Once Upon A Time: 10 Best Villains

Every story has a villain... This one has a lot.

By Geoff Cox /

The small town of Storybrooke, Maine is hardly a place anyone would call quiet. In the years since Once Upon A Time kicked off in 2011, the residents of the series' fictional town have squared off against an assortment of villains who have threatened their lives, memories and more. Not a day seemingly goes by in Storybrooke where the imminent threat of danger isn't looming over everyone's heads. From bringing to life iconic fairy tale villains to creating antagonists entirely from scratch, the series hasn't held back in having fun with the darker side of things, both in the present day story and in its numerous flashback tales. As fans know, the incoming second half of the show's fourth season is bringing three more classic villains into the fold: Ursula, Cruella de Vil and the return of Maleficent. With a huge roster of antagonists already colouring the show's history, the three are bound to have their hands full in becoming some of the most unforgettable. The trio has a lot of competition to overcome, as some of the show's most memorable villains have fully embraced who they are with no remorse, some have seen the error of their ways and others even continue to wrestle with who they are and who they want to be to this day. So as fans count down the days until the series returns on March 1st, let's take a spoiler-filled look at ten of the best villains Once Upon A Time's had to offer to date...

10. King George

It's no surprise that showrunners Eddy Kitsis and Adam Horowitz - both writers and producers on Lost - brought Charles Widmore himself, Alan Dale, over to Once Upon A Time to play the effectively smug King George. Between forcing a young David to assume the identity of his prince brother James and eventually cursing Snow White to prevent her from being able to have children, the King proved time and again that he was a character far removed from decency. Even after the original curse was lifted from Storybrooke, George framed Ruby for the death of Billy, trapped Snow and Emma in the Enchanted Forest by destroying Jefferson's hat and vowed to ruin David's life for as long as he could. Though viewers haven't seen King George since season two, Dale's suitably arrogant performance is one that they won't soon forget. Despite the fact the show has since moved on to much bigger villains, George is still out there and it's hard to imagine him not resurfacing to join part of a grand, evil plot somewhere down the line if it means having another chance to destroy David.

9. Greg & Tamara

The two-in-one deal of Greg and Tamara rolled into Storybrooke during the course of the show's second season. Halfway through the season, Greg drove into town seemingly by chance, with Tamara later arriving alongside Neal as his fiancée. Quickly, though, it was revealed that the two were in cahoots, working for the "Home Office" and tasked with ridding the world of magic. The pair eventually went on to torture Regina, use Hook's desire for revenge against Rumpel for their own gain, nearly destroy the town and even kidnap Henry to Neverland, with August 'dying' along the way and Neal taking a bullet from Tamara before falling into yet another portal. Though Tamara would later outwardly atone for her sins to an unforgiving Rumpel before her death, Greg had no apologies. After having his father taken from him and later killed by Regina before being left in the real world as an orphan destined to have no one believe him about his time in Storybrooke, Greg had a pretty solid motive for wanting to crush the unrepentant Regina. Both characters were quickly shoved aside for the Neverland arc, but between how close they came to succeeding in eliminating Storybrooke and how relatively justified Greg was in having a legitimate beef with Regina - a fact many fans seem to forget - the duo definitely provided a welcome, memorable shake-up.

8. Zelena

The Wicked Witch of the West arrived during the second half of the show's third season with much promotional fanfare. Unfortunately for her, though, she was tasked with having to follow up the solid villainy of Peter Pan before getting swept under the rug to make way for the unexpected popularity of Frozen. Despite that, the abandoned sibling of Regina proved to be memorable for her over-the-top spite, envy and entitlement, with all of her actions hinging on her desire to get from Regina what their mother, Cora, had never given her. Responsible for cursing everyone back to Storybrooke, enslaving the resurrected Rumpel and even for the death of Neal, Zelena managed to have quite an impact in undoing the bittersweet ending to the first half of the season.

7. Ingrid

As part of the show's recent Frozen arc, the character of Ingrid was born to give the story of Anna and Elsa a major threat, inspired by the very same Hans Christian Anderson story, The Snow Queen, that led to Disney's film. While it's hard not to feel the obviousness of Disney and ABC having mandated the show's inclusion of Frozen, particularly due to the fact Elsa arrived just a few months after the film's release, the series at least refrained from retelling the story of the film. Instead, it opted to continue on from where it left off, bringing Ingrid in as Anna and Elsa's powerful aunt with a chip on her shoulder and an inherent need to have a family that accepts her for who she is. Elizabeth Mitchell's innate ability to switch from steely ice queen to teary-eyed ball of emotion on a dime went a long way to helping humanise the character as the arc played out. Though her obsession managed to straddle the line between suitably creepy and somewhat relatable thanks to the revelation of her backstory, especially where Emma was concerned, her final change of heart and sacrifice to - ahem - let it go was earned, even if the deus ex machina letter from her sister that inspired her was a tad too convenient.

6. Captain Hook

Killian Jones has come a long way on the show from his days as the rogue Captain Hook. Introduced as an ally to Cora in the show's second season, Hook has since ditched his villainous ways - with a few bumps along the road - to become a hero in his own right and Emma's current love interest. Though Hook has wrestled with his own demons, including his long history with the Crocodile (Rumpelstiltskin) and his inescapable love of being a pirate, he's one of the show's few villains who, so far, has turned out all right, with his few backslides easily chalked up to being manipulated, physically and emotionally. He's easily earned his status as a fan favourite. Even when he's not given much to do, actor Colin O'Donoghue has managed to sell each second he's allowed, chewing up every one-liner about Netflix and cell phones. He may no longer be labelled a villain anymore, but his journey to becoming a hero has made him one of the show's most indelible reformed antagonists.

