Ranking All 8 Seasons Of Dexter

As Showtime Prepares For A Revival We Look Back At Everyone's Favourite Serial Killer.

By Jamie Evans /

Dexter is the definitive example of a series that had a lot of promise, came out of the gate hot and fizzled out until it ended with one of the most resoundingly hated finales ever shown on TV (move over Line of Duty fans, Dexter heads were here first). The concept is irresistibly intriguing right from the beginning; there’s a serial killer, driven by a dark compulsion to hunt, torture and kill. We’ve seen it a million times before but the difference here is Dexter is the protagonist. We’re rooting for him. He works for the police department and hunts down and murders other serial killers according to a strict moral code established by his step-father, Harry.

Advertisement

Dexter successfully built on its interesting premise for the first few seasons, weaving together moments of levity, intrigue, suspense and brutality into a perfect tapestry of serial killer entertainment. Somewhere around the middle of its run, however, the show began to stumble and falter before giving us that infamous lumberjack ending.

The legacy of Dexter may yet be saved, however, as Showtime recently released a teaser for the upcoming revival season of the show. In anticipation we’ve decided to rank the previous eight seasons of the show once and for all. So here we are, ranked worst to best; all eight seasons of Dexter.

8. Season 8

It has to be, right? Seriously? What was this? Even in weaker seasons the show had been entertaining to watch, but season eight never seems to build up any steam. Charlotte Rampling joins the cast as an old psychiatrist friend of Harry’s and is promptly crowbarred into Dexter’s backstory. This late-in-the-game addition to the mythos never quite fit and didn’t prove as intriguing as the writers clearly hoped. The so called “Brain Surgeon” proved to be an unfulfilling antagonist for the season (to be fair, didn’t they all lack in comparison to Trinity?) and what resulted was a series of uninteresting encounters and a multitude of missteps.

Advertisement

This is all wrapped up in a finale that sees the unwarranted death of Deborah Morgan, which came across as less shocking and more mean-spirited, as if the writers were trying to spite the fans. Dexter, who has supposedly grown so much as a character in the previous eight seasons, eschews all of his development to return to his old self, seeking isolation in the forested wilderness and leaving his young son with another deranged sociopath. But sure, you did that because you cared about him, right Dex?

7. Season 7

Season 7 is a year of the show that, whilst never making the terrible missteps of season 8 that earn it a reputation as one of the worst seasons of television ever, still isn’t very interesting. In fact, it’s downright boring and forgettable. Seriously, what happens in season 7? Does anyone remember?

Advertisement

This is the season where Deborah knows Dexter’s dirty secret and, as a result, we lose out on a lot of the banter that had made the pair so interesting to watch previously. It also introduces Yvonne Strahovski as Hannah McKay, a new love interest for Dexter whose character never quite seems to find her footing. Ray Stevenson rounds out the season's guest stars as the villainous head of a Ukrainian Crime Syndicate and, whilst he certainly doesn’t do a bad job, he just isn’t as interesting of a villain. Ultimately season 7 is a shadow of the show it had once been.

6. Season 5

The problem with having such an amazing, catch you off guard, finish the likes of which season four had, is that there’s inevitably a comedown afterwards. It is a law of nature after all, right? Season 5 stumbles right of the gate and fails to use the momentum passed to it by that incredible season four finale. Much of the season is spent dealing with Dexter’s grief after the events of season four and, whilst this makes for good character exploration, it also slows down the pacing the show had become known for.

Advertisement

Julia Stiles guest stars this season as Lumen, a woman who befriends Dexter in her journey to get revenge on a group of serial rapists led by a motivational speaker (yes, the big bad of this season is a motivational speaker!) named Jordan Chase, played by Johnny Lee Miller. Whilst this initially presents a possible future for Dexter, things of course don’t go to plan and the finale sees Lumen leave the show.

Season 5's placement on the list isn’t really so much the fault of season 5 but rather the incredible heights reached by season 4, which season 5 seemingly failed to capitalise upon. It isn’t a bad season of the show, however, and shouldn’t be skipped over.

5. Season 6

Dexter goes to church as the show explored themes around faith and religion in its sixth season. Miami is haunted by The Doomsday Killer, who is trying to bring about the end of the world by staging elaborate murder scenes inspired by the book of revelation.

