this point onwards there are severe SPOILER warnings, if you have not seen the series up to its final episode be warned that spoilers follow directly from this paragraph. The penultimate episode, 'The End of the Aisle', had set the everything up perfectly for Ted to take centre stage and complete his own personal journey. It brought happy endings to all four of his friends as Barney and Robin finally wed and Marshall and Lily put their disagreements aside to unofficially renew their vows (with an updated twist). The stage was set for the final episode to be all about Ted and Cristin Milioti's "mother" character while viewers said goodbye to the gang and show. But it fluffed its lines. How? Well, read on and see what it got wrong.

7. It Made Spending A Season At The Wedding Pointless

Fans were sceptical upon the news that the entire final season would take place across the course of the wedding weekend, away from the beloved familiar scenery of MacLaren's and instead taking place at the Farhampton Inn. So Bays and Thomas had their work cut out from that moment onwards to warrant such a bold and unique decision. Sadly it wasn't done through consistent episode quality, as the final season wavered between the excellent ('Bass Player Wanted', 'The End of the Aisle') and the terrible ('Sunrise', 'Knight Vision') in the Farhampton based episodes, with many of the stronger season nine episodes taking place outside of the setting through its signature time jumping. After Barney and Robin finally tied the knot in the penultimate episode and Ted finally took a step back from the love triangle to move on to his own love life it seemed like maybe it had been worth it (maybe not a whole season though). The show even did a great job of addressing the fact that fans had been divided on their support for Barney and Robin as a couple, through the mouth of Ted no less, as they explained that love doesn't have to make sense, it just is what it is. However, the finale changed all of that. Robin and Barney were divorced within fifteen minutes of the episode (three years in the timeline) revealed through a bad comedy segment and with the closest thing to an explanation being Robin's career taking the couple around the world. As for Ted moving on, well, not quite would be an understatement. But that will be dealt with later.

6. It Undid Years Of Character Development

In 2005 when How I Met Your Mother first hit screens viewers were introduced to hopeless romantic Ted, who becomes immediately smitten with emotionally detached new-girl-in-town Robin. His best friends Marshall and Lily were deeply in love since college, and his "Bro" Barney was a womanising egotist. Robin finally opened up the idea of settling down but not with Ted. She tried her hand with a few partners and even moved in with co-host Don and later got engaged to Kevin before finding her match but in the least likely of places: Barney Stinson. Barney had matured a lot in the past few seasons, showing a selfless emotional side that wanted to settle down. He tried with Nora and then with Quinn whom he was engaged to, but nothing seemed to work quite like Robin. He officially put his womaniser days behind him with the destruction of the Playbook and even a passing of the torch to the new generation in 'Sunrise'. Yet the finale shows a Barney that has surrendered himself to being no better than a life of sleeping with random women because if he couldn't do it with Robin, he isn't capable. He is soon happy in his old ways, except for the lack of having his friends around him, even completing "the perfect month" but it is here that changes his life forever. #31 falls pregnant and Barney becomes a father and grows up. But it should have been his wedding to Robin that gave him this moment of settling into maturity once and for all, it was the moment built up to and even though Barney has shown a fondness to the idea of babies in the past, he has always decided that he is a better uncle because he wouldn't be willing to drop everything for a child. Robin is also miserable because her wedding to Barney ends, something which clearly neither is over. judging by their interaction on Halloween. She too has shown that she was incapable of settling down instead of being a slave to her work. And Ted still can't move on from Robin. Again, more on that later.

5. Entirely Demeans His Relationship With The Mother

The relationship that the entire series was always moving towards, Ted and "the one". The mother of his children. The woman who was perfect for him in every single way. Ted Mosby and Tracy McConnell, the parents of Heather and Luke. Even as far back in Ted's life as 2009 when he was dating Cindy, he was most interested in Tracy. The show itself had laid plenty of references both directly and indirectly to "The Mother" throughout the first eight seasons. In one of the biggest achievements of the series, viewers cared deeply about a relationship they had never witnessed between a main character and a character they had never even seen. Even under the many predictions that The Mother would have died to in some way motivate Ted telling the story, her importance never felt any less significant. Viewers still felt like she was "the one" to Ted. The finale revealed that they had only been a couple for nine years, only four as husband and wife. After all the searching and all the downs that he went through, Ted knew that the journey was worth it to find Tracy. Yet the show only has them together for a brief period in comparison to his eight years (in the show's chronology) moping after Robin during the series run and however long after the ending. The news that she is dead is brushed over in a minute or so before moving back to Robin once again. Tracy comes across now as a means to allow Ted and Robin to achieve their dreams (children and career respectively) separately before getting back together. And that's just wrong.

4. Makes His Storytelling Motives Very Questionable

Ted has told his children the incredibly long story about "how he met their mother" yet even they saw through the thinly veiled attempt to once again use her as nothing but a plotting device in the middle of a Ted and Robin story. Counting the minutes rather than the nine years of the show, he has been speaking for over four days. Even a generous fan could reduce the number for storytelling being quicker than actual events, but there is no denying that it is an insanely long story. The length of the story Ted tells his children is forgiveable dependent on the motive, especially when factoring in Ted's love of sharing his past tales, but the actual motive supplied by the final two minutes of the finale are insulting to fans and it should have insulted the children as well. The children could be happy for Ted to move on and be with a woman other than their mother, as they said they had observed the affection, but Ted has disguised this plight behind the façade of telling the children about their mother. Who they will have limited memory of if she has been dead six years and therefore died when they were children. Even further, when the children question Ted in 'Pilot' about the fact that he was speaking about Aunt Robin, why didn't they make their point then and simply tell him that they were okay with him asking her out? Everything about it seems a blissful oversight to allow the format to continue rather than any narrative credibility.