5. Cora

After appearing in flashbacks during the show's first season, Barbara Hershey's Cora swept into season two to antagonise Storybrooke in an effort to win Regina back on her quest for power. As one of the series' most important villains, Cora's story has managed to continue on even in the wake of her death, with more revelations about her past and connections to other characters still being unveiled. From her relationship with Rumpel to her time as the Queen of Hearts in Wonderland to abandoning a daughter who would become the Wicked Witch, Cora has quite a legacy that's bound to be revisited further. Having had a profound effect on the lives of characters like Regina, Snow White, Rumpel and Anastasia, Cora's way with words and mastery of manipulation were often more effective than outright displays of power. Considering, too, that nearly all of her actions were born from the belief that love is weakness and through the removal of her own heart, she stands as quite a complex piece of Once Upon A Time's mythology.

4. Jafar

For what faults it may have had, the Wonderland-set spin-off still managed to get a number of things right. While it seems criminal that Naveen Andrews has been reduced to taking a role on a show not many people were invested in from the start, he still gave quite the turn as Jafar. With his villainy born from the abuse suffered at the hands of his father, the Sultan of Agrabah,, Jafar embraced his role, letting no one and nothing stop him from gaining power and ultimately terrorising Wonderland to achieve his goals. In one of the character's best moments and with the laws of magic no longer in effect, Jafar managed to make his father love him, with Jafar letting only a moment of long-brewing emotion wash over him before turning and killing his father to finally make them even. It's a great scene from Andrews, who delivers throughout the entire series. With the popular Will Scarlett having made the jump from Once Upon A Time in Wonderland to the mother show in the current season, hopefully Jafar, too, can be set free from the bottle viewers last saw him in to help reign terror on Storybrooke down the line.

3. Peter Pan

Easily one of the show's most compelling villains, Peter Pan soared into the show at the start of season three. Fueled by a great performance by actor Robbie Kay, who managed to hold his own against even the great Robert Carlyle, Pan set a bar that all future antagonists following in his footsteps would have to strive for. Though the Neverland arc itself arguably dragged out longer than necessary, the exploration of Pan's past served to flesh out Rumpel's character in a whole new way. The revelation that the two were father and son, coupled with the themes of abandonment, cast a whole new light on what viewers had come to know about the Dark One and the cultural image of Pan as a carefree, tad-bit-selfish hero. In his final episode, Pan took nothing back; his resentment of Rumpel and belief that his son had taken away his life and potential despite having simply been a child was just as passionate as ever. With another curse rolling in and with his efforts nearly accomplished, he paved the way for Rumpel's long-needed redemptive arc to conclude, with his own son stabbing both of them with the Dark One's own dagger, effectively killing them both. Though Rumpel has since come back and returned to his power-hungry attitude, Peter Pan's time on the show is no less memorable for how it changed things up and for Kay's entertaining performance.

2. The Evil Queen

Is it really a surprise to see Regina battling for the top spot on this list? Though she started off the show squarely as The Evil Queen, Regina has spent the past few seasons wrestling with the demons of her past and present. Sometimes remorseful, sometimes not, but always ready to blanket a situation with sarcasm, Regina is both one of the series' best villains and one of its best characters period. Even when the writing isn't doing Regina justice - how many times is she going to flip flop on being good or evil despite how she's being accepted nowadays, after all - actress Lana Parrilla always manages to make her entertaining. When she's not getting to relish playing evil in flashbacks or straddling the line in the present, her 'so over it' attitude with the other characters and events on the show always provides laughs. For how unavoidably evil Regina frequently thinks she is destined to be and despite the inexcusable deeds that litter her past, her heart still shines through time and again, whether it's with Henry, Robin Hood or even Emma, ensuring that she's one villain fans will continue to root for during her ongoing reconciliation between her past and who she wants to be in her future.

1. Rumpelstiltskin

Over the course of Once Upon A Time, fans have seen many sides of Rumpelstiltskin. Whether he's a cowardly peasant, the overly eccentric Dark One, a man willing to sacrifice his life for a greater good, a schizophrenic loon with one hell of a dual identity crisis, a mourning father or a man who values power over the love of his life, actor Robert Carlyle has had the chance to play the character all across the board. Immensely frustrating in recent days for his treatment of Belle - his own wife - and for throwing away all the growth he experienced up until he took the lives of both he and his father in favour of pursuing more power, Rumpel's path is seemingly squarely back to one of villainy. Despite that, he still manages to be continually engaging, easily one of the greatest characters on the series, if not the best. Always scheming, always holding secrets close to the chest and always ready to return character requests with nothing more than a clever comeback, Rumpel easily remains the series' most intriguing villain. Even when fans think they have him figured out, he throws them for a loop, for good or, more often, bad. Though it's easy to argue that the show as a whole hasn't been as strong or as promising as it once was, it's hard to deny that its villains often tend to elevate every scene they're in. As for now, fans have no choice but to wait and see if Ursula, Cruella and Maleficent can manage to earn their place among Once Upon A Time's cream of the villainous crop. Do you agree? What villains from Once Upon A Time would make your list? Let us know in the comments below.