Advertisement

Season 6 manages to regain some of the tension that seemed to be missing in season 5 and uses its guest stars to good effect; Edward James Olmos and Colin Hanks are fantastic as a teacher and student duo in conflict with Dexter, and the investigative nature of the season's first half works well to draw you in.

The season features a great twist midway through, as well as a good twist in the finale that saw audiences perched on the edge of their seats back in the day. On the downside, however, this season spends too much time dealing with petty relationship drama between Angel and La Guerta, as well as La Guerta’s political game playing. All of this stuff never quite feels like it’s part of the same show and can be annoyingly distracting.

4. Season 3

Season 3 of Dexter is a bit of a weird one. It never quite feels like the arc is as solid or as well plotted as the prior two seasons, but it’s still entertaining nonetheless. Jimmy Smits guest stars this season as District Attorney Miguel Prado, Dexter’s first true friend in the series. He has a passion for justice and, we learn, a dark driver just like Dexter. Together the two begin a partnership with Dexter teaching Miguel his method for killing his victims. The season explores what happens when a similar character to Dexter is let loose on the world without Harry’s strict code in place and we see through Miguel the potential monster Dexter could become if he was to turn away from his stepfather’s teachings.

Advertisement

Jimmy Smits is a fantastic addition to the cast and is a huge part of why the Miguel Prado character is so intriguing to watch. This is also the season which sees Desmond Harrington join the cast as Detective Quinn, a role he’ll remain in until the end of the series after this point.

Ultimately, season 3 is a perfectly solid season of Dexter, though it fails to break new ground or improve upon its predecessors as some other seasons did.

3. Season 1

Where it all started! Dexter takes a couple of episodes to settle into itself - the pilot in particular seems so in love with its serial-killer-but-good-guy concept that we see more than the usual amount of blood and guts and murder, possibly setting up expectations that later will not be met.

Advertisement

Beyond that though, this is a pretty darn good season of television. The show introduces a cast of quirky and likeable supporting roles, an intriguing murder-mystery and all this narrated by the morbidly wry humour of Dexter Morgan. Dexter’s first season is the only season that is actually based on its corresponding novel; Darkly Dreaming Dexter, with the remainder of the series branching away from the plot of the books.

The central plot of the season involves the hunt for a serial killer known as The Ice Truck Killer, and it is sufficiently engaging and twisting to keep us entertained. However, the true joy of season 1 is getting acquainted with our wonderful cast.

2. Season 4

Deciding the order of the final two spaces was incredibly difficult and there’s not much between them. Season 4 of Dexter is a near-perfect chunk of television. This is Dexter perfected; it’s not overly complicated, it isn’t trying to break new ground, it just relies on a tried-and-true method for epic storytelling; pitting the likeable, charming hero against an interesting nemesis who is always one step ahead. Add in the incredible acting talents of John Lithgow and you officially have the greatest nemesis in the show’s history.

Advertisement

Trinity is a vile, evil man, made all the worse by how nauseatingly nice he appears in public. A family man and church deacon, beneath it all Trinity is the worst of the worst. John Lithgow received universal acclaim for his role as the Trinity Killer, including winning a Golden Globe and an Emmy Award for the performance. Not to forget, in terms of iconic TV moments, who didn’t get chills down their spine the first time Trinity showed up at Dexter’s work, strode right up to him and said; “Hello, Dexter Morgan.”

The series caps it all off with a final, vicious twist that altered the dynamic of the show going forward. There isn’t really much more you can ask from Dexter. It is nearly the perfect season except for…

1. Season 2

Dexter’s second outing is the definition of must-see, edge-of-your-seat TV. How do you make a satisfying villain to replace Season 1’s Ice Truck Killer? Simple; you turn all of Dexter’s friends against him, but they don’t know it!

Advertisement

In season 2, some of Dexter’s discarded bodies are discovered, causing panic throughout Miami and earning him the moniker; The Bay Harbour Butcher. Suddenly Dexter’s friends and colleagues are hunting him. The tension is automatically ratcheted up as Dexter risks constant exposure. Add in the presence of FBI Agent Frank Lundy and the ever-suspicious Sergeant Doakes and every episode of this season is filled with tension.

Jaime Murray also joins the cast this season as a new love interest for Dexter, pitting him in a love triangle with sweet and loyal Rita. The season strikes a perfect balance between both of its plots before beautifully tying them together in the finale. This, my friends, is perfect television!

Advertisement