3. Falls Into The "Ross And Rachel" Cliché

How I Met Your Mother seems formulaic sitcom upon first glance €“ it has the doted couple, the on-off couple and an eccentric side character. However, a simple twist with the closing line of the shows first ever episode it set itself apart by turning expectations on their head. By revealing that Robin wasn't the titular mother the question of "will they / won't they?" was answered with a no. Over the years to come, through Ted and Robin's various relationships and not being over each other, she was still Aunt Robin. Whereas the show was about the mother of his children, something which was completely ruled out in 'Symphony of Illumination' when Robin finds out she cannot have children of her own. Speculation had always continued that Ted would get with Robin after The Mother but mostly due to the audience having not yet met her and because of sitcom expectations rather than narrative logic. The show's writing and the characters within it endlessly pointed out why Ted and Robin were a bad couple that would never work, all to try and move the pair of them out of that slump of returning to one and other despite it being unhealthy for them. For all the innovative things about HIMYM that set it apart in the field of "friends comedies" they were ultimately for nothing as it fell back into the predictable trope of the "Ross and Rachel" for the sake of what was imagined as the happy ending as opposed to feeling forced on to the end due to being too rigid to original plans.

2. Implies A Tragic Existence For Four Major Characters

As previously stated in the article, when 'The End of the Aisle' concluded there were two happy married couples and the impending meeting of another, all of whom had grown into more complete human beings throughout the course of the series. But the events during the final hour of HIMYM suggest that Barney, Robin, Ted and The Mother all led incredibly tragic and depressing existences. And in some cases, it was more an existence than a life. Taking each in turn: Despite meeting the woman of his dreams, who gave him two children and was his perfect match, Ted spent 25 years obsessing over a different woman. One who he met eight years before her, Robin. Therefore Tracy's existence is very tragic. Not only does she lose "the one" on her 21st birthday but when she does finally completely move on after a tough eight year struggle, she does so to a man who is still in love with another woman. As for her lasting memory to Ted? Despite all the fondness he remembers her with he views her as more of a lesson than "the one" by the way he speaks in his final monologue. Barney showed that he was incapable of companionship, after all the progress he made with Robin (and in a smaller sense Quinn and Nora) it was for nothing because he just gave up and went back to meaningless flings but this time without even the presence of his friends. He did eventually achieve maturity thanks to the birth of his daughter, who presumably will never know her mother as Barney and the gang seem to not even know her name. Needless to say, with Barney's partying ways, things don't look good for her growing up. And Robin. Perhaps the most tragic of all. She rejects all of her friends and lives the life of a social recluse, replacing her friends with a new pack of dogs. And she stays that way for the majority of 14 years. She has once again plunged 100% into her work, yet it is seen through her expression when talking about it to Ted and Heather that it isn't bringing her any true joy whatsoever. She simply lives with regret about rejecting Ted for all that time, to the point that as soon as he appears with the blue french horn she is immediately his.

1. Misses What The Audience Cared About

The big one. It doesn't just hit the reset button on many character developments, it does so to take them away from what fans had grown to care about more than the original plan. Yes, Tracy pretty much had to die from a narrative standpoint, but there was no reason to have Ted just run back to Robin. Fans had grown sick and tired of all the back-and-forth with Robin, and it is a big disservice to Cristin Milioti. She managed to walk into the final season of a nearly decade-long hit comedy and not only immediately fit in, but also have the fanbase feel she is the woman they want the main character to be with. The audience had been screaming for more Milioti throughout season nine, particularly together with Ted, because their chemistry was just so perfect that it didn't matter how little was known of her, the fans just knew. Ending the show on the symbolism of the blue horn shows how the ending was planned years ago when Robin was who fans wanted to see Ted with (even though Victoria overtook her as many fans favourite in the shows earlier seasons), whereas the true symbol that fans cared about was the yellow umbrella. The meeting was executed so, so well and delivered what fans had been waiting for and if the episode needed a happy ending to move on from the sorrow of her death, this would've been a better placed final scene. Or their wedding. But the best ending scene was written by the writers themselves years ago and mentioned so frequently that it had to have a place in the finale right? Wrong. Most fans will already know "the dream" referred to, the front porch. Lily and Ted have so frequently told of Lily's vision of the future gang sitting out on the front porch, and the finale could have delivered the perfect one to close the show on a happy note after the news that Tracy was dead. Showing it achieved some time between their marriage in 2020 and her death in 2024, with Marshall and Lily, Ted and Tracy and €“ if they had chosen to keep them together €“ Barney and Robin. All six happily married and fulfilling the prophecy. A much more perfect ending to induce a happy nostalgia, and a fond memory for Ted to end his epic relaying of how he met his children's mother. What were your opinions on the finale? And what would you want to see changed? Or maybe you wouldn't change a thing? Make your thoughts known in the comments section below.